Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2301.06346 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Truncated Wigner approximation for the bosonic model of large spin baths

Mohsen Yarmohammadi, Katrin Bolsmann, Yvonne Ribbeheger, Timo Gräßer, Götz Silvester Uhrig

Published Mar 24, 2023• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The central spin model has a wide applicability. It is ideally suited to describe a small quantum system, for instance a quantum bit, in contact to a bath of spins, e.g., nuclear spins or other small quantum systems in general. According to previous work [R. R\"ohrig et al., Phys. Rev. B 97, 165431 (2018)], a large bath of quantum spins can be described as a bath of quantum harmonic oscillators. But the resulting quantum model is still far from being straightforwardly solvable. Hence we consider a chain representation for the bosonic degrees of freedom to study how well a semi-classical truncated Wigner approximation of the effective model of harmonic oscillators (bTWA) works in comparison with other approximate and exact methods. We find that the bTWA works well for short times, but deviates from the results of other methods for long times. The general message is that the applicability of semi-classical approaches strongly depends on the variables in terms of which the model is formulated. Numerically, we examine the effect of the number of bath spins and of the truncation level, i.e., the chain length.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.107.125421

Related papers

A generalized phase space approach for solving quantum spin dynamics

Bihui Zhu, Ana Maria Rey, Johannes Schachenmayer

Abstract Numerical techniques to efficiently model out-of-equilibrium dynamics in interacting quantum many-body systems are key for advancing our capability to harness and understand complex quantum matter. Here we propose a new numerical approach which we refer to as generalized discrete truncated Wigner approximation (GDTWA). It is based on a discrete semi-classical phase space sampling and allows to investigate quantum dynamics in lattice spin systems with arbitrary S ≥ 1/2. We show that the GDTWA can accurately simulate dynamics of large ensembles in arbitrary dimensions. We apply it for S > 1/2 spin-models with dipolar long-range interactions, a scenario arising in recent experiments with magnetic atoms. We show that the method can capture beyond mean-field effects, not only at short times, but it also can correctly reproduce long time quantum-thermalization dynamics. We benchmark the method with exact diagonalization in small systems, with perturbation theory for short times, and with analytical predictions made for models which feature quantum-thermalization at long times. We apply our method to study dynamics in large S > 1/2 spin-models and compute experimentally accessible observables such as Zeeman level populations, contrast of spin coherence, spin squeezing, and entanglement quantified by single-spin Renyi entropies. We reveal that large S systems can feature larger entanglement than corresponding S = 1/2 systems. Our analyses demonstrate that the GDTWA can be a powerful tool for modeling complex spin dynamics in regimes where other state-of-the art numerical methods fail.

arXiv:1905.08782•New Journal of Physics•Jul 25, 2019•64 citations

Nonequilibrium dynamics of spin-boson models from phase-space methods

Asier Piñeiro Orioli, Arghavan Safavi-Naini, Michael L. Wall +1 more

An accurate description of the nonequilibrium dynamics of systems with coupled spin and bosonic degrees of freedom remains theoretically challenging, especially for large system sizes and in higher than one dimension. Phase-space methods such as the truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) have the advantage of being easily scalable and applicable to arbitrary dimensions. In this work we adapt the TWA to generic spin-boson models by making use of recently developed algorithms for discrete phase spaces [J. Schachenmayer, A. Pikovski, and A. M. Rey, Phys. Rev. X 5, 011022 (2015)]. Furthermore we go beyond the standard TWA approximation by applying a scheme based on the Bogoliubov-Born-Green-Kirkwood-Yvon (BBGKY) hierarchy of equations to our coupled spin-boson model. This allows us, in principle, to study how systematically adding higher-order corrections improves the convergence of the method. To test various levels of approximation we study an exactly solvable spin-boson model, which is particularly relevant for trapped-ion arrays. Using TWA and its BBGKY extension we accurately reproduce the time evolution of a number of one- and two-point correlation functions in several dimensions and for an arbitrary number of bosonic modes.

arXiv:1705.06203•Physical Review A•Sep 5, 2017•50 citations

SU(3) truncated Wigner approximation for strongly interacting Bose gases

Kazuma Nagao, Yosuke Takasu, Yoshiro Takahashi +1 more

We develop and utilize the SU(3) truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) in order to analyze far-from-equilibrium quantum dynamics of strongly interacting Bose gases in an optical lattice. Specifically, we explicitly represent the corresponding Bose-Hubbard model at an arbitrary filling factor with restricted local Hilbert spaces in terms of SU(3) matrices. Moreover, we introduce a discrete Wigner sampling technique for the SU(3) TWA and examine its performance as well as that of the SU(3) TWA with the Gaussian approximation for the continuous Wigner function. We directly compare outputs of these two approaches with exact computations regarding dynamics of the Bose-Hubbard model at unit filling with a small size and that of a fully connected spin-1 model with a large size. We show that both approaches can quantitatively capture quantum dynamics on a timescale of $\ensuremath{\hbar}/(Jz)$, where $J$ and $z$ denote the hopping energy and the coordination number. We apply the two kinds of SU(3) TWA to dynamical spreading of a two-point correlation function of the Bose-Hubbard model on a square lattice with a large system size, which has been measured in recent experiments. Noticeable deviations between the theories and experiments indicate that proper inclusion of effects of the spatial inhomogeneity, which is not straightforward in our formulation of the SU(3) TWA, may be necessary.

