We report on two major hybrid applications of quantum computing, namely, the quantum approximate optimisation algorithm (QAOA) and the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE). Both are hybrid quantum classical algorithms as they require incremental communication between a classical central processing unit and a quantum processing unit to solve a problem. We find that the QAOA scales much better to larger problems than random guessing, but requires significant computational resources. In contrast, a coarsely discretised version of quantum annealing called approximate quantum annealing (AQA) can reach the same promising scaling behaviour using much less computational resources. For the VQE, we find reasonable results in approximating the ground state energy of the Heisenberg model when suitable choices of initial states and parameters are used. Our design and implementation of a general quasi-dynamical evolution further improves these results.
We report on two major hybrid applications of quantum computing, namely, the quantum approximate optimisation algorithm (QAOA) and the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE). Both are hybrid quantum classical algorithms as they require incremental communication between a classical central processing unit and a quantum processing unit to solve a problem. We find that the QAOA scales much better to larger problems than random guessing, but requires significant computational resources. In contrast, a coarsely discretised version of quantum annealing called approximate quantum annealing (AQA) can reach the same promising scaling behaviour using much less computational resources. For the VQE, we find reasonable results in approximating the ground state energy of the Heisenberg model when suitable choices of initial states and parameters are used. Our design and implementation of a general quasi-dynamical evolution further improves these results.
The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm designed for current and near-term quantum devices. Despite its initial success, there is a lack of understanding involving several of its key aspects. There are problems with VQE that forbid a favourable scaling towards quantum advantage. In order to alleviate the problems, we propose and extensively test a quantum annealing inspired heuristic that supplements VQE. The improved VQE enables an efficient initial state preparation mechanism, in a recursive manner, for a quasi-dynamical unitary evolution. We conduct an in-depth scaling analysis of finding the ground state energies with increasing lattice sizes of the Heisenberg model, employing simulations of up to 40 qubits that manipulate the complete state vector. For the current devices, we further propose a benchmarking toolkit using a mean-field model and test it on IBM Q devices. The improved VQE avoids barren plateaus, exits local minima, and works with low-depth circuits. Realistic gate execution times estimate a longer computational time to complete the same computation on a fully functional error-free quantum computer than on a quantum computer emulator implemented on a classical computer. However, our proposal can be expected to help accurate estimations of the ground state energies beyond 50 qubits when the complete state vector can no longer be stored on a classical computer, thus enabling quantum advantage.
The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum classical algorithm designed for current and near-term quantum devices. Despite its initial success, there is a lack of understanding involving several of its key aspects. There are problems with VQE that forbid a favorable scaling towards quantum advantage. In order to alleviate the problems, we propose and extensively test a quantum annealing inspired heuristic that supplements VQE. The improved VQE enables an efficient initial state-preparation mechanism, in a recursive manner, for a quasidynamical unitary evolution. We conduct an in-depth scaling analysis of finding the ground-state energies with increasing lattice sizes of the Heisenberg model, employing simulations of up to 40 qubits that manipulate the complete state vector. In addition to systematically finding the ground-state energy, we observe that it avoids barren plateaus, escapes local minima, and works with low-depth circuits. For the current devices, we further propose a benchmarking toolkit using a mean-field model and test it on IBM Q devices. Realistic gate execution times estimate a longer computational time to complete the same computation on a fully functional error-free quantum computer than on a quantum computer emulator implemented on a classical computer. However, our proposal can be expected to help accurate estimations of the ground-state energies beyond 50 qubits when the complete state vector can no longer be stored on a classical computer, thus enabling quantum advantage.
Quantum optimization allows for up to exponential quantum speedups for specific, possibly industrially relevant problems. As the key algorithm in this field, we motivate and discuss the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA), which can be understood as a slightly generalized version of Quantum Annealing for gate-based quantum computers. We delve into the quantum circuit implementation of the QAOA, including Hamiltonian simulation techniques for higher-order Ising models, and discuss parameter training using the parameter shift rule. An example implementation with Pennylane source code demonstrates practical application for the Maximum Cut problem. Further, we show how constraints can be incorporated into the QAOA using Grover mixers, allowing to restrict the search space to strictly valid solutions for specific problems. Finally, we outline the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) as a generalization of the QAOA, highlighting its potential in the NISQ era and addressing challenges such as barren plateaus and ansatz design.
