Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2212.04807 · PRX Quantum

Satellite-Based Quantum Key Distribution in the Presence of Bypass Channels

Masoud Ghalaii, Sima Bahrani, Carlo Liorni, Federico Grasselli, Hermann Kampermann, Lewis Wooltorton, Rupesh Kumar, Stefano Pirandola, Timothy P. Spiller, Alexander Ling, Bruno Huttner, Mohsen Razavi

Published Nov 1, 2023• 18 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The security of prepare-and-measure satellite-based quantum key distribution (QKD), under restricted eavesdropping scenarios, is addressed.We particularly consider cases where the eavesdropper, Eve, has limited access to the transmitted signal by Alice and/or Bob's receiver station.This restriction is modeled by lossy channels between relevant parties, where the transmissivity of such channels can, in principle, be bounded by monitoring techniques.An artifact of such lossy channels is the possibility of having bypass channels, those that are not accessible to Eve but that may not necessarily be characterized by the users either.This creates interesting unexplored scenarios for analyzing QKD security.In this paper, we obtain generic bounds on the key rate in the presence of bypass channels and apply them to continuousvariable QKD protocols with Gaussian encoding with direct and reverse reconciliation.We find regimes of operation in which the above restrictions on Eve can considerably improve system performance.We also develop customized bounds for several protocols in the BB84 family and show that, in certain regimes, even the simple protocol of BB84 with weak coherent pulses is able to offer positive key rates at high channel losses, which would otherwise be impossible under an unrestricted Eve.In this case, the limitation on Eve would allow Alice to send signals with larger intensities than the optimal value under an ideal Eve, which effectively reduces the effective channel loss.In all these cases, the part of the transmitted signal that does not reach Eve can play a nontrivial role in specifying the achievable key rate.Our work opens up new security frameworks for spaceborne quantum communications systems.

DOI
10.1103/prxquantum.4.040320

Related papers

Numerical security framework for quantum key distribution with bypass channels

Lewis Wooltorton, Twesh Upadhyaya, Mohsen Razavi

Satellite based quantum key distribution (QKD) aims to establish secure key exchange over long distances despite significant technological challenges. To alleviate some of these challenges, Ghalaii et al. [PRX Quantum 4, 040320 (2023)] proposed that any airborne eavesdropper up to a certain size can be detected by classical monitoring techniques, limiting the transmission efficiencies of any undetected Eve. This creates a new QKD scenario in which some of the transmitted signal from Alice to Bob bypasses Eve entirely. In this manuscript, we develop a general framework for computing key rates in this "bypass" scenario for discrete variable protocols. We first numerically support a conjecture that the performance of BB84 with single photons does not improve under bypass constraints, and go on to find new regimes that do. Specifically, we find improvements when the receiver's detectors have an efficiency mismatch and when BB84 is implemented using weak coherent pulses under certain squashing assumptions. Technically, our framework is realized by including marginal constraints on the source to account for bypass effects, combined with existing numerical approaches for minimizing the key rate and squashing and dimension reduction techniques to handle photonic states of unbounded dimension.

quant-pharXiv:2603.21843•Mar 24, 2026•0 citations

Secret Key Distillation over Satellite-to-satellite Free-space Optics Channel with Eavesdropper Dynamic Positioning

Ziwen Pan, Ivan B. Djordjević

The conventional omnipotent eavesdropper assumption in quantum cryptography study can be too strict for some realistic scenarios. In this paper, we study the secret key distillation over a satellite-to-satellite free space optics channel in which we assume that the eavesdropper (Eve) is restricted in her ability of power collection due to the limited size of her aperture but can change the position of her aperture to gain advantages over the communication parties (Alice and Bob) and we determine the achievable key rate lower and upper bounds with respect to different scenarios. We first study the case where Eve is behind Bob and we prove that the optimal eavesdropping strategy for her in long-distance transmission case is to place her aperture on the beam transmission axis and set Bob-to-Eve distance equal to Alice-to-Bob distance. We also show that the achievable key rate would be characterized by a Bessel function integral related to Eve's position in a short-distance transmission case. We then investigate the case where Eve is before Bob and show similar results with Eve's and Bob's roles exchanged.

