Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2208.10341 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Dispensing of quantum information beyond no-broadcasting theorem—is it possible to broadcast anything genuinely quantum?

Teiko Heinosaari, Anna Jenčová, Martin Plávala

Published Feb 15, 2023• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract No-broadcasting theorem is one of the most fundamental results in quantum information theory; it guarantees that the simplest attacks on any quantum protocol, based on eavesdropping and copying of quantum information, are impossible. Due to the fundamental importance of the no-broadcasting theorem, it is essential to understand the exact boundaries of this limitation. We generalize the standard definition of broadcasting by restricting the set of states which we want to broadcast and restricting the sets of measurements which we use to test the broadcasting. We show that in some of the investigated cases broadcasting is equivalent to commutativity, while in other cases commutativity is not necessary.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8121/acbc5b

Related papers

No-local-broadcasting theorem for nonsignaling behaviors and assemblages

Adrian Solymos, Carlos Vieira, Cristhiano Duarte +1 more

The no-broadcasting theorem is a fundamental result in quantum information theory. It guarantees that a class of attacks on quantum protocols, based on eavesdropping and indiscriminate copying of quantum information, are impossible. Due to its fundamental importance, it is natural to ask whether it is an intrinsic quantum property or whether it also holds for a broader class of non-classical theories. To address this question, one could use the framework of correlation scenarios. Under this standpoint, Joshi, Grudka, and the Horodeckis conjectured that one cannot locally broadcast nonlocal behaviours. In this paper, we prove their conjecture based on the monotonicity of the relative entropy for behaviours. Additionally, following a similar reasoning, we obtain an analogous no-go theorem for steerable assemblages.

arXiv:2211.14351•Physical Review A•Feb 3, 2026•0 citations

Three No-go Theorems

Giacomo Mauro D’Ariano, Giulio Chiribella, Paolo Perinotti

Quantum information theory is a wide area of investigation, which includes two main subjects: quantum computation and quantum communication. The success of quantum computation theory is due to a positive result: Shor's algorithm. The algorithm provides factorization of integers in a much more efficient way with respect to what is achieved not only by present-day computers, but even by the most powerful conceivable computers based on classical physics. On the other hand, the success of quantum communication is due to the intrinsic security of ideal quantum cryptographic protocols, and thus relies on a negative result, that is the impossibility of reading quantum information without scrambling it in an unrecoverable way. The no information without disturbance property spawns other no-go theorems, which represent some of the most famous and classic results in quantum information theory. Among these results one can certainly list the no-cloning theorem, stating the impossibility of copying quantum information. This impossibility is clearly a consequence of the impossibility of extracting information without disturbing it. Indeed, if we could copy exactly the state of a system, reproducing it on another system of the same type, then we would also be able to iterate this process, and produce as many copies as we want. We could then extract all the information we are interested in from the copies, keeping the original intact. This argument is so simple, but hides a very deep point about quantum information, and more generally about any type of information that can be purified. Suppose indeed that there exists a measurement allowing us to determine the state of a system, with absolute precision. We could then use such a measurement on the system, and once we know its exact state, we can in principle re-prepare the same state as many times as we want. If copying the state is forbidden within a theory, we must then conclude that, in that theory, measuring the state is forbidden, too! This is exactly the case in theories with purification, and in particular in quantum theory. In quantum theory, determining the state of a system is impossible. We can only have some information about what state our system is prepared in. The information may be accurate, but it will never be certain. This could be practically the case in classical theory, too.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 2, 2016•0 citations

No-Broadcasting characterizes operational contextuality

Pauli Jokinen, Mirjam Weilenmann, Martin Plávala +3 more

Operational contextuality forms a rapidly developing subfield of quantum information theory. However, the characterization of the quantum mechanical entities that fuel the phenomenon has remained unknown with many partial results existing. Here, we present a resolution to this problem by connecting operational contextuality one-to-one with the no-broadcasting theorem. The connection works both on the level of full quantum theory and subtheories thereof. We demonstrate the connection in various relevant cases, showing especially that for quantum states the possibility of demonstrating contextuality is exactly characterized by non-commutativity, and for measurements this is done by a norm-1 property closely related to repeatability. Moreover, we show how techniques from broadcasting can be used to simplify known foundational results in contextuality.

•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Copying Quantum States

Hans Maassen, Burkhard Kümmerer

The no-broadcasting theorem in quantum information says that a set of states on a quantum system admits a common broadcasting (copying) operation if and only if their density matrices belong to a commuting family. We discuss and prove this theorem, as well as the closely related no-cloning theorem in the context of quantum probability theory, i.e. in the category of (finite dimensional) C-star-algebras with unital completely positive maps.

quant-pharXiv:2607.02408•Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Mathematics•Jul 3, 2026•0 citations

No-Broadcasting Characterizes Operational Contextuality

Pauli Jokinen, Mirjam Weilenmann, Martin Plávala +3 more

Operational contextuality forms a rapidly developing subfield of quantum information theory. However, the characterization of the quantum mechanical entities that fuel the phenomenon has remained unknown with many partial results existing. Here, we present a resolution to this problem by connecting operational contextuality one-to-one with the no-broadcasting theorem. The connection works both on the level of full quantum theory and subtheories thereof. We demonstrate the connection in various relevant cases, showing especially that for quantum states the possibility of demonstrating contextuality is exactly characterized by non-commutativity, and for measurements this is done by a norm-1 property closely related to repeatability. Moreover, we show how techniques from broadcasting can be used to simplify known foundational results in contextuality.

Physical Review Letters•Dec 9, 2024•8 citations

No-Broadcasting characterizes operational contextuality

Pauli Jokinen, Mirjam Weilenmann, Martin Plávala +3 more

Operational contextuality forms a rapidly developing subfield of quantum information theory. However, the characterization of the quantum mechanical entities that fuel the phenomenon has remained unknown with many partial results existing. Here, we present a resolution to this problem by connecting operational contextuality one-to-one with the no-broadcasting theorem. The connection works both on the level of full quantum theory and subtheories thereof. We demonstrate the connection in various relevant cases, showing especially that for quantum states the possibility of demonstrating contextuality is exactly characterized by non-commutativity, and for measurements this is done by a norm-1 property closely related to repeatability. Moreover, we show how techniques from broadcasting can be used to simplify known foundational results in contextuality.

arXiv:2406.07305•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations
Abstract No-broadcasting theorem is one of the most fundamental results in quantum information theory; it guarantees that the simplest attacks on any quantum protocol, based on eavesdropping and copying of quantum information, are impossible. Due to the fundamental importance of the no-broadcasting theorem, it is essential to understand the exact boundaries of this limitation. We generalize the standard definition of broadcasting by restricting the set of states which we want to broadcast and restricting the sets of measurements which we use to test the broadcasting. We show that in some of the investigated cases broadcasting is equivalent to commutativity, while in other cases commutativity is not necessary.
The no-broadcasting theorem is a fundamental result in quantum information theory. It guarantees that a class of attacks on quantum protocols, based on eavesdropping and indiscriminate copying of quantum information, are impossible. Due to its fundamental importance, it is natural to ask whether it is an intrinsic quantum property or whether it also holds for a broader class of non-classical theories. To address this question, one could use the framework of correlation scenarios. Under this standpoint, Joshi, Grudka, and the Horodeckis conjectured that one cannot locally broadcast nonlocal behaviours. In this paper, we prove their conjecture based on the monotonicity of the relative entropy for behaviours. Additionally, following a similar reasoning, we obtain an analogous no-go theorem for steerable assemblages.
Quantum information theory is a wide area of investigation, which includes two main subjects: quantum computation and quantum communication. The success of quantum computation theory is due to a positive result: Shor's algorithm. The algorithm provides factorization of integers in a much more efficient way with respect to what is achieved not only by present-day computers, but even by the most powerful conceivable computers based on classical physics. On the other hand, the success of quantum communication is due to the intrinsic security of ideal quantum cryptographic protocols, and thus relies on a negative result, that is the impossibility of reading quantum information without scrambling it in an unrecoverable way. The no information without disturbance property spawns other no-go theorems, which represent some of the most famous and classic results in quantum information theory. Among these results one can certainly list the no-cloning theorem, stating the impossibility of copying quantum information. This impossibility is clearly a consequence of the impossibility of extracting information without disturbing it. Indeed, if we could copy exactly the state of a system, reproducing it on another system of the same type, then we would also be able to iterate this process, and produce as many copies as we want. We could then extract all the information we are interested in from the copies, keeping the original intact. This argument is so simple, but hides a very deep point about quantum information, and more generally about any type of information that can be purified. Suppose indeed that there exists a measurement allowing us to determine the state of a system, with absolute precision. We could then use such a measurement on the system, and once we know its exact state, we can in principle re-prepare the same state as many times as we want. If copying the state is forbidden within a theory, we must then conclude that, in that theory, measuring the state is forbidden, too! This is exactly the case in theories with purification, and in particular in quantum theory. In quantum theory, determining the state of a system is impossible. We can only have some information about what state our system is prepared in. The information may be accurate, but it will never be certain. This could be practically the case in classical theory, too.
Operational contextuality forms a rapidly developing subfield of quantum information theory. However, the characterization of the quantum mechanical entities that fuel the phenomenon has remained unknown with many partial results existing. Here, we present a resolution to this problem by connecting operational contextuality one-to-one with the no-broadcasting theorem. The connection works both on the level of full quantum theory and subtheories thereof. We demonstrate the connection in various relevant cases, showing especially that for quantum states the possibility of demonstrating contextuality is exactly characterized by non-commutativity, and for measurements this is done by a norm-1 property closely related to repeatability. Moreover, we show how techniques from broadcasting can be used to simplify known foundational results in contextuality.
Operational contextuality forms a rapidly developing subfield of quantum information theory. However, the characterization of the quantum mechanical entities that fuel the phenomenon has remained unknown with many partial results existing. Here, we present a resolution to this problem by connecting operational contextuality one-to-one with the no-broadcasting theorem. The connection works both on the level of full quantum theory and subtheories thereof. We demonstrate the connection in various relevant cases, showing especially that for quantum states the possibility of demonstrating contextuality is exactly characterized by non-commutativity, and for measurements this is done by a norm-1 property closely related to repeatability. Moreover, we show how techniques from broadcasting can be used to simplify known foundational results in contextuality.
Operational contextuality forms a rapidly developing subfield of quantum information theory. However, the characterization of the quantum mechanical entities that fuel the phenomenon has remained unknown with many partial results existing. Here, we present a resolution to this problem by connecting operational contextuality one-to-one with the no-broadcasting theorem. The connection works both on the level of full quantum theory and subtheories thereof. We demonstrate the connection in various relevant cases, showing especially that for quantum states the possibility of demonstrating contextuality is exactly characterized by non-commutativity, and for measurements this is done by a norm-1 property closely related to repeatability. Moreover, we show how techniques from broadcasting can be used to simplify known foundational results in contextuality.