We present a quantum annealing-based solution method for topology optimization (TO). In particular, we consider TO in a more general setting, i.e., applied to structures of continuum domains where designs are represented as distributed functions, referred to as continuum TO problems. According to the problem's properties and structure, we formulate appropriate sub-problems that can be solved on an annealing-based quantum computer. The methodology established can effectively tackle continuum TO problems formulated as mixed-integer nonlinear programs. To maintain the resulting sub-problems small enough to be solved on quantum computers currently accessible with small numbers of qubits and limited connectivity, we further develop a splitting approach that splits the problem into two parts: the first part can be efficiently solved on classical computers, and the second part with a reduced number of variables is solved on a quantum computer. By such, a practical continuum TO problem of varying scales can be handled on the D-Wave quantum annealer. More specifically, we concern the minimum compliance, a canonical TO problem that seeks an optimal distribution of materials to minimize the compliance with desired material usage. The superior performance of the developed methodology is assessed and compared with the stateof-the-art heuristic classical methods, in terms of both solution quality and computational efficiency. The present work hence provides a promising new avenue of applying quantum computing to practical designs of topology for various applications.
We present a quantum annealing-based solution method for topology optimization (TO). In particular, we consider TO in a more general setting, i.e., applied to structures of continuum domains where designs are represented as distributed functions, referred to as continuum TO problems. According to the problem's properties and structure, we formulate appropriate sub-problems that can be solved on an annealing-based quantum computer. The methodology established can effectively tackle continuum TO problems formulated as mixed-integer nonlinear programs. To maintain the resulting sub-problems small enough to be solved on quantum computers currently accessible with small numbers of qubits and limited connectivity, we further develop a splitting approach that splits the problem into two parts: the first part can be efficiently solved on classical computers, and the second part with a reduced number of variables is solved on a quantum computer. By such, a practical continuum TO problem of varying scales can be handled on the D-Wave quantum annealer. More specifically, we concern the minimum compliance, a canonical TO problem that seeks an optimal distribution of materials to minimize the compliance with desired material usage. The superior performance of the developed methodology is assessed and compared with the stateof-the-art heuristic classical methods, in terms of both solution quality and computational efficiency. The present work hence provides a promising new avenue of applying quantum computing to practical designs of topology for various applications.
Quantum computing has emerged as a promising computational paradigm with the potential to solve problems that are intractable for classical computers. This paper provides an overview of the current state of quantum computing, including its historical development, hardware advancements, applications, and challenges. Special attention is given to combinatorial optimization, which is considered one of the most promising application domains. The limitations of current quantum systems and future research directions are also discussed. This paper presents a comparative study between a conventional D-Wave-based simulated annealing approach and a proposed hybrid optimization model for solving largescale combinatorial optimization problems. The study focuses on benchmark problems, including AES, TSP gr24, and a real-world load balancing problem, all formulated as QUBO models. The D-Wave approach employs the dwave-neal simulated annealing engine with various parameter settings, while the proposed model introduces a decomposition-based framework combined with adaptive parameter control and iterative refinement. The experimental results demonstrate that the proposed model consistently outperforms the conventional approach in terms of solution quality, achieving significantly lower energy values across all problem instances. In particular, for the TSP gr24 problem, the proposed model achieves near-optimal solutions with substantially reduced computation time. For large-scale problems such as AES and load balancing, the proposed model maintains scalability and robustness, whereas the conventional approach suffers from increased computational cost and performance degradation. Although the proposed method introduces additional computational steps, its hybrid structure effectively mitigates limitations related to local minima, parameter sensitivity, and scalability. These findings indicate that integrating classical optimization techniques with quantum-inspired methods is essential for practical applications. The proposed model provides a promising framework for solving complex real-world optimization problems and highlights the importance of hybrid approaches in advancing quantum annealing technologies.
Abstract As a typical quantum computing algorithm, quantum annealing is widely used in the optimization of glass-like problems to find the best solution. However, the optimization problems in constrained complex systems usually involve topological structures, and the performance of the quantum annealing algorithm is still largely unknown. Here, we take an Ising system as a typical example with local constraints accompanied by intrinsic topological properties that can be implemented on quantum computing platforms such as the D-wave machine, and study the effectiveness of the quantum annealing algorithm in its optimization and compare it with that of the thermal annealing. We find that although conventional quantum annealing is difficult for the optimization of constrained topological problems, a generalized algorithm --- the sweeping quantum annealing method --- can be designed and solve the problem with better efficiency than both conventional quantum and thermal annealing algorithms. The sweeping quantum annealing algorithm, therefore, opens up a promising avenue for quantum computing of constrained problems and can be readily employed on the optimizations in quantum material design, engineering, and even social sciences.
