Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2211.05149 · PRX Quantum

Precision Bounds on Continuous-Variable State Tomography Using Classical Shadows

Srilekha Gandhari, Victor V. Albert, Thomas Gerrits, Jacob M. Taylor, Michael J. Gullans

Published Mar 18, 2024• 16 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Shadow tomography is a framework for constructing succinct descriptions of quantum states using randomized measurement bases, called “classical shadows,” with powerful methods to bound the estimators used. We recast existing experimental protocols for continuous-variable quantum state tomography in the classical-shadow framework, obtaining rigorous bounds on the number of independent measurements needed for estimating density matrices from these protocols. We analyze the efficiency of homodyne, heterodyne, photon-number-resolving, and photon-parity protocols. To reach a desired precision on the classical shadow of an N -photon density matrix with high probability, we show that homodyne detection requires order O(N4+1/3) measurements in the worst case, whereas photon-number-resolving and photon-parity detection require O(N4) measurements in the worst case (both up to logarithmic corrections). We benchmark these results against numerical simulation as well as experimental data from optical homodyne experiments. We find that numerical and experimental analyses of homodyne tomography match closely with our theoretical predictions. We extend our single-mode results to an efficient construction of multimode shadows based on local measurements. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/prxquantum.5.010346

Related papers

Continuous-variable state moments from randomized homodyne and heterodyne measurements

Michael Tsesmelis, Moritz Straeter, Leong-Chuan Kwek

Continuous-variable (CV) quantum states are naturally characterized by their moments, defined as expectation values of products of single- or multimode ladder operators. Many CV Hamiltonians and quantum algorithms are formulated directly in terms of these moments, and therefore an efficient procedure to estimate moments with limited state measurements is necessary. In this paper, we present a protocol for shadow tomography of moment-generating functions (MGFs) of CV states based on randomized homodyne and heterodyne measurements. The resulting shadows enable an efficient and concurrent estimation of many multimode moments. Our complexity analysis shows that the number of measurements required to estimate a certain moment to a given precision grows exponentially in the order of the moments. Finally, we assess the precision of these moment estimators by applying them to two tasks: detecting entanglement in both Gaussian and non-Gaussian states via the Shchukin-Vogel protocol, and characterizing optical loss in a photonic chip. We demonstrate that both tasks can be accomplished with only a few thousand randomized measurements. The small number of required measurements, combined with efficient sample processing, makes our protocol applicable to a wide range of CV simulation tasks.

quant-pharXiv:2608.11811•Aug 13, 2026•0 citations

Classical Shadow Tomography for Continuous Variables Quantum Systems

Simon Becker, Nilanjana Datta, Ludovico Lami +1 more

In this article we develop a continuous variable (CV) shadow tomography scheme with wide ranging applications in quantum optics. Our work is motivated by the increasing experimental and technological relevance of CV systems in quantum information, quantum communication, quantum sensing, quantum simulations, quantum computing and error correction. We introduce two experimentally realisable schemes for obtaining classical shadows of CV (possibly non-Gaussian) quantum states using only randomised Gaussian unitaries and easily implementable Gaussian measurements such as homodyne and heterodyne detection. For both schemes, we show thatN=O(poly (1 /ϵ, log (1/δ),Mr+αn, log(m) )) samples of an unknownm-mode state ρ suffice to learn the expected value of anyr-local polynomial in the canonical observables of degree α, both with high probability 1 - δ and accuracy ϵ, as long as the state ρ has moments of ordern> α bounded byMn. By simultaneously truncating states and operators in energy and phase space, we are able to overcome new mathematical challenges that arise due to the infinite-dimensionality of CV systems. We also provide a scheme to learn nonlinear functionals of the state, such as entropies over any small number of modes, by leveraging recent energy-constrained entropic continuity bounds. Finally, we provide numerical evidence of the efficiency of our protocols in the case of CV states of relevance in quantum information theory, including ground states of quadratic Hamiltonians of many-body systems and cat qubit states. We expect our scheme to provide good recovery in learning relevant states of 2D materials and photonic crystals.

