Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2206.01151 · Acta Physica Polonica B

Equilibration and Locality

M. Gaździcki, M. I. Gorenstein, I. Pidhurskyi, Oleh Savchuk, Leonardo Tinti

Published Jan 1, 2022• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Experiments motivated by predictions of quantum mechanics indicate non-trivial correlations between spacelike-separated measurements. The phenomenon is referred to as a violation of strong-locality and, after Einstein, called ghostly action at a distance. An intriguing and previously unasked question is how the evolution of an assembly of particles to equilibrium-state relates to strong-locality. More specifically, whether, with this respect, indistinguishable particles differ from distinguishable ones. To address the question, we introduce a Markov-chain based framework over a finite set of microstates. For the first time, we formulate conditions needed to obey the particle transport- and strong-locality for indistinguishable particles. Models which obey transport-locality and lead to equilibrium-state are considered. We show that it is possible to construct models obeying and violating strong-locality both for indistinguishable particles and for distinguishable ones. However, we find that only for distinguishable particles strongly-local evolution to equilibrium is possible without breaking the microstate-symmetry. This is the strongest symmetry one can impose and leads to the shortest equilibration time. We hope that the results presented here may provide a new perspective on a violation of strong-locality, and the developed framework will help in future studies. Specifically they may help to interpret results on high-energy nuclear collisions indicating a fast equilibration of indistinguishable particles.

DOI
10.5506/aphyspolb.53.8-a2

Related papers

Locality and evolution to equilibrium

M. Gaździcki, M. I. Gorenstein, I. Pidhurskyi +2 more

Abstract Quantum statistics and non-locality are deeply rooted in quantum mechanics and go beyond our intuition reflected in classical physics. Quantum statistics can be derived using statistical methods for indistinguishable particles - particles of quantum mechanics. Violation of strong locality - colloquially called the ghostly action at a distance - is one of the most amazing properties of nature derived from quantum mechanics. An intriguing question is whether the non-local evolution of indistinguishable particles is needed to reach the equilibrium state given by quantum statistics. Motivated by the above and similar questions, we developed a simple framework that allows us to follow space-time evolution of assembly of particles. It is based on a discrete-time Markov chain on countable space for indistinguishable particles. We summarise well-known and introduced new constraints on the transition matrix that grant space-time symmetries, locality of particle-transport, strong locality, and equilibrium state. Then, within the framework, several important cases are considered. First, we show that the simplest transition matrix leads to equilibrium but violates particle transport and strong localities. Furthermore, we construct a simple matrix that leads to equilibrium obeying particle-transport locality and violating strong locality. This resembles the properties of quantum mechanics. Finally, we demonstrate that it is also possible to reach equilibrium by obeying both particle-transport and strong localities. Thus, within this framework, the violation of a strong locality is not needed to reach the equilibrium of indistinguishable particles. However, to obey strong locality, a complex structure of the transition matrix is needed. In addition, we comment on distinguishable particles and, in particular, show that their evolution seen by an observer blind to particle differences may look like the evolution of indistinguishable particles with the properties of quantum mechanics. We hope that this work may help to study the relation between symmetries, localities and the evolution to equilibrium for indistinguishable and distinguishable particles.

•Aug 12, 2021•0 citations

IDENTICAL PARTICLES ARE INHERENTLY INDISTINGUISHABLE

The preceding development has been specifically restricted to systems of identical indistinguishable particles, but no further conditions were imposed on the particles or their microstates. The relations derived in Chapter 8 are therefore equally applicable to systems of identical particles in both classical and quantum mechanics, provided the particles are regarded as indistinguishable . As discussed in the Preface and Introduction, it is our firm conviction that identical particles, by their very nature, are indeed inherently and unconditionally indistinguishable. If that proposition is accepted, the relations of Chapter 8 combine with the results of previous chapters to provide a unified general statistical formalism which applies to both classical and quantum particles. However, the appealing simplicity of this picture is undermined by the widespread misconception that identical classical particles are distinguishable, at least in principle, and must be treated as such. In this section we discuss the apparent origins and rationale for this unfortunate misconception in an attempt to reconstruct and rectify the fallacious notions on which it is based.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 22, 2017•0 citations

Quasilocality and equilibration in quantum systems

Marko Medenjak

The primary area, on which we focus in the thesis, are the out-of-equilibrium properties of quantum and classical systems. The playground we use to study those properties, are interacting integrable and solitonic systems, whose structure enables us to perform analytical calculations. In the context of the out-of-equilibrium physics we focus on two questions. The first problem is related to the set of stationary states in quantum systems. The question is especially important in the context of the homogeneous quantum quenches, since it makes possible the calculations of expectation values of local observables. The building blocks of stationary states are quasilocal conserved quantities which constitute the information that is preserved under the time evolution. In the first part of the thesis we deal with the construction of quasilocal conserved quantities in one dimensional anisotropic Heisenberg model and bosonic models. Quasilocal charges are put in the context of the standard theory of integrability, which in turn allows for the calculation of physical quantities. The second question we deal with are the transport properties of one dimensional systems. The connection between the local integrals of motion and ideal transport was established in 90's. Here we extend the connection to the diffusive transport. This enables us to obtain explicit lower bound on diffusion constant in Heisenberg model, which proves that the Heisenberg model is not an insulator at finite temperatures. In the last chapter we deal with the transport properties of classical celular automata. The first example we consider is the gas of charged hard core interacting particles, and the second one the gas of interacting solitons. Explicit solution of the dynamics of local observables allows for the explicit calculation of transport coeffcients, and the solution of the inhomogeneous quench problem. Despite their simplicity, the models exhibit wide range of transport phenomena ranging from insulating, through diffusive to ballistic transport.

•Jan 1, 2018•1 citation

Climbing the Fusion Tree: Center Ordering and Decoding Hierarchy in Non-Abelian Mixed States

Pablo Sala, Vlad Temkin, Cenke Xu +2 more

We develop an operational approach to strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (sw-SSB) of a non-Abelian symmetry group G. We formulate it as the decoding task of distinguishing two strongly symmetric states that differ by a pair of inserted irreps, after both are corrupted by strongly symmetric decoherence. For finite G, this task is dual to distinguishing logical states of the quantum double D(G) under pure-charge noise. We derive a hierarchy of statistical mechanics models describing optimal decoding from the fusion outcomes measured on successively larger nested regions. As for maximum-likelihood decoders of Abelian codes the measured irreps act as quenched disorder obeying a Nishimori-like condition. Strikingly, because local irreps do not determine how they fuse globally, the strong $G\times G$ symmetry is realized only nonlocally, and irreps trivially charged under Z(G) (the center of G) can hide inside noise-generated ones. As a result, the strong symmetry spontaneously breaks down to Z(G), times the weak symmetry. The only transition at nonzero error rate is then an ordering of the center, whose threshold cannot decrease as the hierarchy is ascended. This conclusion holds at any finite level of the hierarchy for non-nilpotent groups. We confirm these predictions with tensor-network calculations for $S_3$ and SU(2). At the first level, the $S_3$ model, whose center is trivial, shows no transition, and the fidelity correlations of all irreps provably decay to non-zero values. The SU(2) model exhibits a $Z_2$ transition consistent with the Nishimori-Ising universality class, where the fidelity correlations of spin-$1/2$ irreps become long-range. The threshold rises from the first to the second level of the hierarchy by $16\%$. Our results provide a systematic framework for studying non-Abelian sw-SSB and for constructing decoders for non Abelian topological codes.

quant-pharXiv:2610.06692•Oct 6, 2026•4 citations

Locality and entanglement of indistinguishable particles

Till Jonas Frederick Johann, Ugo Marzolino

Entanglement is one of the strongest quantum correlation, and is a key ingredient in fundamental aspects of quantum mechanics and a resource for quantum technologies. While entanglement theory is well settled for distinguishable particles, there are five inequivalent approaches to entanglement of indistinguishable particles. We analyse the different definitions of indistinguishable particle entanglement in the light of the locality notion. This notion is specified by two steps: (i) the identification of subsystems by means of their local operators; (ii) the requirement that entanglement represent correlations between the above subsets of operators. We prove that three of the aforementioned five entanglement definitions are incompatible with any locality notion defined as above.