arXiv:2008.09900•Physical Review Research•Nov 1, 2021•11 citations

Quantum diffusion in spin chains with phase space methods

Jonathan Wurtz, Anatoli Polkovnikov

Connecting short-time microscopic dynamics with long-time hydrodynamics in strongly correlated quantum systems is one of the outstanding questions. In particular, it is hard to determine various hydrodynamic coefficients such as the diffusion constant or viscosity starting from a microscopic model: exact quantum simulations are limited to either small system sizes or to short times, which are insufficient to reach asymptotic behavior and so various approximations must be applied. We show that these difficulties, at least for particular models, can be circumvented by using the cluster truncated Wigner approximation (CTWA), which maps quantum Hamiltonian dynamics into classical Hamiltonian dynamics in auxiliary high-dimensional phase space. We apply CTWA to XXZ next-nearest-neighbor spin-1/2 chains and XY spin ladders, and find behavior consisting of short-time spin relaxation which gradually crosses over to emergent diffusive behavior at long times. For a random initial state, we show that CTWA correctly reproduces the whole spin spectral function. Necessary in this construction is sampling from properly fluctuating initial conditions: the Dirac mean-field (variational) ansatz, which neglects such fluctuations, leads to incorrect predictions.

arXiv:1808.08977•Physical review. E•May 15, 2020•23 citations

Orthogonal Polynomials and Open Quantum Systems

Mischa P. Woods

This thesis is concerned with the study of quantum systems coupled linearly to a continuous bath of oscillators examples of which are the spin-boson model and the Nelson model. The main theme throughout is to develop a better understanding of the properties of the bath of oscillators such that more efficient representations of it can be made to facilitate the understanding of the system dynamics. The main difficulty in simulating the system dynamics is that the bath of oscillators composes an infinite number of degrees of freedom. In this thesis, we investigate the mathematical properties of an approach in which the bath modes are written as a semi-infinite chain of nearest neighbour interacting harmonic oscillators such that the efficient time dependent density-matrix renormalisation group (t-DMRG) methods can be applied for simulation. In the first section, we show how there are many different ways to represent the bath as semiinfinite chains and prove that seemingly unrelated methods can all be achieved using the same mathematical formalism. We show that in an iterative process the bath can be transformed into a chain of oscillators with nearest neighbour interactions. This is achieved using the formalism of orthogonal polynomials. This allows one to define a sequence of residual spectral densities at each site along the chain. We show that this sequence of residual spectral densities is provided by the so-called ”sequence of secondary measures”. We derive a systematic procedure to obtain the spectral density of the residual bath in each step. We find that these residual spectral densities are related to an old abstract problem in mathematics known as the ”secondary measures”. We solve this problem from the field of orthogonal polynomials to give an explicit expression for the residual spectral densities and go on to prove that these functions converge under very general conditions. That is, the asymptotic part of the chain is universal, translation invariant with universal spectral density. These results suggest efficient methods for handling the numerical treatment of the residual bath. In the second section, we take a different approach. Rather than studying the properties of residual baths, we look at how system observables are affected by truncating the semi-infinite chain of harmonic oscillators to a finite length chain. By developing locality bounds for the dynamics, we derive an upper bound to the error introduced by such a truncation and show that for all finite times it can be made arbitrarily small by including a sufficient number of harmonic oscillators 3 before truncating. Furthermore, it is shown that the speed at which the system communicates with different harmonic oscillators in the chain is proportional to the maximum frequency of the environment but that this speed also depends on the particular version of the chain. These bounds are given for when the dynamics are calculated in the Interaction picture and in the Schrodinger picture.