Quantum computing is a new form of computational technology, which can potentially be used to solve certain problems faster than is possible using classical computers. For this reason, there is an industry drive to develop early quantum computing applications. In this thesis, an overview of quantum computing technologies is provided, along with a practical discussion of the Traveling Salesman Problem, making use of the D-Wave quantum annealer. Subsequently, the main objective of the thesis can be investigated, which is to explore how quantum computing can be used to aid in solving structural optimization problems. Two methods are developed with which simple 2-dimensional truss systems can be optimized using the D-Wave quantum annealer. The methods aim to find the most lightweight choices for the truss cross-sectional areas while complying with material limit stress constraints. The first method directly casts such an optimization problem into a QUBO format. However, due to difficulties with formulating the stress constraint, this method was found to produce a trivial optimization problem. The second method attempts to symbolically solve a truss finite-element problem, using the resulting symbolic expressions to set up an optimization objective function. Although these objective functions are confirmed to work via classical brute-force analysis, the quantum annealer is shown to have difficulty finding the global optimum solution for truss systems with three or more elements. These results indicate that it is not currently beneficial to use quantum annealing for these structural optimization problems. Nevertheless, some improvements to the method for setting up the objective functions are suggested. The next generation of quantum annealers is expected to perform better for these practical applications, potentially becoming a useful tool in the engineering toolbox.
We present a novel formulation of structural design optimization problems specifically tailored to be solved by qa. Structural design optimization aims to find the best, i.e., material-efficient yet high-performance, configuration of a structure. To this end, computational optimization strategies can be employed, where a recently evolving strategy based on quantum mechanical effects is qa. This approach requires the optimization problem to be present, e.g., as a qubo model. Thus, we develop a novel formulation of the optimization problem. The latter typically involves an analysis model for the component. Here, we use energy minimization principles that govern the behavior of structures under applied loads. This allows us to state the optimization problem as one overall minimization problem. Next, we map this to a qubo problem that can be immediately solved by qa. We validate the proposed approach using a size optimization problem of a compound rod under self-weight loading. To this end, we develop strategies to account for the limitations of currently available hardware. Remarkably, for small-scale problems, our approach showcases functionality on today’s hardware such that this study can lay the groundwork for continued exploration of qa’s impact on engineering design optimization problems.
Product development processes frequently use numerical simulations and mathematical programming techniques. Structural optimization, especially topology optimization, is one of the most promising techniques for generating insightful design choices. Topology optimization for discrete structures, such as truss structures, can be formulated as a combinatorial optimization problem, where the combination of the existence or absence of the material is optimized. In this study, we examine the usage of quantum computers as a potential solution to discrete topology optimization problems. The proposed method consists of two variational quantum algorithms (VQAs); the first solves the state equilibrium equation for all possible structures, and the second amplifies the probability of the optimal structure in quantum superposition. Several experiments, including a real device experiment, show that the proposed method successfully obtained the optimal structure. These findings suggest that quantum computers could be a potential tool for solving topology optimization problems.
The recent availability of the first commercial quantum computers has provided a promising tool to tackle NP hard problems which can only be solved heuristically with present techniques. However, it is unclear if the current state of quantum computing already provides a quantum advantage over the current state of the art in classical computing. This article assesses the performance of the D-Wave 2X quantum annealer on two NP hard graph problems, in particular clique finding and graph partitioning. For this, we provide formulations as Qubo and Ising Hamiltonians suitable for the quantum annealer and compare a variety of quantum solvers (Sapi, QBSolv, QSage provided by D-Wave Sys, Inc.) to current classical algorithms (METIS, Simulated Annealing, third-party clique finding and graph splitting heuristics) on certain test sets of graphs. We demonstrate that for small graph instances, classical methods still outperform the quantum annealer in terms of computing time, even though the quality of the best solutions obtained is comparable. Nevertheless, due to the limited problem size which can be embedded on the D-Wave 2X chip, the aforementioned finding applies to most of problems of general nature solvable on the quantum annealer. For instances specifically designed to fit the D-Wave 2X architecture, we observe substantial speed-ups in computing time over classical approaches.