arXiv:2107.13911•Scientific Reports•Jul 29, 2021•7 citations

Characterization of ergodicity breaking in disordered quantum systems

Giuseppe De Tomasi

The interplay between quenched disorder and interaction effects opens the possibility in a closed quantum many-body system of a phase transition at finite energy density between an ergodic phase, which is governed by the laws of statistical physics, and a localized one, in which the degrees of freedom are frozen and ergodicity breaks down. The possible existence of a quantum phase transition at finite energy density is strongly questioning our understanding of the fundamental laws of nature and has generated an active field of research called many-body localization. This thesis consists of three parts and is dedicated to the understanding and characterization of the phenomenon of many-body localization, approaching it from complementary facets. In particular, borrowing methods and tools from different fields, we analyze timely problems. The first part of the thesis is devoted to detecting the many-body localization transition and to characterize both the ergodic and the localized phase it separates. Here we provide a characterization from two different perspectives: the first one is based on the study of local entanglement properties. In the second one, using tools from quantum-chaos theory, we attempt to answer the question of understanding time-irreversibility, and thus probing the breaking of ergodicity. We analyze experimentally viable observables. Moreover, we propose two different quantities to distinguish an Anderson insulating phase from a many-body localized one, which is one of the issues in experiments. The second part focuses on understanding the existence of a putative subdiffusive multifractal phase. Analyzing the quantum dynamics of the system in this region of the phase diagram, we point out the importance of finite-size effects, questioning the existence of this multifractal phase. We speculate with a possible scenario in which the diffusivity and thus ergodicity could be restored in the thermodynamic limit. Furthermore, we find that the propagation is highly non-Gaussian, which could have an important effect on understanding the critical point of the according transition. We tackle this problem also from a different angle. A possible toy-model to understand many-body localization entails the Anderson model on a random-regular graph. Also in the latter model the possible existence of an intermediate multifractal phase has been conjectured. There, studying the survival return probability of a particle with time, we give a new characterization of multifractal phases and give indication of the possible existence of this phase. Nevertheless, we also outline possible caveats. In the last part of this thesis we study the interplay between symmetry and correlated disorder in a non-interacting fermionic system. We show another possible mechanism for breaking localization. In particular, we focus on studying information and particle transport, emphasizing how the two types of propagation can be different.