•Nov 1, 2013•0 citations

Truncated Wigner approximation for spins in continuous phase space

Jens Hartmann, Tom Schlegel, Viktoria Noel +2 more

We review the truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) for spins as a computationally inexpensive numerical approximation method to describe interacting and / or dissipative many-body spin systems. Using the Wigner-Moyal mapping from Hilbert space to a suitable phase space, the many-body density matrix is represented by a c-number distribution, the Wigner function. The gauge freedom in continuous phase space can be exploited to find positive Wigner functions for a large class of spin states, including entangled ones. Employing different sets of correspondence rules, we derive equations of motion for the Wigner function, which, applying controlled approximations, can be mapped to stochastic differential equations. This allows a computationally inexpensive simulation of expectation values. Using a phase-space analog of the quantum regression theorem also multi-time correlations and spectra can be obtained. To illustrate the potential of the method, we benchmark the TWA for spins with some exactly solvable problems of interacting, dissipative spin systems, and then discuss its application to collective processes, such as the superradiant emission of light. Extending the TWA to imaginary time furthermore provides a tool to approximately calculate thermal and ground states of spin Hamiltonians. Finally, we show that the TWA stochastic equations can equivalently be derived within a path-integral approach, provided that the operator products in the dissipator are rigorously mapped onto the curved phase space.

