Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2304.03366 · IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control

Performance Bounds for Quantum Feedback Control

Flemming Holtorf, Frank Schäfer, Julian Arnold, Christopher Rackauckas, Alan S. Edelman

Published Jun 18, 2024• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The limits of quantum feedback control have immediate consequences for quantum information science at large, yet remain largely unexplored. Here, we combine quantum filtering theory and moment-sum-of-squares techniques to construct a hierarchy of convex optimization problems that furnish monotonically improving, computable bounds on the best attainable performance for a broad class of quantum feedback control problems. These bounds may serve as witnesses of fundamental limitations, optimality certificates, or performance targets. We prove convergence of the bounds to the optimal control performance under technical conditions and demonstrate the practical utility of our approach by designing certifiably near-optimal controllers for a qubit in a cavity subjected to photon counting and homodyne detection measurements.

DOI
10.1109/tac.2024.3416008

Related papers

Sum-of-Squares Bounds for Quantum Optimal Control

Flemming Holtorf, Frank Schäfer, Julian Arnold +2 more

The precise control of devices on the quantum scale is crucial for all quantum computing applications. The limitations of quantum control are therefore of great interest to those developing quantum hardware or researching quantum information protocols. We show how moment-sum-of-squares techniques can be combined with quantum dynamics and filtering theory to construct a hierarchy of convex optimization problems that furnish hard, computable bounds on the best achievable performance in quantum control tasks. These bounds can serve as witnesses of fundamental limitations, certificates of optimality, or performance targets and thus complement existing controller design strategies. In particular, our work allows us to compute bounds for common quantum control tasks, such as maximizing the fidelity of the final quantum state relative to a target state given a finite time budget or finding the minimum time required to reach the target state with near-unit fidelity. Our work also naturally applies to feedback-controlled quantum systems subjected to continuous observations, e.g., homodyne detection or photon counting, which are of emerging interest for the next generation of quantum devices. We provide an open-source package, MarkovBounds.jl, that is built upon the optimization ecosystem in the Julia programming language and exposes a high-level interface to the proposed bounding framework.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 17, 2023•0 citations

Replacing quantum feedback with open-loop control and quantum filtering

Joshua Combes, Howard M. Wiseman, A. J. Scott

Feedback control protocols can stabilize and enhance the operation of quantum devices, however, unavoidable delays in the feedback loop adversely affect their performance. We introduce a quantum control methodology, combining open-loop control with quantum filtering, which is not constrained by feedback delays. For the problems studied (rapid purification and rapid measurement) we analytically derive lower bounds on the control performance that are comparable with the best corresponding bounds for feedback protocols.

arXiv:0908.0198•Physical Review A•Feb 4, 2010•21 citations

Quantum control and Quantum information

Mohan Sarovar

Quantum information science has blossomed into a major research field over the past decade or so. In doing so, it has established links with several other areas of physics, computer science, and engineering. One of these areas is quantum control – the extension of control theory to physical systems whose dynamics are governed by quantum mechanics. Quantum control, like quantum information, is a fairly young field with remarkable technological consequences, and this cross-pollination is proving to be stimulating. In this thesis we explore some of the connections between quantum information and quantum control. In particular, (i) we examine quantum error correction from a quantum feedback control perspective, and demonstrate new continuous time implementations of quantum error correcting codes; (ii) we consider performing quantum feedback control experiments on a solid-state quantum computing architecture – circuit QED – and propose new measurement schemes that would enable such experiments; and (iii) we consider the problem of optimally estimating quantum processes, and in particular, analyze in detail the problem of optimally estimating a one-parameter quantum process.

•Jan 1, 2007•1 citation

Information Theoretical Limits on Quantum Control

Shiro Kawabata

Fundamental limits on the controllability of quantum mechanical systems are discussed in the light of quantum information theory. It is shown that the amount of entropy-reduction that can be extracted from a quantum system by feedback controller is upper bounded by a sum of the decrease of entropy achievable in open-loop control and the mutual information between the quantum system and the controller. This upper bound sets a fundamental limit on the performance of any quantum controllers whose designs are based on the possibilities to attain low entropy states.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Jan 1, 2003•1 citation

Information-theoretical approach to control of quantum-mechanical systems

Shiro Kawabata

Fundamental limits on the controllability of quantum mechanical systems are discussed in the light of quantum information theory. It is shown that the amount of entropy-reduction that can be extracted from a quantum system by feedback controller is upper bounded by a sum of the decrease of entropy achievable in open-loop control and the mutual information between the quantum system and the controller. This upper bound sets a fundamental limit on the performance of any quantum controllers whose designs are based on the possibilities to attain low entropy states. An application of this approach pertaining to quantum error correction is also discussed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0409187•Physical Review A•Dec 17, 2003•4 citations