•May 7, 2018•0 citations
Experiments motivated by predictions of quantum mechanics indicate non-trivial correlations between spacelike-separated measurements. The phenomenon is referred to as a violation of strong-locality and, after Einstein, called ghostly action at a distance. An intriguing and previously unasked question is how the evolution of an assembly of particles to equilibrium-state relates to strong-locality. More specifically, whether, with this respect, indistinguishable particles differ from distinguishable ones. To address the question, we introduce a Markov-chain based framework over a finite set of microstates. For the first time, we formulate conditions needed to obey the particle transport- and strong-locality for indistinguishable particles. Models which obey transport-locality and lead to equilibrium-state are considered. We show that it is possible to construct models obeying and violating strong-locality both for indistinguishable particles and for distinguishable ones. However, we find that only for distinguishable particles strongly-local evolution to equilibrium is possible without breaking the microstate-symmetry. This is the strongest symmetry one can impose and leads to the shortest equilibration time. We hope that the results presented here may provide a new perspective on a violation of strong-locality, and the developed framework will help in future studies. Specifically they may help to interpret results on high-energy nuclear collisions indicating a fast equilibration of indistinguishable particles.
Abstract Quantum statistics and non-locality are deeply rooted in quantum mechanics and go beyond our intuition reflected in classical physics. Quantum statistics can be derived using statistical methods for indistinguishable particles - particles of quantum mechanics. Violation of strong locality - colloquially called the ghostly action at a distance - is one of the most amazing properties of nature derived from quantum mechanics. An intriguing question is whether the non-local evolution of indistinguishable particles is needed to reach the equilibrium state given by quantum statistics. Motivated by the above and similar questions, we developed a simple framework that allows us to follow space-time evolution of assembly of particles. It is based on a discrete-time Markov chain on countable space for indistinguishable particles. We summarise well-known and introduced new constraints on the transition matrix that grant space-time symmetries, locality of particle-transport, strong locality, and equilibrium state. Then, within the framework, several important cases are considered. First, we show that the simplest transition matrix leads to equilibrium but violates particle transport and strong localities. Furthermore, we construct a simple matrix that leads to equilibrium obeying particle-transport locality and violating strong locality. This resembles the properties of quantum mechanics. Finally, we demonstrate that it is also possible to reach equilibrium by obeying both particle-transport and strong localities. Thus, within this framework, the violation of a strong locality is not needed to reach the equilibrium of indistinguishable particles. However, to obey strong locality, a complex structure of the transition matrix is needed. In addition, we comment on distinguishable particles and, in particular, show that their evolution seen by an observer blind to particle differences may look like the evolution of indistinguishable particles with the properties of quantum mechanics. We hope that this work may help to study the relation between symmetries, localities and the evolution to equilibrium for indistinguishable and distinguishable particles.
The preceding development has been specifically restricted to systems of identical indistinguishable particles, but no further conditions were imposed on the particles or their microstates. The relations derived in Chapter 8 are therefore equally applicable to systems of identical particles in both classical and quantum mechanics, provided the particles are regarded as indistinguishable . As discussed in the Preface and Introduction, it is our firm conviction that identical particles, by their very nature, are indeed inherently and unconditionally indistinguishable. If that proposition is accepted, the relations of Chapter 8 combine with the results of previous chapters to provide a unified general statistical formalism which applies to both classical and quantum particles. However, the appealing simplicity of this picture is undermined by the widespread misconception that identical classical particles are distinguishable, at least in principle, and must be treated as such. In this section we discuss the apparent origins and rationale for this unfortunate misconception in an attempt to reconstruct and rectify the fallacious notions on which it is based.
The primary area, on which we focus in the thesis, are the out-of-equilibrium properties of quantum and classical systems. The playground we use to study those properties, are interacting integrable and solitonic systems, whose structure enables us to perform analytical calculations. In the context of the out-of-equilibrium physics we focus on two questions. The first problem is related to the set of stationary states in quantum systems. The question is especially important in the context of the homogeneous quantum quenches, since it makes possible the calculations of expectation values of local observables. The building blocks of stationary states are quasilocal conserved quantities which constitute the information that is preserved under the time evolution. In the first part of the thesis we deal with the construction of quasilocal conserved quantities in one dimensional anisotropic Heisenberg model and bosonic models. Quasilocal charges are put in the context of the standard theory of integrability, which in turn allows for the calculation of physical quantities. The second question we deal with are the transport properties of one dimensional systems. The connection between the local integrals of motion and ideal transport was established in 90's. Here we extend the connection to the diffusive transport. This enables us to obtain explicit lower bound on diffusion constant in Heisenberg model, which proves that the Heisenberg model is not an insulator at finite temperatures. In the last chapter we deal with the transport properties of classical celular automata. The first example we consider is the gas of charged hard core interacting particles, and the second one the gas of interacting solitons. Explicit solution of the dynamics of local observables allows for the explicit calculation of transport coeffcients, and the solution of the inhomogeneous quench problem. Despite their simplicity, the models exhibit wide range of transport phenomena ranging from insulating, through diffusive to ballistic transport.