arXiv:2012.13865•Dec 27, 2020•2 citations

Secret key distillation over a pure loss quantum wiretap channel under restricted eavesdropping

Ziwen Pan, Kaushik Parasuram Seshadreesan, William Clark +4 more

Quantum cryptography provides absolute security against an all-powerful eavesdropper (Eve). However, in practice Eve's resources may be restricted to a limited aperture size so that she cannot collect all paraxial light without alerting the communicating parties (Alice and Bob). In this paper we study a quantum wiretap channel in which the connection from Alice to Eve is lossy, so that some of the transmitted quantum information is inaccessible to both Bob and Eve. For a pureloss channel under such restricted eavesdropping, we show that the key rates achievable with a two-mode squeezed vacuum state, heterodyne detection, and public classical communication assistance-given by the Hashing inequality-can exceed the secret key distillation capacity of the channel against an omnipotent eavesdropper. We report upper bounds on the key rates under the restricted eavesdropping model based on the relative entropy of entanglement, which closely match the achievable rates. For the pure-loss channel under restricted eavesdropping, we compare the secret-key rates of continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD) based on Gaussian-modulated coherent states and heterodyne detection with the discrete variable (DV) decoystate BB84 QKD protocol based on polarization qubits encoded in weak coherent laser pulses.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jul 1, 2019•11 citations

Quantum Keyless Private Communication Versus Quantum Key Distribution for Space Links

A. Vázquez-Castro, D. Rusca, H. Zbinden

We study information-theoretical security for space links between a satellite and a ground station. Quantum key distribution (QKD) is a well-established method for information-theoretical secure communication, giving the eavesdropper unlimited access to the channel and technological resources limited by only the laws of quantum physics. But QKD for space links is extremely challenging, the achieved key rates are extremely low, and daytime operating impossible. However, eavesdropping on a channel in free space without being noticed seems complicated, given the constraints imposed by orbital mechanics. If we also exclude the eavesdropper's presence in a given area around the emitter and receiver, we can guarantee that he has access to only a fraction of the optical signal. In this setting, quantum keyless private (direct) communication based on the wiretap channel model is a valid alternative to provide information-theoretical security. Like for QKD, we assume that the legitimate users are limited by state-of-the-art technology, while the potential eavesdropper is only limited by physical laws: either by specifying her detection strategy (Helstrom detector) or by bounding her knowledge, assuming the most powerful strategy through the Holevo information. Nevertheless, we demonstrate information-theoretical secure communication rates (positive keyless private capacity) over a classical-quantum wiretap channel using on-off keying of coherent states. We present numerical results for a setting equivalent to the recent experiments with the Micius satellite and compare them to the fundamental limit for the secret key rate of QKD. We obtain much higher rates compared with QKD with an exclusion area of less than 13 m for low earth orbit satellites. Moreover, we show that the wiretap channel quantum keyless privacy is much less sensitive to noise and signal dynamics and daytime operation is possible.

arXiv:2012.03407•Physical Review Applied•Jul 2, 2021•23 citations

Notes on a Continuous-Variable Quantum Key Distribution Scheme

Tsubasa Ichikawa, Takuya Hirano, Takuto Matsubara +2 more

We develop a physical model to describe the signal transmission for a continuous-variable quantum key distribution scheme and investigate its security against a couple of eavesdropping attacks assuming that the eavesdropper’s power is partly restricted owing to today’s technological limitations. We consider an eavesdropper performing quantum optical homodyne measurement on the signal obtained by a type of beamsplitting attack. We also consider the case in which the eavesdropper Eve is unable to access a quantum memory and she performs heterodyne measurement on her signal without performing a delayed measurement. Our formulation includes a model in which the receiver’s loss and noise are unaccessible by the eavesdropper. This setup enables us to investigate the condition that Eve uses a practical fiber differently from the usual beamsplitting attack where she can deploy a lossless transmission channel. The secret key rates are calculated in both the direct and reverse reconciliation scenarios.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Aug 10, 2017•1 citation

Covert Communications-Based Information Reconciliation for Quantum Key Distribution Protocols

John Gariano, Ivan B. Djordjević

The rate at which a secure key can be generated in a quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol is limited by the channel loss and the quantum bit-error rate (QBER). Increases to the QBER can stem from detector noise, channel noise, or the presence of an eavesdropper, Eve. Eve is capable of obtaining information of the unsecure key by performing an attack on the quantum channel or by listening to all discussion performed via a noiseless public channel. Conventionally a QKD protocol will perform the information reconciliation over the authenticated public channel, revealing the parity bits used to correct for any quantum bit errors. In this invited paper, the possibility of limiting the information revealed to Eve during the information reconciliation is considered. Using a covert communication channel for the transmission of the parity bits, secure key rates are possible at much higher QBERs. This is demonstrated through the simulation of a polarization based QKD system implementing the BB84 protocol, showing significant improvement of the SKRs over the conventional QKD protocols.

International Conference on Transparent Optical Networks•Jul 1, 2019•2 citations
The security of prepare-and-measure satellite-based quantum key distribution (QKD), under restricted eavesdropping scenarios, is addressed.We particularly consider cases where the eavesdropper, Eve, has limited access to the transmitted signal by Alice and/or Bob's receiver station.This restriction is modeled by lossy channels between relevant parties, where the transmissivity of such channels can, in principle, be bounded by monitoring techniques.An artifact of such lossy channels is the possibility of having bypass channels, those that are not accessible to Eve but that may not necessarily be characterized by the users either.This creates interesting unexplored scenarios for analyzing QKD security.In this paper, we obtain generic bounds on the key rate in the presence of bypass channels and apply them to continuousvariable QKD protocols with Gaussian encoding with direct and reverse reconciliation.We find regimes of operation in which the above restrictions on Eve can considerably improve system performance.We also develop customized bounds for several protocols in the BB84 family and show that, in certain regimes, even the simple protocol of BB84 with weak coherent pulses is able to offer positive key rates at high channel losses, which would otherwise be impossible under an unrestricted Eve.In this case, the limitation on Eve would allow Alice to send signals with larger intensities than the optimal value under an ideal Eve, which effectively reduces the effective channel loss.In all these cases, the part of the transmitted signal that does not reach Eve can play a nontrivial role in specifying the achievable key rate.Our work opens up new security frameworks for spaceborne quantum communications systems.
Satellite based quantum key distribution (QKD) aims to establish secure key exchange over long distances despite significant technological challenges. To alleviate some of these challenges, Ghalaii et al. [PRX Quantum 4, 040320 (2023)] proposed that any airborne eavesdropper up to a certain size can be detected by classical monitoring techniques, limiting the transmission efficiencies of any undetected Eve. This creates a new QKD scenario in which some of the transmitted signal from Alice to Bob bypasses Eve entirely. In this manuscript, we develop a general framework for computing key rates in this "bypass" scenario for discrete variable protocols. We first numerically support a conjecture that the performance of BB84 with single photons does not improve under bypass constraints, and go on to find new regimes that do. Specifically, we find improvements when the receiver's detectors have an efficiency mismatch and when BB84 is implemented using weak coherent pulses under certain squashing assumptions. Technically, our framework is realized by including marginal constraints on the source to account for bypass effects, combined with existing numerical approaches for minimizing the key rate and squashing and dimension reduction techniques to handle photonic states of unbounded dimension.
The conventional omnipotent eavesdropper assumption in quantum cryptography study can be too strict for some realistic scenarios. In this paper, we study the secret key distillation over a satellite-to-satellite free space optics channel in which we assume that the eavesdropper (Eve) is restricted in her ability of power collection due to the limited size of her aperture but can change the position of her aperture to gain advantages over the communication parties (Alice and Bob) and we determine the achievable key rate lower and upper bounds with respect to different scenarios. We first study the case where Eve is behind Bob and we prove that the optimal eavesdropping strategy for her in long-distance transmission case is to place her aperture on the beam transmission axis and set Bob-to-Eve distance equal to Alice-to-Bob distance. We also show that the achievable key rate would be characterized by a Bessel function integral related to Eve's position in a short-distance transmission case. We then investigate the case where Eve is before Bob and show similar results with Eve's and Bob's roles exchanged.
Quantum cryptography provides absolute security against an all-powerful eavesdropper (Eve). However, in practice Eve's resources may be restricted to a limited aperture size so that she cannot collect all paraxial light without alerting the communicating parties (Alice and Bob). In this paper we study a quantum wiretap channel in which the connection from Alice to Eve is lossy, so that some of the transmitted quantum information is inaccessible to both Bob and Eve. For a pureloss channel under such restricted eavesdropping, we show that the key rates achievable with a two-mode squeezed vacuum state, heterodyne detection, and public classical communication assistance-given by the Hashing inequality-can exceed the secret key distillation capacity of the channel against an omnipotent eavesdropper. We report upper bounds on the key rates under the restricted eavesdropping model based on the relative entropy of entanglement, which closely match the achievable rates. For the pure-loss channel under restricted eavesdropping, we compare the secret-key rates of continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD) based on Gaussian-modulated coherent states and heterodyne detection with the discrete variable (DV) decoystate BB84 QKD protocol based on polarization qubits encoded in weak coherent laser pulses.
We study information-theoretical security for space links between a satellite and a ground station. Quantum key distribution (QKD) is a well-established method for information-theoretical secure communication, giving the eavesdropper unlimited access to the channel and technological resources limited by only the laws of quantum physics. But QKD for space links is extremely challenging, the achieved key rates are extremely low, and daytime operating impossible. However, eavesdropping on a channel in free space without being noticed seems complicated, given the constraints imposed by orbital mechanics. If we also exclude the eavesdropper's presence in a given area around the emitter and receiver, we can guarantee that he has access to only a fraction of the optical signal. In this setting, quantum keyless private (direct) communication based on the wiretap channel model is a valid alternative to provide information-theoretical security. Like for QKD, we assume that the legitimate users are limited by state-of-the-art technology, while the potential eavesdropper is only limited by physical laws: either by specifying her detection strategy (Helstrom detector) or by bounding her knowledge, assuming the most powerful strategy through the Holevo information. Nevertheless, we demonstrate information-theoretical secure communication rates (positive keyless private capacity) over a classical-quantum wiretap channel using on-off keying of coherent states. We present numerical results for a setting equivalent to the recent experiments with the Micius satellite and compare them to the fundamental limit for the secret key rate of QKD. We obtain much higher rates compared with QKD with an exclusion area of less than 13 m for low earth orbit satellites. Moreover, we show that the wiretap channel quantum keyless privacy is much less sensitive to noise and signal dynamics and daytime operation is possible.
We develop a physical model to describe the signal transmission for a continuous-variable quantum key distribution scheme and investigate its security against a couple of eavesdropping attacks assuming that the eavesdropper’s power is partly restricted owing to today’s technological limitations. We consider an eavesdropper performing quantum optical homodyne measurement on the signal obtained by a type of beamsplitting attack. We also consider the case in which the eavesdropper Eve is unable to access a quantum memory and she performs heterodyne measurement on her signal without performing a delayed measurement. Our formulation includes a model in which the receiver’s loss and noise are unaccessible by the eavesdropper. This setup enables us to investigate the condition that Eve uses a practical fiber differently from the usual beamsplitting attack where she can deploy a lossless transmission channel. The secret key rates are calculated in both the direct and reverse reconciliation scenarios.
The rate at which a secure key can be generated in a quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol is limited by the channel loss and the quantum bit-error rate (QBER). Increases to the QBER can stem from detector noise, channel noise, or the presence of an eavesdropper, Eve. Eve is capable of obtaining information of the unsecure key by performing an attack on the quantum channel or by listening to all discussion performed via a noiseless public channel. Conventionally a QKD protocol will perform the information reconciliation over the authenticated public channel, revealing the parity bits used to correct for any quantum bit errors. In this invited paper, the possibility of limiting the information revealed to Eve during the information reconciliation is considered. Using a covert communication channel for the transmission of the parity bits, secure key rates are possible at much higher QBERs. This is demonstrated through the simulation of a polarization based QKD system implementing the BB84 protocol, showing significant improvement of the SKRs over the conventional QKD protocols.