Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2205.15095 · SciPost Physics

Estimation of the geometric measure of entanglement with Wehrl moments through artificial neural networks

Jérôme Denis, François Damanet, John Martin

Published Nov 27, 2023• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In recent years, artificial neural networks (ANNs) have become an increasingly popular tool for studying problems in quantum theory, and in particular entanglement theory. In this work, we analyse to what extent ANNs can accurately predict the geometric measure of entanglement of symmetric multiqubit states using only a limited number of Wehrl moments (moments of the Husimi function of the state) as input, which represents partial information about the state. We consider both pure and mixed quantum states. We compare the results we obtain by training ANNs with the informed use of convergence acceleration methods. We find that even some of the most powerful convergence acceleration algorithms do not compete with ANNs when given the same input data, provided that enough data is available to train these ANNs. We also provide an experimental protocol for measuring Wehrl moments, which is state-independent. More generally, this work opens up perspectives for the estimation of entanglement measures and other SU(2)-invariant quantities, such as the Wehrl entropy, in a way that is more accessible in experiments than by means of full state tomography.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphys.15.5.208

Related papers

Quantifying entanglement for unknown quantum states via artificial neural networks

Guo‐Zhu Pan, Yang Ming, Jian Zhou +3 more

Quantum entanglement acts as a crucial part in quantum computation and quantum information, hence quantifying unknown entanglement is an important task. Due to the fact that the amount of entanglement cannot be achieved directly by measuring any physical observables, it remains an open problem to quantify entanglement experimentally. In this work, we provide an effective way to quantify entanglement for the unknown quantum states via artificial neural networks. By choosing the expectation values of measurements as input features and the values of entanglement measures as labels, we train artificial neural network models to predict the entanglement for new quantum states accurately. Our method does not require the full information about unknown quantum states, which highlights the effectiveness and versatility of machine learning in exploring quantum entanglement.

Scientific Reports•Nov 1, 2024•4 citations

Measuring Quantum Entanglement from Local Information by Machine Learning

Yulei Huang, Liangyu Che, Wei, Chao +5 more

Entanglement is a key property in the development of quantum technologies and in the study of quantum many-body simulations. However, entanglement measurement typically requires quantum full-state tomography (FST). Here we present a neural network-assisted protocol for measuring entanglement in equilibrium and non-equilibrium states of local Hamiltonians. Instead of FST, it can learn comprehensive entanglement quantities from single-qubit or two-qubit Pauli measurements, such as Rényi entropy, partially-transposed (PT) moments, and coherence. It is also exciting that our neural network is able to learn the future entanglement dynamics using only single-qubit traces from the previous time. In addition, we perform experiments using a nuclear spin quantum processor and train an adoptive neural network to study entanglement in the ground and dynamical states of a one-dimensional spin chain. Quantum phase transitions (QPT) are revealed by measuring static entanglement in ground states, and the entanglement dynamics beyond measurement time is accurately estimated in dynamical states. These precise results validate our neural network. Our work will have a wide range of applications in quantum many-body systems, from quantum phase transitions to intriguing non-equilibrium phenomena such as quantum thermalization.

arXiv:2209.08501•Sep 18, 2022•1 citation

Quantifying Unknown Multiqubit Entanglement Using Machine Learning

Yukun Wang, Shaoxuan Wang, Jincheng Xing +2 more

Entanglement plays a pivotal role in numerous quantum applications, and as technology progresses, entanglement systems continue to expand. However, quantifying entanglement is a complex problem, particularly for multipartite quantum states. The currently available entanglement measures suffer from high computational complexity, and for unknown multipartite entangled states, complete information about the quantum state is often necessary, further complicating calculations. In this paper, we train neural networks to quantify unknown multipartite entanglement using input features based on squared entanglement (SE) and outcome statistics data produced by locally measuring target quantum states. By leveraging machine learning techniques to handle non-linear relations between outcome statistics and entanglement measurement SE, we achieve high-precision quantification of unknown multipartite entanglement states with a linear number of measurements, avoiding the need for global measurements and quantum state tomography. The proposed method exhibits robustness against noise and extends its applicability to pure and mixed states, effectively scaling to large-scale multipartite entanglement systems. The results of the experiment show that the predicted entanglement measures are very close to the actual values, which confirms the effectiveness of the proposed method.