arXiv:2211.07578•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Jan 26, 2024•32 citations

Practical Homodyne Shadow Estimation

Ruyu Yang, Xiaoming Sun, Hongyi Zhou

Shadow estimation provides an efficient framework for estimating observable expectation values using randomized measurements. While originally developed for discrete-variable systems, its recent extensions to continuous-variable (CV) quantum systems face practical limitations due to idealized assumptions of continuous phase modulation and infinite measurement resolution. In this work, we develop a practical shadow estimation protocol for CV systems using discretized homodyne detection with a finite number of phase settings and quadrature bins. We construct an unbiased estimator for the quantum state and establish both sufficient conditions and necessary conditions for informational completeness within a truncated Fock space up to $n_{\mathrm{max}}$ photons. We further provide a comprehensive variance analysis, showing that the shadow norm scales as $\mathcal{O}(n_{\mathrm{max}}^4)$, improving upon previous $\mathcal{O}(n_{\mathrm{max}}^{13/3})$ bounds. Our work bridges the gap between theoretical shadow estimation and experimental implementations, enabling robust and scalable quantum state characterization in realistic CV systems.

quant-pharXiv:2512.13146•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations

Enhancing quantum state reconstruction with structured classical shadows

Zhen Qin, Joseph M. Lukens, Brian T. Kirby +1 more

While classical shadows can efficiently predict key quantum state properties, their suitability for certified quantum state tomography remains uncertain. In this paper, we address this challenge by introducing a projected classical shadow (PCS) that extends the standard classical shadow by incorporating a projection step onto the target subspace. For a general quantum state consisting of n qubits, our method requires a minimum of O (4 n ) total state copies to achieve a bounded recovery error in the Frobenius norm between the reconstructed and true density matrices, reducing to O (2 n r ) for states of rank r < 2 n —meeting information-theoretic optimal bounds in both cases. For matrix product operator states, we demonstrate that the PCS can recover the ground-truth state with O ( n 2 ) total state copies, improving upon the previously established Haar-random bound of O ( n 3 ). Numerical simulations validate our scaling results and demonstrate the practical accuracy of the proposed PCS method.

arXiv:2501.03144•npj Quantum Information•Sep 2, 2025•4 citations

Direct reconstruction of the quantum density matrix elements with classical shadow tomography

Yu Wang

We introduce a direct estimation framework for reconstructing multiple density matrix elements of an unknown quantum state using classical shadow tomography. Traditional direct measurement protocols (DMPs), while effective for individual elements, suffer from poor scalability due to post-selection losses and the need for element-specific measurement configurations. In contrast, our method, DMP-ST, leverages random Clifford or biased mutually unbiased basis measurements to enable global estimation: a single dataset suffices to estimate arbitrary off-diagonal entries with high accuracy. We prove that estimating \(K\) off-diagonal matrix elements up to additive error \(ε\) requires only \(\mathcal{O}(\log K/ε^2)\) samples, achieving exponential improvement over conventional DMPs. The number of required measurement configurations can also be exponentially reduced for large K. When extended to full state tomography, DMP-ST attains trace distance error \(\le ε\) with sample complexity \(\mathcal{O}(d^3 \log d/ε^2)\), which is closed to the optimal scaling for single-copy measurements. Moreover, biased MUB measurements reduce sample complexity by a constant factor than random Clifford measurements. This work provides both theoretical guarantees and explicit protocols for efficient, entrywise quantum state reconstruction. It significantly advances the practicality of direct tomography, especially for high-dimensional systems and near-term quantum platforms.

arXiv:2505.15243•May 21, 2025•0 citations

Bayesian homodyne and heterodyne tomography

Joseph C. Chapman, Joseph M. Lukens, Bing Qi +2 more

Continuous-variable (CV) photonic states are of increasing interest in quantum information science, bolstered by features such as deterministic resource state generation and error correction via bosonic codes. Data-efficient characterization methods will prove critical in the fine-tuning and maturation of such CV quantum technology. Although Bayesian inference offers appealing properties-including uncertainty quantification and optimality in mean-squared error-Bayesian methods have yet to be demonstrated for the tomography of arbitrary CV states. Here we introduce a complete Bayesian quantum state tomography workflow capable of inferring generic CV states measured by homodyne or heterodyne detection, with no assumption of Gaussianity. As examples, we demonstrate our approach on experimental coherent, thermal, and cat state data, obtaining excellent agreement between our Bayesian estimates and theoretical predictions. Our approach lays the groundwork for Bayesian estimation of highly complex CV quantum states in emerging quantum photonic platforms, such as quantum communications networks and sensors.

arXiv:2202.03499•Optics Express•Apr 7, 2022•17 citations
Shadow tomography is a framework for constructing succinct descriptions of quantum states using randomized measurement bases, called “classical shadows,” with powerful methods to bound the estimators used. We recast existing experimental protocols for continuous-variable quantum state tomography in the classical-shadow framework, obtaining rigorous bounds on the number of independent measurements needed for estimating density matrices from these protocols. We analyze the efficiency of homodyne, heterodyne, photon-number-resolving, and photon-parity protocols. To reach a desired precision on the classical shadow of an N -photon density matrix with high probability, we show that homodyne detection requires order O(N4+1/3) measurements in the worst case, whereas photon-number-resolving and photon-parity detection require O(N4) measurements in the worst case (both up to logarithmic corrections). We benchmark these results against numerical simulation as well as experimental data from optical homodyne experiments. We find that numerical and experimental analyses of homodyne tomography match closely with our theoretical predictions. We extend our single-mode results to an efficient construction of multimode shadows based on local measurements. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Continuous-variable (CV) quantum states are naturally characterized by their moments, defined as expectation values of products of single- or multimode ladder operators. Many CV Hamiltonians and quantum algorithms are formulated directly in terms of these moments, and therefore an efficient procedure to estimate moments with limited state measurements is necessary. In this paper, we present a protocol for shadow tomography of moment-generating functions (MGFs) of CV states based on randomized homodyne and heterodyne measurements. The resulting shadows enable an efficient and concurrent estimation of many multimode moments. Our complexity analysis shows that the number of measurements required to estimate a certain moment to a given precision grows exponentially in the order of the moments. Finally, we assess the precision of these moment estimators by applying them to two tasks: detecting entanglement in both Gaussian and non-Gaussian states via the Shchukin-Vogel protocol, and characterizing optical loss in a photonic chip. We demonstrate that both tasks can be accomplished with only a few thousand randomized measurements. The small number of required measurements, combined with efficient sample processing, makes our protocol applicable to a wide range of CV simulation tasks.
In this article we develop a continuous variable (CV) shadow tomography scheme with wide ranging applications in quantum optics. Our work is motivated by the increasing experimental and technological relevance of CV systems in quantum information, quantum communication, quantum sensing, quantum simulations, quantum computing and error correction. We introduce two experimentally realisable schemes for obtaining classical shadows of CV (possibly non-Gaussian) quantum states using only randomised Gaussian unitaries and easily implementable Gaussian measurements such as homodyne and heterodyne detection. For both schemes, we show thatN=O(poly (1 /ϵ, log (1/δ),Mr+αn, log(m) )) samples of an unknownm-mode state ρ suffice to learn the expected value of anyr-local polynomial in the canonical observables of degree α, both with high probability 1 - δ and accuracy ϵ, as long as the state ρ has moments of ordern> α bounded byMn. By simultaneously truncating states and operators in energy and phase space, we are able to overcome new mathematical challenges that arise due to the infinite-dimensionality of CV systems. We also provide a scheme to learn nonlinear functionals of the state, such as entropies over any small number of modes, by leveraging recent energy-constrained entropic continuity bounds. Finally, we provide numerical evidence of the efficiency of our protocols in the case of CV states of relevance in quantum information theory, including ground states of quadratic Hamiltonians of many-body systems and cat qubit states. We expect our scheme to provide good recovery in learning relevant states of 2D materials and photonic crystals.
