Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2205.03333 · Entropy

Quantum Non-Markovian Environment-to-System Backflows of Information: Nonoperational vs. Operational Approaches

Adrián A. Budini

Published May 5, 2022• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum memory effects can be qualitatively understood as a consequence of an environment-to-system backflow of information. Here, we analyze and compare how this concept is interpreted and implemented in different approaches to quantum non-Markovianity. We study a nonoperational approach, defined by the distinguishability between two system states characterized by different initial conditions, and an operational approach, which is defined by the correlation between different outcomes associated to successive measurement processes performed over the system of interest. The differences, limitations, and vantages of each approach are characterized in detail by considering diverse system-environment models and dynamics. As a specific example, we study a non-Markovian depolarizing map induced by the interaction of the system of interest with an environment characterized by incoherent and coherent self-dynamics.

DOI
10.3390/e24050649

Related papers

Non-Markovianity, information backflow, and system-environment correlation for open-quantum-system processes

Yun-Yi Hsieh, Zheng-Yao Su, Hsi‐Sheng Goan

A Markovian process of a system is defined classically as a process in which the future state of the system is fully determined by only its present state, not by its previous history. There have been several measures of non-Markovianity to quantify the degrees of non-Markovian effect in a process of an open quantum system based on information backflow from the environment to the system. However, the condition for the witness of the system information backflow does not coincide with the classical definition of a Markovian process. Recently, a new measure with a condition that coincides with the classical definition in the relevant limit has been proposed. Here, we focus on the new definition (measure) for quantum non-Markovian processes, and characterize the Markovian condition as a quantum process that has no information backflow through the reduced environment state (IBTRES) and no system-environment correlation effect (SECE). The action of IBTRES produces non-Markovian effects by flowing the information of quantum operations performed by an experimenter at earlier times back to the system through the environment, while the SECE can produce non-Markovian effect without carrying any earlier quantum operation information. We give the necessary and sufficient conditions for no IBTRES and no SECE, respectively, and show that a process is Markovian if and only if it has no IBTRES and no SECE. The quantitative measures and algorithms for calculating non-Markovianity, IBTRES, and solely SECE are explicitly presented.

arXiv:1906.08086•Physical Review A•Jul 17, 2019•21 citations

Mixing-induced quantum non-Markovianity and information flow

Heinz-Peter Breuer, Giulio Amato, Bassano Vacchini

Mixing dynamical maps describing open quantum systems can lead from Markovian to non-Markovian processes. Being surprising and counter-intuitive, this result has been used as argument against characterization of non-Markovianity in terms of information exchange. Here, we demonstrate that, quite the contrary, mixing can be understood in a natural way which is fully consistent with existing theories of memory effects. In particular, we show how mixing-induced non-Markovianity can be interpreted in terms of the distinguishability of quantum states, system-environment correlations and the information flow between system and environment.

arXiv:1712.06719•New Journal of Physics•Feb 28, 2018•41 citations

Genuine and Non-Genuine Quantum Non-Markovianity: A Unified Information-Theoretic Review

Rajeev Gangwar, Ujjwal Sen

Understanding whether the features of open quantum dynamics are genuinely quantum remains a central challenge in quantum dynamics. Even though the non-Markovian behavior of quantum dynamics has been widely investigated across different settings, there is still no consensus on which properties of a dynamics reflect genuine quantum features and which arise from classical or non-genuine quantum sources. In this review, we provide detailed information on recent developments in characterizing quantum non-Markovianity based on information backflow and the nature of its origin. We also present a survey on how various approaches separate classical and quantum contributions, as well as how they define operational tasks that reveal genuine quantum non-Markovianity. We analyze several frameworks, including state-distinguishability -based, channel-based (``CP-divisibility''), and process-tensor methods. For each framework, we outline the underlying physical motivation, the criteria proposed to distinguish genuine quantum non-Markovianity from practical or apparent memory effects. We further compare different approaches and their strengths and limitations. The review aims to clarify the conceptual and operational aspects of quantum non-Markovian processes based on their nature and to provide a foundation for future research on quantum non-Markovianity and its role in advancing quantum information science and technology.