Abstract The emergence of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices has fueled the development of hybrid quantum-classical algorithms for machine learning (ML), promising potential advantages over classical methods. However, the practical efficacy of these algorithms remains uncertain due to challenges like noise susceptibility, trainability issues, and a lack of rigorous benchmarking. This study presents a comprehensive empirical evaluation of two flagship hybrid algorithms the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) for classification and the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) for combinatorial optimization against state-of-the-art classical baselines under equivalent resource constraints. Through extensive simulations incorporating realistic noise models, we demonstrate that while these quantum approaches achieve competitive performance (e.g., 91.2% accuracy for VQE on a binary classification task), they consistently underperformed optimized classical models like Support Vector Machines (94.8% accuracy) and require orders of magnitude more computational time. Furthermore, we provide empirical validation of critical barriers to scalability, including the barren plateau phenomenon and significant performance degradation under noise, even with advanced error mitigation. Our results indicate that for the tasks studied, current NISQ era algorithms do not yet provide a tangible quantum advantage. This work contributes a rigorous benchmarking framework and a critical, realistic assessment of the field, suggesting that future progress hinges on fundamental algorithmic innovations and hardware improvements rather than incremental refinements of existing paradigms.
We propose a divide-and-conquer method for the quantum-classical hybrid algorithm to solve larger problems with small-scale quantum computers.Specifically, we concatenate a variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) with a reduction in the system dimension, where the interactions between divided subsystems are taken as an effective Hamiltonian expanded by the reduced basis.Then the effective Hamiltonian is further solved by the VQE, which we call deep VQE.Deep VQE allows us to apply quantum-classical hybrid algorithms on small-scale quantum computers to large systems with strong intrasubsystem interactions and weak intersubsystem interactions, or strongly correlated spin models on large regular lattices.As proof-of-principle numerical demonstrations, we use the proposed method for quasi-one-dimensional models, including one-dimensionally coupled 12-qubit Heisenberg antiferromagnetic models on kagome lattices as well as two-dimensional Heisenberg antiferromagnetic models on square lattices.The largest problem size of 64 qubits is solved by simulating 20-qubit quantum computers with a reasonably good accuracy approximately a few %.The proposed scheme enables us to handle the problems of > 1000 qubits by concatenating VQEs with a few tens of qubits.While it is unclear how accurate ground-state energy can be obtained for such a large system, our numerical results on a 64-qubit system suggest that deep VQE provides a good approximation (discrepancy within a few percent) and has room for further improvement.Therefore, deep VQE provides us a promising pathway to solve practically important problems on noisy intermediate-scale quantum computers.
ABSTRACT: Even if the quantum computing popularity has recently grown, the currently-available technology is not ready for a fundamental revolution of informatics. In this transition phase, hybrid quantum-classical algorithms can help in understanding the real power that this novel paradigm can reach in the future. In this work, we tested the capability of two such algorithms to solve combinatorial optimization problems: the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) and the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). We used them to solve max-cut problems, consisting of separating the vertices of an undirected graph in two sub-groups so that the number of edges connecting vertices of different sub-groups is maximal. To do that, we mapped the problem into a quantum system, using the Ising formalism. In particular, we investigated the effect of changing the number of measurements of the quantum circuit associated with the system on the algorithms convergence. A large number of measurements (or shots) allows a better knowledge of the quantum state, but on the other hand, increases the convergence time, making the algorithms less competitive compared to classical techniques. The results showed that VQE needs a mínimum number of measurements to start converging towards the optimal problem solution. Once this threshold is overcome, the solution improves as 1/√shots. QAOA, on the other hand, does not seem to converge, independently of the number of shots.