Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2207.04842 · Physical Review Research

Entanglement witnesses in the XY chain: Thermal equilibrium and postquench nonequilibrium states

Ferenc Iglói, Géza Tóth

Published Mar 1, 2023• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We use entanglement witnesses to detect entanglement in the $XY$ chain in thermal equilibrium and determine the temperature bound below which the state is detected as entangled. We consider the entanglement witness based on the Hamiltonian. Such a witness detects a state as entangled if its energy is smaller than the energy of separable states. We also consider a family of entanglement witnesses related to the entanglement negativity of the state. We test the witnesses in infinite and finite systems. We study how the temperature bounds obtained are influenced by a quantum phase transition or a disorder line in the ground state. Very strong finite-size corrections are observed in the ordered phase due to the presence of a quasidegenerate excitation. We also study the postquench states in the thermodynamic limit after a quench when the parameters of the Hamiltonian are changed suddenly. In the case of the Ising model, we find that the mixed postquench state is detected as entangled by the two methods if the parameters of the Hamiltonian before and after the quench are close to each other. We find that the two witnesses give qualitatively similar results, showing that energy-based entanglement witnesses are efficient in detecting the nearest-neighbor entanglement in spin chains in various circumstances. For other XY models, we find that the negativity-based witnesses also detect states in some parameter regions where the energy-based witness does not, in particular, if the quench is performed from the paramagnetic phase to the ferromagnetic phase and vice versa. The domains in parameter space corresponding to postquench states detected as entangled by the energy-based witness have been determined analytically, which stresses further the utility of our method.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.5.013158

Related papers

Entanglement detection in postquench nonequilibrium states: thermal Gibbs vs. generalized Gibbs ensemble

Ferenc Iglói, Csaba Zoltán Király

Abstract We use entanglement witnesses related to the entanglement negativity of the state to detect entanglement in the XY chain in the postquench states in the thermodynamic limit after a quench when the parameters of the Hamiltonian are changed suddenly. The entanglement negativity is related to correlations, which in the postquench stationary state are described by a generalized Gibbs ensemble, in the ideal case. If, however, integrability breaking perturbations are present, the system is expected to thermalize. Here, we compare the nearest-neighbor entanglement in the two circumstances. Graphical Abstract Postquench states after a sudden quench protocol $$(h_0, \gamma ) \rightarrow (h, \gamma )$$ ( h 0 , γ ) → ( h , γ ) in the XY chain.

arXiv:2403.07897•The European Physical Journal B•Jun 1, 2024•1 citation

Entanglement witnesses in spin models

Géza Tóth

We construct entanglement witnesses using fundamental quantum operators of spin models which contain two-particle interactions and have a certain symmetry. By choosing the Hamiltonian as such an operator, our method can be used for detecting entanglement by energy measurement. We apply this method to the Heisenberg model in a cubic lattice with a magnetic field, the $XY$ model, and other familiar spin systems. Our method provides a temperature bound for separable states for systems in thermal equilibrium. We also study the Bose-Hubbard model and relate its energy minimum for separable states to the minimum obtained from the Gutzwiller ansatz.

arXiv:quant-ph/0406061•Physical Review A•Jan 6, 2005•184 citations

Global geometric entanglement in transverse-field XY spin chains: finite and infinite systems

Tzu-Chieh Wei, Smitha Vishveshwara, Paul M. Goldbart

The entanglement in quantum XY spin chains of arbitrary length is investigated via the geometric measure of entanglement. The emergence of entanglement is explained intuitively from the perspective of perturbations. The model is solved exactly and the energy spectrum is determined and analyzed in particular for the lowest two levels for both finite and infinite systems. The overlaps for these two levels are calculated analytically for arbitrary number of spins. The entanglement is hence obtained by maximizing over a single parameter. The corresponding ground-state entanglement surface is then determined over the entire phase diagram, and its behavior can be used to delineate the boundaries in the phase diagram. For example, the field-derivative of the entanglement becomes singular along the critical line. The form of the divergence is derived analytically and it turns out to be dictated by the universality class controlling the quantum phase transition. The behavior of the entanglement near criticality can be understood via a scaling hypothesis, analogous to that for free energies. The entanglement density vanishes along the so-called disorder line in the phase diagram, the ground space is doubly degenerate and spanned by two product states. The entanglement for the superposition of the lowest two states is also calculated. The exact value of the entanglement depends on the specific form of superposition. However, in the thermodynamic limit the entanglement density turns out to be independent of the superposition. This proves that the entanglement density is insensitive to whether the ground state is chosen to be the spontaneously $Z_2$ symmetry broken one or not. The finite-size scaling of entanglement at critical points is also investigated from two different view points. First, the maximum in the field-derivative of the entanglement density is computed and fitted to a logarithmic dependence of the system size, thereby deducing the correlation length exponent for the Ising class using only the behavior of entanglement. Second, the entanglement density itself is shown to possess a correction term inversely proportional to the system size, with the coefficient being universal (but with different values for the ground state and the first excited state, respectively).

