Overcoming the influence of noise and imperfections in quantum devices is one of the main challenges for viable quantum applications. In this article, we present different protocols, which we denote as ``superposed quantum error mitigation,'' that enhance the fidelity of single gates or entire computations by performing them in coherent superposition. Our results demonstrate that via our methods, significant noise suppression can be achieved for most kinds of decoherence and standard experimental parameter regimes. Our protocols can be either deterministic, such that the outcome is never postselected, or probabilistic, in which case the resulting state must be discarded unless a well-specified condition is met. By using sufficiently many resources and working under broad assumptions, our methods can yield the desired output state with unit fidelity. Finally, we analyze our approach for gate-based, measurement-based, and interferometric-based models, demonstrating the applicability in all cases and investigating the fundamental mechanisms they rely upon.
Overcoming the influence of noise and imperfections in quantum devices is one of the main challenges for viable quantum applications. In this article, we present different protocols, which we denote as ``superposed quantum error mitigation,'' that enhance the fidelity of single gates or entire computations by performing them in coherent superposition. Our results demonstrate that via our methods, significant noise suppression can be achieved for most kinds of decoherence and standard experimental parameter regimes. Our protocols can be either deterministic, such that the outcome is never postselected, or probabilistic, in which case the resulting state must be discarded unless a well-specified condition is met. By using sufficiently many resources and working under broad assumptions, our methods can yield the desired output state with unit fidelity. Finally, we analyze our approach for gate-based, measurement-based, and interferometric-based models, demonstrating the applicability in all cases and investigating the fundamental mechanisms they rely upon.
Overcoming the influence of noise and imperfections is a major challenge in quantum computing. Here, we present an approach based on applying a desired unitary computation in superposition between the system of interest and some auxiliary states. We demonstrate, numerically and on the IBM Quantum Platform, that parallel applications of the same operation lead to significant noise mitigation when arbitrary noise processes are considered. We first design probabilistic implementations of our scheme that are plug and play, independent of the noise characteristic and require no postprocessing. We then enhance the success probability (up to deterministic) using adaptive corrections. We provide an analysis of our protocol performance and demonstrate that unit fidelity can be achieved asymptotically. Our approaches are suitable to both standard gate-based and measurement-based computational models.
Using near-term quantum computers to achieve a quantum advantage requires efficient strategies to improve the performance of the noisy quantum devices presently available. We develop and experimentally validate two efficient error mitigation protocols named ``Noiseless Output Extrapolation" and ``Pauli Error Cancellation" that can drastically enhance the performance of quantum circuits composed of noisy cycles of gates. By combining popular mitigation strategies such as probabilistic error cancellation and noise amplification with efficient noise reconstruction methods, our protocols can mitigate a wide range of noise processes that do not satisfy the assumptions underlying existing mitigation protocols, including non-local and gate-dependent processes. We test our protocols on a four-qubit superconducting processor at the Advanced Quantum Testbed. We observe significant improvements in the performance of both structured and random circuits, with up to 86% improvement in variation distance over the unmitigated outputs. Our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our protocols, as well as their practicality for current hardware platforms.
Abstract Quantum measurements are crucial for extracting information from quantum systems, but they are error-prone due to hardware imperfections in near-term devices. Measurement errors can be mitigated through classical post-processing, based on the assumption of a classical noise model. However, the coherence of quantum measurements leads to unavoidable quantum noise that defies this assumption. In this work, we introduce a two-stage procedure to systematically tackle such quantum noise in measurements. The idea is intuitive: we first detect and then eliminate quantum noise. In the first stage, inspired by coherence witness in the resource theory of quantum coherence, we design an efficient method to detect quantum noise. It works by fitting the difference between two measurement statistics to the Fourier series, where the statistics are obtained using maximally coherent states with relative phase and maximally mixed states as inputs. The fitting coefficients quantitatively benchmark quantum noise. In the second stage, we design various methods to eliminate quantum noise, inspired by the Pauli twirling technique. They work by executing randomly sampled Pauli gates before the measurement device and conditionally flipping the measurement outcomes in such a way that the effective measurement device contains only classical noise. We numerically demonstrate the two-stage procedure’s feasibility on the Baidu Quantum Platform. Notably, the results reveal significant suppression of quantum noise in measurement devices and substantial enhancement in quantum computation accuracy. We highlight that the two-stage procedure complements existing measurement error mitigation techniques, and they together form a standard toolbox for manipulating measurement errors in near-term quantum devices.
Abstract Quantum computing has recently emerged as a novel paradigm for solving problems otherwise intractable on classical computers, yet the practical progress of quantum computers is severely impacted by noise, decoherence, and imperfect gate operations in Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices. Specific to IBM Quantum hardware, imperfections due to readout error, gate errors, and device drift, which depends on time, resolves limits for the accuracy of outputs from our algorithms. The mitigation strategies currently used, for example, Measurement Error Mitigation (MEM), Zero Noise Extrapolation (ZNE), and Clifford Data Regression (CDR), offer improvement over raw, unmitigated outputs, but they are static and not dynamic; the reduction of noise in within an NISQ device is temporal and can vary in patterns that are non-zero. In addition to this, using the conventional methods provides inconsistent and suboptimal results.This study will provide enhanced reliability with respect to performing quantum computation on IBM Quantum hardware with a unique mitigation framework that is adaptive and computationally efficient for a high-fidelity output. The problem taken on here is the failure of existing error mitigation strategies to provide adaptive noise compensation, as they assume a statically-distributed error, despite the performance-related characteristics already being documented in regards to calibration drift and variation over time.To achieve this, we propose a Hybrid Adaptive Error Mitigation (HAEM) approach that includes baseline measurement error mitigation and an additional correction layer that utilizes realtime calibration information, along with lightweight machine learning models. The approach can be broken down into three steps: (i) perform standard measurement error mitigation to reduce classical readout noise, (ii) execute compact calibration circuits, such as Bell states, GHZ states and Clifford benchmarks to capture then current error profile of the device, and (iii) use a lightweight machine learning model (having been trained on historical and newest calibration data) to dynamically change the mitigation weights applied for the target quantum algorithm. All implementation is done using Qiskit Runtime to ensure low-latency execution, and we completed experiments on both Qiskit Aer noisy simulators and IBM Quantum devices.Initial results suggest HAEM improved the outputs of quantum algorithms' fidelity compared to the unmitigated runs and the baseline measurement error mitigation (MEM) runs. On the noisy simulators, HAEM increased fidelity from a raw performance of 0.65 to 0.87, nearly a 34% improvement. In fairer hardware-like scenarios, fidelity-on-average was persistently 12% better than MEM, with nearly equal time duration for the additional adaptive measurements. The adaptive aspect of HAEM consistently supported subsequent calibration cycles of the device and was effective to continue providing fidelity improvements despite the static mitigation performance degrading.To sum up, the proposed HAEM framework is a modern and viable alternative for error mitigation which brings together the benefits of baseline approaches with corrections that are driven by fixed-function error-corrective, adaptive learning. As both learning-based and standard baseline approaches can only achieve fixed levels of performance, HAEM, through its use of noise mitigation both at execution time and through correlating it with standard data, provides a route towards reliable quantum computations on current IBM hardware. HAEM also presents a contribution to the NISQ error-resilient landscape, and however it is intended that it will continue to improve future applications of hybrid workflows of quantum and classical computation where error mitigation and resilience is important.
With sub-threshold quantum error correction on quantum hardware still out of reach, quantum error mitigation methods are currently deemed an attractive option for implementing certain applications on near-term noisy quantum devices. One such application is quantum routing - the ability to map an incoming quantum signal into a superposition of paths. In this work, we use a 7-qubit IBM quantum device to experimentally deploy two promising quantum error mitigation methods, Zero-Noise Extrapolation (ZNE) and Probabilistic Error Cancellation (PEC), in the context of quantum routing. Importantly, beyond investigating the improved performance of quantum routing via ZNE and PEC separately, we also investigate the routing performance provided by the concatenation of these two error-mitigation methods. Our experimental results demonstrate that such concatenation leads a very significant performance improvement relative to implementation with no error mitigation. Indeed, an almost perfect performance in terms of fidelity of the output entangled paths is found. These new results reveal that with concatenated quantum error-mitigation embedded, useful quantum routing becomes feasible on current devices without the need for quantum error correction - opening up a potential implementation pathway to other applications that utilize a superposition of communication links.
In the current era of Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) technology, the practical use of quantum computers remains inhibited by our inability to aptly decouple qubits from their environment to mitigate computational errors. In this work, we introduce an approach by which knowledge of a qubit's initial quantum state and the standard parameters describing its decoherence can be leveraged to mitigate the noise present during the execution of a single-qubit gate. We benchmark our protocol using cloud-based access to IBM quantum processors. On ibmq_rome, we demonstrate a reduction of the single-qubit error rate by 38%, from 1.6×10−3 to 1.0×10−3, provided the initial state of the input qubit is known. On ibmq_bogota, we prove that our protocol will never decrease gate fidelity, provided the system's T1 and T2 times have not drifted above 100 times their assumed values. The protocol can be used to reduce quantum state preparation errors, as well as to improve the fidelity of quantum circuits for which some knowledge of the qubits' intermediate states can be inferred. This work presents a pathway to using information about noise levels and quantum state distributions to significantly reduce error rates associated with quantum gates via optimized decomposition into native gates.