Shadow estimation provides an efficient framework for estimating observable expectation values using randomized measurements. While originally developed for discrete-variable systems, its recent extensions to continuous-variable (CV) quantum systems face practical limitations due to idealized assumptions of continuous phase modulation and infinite measurement resolution. In this work, we develop a practical shadow estimation protocol for CV systems using discretized homodyne detection with a finite number of phase settings and quadrature bins. We construct an unbiased estimator for the quantum state and establish both sufficient conditions and necessary conditions for informational completeness within a truncated Fock space up to nmaxn_{\mathrm{max}}nmax​ photons. We further provide a comprehensive variance analysis, showing that the shadow norm scales as O(nmax4)\mathcal{O}(n_{\mathrm{max}}^4)O(nmax4​), improving upon previous O(nmax13/3)\mathcal{O}(n_{\mathrm{max}}^{13/3})O(nmax13/3​) bounds. Our work bridges the gap between theoretical shadow estimation and experimental implementations, enabling robust and scalable quantum state characterization in realistic CV systems.
While classical shadows can efficiently predict key quantum state properties, their suitability for certified quantum state tomography remains uncertain. In this paper, we address this challenge by introducing a projected classical shadow (PCS) that extends the standard classical shadow by incorporating a projection step onto the target subspace. For a general quantum state consisting of n qubits, our method requires a minimum of O (4 n ) total state copies to achieve a bounded recovery error in the Frobenius norm between the reconstructed and true density matrices, reducing to O (2 n r ) for states of rank r < 2 n —meeting information-theoretic optimal bounds in both cases. For matrix product operator states, we demonstrate that the PCS can recover the ground-truth state with O ( n 2 ) total state copies, improving upon the previously established Haar-random bound of O ( n 3 ). Numerical simulations validate our scaling results and demonstrate the practical accuracy of the proposed PCS method.
We introduce a direct estimation framework for reconstructing multiple density matrix elements of an unknown quantum state using classical shadow tomography. Traditional direct measurement protocols (DMPs), while effective for individual elements, suffer from poor scalability due to post-selection losses and the need for element-specific measurement configurations. In contrast, our method, DMP-ST, leverages random Clifford or biased mutually unbiased basis measurements to enable global estimation: a single dataset suffices to estimate arbitrary off-diagonal entries with high accuracy. We prove that estimating KKK off-diagonal matrix elements up to additive error εεε requires only O(log⁡K/ε2)\mathcal{O}(\log K/ε^2)O(logK/ε2) samples, achieving exponential improvement over conventional DMPs. The number of required measurement configurations can also be exponentially reduced for large K. When extended to full state tomography, DMP-ST attains trace distance error ≤ε\le ε≤ε with sample complexity O(d3log⁡d/ε2)\mathcal{O}(d^3 \log d/ε^2)O(d3logd/ε2), which is closed to the optimal scaling for single-copy measurements. Moreover, biased MUB measurements reduce sample complexity by a constant factor than random Clifford measurements. This work provides both theoretical guarantees and explicit protocols for efficient, entrywise quantum state reconstruction. It significantly advances the practicality of direct tomography, especially for high-dimensional systems and near-term quantum platforms.
Continuous-variable (CV) photonic states are of increasing interest in quantum information science, bolstered by features such as deterministic resource state generation and error correction via bosonic codes. Data-efficient characterization methods will prove critical in the fine-tuning and maturation of such CV quantum technology. Although Bayesian inference offers appealing properties-including uncertainty quantification and optimality in mean-squared error-Bayesian methods have yet to be demonstrated for the tomography of arbitrary CV states. Here we introduce a complete Bayesian quantum state tomography workflow capable of inferring generic CV states measured by homodyne or heterodyne detection, with no assumption of Gaussianity. As examples, we demonstrate our approach on experimental coherent, thermal, and cat state data, obtaining excellent agreement between our Bayesian estimates and theoretical predictions. Our approach lays the groundwork for Bayesian estimation of highly complex CV quantum states in emerging quantum photonic platforms, such as quantum communications networks and sensors.