quant-pharXiv:2607.17295•Jul 21, 2026•6 citations
The central spin model has a wide applicability. It is ideally suited to describe a small quantum system, for instance a quantum bit, in contact to a bath of spins, e.g., nuclear spins or other small quantum systems in general. According to previous work [R. R"ohrig et al., Phys. Rev. B 97, 165431 (2018)], a large bath of quantum spins can be described as a bath of quantum harmonic oscillators. But the resulting quantum model is still far from being straightforwardly solvable. Hence we consider a chain representation for the bosonic degrees of freedom to study how well a semi-classical truncated Wigner approximation of the effective model of harmonic oscillators (bTWA) works in comparison with other approximate and exact methods. We find that the bTWA works well for short times, but deviates from the results of other methods for long times. The general message is that the applicability of semi-classical approaches strongly depends on the variables in terms of which the model is formulated. Numerically, we examine the effect of the number of bath spins and of the truncation level, i.e., the chain length.
Abstract Numerical techniques to efficiently model out-of-equilibrium dynamics in interacting quantum many-body systems are key for advancing our capability to harness and understand complex quantum matter. Here we propose a new numerical approach which we refer to as generalized discrete truncated Wigner approximation (GDTWA). It is based on a discrete semi-classical phase space sampling and allows to investigate quantum dynamics in lattice spin systems with arbitrary S ≥ 1/2. We show that the GDTWA can accurately simulate dynamics of large ensembles in arbitrary dimensions. We apply it for S > 1/2 spin-models with dipolar long-range interactions, a scenario arising in recent experiments with magnetic atoms. We show that the method can capture beyond mean-field effects, not only at short times, but it also can correctly reproduce long time quantum-thermalization dynamics. We benchmark the method with exact diagonalization in small systems, with perturbation theory for short times, and with analytical predictions made for models which feature quantum-thermalization at long times. We apply our method to study dynamics in large S > 1/2 spin-models and compute experimentally accessible observables such as Zeeman level populations, contrast of spin coherence, spin squeezing, and entanglement quantified by single-spin Renyi entropies. We reveal that large S systems can feature larger entanglement than corresponding S = 1/2 systems. Our analyses demonstrate that the GDTWA can be a powerful tool for modeling complex spin dynamics in regimes where other state-of-the art numerical methods fail.
An accurate description of the nonequilibrium dynamics of systems with coupled spin and bosonic degrees of freedom remains theoretically challenging, especially for large system sizes and in higher than one dimension. Phase-space methods such as the truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) have the advantage of being easily scalable and applicable to arbitrary dimensions. In this work we adapt the TWA to generic spin-boson models by making use of recently developed algorithms for discrete phase spaces [J. Schachenmayer, A. Pikovski, and A. M. Rey, Phys. Rev. X 5, 011022 (2015)]. Furthermore we go beyond the standard TWA approximation by applying a scheme based on the Bogoliubov-Born-Green-Kirkwood-Yvon (BBGKY) hierarchy of equations to our coupled spin-boson model. This allows us, in principle, to study how systematically adding higher-order corrections improves the convergence of the method. To test various levels of approximation we study an exactly solvable spin-boson model, which is particularly relevant for trapped-ion arrays. Using TWA and its BBGKY extension we accurately reproduce the time evolution of a number of one- and two-point correlation functions in several dimensions and for an arbitrary number of bosonic modes.
We develop and utilize the SU(3) truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) in order to analyze far-from-equilibrium quantum dynamics of strongly interacting Bose gases in an optical lattice. Specifically, we explicitly represent the corresponding Bose-Hubbard model at an arbitrary filling factor with restricted local Hilbert spaces in terms of SU(3) matrices. Moreover, we introduce a discrete Wigner sampling technique for the SU(3) TWA and examine its performance as well as that of the SU(3) TWA with the Gaussian approximation for the continuous Wigner function. We directly compare outputs of these two approaches with exact computations regarding dynamics of the Bose-Hubbard model at unit filling with a small size and that of a fully connected spin-1 model with a large size. We show that both approaches can quantitatively capture quantum dynamics on a timescale of $\ensuremath{\hbar}/(Jz)$, where JJJ and zzz denote the hopping energy and the coordination number. We apply the two kinds of SU(3) TWA to dynamical spreading of a two-point correlation function of the Bose-Hubbard model on a square lattice with a large system size, which has been measured in recent experiments. Noticeable deviations between the theories and experiments indicate that proper inclusion of effects of the spatial inhomogeneity, which is not straightforward in our formulation of the SU(3) TWA, may be necessary.
Connecting short-time microscopic dynamics with long-time hydrodynamics in strongly correlated quantum systems is one of the outstanding questions. In particular, it is hard to determine various hydrodynamic coefficients such as the diffusion constant or viscosity starting from a microscopic model: exact quantum simulations are limited to either small system sizes or to short times, which are insufficient to reach asymptotic behavior and so various approximations must be applied. We show that these difficulties, at least for particular models, can be circumvented by using the cluster truncated Wigner approximation (CTWA), which maps quantum Hamiltonian dynamics into classical Hamiltonian dynamics in auxiliary high-dimensional phase space. We apply CTWA to XXZ next-nearest-neighbor spin-1/2 chains and XY spin ladders, and find behavior consisting of short-time spin relaxation which gradually crosses over to emergent diffusive behavior at long times. For a random initial state, we show that CTWA correctly reproduces the whole spin spectral function. Necessary in this construction is sampling from properly fluctuating initial conditions: the Dirac mean-field (variational) ansatz, which neglects such fluctuations, leads to incorrect predictions.
This thesis is concerned with the study of quantum systems coupled linearly to a continuous bath of oscillators examples of which are the spin-boson model and the Nelson model. The main theme throughout is to develop a better understanding of the properties of the bath of oscillators such that more efficient representations of it can be made to facilitate the understanding of the system dynamics. The main difficulty in simulating the system dynamics is that the bath of oscillators composes an infinite number of degrees of freedom. In this thesis, we investigate the mathematical properties of an approach in which the bath modes are written as a semi-infinite chain of nearest neighbour interacting harmonic oscillators such that the efficient time dependent density-matrix renormalisation group (t-DMRG) methods can be applied for simulation. In the first section, we show how there are many different ways to represent the bath as semiinfinite chains and prove that seemingly unrelated methods can all be achieved using the same mathematical formalism. We show that in an iterative process the bath can be transformed into a chain of oscillators with nearest neighbour interactions. This is achieved using the formalism of orthogonal polynomials. This allows one to define a sequence of residual spectral densities at each site along the chain. We show that this sequence of residual spectral densities is provided by the so-called ”sequence of secondary measures”. We derive a systematic procedure to obtain the spectral density of the residual bath in each step. We find that these residual spectral densities are related to an old abstract problem in mathematics known as the ”secondary measures”. We solve this problem from the field of orthogonal polynomials to give an explicit expression for the residual spectral densities and go on to prove that these functions converge under very general conditions. That is, the asymptotic part of the chain is universal, translation invariant with universal spectral density. These results suggest efficient methods for handling the numerical treatment of the residual bath. In the second section, we take a different approach. Rather than studying the properties of residual baths, we look at how system observables are affected by truncating the semi-infinite chain of harmonic oscillators to a finite length chain. By developing locality bounds for the dynamics, we derive an upper bound to the error introduced by such a truncation and show that for all finite times it can be made arbitrarily small by including a sufficient number of harmonic oscillators 3 before truncating. Furthermore, it is shown that the speed at which the system communicates with different harmonic oscillators in the chain is proportional to the maximum frequency of the environment but that this speed also depends on the particular version of the chain. These bounds are given for when the dynamics are calculated in the Interaction picture and in the Schrodinger picture.
We review the truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) for spins as a computationally inexpensive numerical approximation method to describe interacting and / or dissipative many-body spin systems. Using the Wigner-Moyal mapping from Hilbert space to a suitable phase space, the many-body density matrix is represented by a c-number distribution, the Wigner function. The gauge freedom in continuous phase space can be exploited to find positive Wigner functions for a large class of spin states, including entangled ones. Employing different sets of correspondence rules, we derive equations of motion for the Wigner function, which, applying controlled approximations, can be mapped to stochastic differential equations. This allows a computationally inexpensive simulation of expectation values. Using a phase-space analog of the quantum regression theorem also multi-time correlations and spectra can be obtained. To illustrate the potential of the method, we benchmark the TWA for spins with some exactly solvable problems of interacting, dissipative spin systems, and then discuss its application to collective processes, such as the superradiant emission of light. Extending the TWA to imaginary time furthermore provides a tool to approximately calculate thermal and ground states of spin Hamiltonians. Finally, we show that the TWA stochastic equations can equivalently be derived within a path-integral approach, provided that the operator products in the dissipator are rigorously mapped onto the curved phase space.