We develop an operational approach to strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (sw-SSB) of a non-Abelian symmetry group G. We formulate it as the decoding task of distinguishing two strongly symmetric states that differ by a pair of inserted irreps, after both are corrupted by strongly symmetric decoherence. For finite G, this task is dual to distinguishing logical states of the quantum double D(G) under pure-charge noise. We derive a hierarchy of statistical mechanics models describing optimal decoding from the fusion outcomes measured on successively larger nested regions. As for maximum-likelihood decoders of Abelian codes the measured irreps act as quenched disorder obeying a Nishimori-like condition. Strikingly, because local irreps do not determine how they fuse globally, the strong G×GG\times GG×G symmetry is realized only nonlocally, and irreps trivially charged under Z(G) (the center of G) can hide inside noise-generated ones. As a result, the strong symmetry spontaneously breaks down to Z(G), times the weak symmetry. The only transition at nonzero error rate is then an ordering of the center, whose threshold cannot decrease as the hierarchy is ascended. This conclusion holds at any finite level of the hierarchy for non-nilpotent groups. We confirm these predictions with tensor-network calculations for S3S_3S3​ and SU(2). At the first level, the S3S_3S3​ model, whose center is trivial, shows no transition, and the fidelity correlations of all irreps provably decay to non-zero values. The SU(2) model exhibits a Z2Z_2Z2​ transition consistent with the Nishimori-Ising universality class, where the fidelity correlations of spin-1/21/21/2 irreps become long-range. The threshold rises from the first to the second level of the hierarchy by 16%16\%16%. Our results provide a systematic framework for studying non-Abelian sw-SSB and for constructing decoders for non Abelian topological codes.
Entanglement is one of the strongest quantum correlation, and is a key ingredient in fundamental aspects of quantum mechanics and a resource for quantum technologies. While entanglement theory is well settled for distinguishable particles, there are five inequivalent approaches to entanglement of indistinguishable particles. We analyse the different definitions of indistinguishable particle entanglement in the light of the locality notion. This notion is specified by two steps: (i) the identification of subsystems by means of their local operators; (ii) the requirement that entanglement represent correlations between the above subsets of operators. We prove that three of the aforementioned five entanglement definitions are incompatible with any locality notion defined as above.
The interplay between quenched disorder and interaction effects opens the possibility in a closed quantum many-body system of a phase transition at finite energy density between an ergodic phase, which is governed by the laws of statistical physics, and a localized one, in which the degrees of freedom are frozen and ergodicity breaks down. The possible existence of a quantum phase transition at finite energy density is strongly questioning our understanding of the fundamental laws of nature and has generated an active field of research called many-body localization. This thesis consists of three parts and is dedicated to the understanding and characterization of the phenomenon of many-body localization, approaching it from complementary facets. In particular, borrowing methods and tools from different fields, we analyze timely problems. The first part of the thesis is devoted to detecting the many-body localization transition and to characterize both the ergodic and the localized phase it separates. Here we provide a characterization from two different perspectives: the first one is based on the study of local entanglement properties. In the second one, using tools from quantum-chaos theory, we attempt to answer the question of understanding time-irreversibility, and thus probing the breaking of ergodicity. We analyze experimentally viable observables. Moreover, we propose two different quantities to distinguish an Anderson insulating phase from a many-body localized one, which is one of the issues in experiments. The second part focuses on understanding the existence of a putative subdiffusive multifractal phase. Analyzing the quantum dynamics of the system in this region of the phase diagram, we point out the importance of finite-size effects, questioning the existence of this multifractal phase. We speculate with a possible scenario in which the diffusivity and thus ergodicity could be restored in the thermodynamic limit. Furthermore, we find that the propagation is highly non-Gaussian, which could have an important effect on understanding the critical point of the according transition. We tackle this problem also from a different angle. A possible toy-model to understand many-body localization entails the Anderson model on a random-regular graph. Also in the latter model the possible existence of an intermediate multifractal phase has been conjectured. There, studying the survival return probability of a particle with time, we give a new characterization of multifractal phases and give indication of the possible existence of this phase. Nevertheless, we also outline possible caveats. In the last part of this thesis we study the interplay between symmetry and correlated disorder in a non-interacting fermionic system. We show another possible mechanism for breaking localization. In particular, we focus on studying information and particle transport, emphasizing how the two types of propagation can be different.