Entropy•Feb 12, 2025•3 citations

How confused can an entanglement witness be to be still persuasive

Jan Roik, Karol Bartkiewicz, Antonín Černoch +1 more

Detection of entangled states is essential in both fundamental and applied quantum physics. However, this task proves to be challenging especially for general quantum states. One can execute full state tomography but this method is time demanding especially in complex systems. Other approaches use entanglement witnesses, these methods tend to be less demanding but lack reliability. Here, we demonstrate that ANN -- artificial neural networks provide a balance between both approaches. In this paper, we make a comparison of ANN performance against witness-based methods for random general 2-qubit quantum states without any prior information on the states. Furthermore, we apply our approach to real experimental data set.

arXiv:2011.11340•Nov 23, 2020•26 citations

Deep learning of quantum entanglement from incomplete measurements

Dominik Koutný, Laia Ginés, Magdalena Moczała-Dusanowska +4 more

The quantification of the entanglement present in a physical system is of paramount importance for fundamental research and many cutting-edge applications. Now, achieving this goal requires either a priori knowledge on the system or very demanding experimental procedures such as full state tomography or collective measurements. Here, we demonstrate that, by using neural networks, we can quantify the degree of entanglement without the need to know the full description of the quantum state. Our method allows for direct quantification of the quantum correlations using an incomplete set of local measurements. Despite using undersampled measurements, we achieve a quantification error of up to an order of magnitude lower than the state-of-the-art quantum tomography. Furthermore, we achieve this result using networks trained using exclusively simulated data. Last, we derive a method based on a convolutional network input that can accept data from various measurement scenarios and perform, to some extent, independently of the measurement device.

arXiv:2205.01462•Science Advances•Jul 19, 2023•49 citations

Entanglement classification of arbitrary three-qubit states via artificial neural networks

Jorawar Singh, Vaishali Gulati, Kavita Dorai +1 more

We design and successfully implement artificial neural networks (ANNs) to detect and classify entanglement for three-qubit systems using limited state features. The overall design principle is a feed forward neural network (FFNN), with the output layer consisting of a single neuron for the detection of genuine multipartite entanglement (GME) and six neurons for the classification problem corresponding to six entanglement classes under stochastic local operations and classical communication (SLOCC). The models are trained and validated on a simulated dataset of randomly generated states. We achieve high accuracy, around 98%, for detecting GME as well as for SLOCC classification. Remarkably, we find that feeding only 7 diagonal elements of the density matrix into the ANN results in an accuracy greater than 94% for both the tasks, showcasing the strength of the method in reducing the required input data while maintaining efficient performance. Reducing the feature set makes it easier to apply ANN models for entanglement classification, particularly in resource-constrained environments, without sacrificing accuracy. The performance of the ANN models was further evaluated by introducing white noise into the data set, and the results indicate that the models are robust and are able to well tolerate noise.

arXiv:2411.11330•Physical Review Applied•Aug 21, 2025•2 citations
In recent years, artificial neural networks (ANNs) have become an increasingly popular tool for studying problems in quantum theory, and in particular entanglement theory. In this work, we analyse to what extent ANNs can accurately predict the geometric measure of entanglement of symmetric multiqubit states using only a limited number of Wehrl moments (moments of the Husimi function of the state) as input, which represents partial information about the state. We consider both pure and mixed quantum states. We compare the results we obtain by training ANNs with the informed use of convergence acceleration methods. We find that even some of the most powerful convergence acceleration algorithms do not compete with ANNs when given the same input data, provided that enough data is available to train these ANNs. We also provide an experimental protocol for measuring Wehrl moments, which is state-independent. More generally, this work opens up perspectives for the estimation of entanglement measures and other SU(2)-invariant quantities, such as the Wehrl entropy, in a way that is more accessible in experiments than by means of full state tomography.
Quantum entanglement acts as a crucial part in quantum computation and quantum information, hence quantifying unknown entanglement is an important task. Due to the fact that the amount of entanglement cannot be achieved directly by measuring any physical observables, it remains an open problem to quantify entanglement experimentally. In this work, we provide an effective way to quantify entanglement for the unknown quantum states via artificial neural networks. By choosing the expectation values of measurements as input features and the values of entanglement measures as labels, we train artificial neural network models to predict the entanglement for new quantum states accurately. Our method does not require the full information about unknown quantum states, which highlights the effectiveness and versatility of machine learning in exploring quantum entanglement.
Entanglement is a key property in the development of quantum technologies and in the study of quantum many-body simulations. However, entanglement measurement typically requires quantum full-state tomography (FST). Here we present a neural network-assisted protocol for measuring entanglement in equilibrium and non-equilibrium states of local Hamiltonians. Instead of FST, it can learn comprehensive entanglement quantities from single-qubit or two-qubit Pauli measurements, such as Rényi entropy, partially-transposed (PT) moments, and coherence. It is also exciting that our neural network is able to learn the future entanglement dynamics using only single-qubit traces from the previous time. In addition, we perform experiments using a nuclear spin quantum processor and train an adoptive neural network to study entanglement in the ground and dynamical states of a one-dimensional spin chain. Quantum phase transitions (QPT) are revealed by measuring static entanglement in ground states, and the entanglement dynamics beyond measurement time is accurately estimated in dynamical states. These precise results validate our neural network. Our work will have a wide range of applications in quantum many-body systems, from quantum phase transitions to intriguing non-equilibrium phenomena such as quantum thermalization.
Entanglement plays a pivotal role in numerous quantum applications, and as technology progresses, entanglement systems continue to expand. However, quantifying entanglement is a complex problem, particularly for multipartite quantum states. The currently available entanglement measures suffer from high computational complexity, and for unknown multipartite entangled states, complete information about the quantum state is often necessary, further complicating calculations. In this paper, we train neural networks to quantify unknown multipartite entanglement using input features based on squared entanglement (SE) and outcome statistics data produced by locally measuring target quantum states. By leveraging machine learning techniques to handle non-linear relations between outcome statistics and entanglement measurement SE, we achieve high-precision quantification of unknown multipartite entanglement states with a linear number of measurements, avoiding the need for global measurements and quantum state tomography. The proposed method exhibits robustness against noise and extends its applicability to pure and mixed states, effectively scaling to large-scale multipartite entanglement systems. The results of the experiment show that the predicted entanglement measures are very close to the actual values, which confirms the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Detection of entangled states is essential in both fundamental and applied quantum physics. However, this task proves to be challenging especially for general quantum states. One can execute full state tomography but this method is time demanding especially in complex systems. Other approaches use entanglement witnesses, these methods tend to be less demanding but lack reliability. Here, we demonstrate that ANN -- artificial neural networks provide a balance between both approaches. In this paper, we make a comparison of ANN performance against witness-based methods for random general 2-qubit quantum states without any prior information on the states. Furthermore, we apply our approach to real experimental data set.
The quantification of the entanglement present in a physical system is of paramount importance for fundamental research and many cutting-edge applications. Now, achieving this goal requires either a priori knowledge on the system or very demanding experimental procedures such as full state tomography or collective measurements. Here, we demonstrate that, by using neural networks, we can quantify the degree of entanglement without the need to know the full description of the quantum state. Our method allows for direct quantification of the quantum correlations using an incomplete set of local measurements. Despite using undersampled measurements, we achieve a quantification error of up to an order of magnitude lower than the state-of-the-art quantum tomography. Furthermore, we achieve this result using networks trained using exclusively simulated data. Last, we derive a method based on a convolutional network input that can accept data from various measurement scenarios and perform, to some extent, independently of the measurement device.
We design and successfully implement artificial neural networks (ANNs) to detect and classify entanglement for three-qubit systems using limited state features. The overall design principle is a feed forward neural network (FFNN), with the output layer consisting of a single neuron for the detection of genuine multipartite entanglement (GME) and six neurons for the classification problem corresponding to six entanglement classes under stochastic local operations and classical communication (SLOCC). The models are trained and validated on a simulated dataset of randomly generated states. We achieve high accuracy, around 98%, for detecting GME as well as for SLOCC classification. Remarkably, we find that feeding only 7 diagonal elements of the density matrix into the ANN results in an accuracy greater than 94% for both the tasks, showcasing the strength of the method in reducing the required input data while maintaining efficient performance. Reducing the feature set makes it easier to apply ANN models for entanglement classification, particularly in resource-constrained environments, without sacrificing accuracy. The performance of the ANN models was further evaluated by introducing white noise into the data set, and the results indicate that the models are robust and are able to well tolerate noise.