arXiv:1012.4114•Quantum Information and Computation•Mar 1, 2011•10 citations

Probing non-equilibrium physics through the two-body Bell correlator

Abhishek Muhuri, Tanoy Kanti Konar, Leela Ganesh Chandra Lakkaraju +1 more

Identifying equilibrium criticalities and phases from the dynamics of a system, known as a dynamical quantum phase transition (DQPT), is a challenging task when relying solely on local observables. We exhibit that the experimentally accessible two-body Bell operator, originally designed to detect nonlocal correlations in quantum states, serves as an effective witness of DQPTs in a long-range (LR) XY spin chain subjected to a magnetic field, where the interaction strength decays as a power law. Following a sudden quench of the system parameters, the Bell operator between nearest-neighbor spins exhibits a distinct drop at the critical boundaries. In this study, we consider two quenching protocols, namely sudden quenches of the magnetic field strength and the interaction fall-off rate. This pronounced behavior defines a threshold, distinguishing intra-phase from inter-phase quenches, remaining valid regardless of the strength of long-range interactions, anisotropy, and system sizes. Comparative analyses further demonstrate that conventional classical and quantum correlators, including entanglement, fail to capture this transition during dynamics.

arXiv:2510.27657•Oct 31, 2025•0 citations

Energy as an Entanglement Indicator

Miłosz R. Michalski

We explore the method of constructing an entanglement witness utilising the Hamiltonian of a physical system in consideration. Already a partial knowledge of the energy spectrum allows one not only to detect entanglement in thermal equilibrium states, but also to discriminate among its various multipartite genres. We propose an efficient approximate algorithm producing a witness capable of detecting genuine n-partite entanglement. As an illustration, the method is applied to an analytically computable example of anisotropic XXZ Heisenberg chain.

Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Mar 1, 2011•0 citations

Entanglement in a spin- s antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain

Xiang Hao, Shiqun Zhu

The entanglement in a general Heisenberg antiferromagnetic chain of arbitrary spin-$s$ is investigated. The entanglement is witnessed by the thermal energy which equals the minimum energy of any separable state. There is a characteristic temperature below that an entangled thermal state exists. The characteristic temperature for thermal entanglement is increased with spin $s$. When the total number of lattice is increased, the characteristic temperature decreases and then approaches a constant. This effect shows that the thermal entanglement can be detected in a real solid state system of larger number of lattices for finite temperature. The comparison of negativity and entanglement witness is obtained from the separability of the unentangled states. It is found that the thermal energy provides a sufficient condition for the existence of the thermal entanglement in a spin-$s$ antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain.

