Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2209.14660 · Physical Review A

Comment on “Revisiting the phase transitions of the Dicke model”

Ángel L. Corps, Armando Relaño

Published Oct 13, 2022• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the work of Das and Sharma [Phys. Rev. A 105, 033716 (2022)] the phase transitions of the Dicke model are studied. Its main result is that, besides the well-known quantum phase transition, excited-state quantum phase transition, and thermal phase transition exhibited by the model, there exists an upper bound energy ${E}_{*}$ beyond which the model ceases to exhibit quantum chaotic behavior and the structure of the eigenfunctions changes. Based on this finding, a number of well-established results about the Dicke model are called into question. We argue that this result and all its consequences are spurious numerical effects resulting from an improper truncation of the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space necessary for numerical diagonalization.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.106.047701

Related papers

Revisiting the phase transitions of the Dicke model

Pragna Das, Auditya Sharma

The Dicke model exhibits a variety of phase transitions. The quantum phase transition from the normal phase to the super-radiant phase is marked by a dramatic change in the scaling of the participation ratio. We find that the ground state in the super-radiant phase exhibits multifractality manifest in the participation ratio scaling as the square root of the full Hilbert-space dimension. The thermal phase transition temperature, for which an exact analytical expression may be obtained using the partition function, is strikingly captured by the mutual information between two spins. In the excited-state quantum phase transition within the super-radiant phase, there are two cutoff energies; the central energy bands between the lower and upper cutoff energies show distinctly different behaviors. While the level statistics of the central band is Wigner-Dyson, the lower and upper bands show mixed behavior that is closer to Poisson than Wigner-Dyson. This finding is corroborated with the aid of several eigenvector properties: von Neumann entanglement entropy between spins and bosons, the mean photon number, concurrence between two spins, and participation ratio.

arXiv:2109.06227•Physical Review A•Mar 30, 2022•16 citations

Comment on “Exploring chaos in the Dicke model using ground-state fidelity and Loschmidt echo”

Ignacio García-Mata, Augusto J. Roncaglia, Diego A. Wisniacki

In a recent paper [Phys. Rev. E 90, 022920 (2014)] a study of the ground-state fidelity of the Dicke model as a function of the coupling parameter is presented. Abrupt jumps of the fidelity in the superradiant phase are observed and are assumed to be related to the transition to chaos. We show that this conclusion results from a misinterpretation of the numerics. In fact, if the parity symmetry is taken into account, the unexpected jumps disappear.

arXiv:1410.6848•Physical Review E•Mar 10, 2015•2 citations

Excited-state quantum phase transitions and their manifestations in an extended Dicke model

Pavel Stránský, Michal Kloc, Pavel Cejnar

An Excited-State Quantum Phase Transition (esqpt) is a singularity observed in quantum energy spectra in the infinite-size limit of the system. It originates in the existence of stationary points in the semiclassical Hamiltonian function. We review the classification of esqpts and present a case study in an extended Dicke model. Finally, we show some preliminary results on the dynamical effect induced by esqpts.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2017•2 citations

Chaos and Thermalization in the Spin-Boson Dicke Model

David Villaseñor, Saúl Pilatowsky-Cameo, M. A. Bastarrachea-Magnani +3 more

We present a detailed analysis of the connection between chaos and the onset of thermalization in the spin-boson Dicke model. This system has a well-defined classical limit with two degrees of freedom, and it presents both regular and chaotic regions. Our studies of the eigenstate expectation values and the distributions of the off-diagonal elements of the number of photons and the number of excited atoms validate the diagonal and off-diagonal eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) in the chaotic region, thus ensuring thermalization. The validity of the ETH reflects the chaotic structure of the eigenstates, which we corroborate using the von Neumann entanglement entropy and the Shannon entropy. Our results for the Shannon entropy also make evident the advantages of the so-called "efficient basis" over the widespread employed Fock basis when investigating the unbounded spectrum of the Dicke model. The efficient basis gives us access to a larger number of converged states than what can be reached with the Fock basis.

arXiv:2211.08434•Entropy•Dec 21, 2022•24 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Exploring chaos in the Dicke model using ground-state fidelity and Loschmidt echo’ ”

Utso Bhattacharya, Sayak Dasgupta, Amit Dutta

Although we agree with the fact reported in García-Mata et al. [Phys. Rev. E 91, 036901 (2015)] that a computational error resulted in misinterpretation of the behavior of the ground-state fidelity only, we emphasize below that this does not alter the main conclusion of our paper. That is the main claim that we had made about the use of quantum information measures to study chaos in the Dicke model still holds true.

Physical Review E•Mar 10, 2015•1 citation

Once more on the equivalence between quantum phase transition phenomena in radiation-matter and magnetic systems

J.G. Brankov, N. S. Tonchev, Valentin Anatol'evich Zagrebnov

In answer to the replies of Reslen {\it et al} [arXiv: quant-ph/0507164 (2005)], and Liberti and Zaffino [arXiv:cond-mat/0507019, (2005)], we comment once more on the temperature-dependent effective Hamiltonians for the Dicke model derived by them in [Europhys. Lett., {\bf 69} (2005) 8] and [Eur. Phys. J., {\bf 44} (2005) 535], respectively. These approximate Hamiltonians cannot be correct for any finite nonzero temperature because they both violate a rigorous result. The fact that the Dicke model belongs to the universality class of, and its thermodynamics is described by the infinitely coordinated transverse-field XY model is known for more than 30 years.

arXiv:quant-ph/0508039•Aug 4, 2005•0 citations
In the work of Das and Sharma [Phys. Rev. A 105, 033716 (2022)] the phase transitions of the Dicke model are studied. Its main result is that, besides the well-known quantum phase transition, excited-state quantum phase transition, and thermal phase transition exhibited by the model, there exists an upper bound energy E∗{E}_{*}E∗​ beyond which the model ceases to exhibit quantum chaotic behavior and the structure of the eigenfunctions changes. Based on this finding, a number of well-established results about the Dicke model are called into question. We argue that this result and all its consequences are spurious numerical effects resulting from an improper truncation of the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space necessary for numerical diagonalization.
The Dicke model exhibits a variety of phase transitions. The quantum phase transition from the normal phase to the super-radiant phase is marked by a dramatic change in the scaling of the participation ratio. We find that the ground state in the super-radiant phase exhibits multifractality manifest in the participation ratio scaling as the square root of the full Hilbert-space dimension. The thermal phase transition temperature, for which an exact analytical expression may be obtained using the partition function, is strikingly captured by the mutual information between two spins. In the excited-state quantum phase transition within the super-radiant phase, there are two cutoff energies; the central energy bands between the lower and upper cutoff energies show distinctly different behaviors. While the level statistics of the central band is Wigner-Dyson, the lower and upper bands show mixed behavior that is closer to Poisson than Wigner-Dyson. This finding is corroborated with the aid of several eigenvector properties: von Neumann entanglement entropy between spins and bosons, the mean photon number, concurrence between two spins, and participation ratio.
We present a detailed analysis of the connection between chaos and the onset of thermalization in the spin-boson Dicke model. This system has a well-defined classical limit with two degrees of freedom, and it presents both regular and chaotic regions. Our studies of the eigenstate expectation values and the distributions of the off-diagonal elements of the number of photons and the number of excited atoms validate the diagonal and off-diagonal eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) in the chaotic region, thus ensuring thermalization. The validity of the ETH reflects the chaotic structure of the eigenstates, which we corroborate using the von Neumann entanglement entropy and the Shannon entropy. Our results for the Shannon entropy also make evident the advantages of the so-called "efficient basis" over the widespread employed Fock basis when investigating the unbounded spectrum of the Dicke model. The efficient basis gives us access to a larger number of converged states than what can be reached with the Fock basis.
In answer to the replies of Reslen {\it et al} [arXiv: quant-ph/0507164 (2005)], and Liberti and Zaffino [arXiv:cond-mat/0507019, (2005)], we comment once more on the temperature-dependent effective Hamiltonians for the Dicke model derived by them in [Europhys. Lett., {\bf 69} (2005) 8] and [Eur. Phys. J., {\bf 44} (2005) 535], respectively. These approximate Hamiltonians cannot be correct for any finite nonzero temperature because they both violate a rigorous result. The fact that the Dicke model belongs to the universality class of, and its thermodynamics is described by the infinitely coordinated transverse-field XY model is known for more than 30 years.