Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2205.07097 · Physical Review Research

Adaptive construction of shallower quantum circuits with quantum spin projection for fermionic systems

Takashi Tsuchimochi, Masaki Taii, Taisei Nishimaki, Seiichiro Ten‐no

Published Aug 4, 2022• 21 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum computing is a promising approach to harnessing strong correlation in molecular systems; however, current devices only allow for hybrid quantum-classical algorithms with a shallow circuit depth, such as the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE). In this paper, we report the importance of the Hamiltonian symmetry in constructing VQE circuits adaptively (ADAPT-VQE). This treatment often violates symmetry, thereby deteriorating the convergence of fidelity to the exact solution and ultimately resulting in deeper circuits. We demonstrate that spin-symmetry projection can provide a simple yet effective solution to this problem, by keeping the quantum state in the correct symmetry space, to reduce the overall gate operations. To further investigate the role of spin-symmetry in computing molecular properties with ADAPT-VQE, we have derived the analytical derivative of symmetry-projected VQE energy. Our illustrative calculations reveal the significance of preserving symmetry in providing accurate dipole moments and geometries with variational approximations.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.4.033100

Related papers

Symmetry-adapted variational quantum eigensolver

Kazuhiro Seki, Tomonori Shirakawa, Seiji Yunoki

We propose a scheme to restore spatial symmetry of Hamiltonian in the variational-quantum-eigensolver (VQE) algorithm for which the quantum circuit structures used usually break the Hamiltonian symmetry. The symmetry-adapted VQE scheme introduced here simply applies the projection operator, which is Hermitian but not unitary, to restore the spatial symmetry in a desired irreducible representation of the spatial group. The entanglement of a quantum state is still represented in a quantum circuit but the nonunitarity of the projection operator is treated classically as postprocessing in the VQE framework. By numerical simulations for a spin-$1/2$ Heisenberg model on a one-dimensional ring, we demonstrate that the symmetry-adapted VQE scheme with a shallower quantum circuit can achieve significant improvement in terms of the fidelity of the ground state and has a great advantage in terms of the ground-state energy with decent accuracy, as compared to the non-symmetry-adapted VQE scheme. We also demonstrate that the present scheme can approximate low-lying excited states that can be specified by symmetry sectors, using the same circuit structure for the ground-state calculation.

arXiv:1912.13146•Physical Review A•May 28, 2020•81 citations

Self-Consistent Field Approach for the Variational Quantum Eigensolver: Orbital Optimization Goes Adaptive

Aaron Fitzpatrick, Anton Nykänen, N. Walter Talarico +4 more

We present a self-consistent field (SCF) approach within the adaptive derivative-assembled problem-tailored ansatz variational quantum eigensolver (ADAPT-VQE) framework for efficient quantum simulations of chemical systems on near-term quantum computers. To this end, our ADAPT-VQE-SCF approach combines the idea of generating an ansatz with a small number of parameters, resulting in shallow-depth quantum circuits with a direct minimization of an energy expression that is correct to second order with respect to changes in the molecular orbital basis. Our numerical analysis, including calculations for the transition-metal complex ferrocene [Fe (C 5 H 5 ) 2 ], indicates that convergence in the self-consistent orbital optimization loop can be reached without a considerable increase in the number of two-qubit gates in the quantum circuit by comparison to a VQE optimization in the initial molecular orbital basis. Moreover, the orbital optimization can be carried out simultaneously within each iteration of the ADAPT-VQE cycle. ADAPT-VQE-SCF thus allows us to implement a routine analogous to the complete active space SCF, a cornerstone of state-of-the-art computational chemistry, in a hardware-efficient manner on near-term quantum computers. Hence, ADAPT-VQE-SCF paves the way toward a paradigm shift for quantitative quantum-chemistry simulations on quantum computers by requiring fewer qubits and opening up for the use of large and flexible atomic orbital basis sets in contrast to earlier methods that are predominantly based on the idea of full active spaces with minimal basis sets.

arXiv:2212.11405•The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Mar 28, 2024•22 citations

Avoiding symmetry roadblocks and minimizing the measurement overhead of adaptive variational quantum eigensolvers