Physical Review A•Oct 5, 2005•18 citations
We use entanglement witnesses to detect entanglement in the XYXYXY chain in thermal equilibrium and determine the temperature bound below which the state is detected as entangled. We consider the entanglement witness based on the Hamiltonian. Such a witness detects a state as entangled if its energy is smaller than the energy of separable states. We also consider a family of entanglement witnesses related to the entanglement negativity of the state. We test the witnesses in infinite and finite systems. We study how the temperature bounds obtained are influenced by a quantum phase transition or a disorder line in the ground state. Very strong finite-size corrections are observed in the ordered phase due to the presence of a quasidegenerate excitation. We also study the postquench states in the thermodynamic limit after a quench when the parameters of the Hamiltonian are changed suddenly. In the case of the Ising model, we find that the mixed postquench state is detected as entangled by the two methods if the parameters of the Hamiltonian before and after the quench are close to each other. We find that the two witnesses give qualitatively similar results, showing that energy-based entanglement witnesses are efficient in detecting the nearest-neighbor entanglement in spin chains in various circumstances. For other XY models, we find that the negativity-based witnesses also detect states in some parameter regions where the energy-based witness does not, in particular, if the quench is performed from the paramagnetic phase to the ferromagnetic phase and vice versa. The domains in parameter space corresponding to postquench states detected as entangled by the energy-based witness have been determined analytically, which stresses further the utility of our method.
Abstract We use entanglement witnesses related to the entanglement negativity of the state to detect entanglement in the XY chain in the postquench states in the thermodynamic limit after a quench when the parameters of the Hamiltonian are changed suddenly. The entanglement negativity is related to correlations, which in the postquench stationary state are described by a generalized Gibbs ensemble, in the ideal case. If, however, integrability breaking perturbations are present, the system is expected to thermalize. Here, we compare the nearest-neighbor entanglement in the two circumstances. Graphical Abstract Postquench states after a sudden quench protocol (h0,γ)→(h,γ)(h_0, \gamma ) \rightarrow (h, \gamma )(h0​,γ)→(h,γ) ( h 0 , γ ) → ( h , γ ) in the XY chain.
We construct entanglement witnesses using fundamental quantum operators of spin models which contain two-particle interactions and have a certain symmetry. By choosing the Hamiltonian as such an operator, our method can be used for detecting entanglement by energy measurement. We apply this method to the Heisenberg model in a cubic lattice with a magnetic field, the XYXYXY model, and other familiar spin systems. Our method provides a temperature bound for separable states for systems in thermal equilibrium. We also study the Bose-Hubbard model and relate its energy minimum for separable states to the minimum obtained from the Gutzwiller ansatz.
The entanglement in quantum XY spin chains of arbitrary length is investigated via the geometric measure of entanglement. The emergence of entanglement is explained intuitively from the perspective of perturbations. The model is solved exactly and the energy spectrum is determined and analyzed in particular for the lowest two levels for both finite and infinite systems. The overlaps for these two levels are calculated analytically for arbitrary number of spins. The entanglement is hence obtained by maximizing over a single parameter. The corresponding ground-state entanglement surface is then determined over the entire phase diagram, and its behavior can be used to delineate the boundaries in the phase diagram. For example, the field-derivative of the entanglement becomes singular along the critical line. The form of the divergence is derived analytically and it turns out to be dictated by the universality class controlling the quantum phase transition. The behavior of the entanglement near criticality can be understood via a scaling hypothesis, analogous to that for free energies. The entanglement density vanishes along the so-called disorder line in the phase diagram, the ground space is doubly degenerate and spanned by two product states. The entanglement for the superposition of the lowest two states is also calculated. The exact value of the entanglement depends on the specific form of superposition. However, in the thermodynamic limit the entanglement density turns out to be independent of the superposition. This proves that the entanglement density is insensitive to whether the ground state is chosen to be the spontaneously Z2Z_2Z2​ symmetry broken one or not. The finite-size scaling of entanglement at critical points is also investigated from two different view points. First, the maximum in the field-derivative of the entanglement density is computed and fitted to a logarithmic dependence of the system size, thereby deducing the correlation length exponent for the Ising class using only the behavior of entanglement. Second, the entanglement density itself is shown to possess a correction term inversely proportional to the system size, with the coefficient being universal (but with different values for the ground state and the first excited state, respectively).
Identifying equilibrium criticalities and phases from the dynamics of a system, known as a dynamical quantum phase transition (DQPT), is a challenging task when relying solely on local observables. We exhibit that the experimentally accessible two-body Bell operator, originally designed to detect nonlocal correlations in quantum states, serves as an effective witness of DQPTs in a long-range (LR) XY spin chain subjected to a magnetic field, where the interaction strength decays as a power law. Following a sudden quench of the system parameters, the Bell operator between nearest-neighbor spins exhibits a distinct drop at the critical boundaries. In this study, we consider two quenching protocols, namely sudden quenches of the magnetic field strength and the interaction fall-off rate. This pronounced behavior defines a threshold, distinguishing intra-phase from inter-phase quenches, remaining valid regardless of the strength of long-range interactions, anisotropy, and system sizes. Comparative analyses further demonstrate that conventional classical and quantum correlators, including entanglement, fail to capture this transition during dynamics.
We explore the method of constructing an entanglement witness utilising the Hamiltonian of a physical system in consideration. Already a partial knowledge of the energy spectrum allows one not only to detect entanglement in thermal equilibrium states, but also to discriminate among its various multipartite genres. We propose an efficient approximate algorithm producing a witness capable of detecting genuine n-partite entanglement. As an illustration, the method is applied to an analytically computable example of anisotropic XXZ Heisenberg chain.
The entanglement in a general Heisenberg antiferromagnetic chain of arbitrary spin-sss is investigated. The entanglement is witnessed by the thermal energy which equals the minimum energy of any separable state. There is a characteristic temperature below that an entangled thermal state exists. The characteristic temperature for thermal entanglement is increased with spin sss. When the total number of lattice is increased, the characteristic temperature decreases and then approaches a constant. This effect shows that the thermal entanglement can be detected in a real solid state system of larger number of lattices for finite temperature. The comparison of negativity and entanglement witness is obtained from the separability of the unentangled states. It is found that the thermal energy provides a sufficient condition for the existence of the thermal entanglement in a spin-sss antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain.