Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2304.05539 · Physical Review Research

Bayesian minimum mean square error for transmissivity sensing

Boyu Zhou, Boulat A. Bash, Saikat Guha, Christos N. Gagatsos

Published Oct 11, 2023• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We address the problem of estimating the transmissivity of the pure-loss single-mode bosonic channel from the Bayesian point of view, i.e., when a prior probability distribution function (PDF) on the transmissivity is available. We compute the quantum limit of the Bayesian minimum mean square error of estimating transmissivity. Specifically, we consider two prior PDFs: the two-point distribution (relevant for reading from an optical drive) and the beta distribution (relevant for imaging a reflective pixelated scene). If the probe's mean photon number is an integer, for the two-point PDF we prove that the optimal probe is a Fock state and the optimal measurement is photon counting, while for the beta PDF our numerical results provide evidence on the optimality of the Fock state probe and photon counting. When the probe's mean photon number is any (nonnegative) real number, we conjecture the form of the optimal probe state and we study the performance of photon counting, which is a suboptimal yet practical measurement. Our methods can be applied for any prior PDF. We discuss how different precision metrics and priors on the parameter influence the quantum-optimal probe and measurement. To our knowledge, these results on transmissivity estimation with quantum-limited precision represent the first Bayesian analysis of the problem.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.5.043033

Related papers

Bayesian quantum phase estimation with fixed photon states

Boyu Zhou, Saikat Guha, Christos N. Gagatsos

We consider a two-mode bosonic state with fixed photon number $$n \in \mathbb {N}$$ , whose upper and lower modes pick up a phase $$\phi $$ and $$-\phi $$ , respectively. We compute the optimal Fock coefficients of the input state, such that the mean square error (MSE) for estimating $$\phi $$ is minimized, while the minimum MSE is always attainable by a measurement. Our setting is Bayesian, i.e., we consider $$\phi $$ to be a random variable that follows a prior probability distribution function (PDF). Initially, we consider the flat prior PDF and we discuss the well-known fact that the MSE is not an informative tool for estimating a phase when the variance of the prior PDF is large. Therefore, we move on to study truncated versions of the flat prior in both single-shot and adaptive approaches. For our adaptive technique, we consider $$n=1$$ and truncated prior PDFs. Each subsequent step utilizes as prior PDF the posterior probability of the previous step, and at the same time we update the optimal state and optimal measurement.

arXiv:2308.01293•Quantum Information Processing•Oct 28, 2024•3 citations

Quantum-Inspired Multi-Parameter Adaptive Bayesian Estimation for Sensing and Imaging

Kwan K. Lee, Christos N. Gagatsos, Saikat Guha +1 more

It is well known in Bayesian estimation theory that the conditional estimator attains the minimum mean squared error (MMSE) for estimating a scalar parameter of interest. In quantum, e.g., optical and atomic, imaging and sensing tasks the user has access to the quantum state that encodes the parameter. The choice of a measurement operator, i.e. a positive-operator valued measure (POVM), leads to a measurement outcome on which the aforesaid classical MMSE estimator is employed. Personick found the optimum POVM that attains the MMSE over all possible physically allowable measurements and the resulting MMSE (Personick, 1997). This result from 1971 is less-widely known than the quantum Fisher information (QFI), which lower bounds the variance of an unbiased estimator over all measurements without considering any prior probability. For multi-parameter estimation, in quantum Fisher estimation theory the inverse of the QFI matrix provides an operator lower bound on the covariance of an unbiased estimator, and this bound is understood in the positive semidefinite sense. However, there has been little work on quantifying the quantum limits and measurement designs, for multi-parameter quantum estimation in aBayesiansetting. In this work, we build upon Personick's result to construct a Bayesian adaptive (greedy) measurement scheme for multi-parameter estimation. We illustrate our proposed measurement scheme with the application of localizing a cluster of point emitters in a highly sub-Rayleigh angular field-of-view, an important problem in fluorescence microscopy and astronomy. Our algorithm translates to a multi-spatial-mode transformation prior to a photon-detection array, with electro-optic feedback to adapt the mode sorter. We show that this receiver performs superior to quantum-noise-limited focal-plane direct imaging.

IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Signal Processing•Oct 14, 2022•26 citations

Quantum Multi-Parameter Adaptive Bayesian Estimation and Application to Super-Resolution Imaging

Kwan Kit Lee, Christos N. Gagatsos, Saikat Guha +1 more

In Bayesian estimation theory, the estimator ${\hat θ} = E[θ|l]$ attains the minimum mean squared error (MMSE) for estimating a scalar parameter of interest $θ$ from the observation of $l$ through a noisy channel $P_{l|θ}$, given a prior $P_θ$ on $θ$. In quantum sensing tasks, the user gets $ρ_θ$, the quantum state that encodes $θ$. They choose a measurement, a positive-operator valued measure (POVM) $Π_l$, which induces the channel $P_{l|θ} = {\rm Tr}(ρ_θΠ_l)$ to the measurement outcome $l$, on which the aforesaid classical MMSE estimator is employed. Personick found the optimum POVM $Π_l$ that minimizes the MMSE over all possible measurements, and that MMSE. This result from 1971 is less-widely known than the quantum Fisher information (QFI), which lower bounds the variance of an unbiased estimator over all measurements, when $P_θ$ is unavailable. For multi-parameter estimation, i.e., when $θ$ is a vector, in Fisher quantum estimation theory, the inverse of the QFI matrix provides an operator lower bound to the covariance of an unbiased estimator. However, there has been little work on quantifying quantum limits and measurement designs, for multi-parameter quantum estimation in the {\em Bayesian} setting. In this paper, we build upon Personick's result to construct a Bayesian adaptive measurement scheme for multi-parameter estimation when $N$ copies of $ρ_θ$ are available. We illustrate an application to localizing a cluster of point emitters in a highly sub-Rayleigh angular field-of-view, an important problem in fluorescence microscopy and astronomy. Our algorithm translates to a multi-spatial-mode transformation prior to a photon-detection array, with electro-optic feedback to adapt the mode sorter. We show that this receiver performs far superior to quantum-noise-limited focal-plane direct imaging.

arXiv:2202.09980•Feb 21, 2022•1 citation

Bounding the quantum limits of precision for phase estimation with loss and thermal noise

Christos N. Gagatsos, Boulat A. Bash, Saikat Guha +1 more

We consider the problem of estimating an unknown but constant carrier phase modulation $\ensuremath{\theta}$ using a general, possibly entangled, $n$-mode optical probe through $n$ independent and identical uses of a lossy bosonic channel with additive thermal noise. We find an upper bound to the quantum Fisher information (QFI) of estimating $\ensuremath{\theta}$ as a function of $n$, the mean and variance of the total number of photons ${N}_{\mathrm{S}}$ in the $n$-mode probe, the transmissivity $\ensuremath{\eta}$, and mean thermal photon number per mode ${\overline{n}}_{\mathrm{B}}$ of the bosonic channel. Since the inverse of QFI provides a lower bound to the mean-square error (MSE) of an unbiased estimator $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ of $\ensuremath{\theta}$, our upper bound to the QFI provides a lower bound to the MSE. It already has found use in proving fundamental limits of covert sensing and could find other applications requiring bounding the fundamental limits of sensing an unknown parameter embedded in a correlated field.

arXiv:1701.05518•Physical Review A•Dec 4, 2017•22 citations

Bayesian quantum estimation of the separation of two incoherent point sources

Boyu Zhou, Saikat Guha, Christos N. Gagatsos

We examine the problem of estimating the separation between two arbitrarily close incoherent point sources from a quantum Bayesian perspective—that is, assuming the availability of a prior probability distribution function (PDF) for the separation. In particular, we consider both non-displaced and displaced half-Gaussian prior PDFs to evaluate the performance of Hermite–Gauss spatial mode demultiplexing (HG-SPADE) and direct imaging (DI). By employing the Bayesian minimum mean square error criterion, which is always attainable by a different kind of spatial demultiplexing, we compare the effectiveness of HG-SPADE and DI and analyze how variations in the parameters of the prior PDF influence the conditions under which one method outperforms the other.

arXiv:2412.05245•APL Quantum•Oct 6, 2025•1 citation

Bayesian estimation of quantum optical phase by photon counting

David Rimmer, William J. Fitzgerald

Single photon count distributions at the outputs of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer are highly dependent on the phase difference between the two arms of the apparatus, so photocount records can be used to estimate an unknown optical phase. Experimental results have shown that phase information can be inferred from the data even at low mean input intensities of ⪅10 photons. Here we consider the optimal Bayesian parameter estimate for the model used by a previous frequentist analysis. In the limit of high input intensity the observation is well-modelled as an intensity measurement of a classical wave in Gaussian measurement noise, however in the low intensity regime this simple model does not apply. It seems that no generally valid closed-form estimator for this problem exists without making the Gaussian approximation. Moreover the 2π radian ambiguity in phase estimates presents a problem in defining cost functions to compare estimator performance, and we consider two reasonable alternatives. We present a numerical study of the experiment along with a novel numerical approach to this problem which out-performs the existing estimators and with a squared error that approaches the Cramer-Rao lower bound previously derived in the literature, in the limit where that bound is valid.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•May 25, 2004•0 citations
We address the problem of estimating the transmissivity of the pure-loss single-mode bosonic channel from the Bayesian point of view, i.e., when a prior probability distribution function (PDF) on the transmissivity is available. We compute the quantum limit of the Bayesian minimum mean square error of estimating transmissivity. Specifically, we consider two prior PDFs: the two-point distribution (relevant for reading from an optical drive) and the beta distribution (relevant for imaging a reflective pixelated scene). If the probe's mean photon number is an integer, for the two-point PDF we prove that the optimal probe is a Fock state and the optimal measurement is photon counting, while for the beta PDF our numerical results provide evidence on the optimality of the Fock state probe and photon counting. When the probe's mean photon number is any (nonnegative) real number, we conjecture the form of the optimal probe state and we study the performance of photon counting, which is a suboptimal yet practical measurement. Our methods can be applied for any prior PDF. We discuss how different precision metrics and priors on the parameter influence the quantum-optimal probe and measurement. To our knowledge, these results on transmissivity estimation with quantum-limited precision represent the first Bayesian analysis of the problem.
We consider a two-mode bosonic state with fixed photon number n∈Nn \in \mathbb {N}n∈N , whose upper and lower modes pick up a phase ϕ\phi ϕ and −ϕ-\phi −ϕ , respectively. We compute the optimal Fock coefficients of the input state, such that the mean square error (MSE) for estimating ϕ\phi ϕ is minimized, while the minimum MSE is always attainable by a measurement. Our setting is Bayesian, i.e., we consider ϕ\phi ϕ to be a random variable that follows a prior probability distribution function (PDF). Initially, we consider the flat prior PDF and we discuss the well-known fact that the MSE is not an informative tool for estimating a phase when the variance of the prior PDF is large. Therefore, we move on to study truncated versions of the flat prior in both single-shot and adaptive approaches. For our adaptive technique, we consider n=1n=1n=1 and truncated prior PDFs. Each subsequent step utilizes as prior PDF the posterior probability of the previous step, and at the same time we update the optimal state and optimal measurement.
It is well known in Bayesian estimation theory that the conditional estimator attains the minimum mean squared error (MMSE) for estimating a scalar parameter of interest. In quantum, e.g., optical and atomic, imaging and sensing tasks the user has access to the quantum state that encodes the parameter. The choice of a measurement operator, i.e. a positive-operator valued measure (POVM), leads to a measurement outcome on which the aforesaid classical MMSE estimator is employed. Personick found the optimum POVM that attains the MMSE over all possible physically allowable measurements and the resulting MMSE (Personick, 1997). This result from 1971 is less-widely known than the quantum Fisher information (QFI), which lower bounds the variance of an unbiased estimator over all measurements without considering any prior probability. For multi-parameter estimation, in quantum Fisher estimation theory the inverse of the QFI matrix provides an operator lower bound on the covariance of an unbiased estimator, and this bound is understood in the positive semidefinite sense. However, there has been little work on quantifying the quantum limits and measurement designs, for multi-parameter quantum estimation in aBayesiansetting. In this work, we build upon Personick's result to construct a Bayesian adaptive (greedy) measurement scheme for multi-parameter estimation. We illustrate our proposed measurement scheme with the application of localizing a cluster of point emitters in a highly sub-Rayleigh angular field-of-view, an important problem in fluorescence microscopy and astronomy. Our algorithm translates to a multi-spatial-mode transformation prior to a photon-detection array, with electro-optic feedback to adapt the mode sorter. We show that this receiver performs superior to quantum-noise-limited focal-plane direct imaging.
In Bayesian estimation theory, the estimator θ^=E[θ∣l]{\hat θ} = E[θ|l]θ^=E[θ∣l] attains the minimum mean squared error (MMSE) for estimating a scalar parameter of interest θθθ from the observation of lll through a noisy channel Pl∣θP_{l|θ}Pl∣θ​, given a prior PθP_θPθ​ on θθθ. In quantum sensing tasks, the user gets ρθρ_θρθ​, the quantum state that encodes θθθ. They choose a measurement, a positive-operator valued measure (POVM) ΠlΠ_lΠl​, which induces the channel Pl∣θ=Tr(ρθΠl)P_{l|θ} = {\rm Tr}(ρ_θΠ_l)Pl∣θ​=Tr(ρθ​Πl​) to the measurement outcome lll, on which the aforesaid classical MMSE estimator is employed. Personick found the optimum POVM ΠlΠ_lΠl​ that minimizes the MMSE over all possible measurements, and that MMSE. This result from 1971 is less-widely known than the quantum Fisher information (QFI), which lower bounds the variance of an unbiased estimator over all measurements, when PθP_θPθ​ is unavailable. For multi-parameter estimation, i.e., when θθθ is a vector, in Fisher quantum estimation theory, the inverse of the QFI matrix provides an operator lower bound to the covariance of an unbiased estimator. However, there has been little work on quantifying quantum limits and measurement designs, for multi-parameter quantum estimation in the {\em Bayesian} setting. In this paper, we build upon Personick's result to construct a Bayesian adaptive measurement scheme for multi-parameter estimation when NNN copies of ρθρ_θρθ​ are available. We illustrate an application to localizing a cluster of point emitters in a highly sub-Rayleigh angular field-of-view, an important problem in fluorescence microscopy and astronomy. Our algorithm translates to a multi-spatial-mode transformation prior to a photon-detection array, with electro-optic feedback to adapt the mode sorter. We show that this receiver performs far superior to quantum-noise-limited focal-plane direct imaging.
We consider the problem of estimating an unknown but constant carrier phase modulation $\ensuremath{\theta}$ using a general, possibly entangled, nnn-mode optical probe through nnn independent and identical uses of a lossy bosonic channel with additive thermal noise. We find an upper bound to the quantum Fisher information (QFI) of estimating $\ensuremath{\theta}$ as a function of nnn, the mean and variance of the total number of photons NS{N}_{\mathrm{S}}NS​ in the nnn-mode probe, the transmissivity $\ensuremath{\eta}$, and mean thermal photon number per mode n‾B{\overline{n}}_{\mathrm{B}}nB​ of the bosonic channel. Since the inverse of QFI provides a lower bound to the mean-square error (MSE) of an unbiased estimator $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ of $\ensuremath{\theta}$, our upper bound to the QFI provides a lower bound to the MSE. It already has found use in proving fundamental limits of covert sensing and could find other applications requiring bounding the fundamental limits of sensing an unknown parameter embedded in a correlated field.
We examine the problem of estimating the separation between two arbitrarily close incoherent point sources from a quantum Bayesian perspective—that is, assuming the availability of a prior probability distribution function (PDF) for the separation. In particular, we consider both non-displaced and displaced half-Gaussian prior PDFs to evaluate the performance of Hermite–Gauss spatial mode demultiplexing (HG-SPADE) and direct imaging (DI). By employing the Bayesian minimum mean square error criterion, which is always attainable by a different kind of spatial demultiplexing, we compare the effectiveness of HG-SPADE and DI and analyze how variations in the parameters of the prior PDF influence the conditions under which one method outperforms the other.
Single photon count distributions at the outputs of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer are highly dependent on the phase difference between the two arms of the apparatus, so photocount records can be used to estimate an unknown optical phase. Experimental results have shown that phase information can be inferred from the data even at low mean input intensities of ⪅10 photons. Here we consider the optimal Bayesian parameter estimate for the model used by a previous frequentist analysis. In the limit of high input intensity the observation is well-modelled as an intensity measurement of a classical wave in Gaussian measurement noise, however in the low intensity regime this simple model does not apply. It seems that no generally valid closed-form estimator for this problem exists without making the Gaussian approximation. Moreover the 2π radian ambiguity in phase estimates presents a problem in defining cost functions to compare estimator performance, and we consider two reasonable alternatives. We present a numerical study of the experiment along with a novel numerical approach to this problem which out-performs the existing estimators and with a squared error that approaches the Cramer-Rao lower bound previously derived in the literature, in the limit where that bound is valid.