Finite de Finetti for convex bodies and Polynomial Optimization

Julius A. Zeiss, Gereon Koßmann, René Schwonnek +1 more

Leveraging a recently proposed notion of relative entropy in general probabilistic theories (GPT), we prove a finite de Finetti representation theorem for general convex bodies. We apply this result to address a fundamental question in polynomial optimization: the existence of a convergent outer hierarchy for problems with inequality constraints and analytical convergence guarantees. Our strategy generalizes a quantitative monogamy-of-entanglement argument from quantum theory to arbitrary convex bodies, establishing a uniform upper bound on mutual information in multipartite extensions. This leads to a finite de Finetti theorem and, subsequently, a convergent conic hierarchy for a wide class of polynomial optimization problems subject to both equality and inequality constraints. We further provide a constructive rounding scheme that yields certified interior points with controlled approximation error. As an application, we express the optimal GPT value of a two-player non-local game as a polynomial optimization problem, allowing our techniques to produce approximation schemes with finite convergence guarantees.

math.OCCross-listedarXiv:2601.15184•Jan 22, 2026•0 citations
The limits of quantum feedback control have immediate consequences for quantum information science at large, yet remain largely unexplored. Here, we combine quantum filtering theory and moment-sum-of-squares techniques to construct a hierarchy of convex optimization problems that furnish monotonically improving, computable bounds on the best attainable performance for a broad class of quantum feedback control problems. These bounds may serve as witnesses of fundamental limitations, optimality certificates, or performance targets. We prove convergence of the bounds to the optimal control performance under technical conditions and demonstrate the practical utility of our approach by designing certifiably near-optimal controllers for a qubit in a cavity subjected to photon counting and homodyne detection measurements.
The precise control of devices on the quantum scale is crucial for all quantum computing applications. The limitations of quantum control are therefore of great interest to those developing quantum hardware or researching quantum information protocols. We show how moment-sum-of-squares techniques can be combined with quantum dynamics and filtering theory to construct a hierarchy of convex optimization problems that furnish hard, computable bounds on the best achievable performance in quantum control tasks. These bounds can serve as witnesses of fundamental limitations, certificates of optimality, or performance targets and thus complement existing controller design strategies. In particular, our work allows us to compute bounds for common quantum control tasks, such as maximizing the fidelity of the final quantum state relative to a target state given a finite time budget or finding the minimum time required to reach the target state with near-unit fidelity. Our work also naturally applies to feedback-controlled quantum systems subjected to continuous observations, e.g., homodyne detection or photon counting, which are of emerging interest for the next generation of quantum devices. We provide an open-source package, MarkovBounds.jl, that is built upon the optimization ecosystem in the Julia programming language and exposes a high-level interface to the proposed bounding framework.
Feedback control protocols can stabilize and enhance the operation of quantum devices, however, unavoidable delays in the feedback loop adversely affect their performance. We introduce a quantum control methodology, combining open-loop control with quantum filtering, which is not constrained by feedback delays. For the problems studied (rapid purification and rapid measurement) we analytically derive lower bounds on the control performance that are comparable with the best corresponding bounds for feedback protocols.
Quantum information science has blossomed into a major research field over the past decade or so. In doing so, it has established links with several other areas of physics, computer science, and engineering. One of these areas is quantum control – the extension of control theory to physical systems whose dynamics are governed by quantum mechanics. Quantum control, like quantum information, is a fairly young field with remarkable technological consequences, and this cross-pollination is proving to be stimulating. In this thesis we explore some of the connections between quantum information and quantum control. In particular, (i) we examine quantum error correction from a quantum feedback control perspective, and demonstrate new continuous time implementations of quantum error correcting codes; (ii) we consider performing quantum feedback control experiments on a solid-state quantum computing architecture – circuit QED – and propose new measurement schemes that would enable such experiments; and (iii) we consider the problem of optimally estimating quantum processes, and in particular, analyze in detail the problem of optimally estimating a one-parameter quantum process.
Fundamental limits on the controllability of quantum mechanical systems are discussed in the light of quantum information theory. It is shown that the amount of entropy-reduction that can be extracted from a quantum system by feedback controller is upper bounded by a sum of the decrease of entropy achievable in open-loop control and the mutual information between the quantum system and the controller. This upper bound sets a fundamental limit on the performance of any quantum controllers whose designs are based on the possibilities to attain low entropy states.
Fundamental limits on the controllability of quantum mechanical systems are discussed in the light of quantum information theory. It is shown that the amount of entropy-reduction that can be extracted from a quantum system by feedback controller is upper bounded by a sum of the decrease of entropy achievable in open-loop control and the mutual information between the quantum system and the controller. This upper bound sets a fundamental limit on the performance of any quantum controllers whose designs are based on the possibilities to attain low entropy states. An application of this approach pertaining to quantum error correction is also discussed.
Leveraging a recently proposed notion of relative entropy in general probabilistic theories (GPT), we prove a finite de Finetti representation theorem for general convex bodies. We apply this result to address a fundamental question in polynomial optimization: the existence of a convergent outer hierarchy for problems with inequality constraints and analytical convergence guarantees. Our strategy generalizes a quantitative monogamy-of-entanglement argument from quantum theory to arbitrary convex bodies, establishing a uniform upper bound on mutual information in multipartite extensions. This leads to a finite de Finetti theorem and, subsequently, a convergent conic hierarchy for a wide class of polynomial optimization problems subject to both equality and inequality constraints. We further provide a constructive rounding scheme that yields certified interior points with controlled approximation error. As an application, we express the optimal GPT value of a two-player non-local game as a polynomial optimization problem, allowing our techniques to produce approximation schemes with finite convergence guarantees.