V. O. Shkolnikov, Nicholas J. Mayhall, Sophia E. Economou +1 more

Quantum simulation of strongly correlated systems is potentially the most feasible useful application of near-term quantum computers. Minimizing quantum computational resources is crucial to achieving this goal. A promising class of algorithms for this purpose consists of variational quantum eigensolvers (VQEs). Among these, problem-tailored versions such as ADAPT-VQE that build variational ansätze step by step from a predefined operator pool perform particularly well in terms of circuit depths and variational parameter counts. However, this improved performance comes at the expense of an additional measurement overhead compared to standard VQEs. Here, we show that this overhead can be reduced to an amount that grows only linearly with the number n of qubits, instead of quartically as in the original ADAPT-VQE. We do this by proving that operator pools of size 2n−2 can represent any state in Hilbert space if chosen appropriately. We prove that this is the minimal size of such "complete" pools, discuss their algebraic properties, and present necessary and sufficient conditions for their completeness that allow us to find such pools efficiently. We further show that, if the simulated problem possesses symmetries, then complete pools can fail to yield convergent results, unless the pool is chosen to obey certain symmetry rules. We demonstrate the performance of such symmetry-adapted complete pools by using them in classical simulations of ADAPT-VQE for several strongly correlated molecules. Our findings are relevant for any VQE that uses an ansatz based on Pauli strings.

arXiv:2109.05340•Quantum•Jun 12, 2023•35 citations

Wave Function Adapted Hamiltonians for Quantum Computing

Leonardo Ratini, Chiara Capecci, F. Benfenati +1 more

The use of the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) for quantum chemistry is one of the most promising applications for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. A major limitation is represented by the need to build compact and shallow circuit ansatzes having the variational flexibility to catch the complexity of the electronic structure problem. To alleviate this drawback, we introduce a modified VQE scheme in which the form of the molecular Hamiltonian is adapted to the circuit ansatz through an optimization procedure. Exploiting the invariance of the Hamiltonian by molecular orbital rotations, we can optimize it using gradients that can be calculated without significant computational overload. The proposed method, named Wavefunction Adapted Hamiltonian Through Orbital Rotation (WAHTOR), has been applied to small molecules in numerical state vector simulations. The results demonstrate that, at variance with standard VQE, the method is less dependent on circuit topology and less prone to be trapped into high-energy local minima. It is able to recover a significant amount of electron correlation even with only empirical ansatzes with shallow circuit depth. Noisy calculations demonstrate the robustness and feasibility of the proposed methodology and indicate the hardware requirements to effectively apply the procedure using forthcoming NISQ devices.

Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Jan 18, 2022•13 citations

Symmetry Breaking Slows Convergence of the ADAPT Variational Quantum Eigensolver

Luke W. Bertels, Harper R. Grimsley, Sophia E. Economou +2 more

Because quantum simulation of molecular systems is expected to provide the strongest advantage over classical computing methods for systems exhibiting strong electron correlation, it is critical that the performance of VQEs be assessed for strongly correlated systems. For classical simulation, strong correlation often results in symmetry breaking of the Hartree–Fock reference, leading to Löwdin’s well-known “symmetry dilemma”, whereby accuracy in the energy can be increased by breaking spin or spatial symmetries. Here, we explore the impact of symmetry breaking on the performance of ADAPT-VQE using two strongly correlated systems: (i) the “fermionized” anisotropic Heisenberg model, where the anisotropy parameter controls the correlation in the system, and (ii) symmetrically stretched linear H 4, where correlation increases with increasing H–H separation. In both of these cases, increasing the level of correlation of the system leads to spontaneous symmetry breaking (parity and S ^ 2, respectively) of the mean-field solutions. We analyze the role that symmetry breaking in the reference states and orbital mappings of the fermionic Hamiltonians have in the compactness and performance of ADAPT-VQE. We observe that improving the energy of the reference states by breaking symmetry has a deleterious effect on ADAPT-VQE by increasing the length of the ansatz necessary for energy convergence and exacerbating the problem of “gradient troughs”.

Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Oct 14, 2022•20 citations

Symmetry breaking slows convergence of the ADAPT Variational Quantum Eigensolver

Luke W. Bertels, Harper R. Grimsley, Sophia E. Economou +2 more

Because quantum simulation of molecular systems is expected to provide the strongest advantage over classical computing methods for systems exhibiting strong electron correlation, it is critical that the performance of VQEs be assessed for strongly correlated systems. For classical simulation, strong correlation often results in symmetry-breaking of the Hartree-Fock reference, leading to Löwdin's well-known ``symmetry dilemma'' whereby accuracy in the energy can be increased by breaking spin or spatial symmetries. Here, we explore the impact of symmetry breaking on the performance of ADAPT-VQE using two strongly correlated systems: (i) the ``fermionized" anisotropic Heisenberg model, where the anisotropy parameter controls the correlation in the system, and (ii) symmetrically-stretched linear \ce{H4}, where correlation increases with increasing H-H separation. In both of these cases, increasing the level of correlation of the system leads to spontaneous symmetry breaking (parity and $\hat{S}^{2}$, respectively) of the mean-field solutions. We analyze the role that symmetry breaking in the reference states and orbital mappings of the fermionic Hamiltonians have on the compactness and performance of ADAPT-VQE. We observe that improving the energy of the reference states by breaking symmetry has a deleterious effect on ADAPT-VQE by increasing the length of the ansatz necessary for energy convergence and exacerbating the problem of ``gradient troughs".

arXiv:2207.03063•Jul 7, 2022•2 citations
Quantum computing is a promising approach to harnessing strong correlation in molecular systems; however, current devices only allow for hybrid quantum-classical algorithms with a shallow circuit depth, such as the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE). In this paper, we report the importance of the Hamiltonian symmetry in constructing VQE circuits adaptively (ADAPT-VQE). This treatment often violates symmetry, thereby deteriorating the convergence of fidelity to the exact solution and ultimately resulting in deeper circuits. We demonstrate that spin-symmetry projection can provide a simple yet effective solution to this problem, by keeping the quantum state in the correct symmetry space, to reduce the overall gate operations. To further investigate the role of spin-symmetry in computing molecular properties with ADAPT-VQE, we have derived the analytical derivative of symmetry-projected VQE energy. Our illustrative calculations reveal the significance of preserving symmetry in providing accurate dipole moments and geometries with variational approximations.
We propose a scheme to restore spatial symmetry of Hamiltonian in the variational-quantum-eigensolver (VQE) algorithm for which the quantum circuit structures used usually break the Hamiltonian symmetry. The symmetry-adapted VQE scheme introduced here simply applies the projection operator, which is Hermitian but not unitary, to restore the spatial symmetry in a desired irreducible representation of the spatial group. The entanglement of a quantum state is still represented in a quantum circuit but the nonunitarity of the projection operator is treated classically as postprocessing in the VQE framework. By numerical simulations for a spin-1/21/21/2 Heisenberg model on a one-dimensional ring, we demonstrate that the symmetry-adapted VQE scheme with a shallower quantum circuit can achieve significant improvement in terms of the fidelity of the ground state and has a great advantage in terms of the ground-state energy with decent accuracy, as compared to the non-symmetry-adapted VQE scheme. We also demonstrate that the present scheme can approximate low-lying excited states that can be specified by symmetry sectors, using the same circuit structure for the ground-state calculation.
We present a self-consistent field (SCF) approach within the adaptive derivative-assembled problem-tailored ansatz variational quantum eigensolver (ADAPT-VQE) framework for efficient quantum simulations of chemical systems on near-term quantum computers. To this end, our ADAPT-VQE-SCF approach combines the idea of generating an ansatz with a small number of parameters, resulting in shallow-depth quantum circuits with a direct minimization of an energy expression that is correct to second order with respect to changes in the molecular orbital basis. Our numerical analysis, including calculations for the transition-metal complex ferrocene [Fe (C 5 H 5 ) 2 ], indicates that convergence in the self-consistent orbital optimization loop can be reached without a considerable increase in the number of two-qubit gates in the quantum circuit by comparison to a VQE optimization in the initial molecular orbital basis. Moreover, the orbital optimization can be carried out simultaneously within each iteration of the ADAPT-VQE cycle. ADAPT-VQE-SCF thus allows us to implement a routine analogous to the complete active space SCF, a cornerstone of state-of-the-art computational chemistry, in a hardware-efficient manner on near-term quantum computers. Hence, ADAPT-VQE-SCF paves the way toward a paradigm shift for quantitative quantum-chemistry simulations on quantum computers by requiring fewer qubits and opening up for the use of large and flexible atomic orbital basis sets in contrast to earlier methods that are predominantly based on the idea of full active spaces with minimal basis sets.
Quantum simulation of strongly correlated systems is potentially the most feasible useful application of near-term quantum computers. Minimizing quantum computational resources is crucial to achieving this goal. A promising class of algorithms for this purpose consists of variational quantum eigensolvers (VQEs). Among these, problem-tailored versions such as ADAPT-VQE that build variational ansätze step by step from a predefined operator pool perform particularly well in terms of circuit depths and variational parameter counts. However, this improved performance comes at the expense of an additional measurement overhead compared to standard VQEs. Here, we show that this overhead can be reduced to an amount that grows only linearly with the number n of qubits, instead of quartically as in the original ADAPT-VQE. We do this by proving that operator pools of size 2n−2 can represent any state in Hilbert space if chosen appropriately. We prove that this is the minimal size of such "complete" pools, discuss their algebraic properties, and present necessary and sufficient conditions for their completeness that allow us to find such pools efficiently. We further show that, if the simulated problem possesses symmetries, then complete pools can fail to yield convergent results, unless the pool is chosen to obey certain symmetry rules. We demonstrate the performance of such symmetry-adapted complete pools by using them in classical simulations of ADAPT-VQE for several strongly correlated molecules. Our findings are relevant for any VQE that uses an ansatz based on Pauli strings.
The use of the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) for quantum chemistry is one of the most promising applications for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. A major limitation is represented by the need to build compact and shallow circuit ansatzes having the variational flexibility to catch the complexity of the electronic structure problem. To alleviate this drawback, we introduce a modified VQE scheme in which the form of the molecular Hamiltonian is adapted to the circuit ansatz through an optimization procedure. Exploiting the invariance of the Hamiltonian by molecular orbital rotations, we can optimize it using gradients that can be calculated without significant computational overload. The proposed method, named Wavefunction Adapted Hamiltonian Through Orbital Rotation (WAHTOR), has been applied to small molecules in numerical state vector simulations. The results demonstrate that, at variance with standard VQE, the method is less dependent on circuit topology and less prone to be trapped into high-energy local minima. It is able to recover a significant amount of electron correlation even with only empirical ansatzes with shallow circuit depth. Noisy calculations demonstrate the robustness and feasibility of the proposed methodology and indicate the hardware requirements to effectively apply the procedure using forthcoming NISQ devices.
Because quantum simulation of molecular systems is expected to provide the strongest advantage over classical computing methods for systems exhibiting strong electron correlation, it is critical that the performance of VQEs be assessed for strongly correlated systems. For classical simulation, strong correlation often results in symmetry breaking of the Hartree–Fock reference, leading to Löwdin’s well-known “symmetry dilemma”, whereby accuracy in the energy can be increased by breaking spin or spatial symmetries. Here, we explore the impact of symmetry breaking on the performance of ADAPT-VQE using two strongly correlated systems: (i) the “fermionized” anisotropic Heisenberg model, where the anisotropy parameter controls the correlation in the system, and (ii) symmetrically stretched linear H 4, where correlation increases with increasing H–H separation. In both of these cases, increasing the level of correlation of the system leads to spontaneous symmetry breaking (parity and S ^ 2, respectively) of the mean-field solutions. We analyze the role that symmetry breaking in the reference states and orbital mappings of the fermionic Hamiltonians have in the compactness and performance of ADAPT-VQE. We observe that improving the energy of the reference states by breaking symmetry has a deleterious effect on ADAPT-VQE by increasing the length of the ansatz necessary for energy convergence and exacerbating the problem of “gradient troughs”.
Because quantum simulation of molecular systems is expected to provide the strongest advantage over classical computing methods for systems exhibiting strong electron correlation, it is critical that the performance of VQEs be assessed for strongly correlated systems. For classical simulation, strong correlation often results in symmetry-breaking of the Hartree-Fock reference, leading to Löwdin's well-known ``symmetry dilemma'' whereby accuracy in the energy can be increased by breaking spin or spatial symmetries. Here, we explore the impact of symmetry breaking on the performance of ADAPT-VQE using two strongly correlated systems: (i) the ``fermionized" anisotropic Heisenberg model, where the anisotropy parameter controls the correlation in the system, and (ii) symmetrically-stretched linear \ce{H4}, where correlation increases with increasing H-H separation. In both of these cases, increasing the level of correlation of the system leads to spontaneous symmetry breaking (parity and S^2\hat{S}^{2}S^2, respectively) of the mean-field solutions. We analyze the role that symmetry breaking in the reference states and orbital mappings of the fermionic Hamiltonians have on the compactness and performance of ADAPT-VQE. We observe that improving the energy of the reference states by breaking symmetry has a deleterious effect on ADAPT-VQE by increasing the length of the ansatz necessary for energy convergence and exacerbating the problem of ``gradient troughs".