quant-pharXiv:2603.28277•Mar 31, 2026•0 citations

Perturbation theory for operational quantum non-Markovianity

Mariano Bonifacio, Adrián A. Budini

The definition of memory in operational approaches to quantum non-Markovianity depends on the statistical properties of different sets of outcomes related to successive measurement processes performed over the system of interest. Using projector techniques we develop a perturbation theory that enable to expressing both joint probabilities and outcome correlations in terms of the unperturbed system density-matrix propagator. This object defines the open system dynamics in the absence of measurement processes. Successive series terms, which are scaled by the system-environment interaction strength, consist in a convolution structure involving system propagators weighted by higher-order bath correlations. The formalism is corroborated by studying different dynamics that admit an exact description. Using the perturbative approach, unusual memory effects induced by the interplay between the system-environment interaction and measurement processes are found in finite temperature reservoirs.

arXiv:2004.11813•Physical Review A•Aug 19, 2020•9 citations

Generalized Loschmidt echoes associated with operational quantum non-Markovianity

Cecilia Cormick, Adrián A. Budini

Non-Markovianity can be characterized by performing a series of successive measurements and analyzing departures of the corresponding outcome statistics from a Markovian probabilistic structure. Considering a system coupled with its environment via a dephasing interaction, we show that joint outcome probabilities can be written in terms of a set of two-time environment correlations. Their definition involves forward and backward propagators with different Hamiltonians, associated with a recently introduced generalization of standard Loschmidt echoes [Cormick and Budini, Phys. Lett. A 593, 132011 (2026)]. This result establishes a solid connection between quantum non-Markovianity defined in an operational (measurement-based) way and complex quantum dynamics studied through their sensitivity to dynamical perturbations. We find conditions that guarantee a Markovian (system) behavior and also determine how the generalized echoes can identify information exchanges between the system and its environment. We illustrate our ideas considering examples of spin environments that realize these different dynamical regimes.

quant-pharXiv:2608.06567•Aug 10, 2026•0 citations

Detection of bidirectional system-environment information exchanges

Adrián A. Budini

Quantum memory effects can be related to a bidirectional exchange of information between an open system and its environment, which in turn modifies the state and dynamical behavior of the last one. Nevertheless, non-Markovianity can also be induced by environments whose dynamics is not affected during the system evolution, implying the absence of any physical information exchange. An unsolved open problem in the formulation of quantum memory measures is the apparent impossibility of discerning between both paradigmatic cases. Here we present an operational scheme that, based on the outcomes of successive measurements processes performed over the system of interest, allows one to distinguish between both kinds of memory effects. The method accurately detects bidirectional information flows in diverse dissipative and dephasing non-Markovian open system dynamics.

arXiv:2101.10308•Physical Review A•Jan 22, 2021•9 citations
Quantum memory effects can be qualitatively understood as a consequence of an environment-to-system backflow of information. Here, we analyze and compare how this concept is interpreted and implemented in different approaches to quantum non-Markovianity. We study a nonoperational approach, defined by the distinguishability between two system states characterized by different initial conditions, and an operational approach, which is defined by the correlation between different outcomes associated to successive measurement processes performed over the system of interest. The differences, limitations, and vantages of each approach are characterized in detail by considering diverse system-environment models and dynamics. As a specific example, we study a non-Markovian depolarizing map induced by the interaction of the system of interest with an environment characterized by incoherent and coherent self-dynamics.
A Markovian process of a system is defined classically as a process in which the future state of the system is fully determined by only its present state, not by its previous history. There have been several measures of non-Markovianity to quantify the degrees of non-Markovian effect in a process of an open quantum system based on information backflow from the environment to the system. However, the condition for the witness of the system information backflow does not coincide with the classical definition of a Markovian process. Recently, a new measure with a condition that coincides with the classical definition in the relevant limit has been proposed. Here, we focus on the new definition (measure) for quantum non-Markovian processes, and characterize the Markovian condition as a quantum process that has no information backflow through the reduced environment state (IBTRES) and no system-environment correlation effect (SECE). The action of IBTRES produces non-Markovian effects by flowing the information of quantum operations performed by an experimenter at earlier times back to the system through the environment, while the SECE can produce non-Markovian effect without carrying any earlier quantum operation information. We give the necessary and sufficient conditions for no IBTRES and no SECE, respectively, and show that a process is Markovian if and only if it has no IBTRES and no SECE. The quantitative measures and algorithms for calculating non-Markovianity, IBTRES, and solely SECE are explicitly presented.
Mixing dynamical maps describing open quantum systems can lead from Markovian to non-Markovian processes. Being surprising and counter-intuitive, this result has been used as argument against characterization of non-Markovianity in terms of information exchange. Here, we demonstrate that, quite the contrary, mixing can be understood in a natural way which is fully consistent with existing theories of memory effects. In particular, we show how mixing-induced non-Markovianity can be interpreted in terms of the distinguishability of quantum states, system-environment correlations and the information flow between system and environment.
Understanding whether the features of open quantum dynamics are genuinely quantum remains a central challenge in quantum dynamics. Even though the non-Markovian behavior of quantum dynamics has been widely investigated across different settings, there is still no consensus on which properties of a dynamics reflect genuine quantum features and which arise from classical or non-genuine quantum sources. In this review, we provide detailed information on recent developments in characterizing quantum non-Markovianity based on information backflow and the nature of its origin. We also present a survey on how various approaches separate classical and quantum contributions, as well as how they define operational tasks that reveal genuine quantum non-Markovianity. We analyze several frameworks, including state-distinguishability -based, channel-based (``CP-divisibility''), and process-tensor methods. For each framework, we outline the underlying physical motivation, the criteria proposed to distinguish genuine quantum non-Markovianity from practical or apparent memory effects. We further compare different approaches and their strengths and limitations. The review aims to clarify the conceptual and operational aspects of quantum non-Markovian processes based on their nature and to provide a foundation for future research on quantum non-Markovianity and its role in advancing quantum information science and technology.
The definition of memory in operational approaches to quantum non-Markovianity depends on the statistical properties of different sets of outcomes related to successive measurement processes performed over the system of interest. Using projector techniques we develop a perturbation theory that enable to expressing both joint probabilities and outcome correlations in terms of the unperturbed system density-matrix propagator. This object defines the open system dynamics in the absence of measurement processes. Successive series terms, which are scaled by the system-environment interaction strength, consist in a convolution structure involving system propagators weighted by higher-order bath correlations. The formalism is corroborated by studying different dynamics that admit an exact description. Using the perturbative approach, unusual memory effects induced by the interplay between the system-environment interaction and measurement processes are found in finite temperature reservoirs.
Non-Markovianity can be characterized by performing a series of successive measurements and analyzing departures of the corresponding outcome statistics from a Markovian probabilistic structure. Considering a system coupled with its environment via a dephasing interaction, we show that joint outcome probabilities can be written in terms of a set of two-time environment correlations. Their definition involves forward and backward propagators with different Hamiltonians, associated with a recently introduced generalization of standard Loschmidt echoes [Cormick and Budini, Phys. Lett. A 593, 132011 (2026)]. This result establishes a solid connection between quantum non-Markovianity defined in an operational (measurement-based) way and complex quantum dynamics studied through their sensitivity to dynamical perturbations. We find conditions that guarantee a Markovian (system) behavior and also determine how the generalized echoes can identify information exchanges between the system and its environment. We illustrate our ideas considering examples of spin environments that realize these different dynamical regimes.
Quantum memory effects can be related to a bidirectional exchange of information between an open system and its environment, which in turn modifies the state and dynamical behavior of the last one. Nevertheless, non-Markovianity can also be induced by environments whose dynamics is not affected during the system evolution, implying the absence of any physical information exchange. An unsolved open problem in the formulation of quantum memory measures is the apparent impossibility of discerning between both paradigmatic cases. Here we present an operational scheme that, based on the outcomes of successive measurements processes performed over the system of interest, allows one to distinguish between both kinds of memory effects. The method accurately detects bidirectional information flows in diverse dissipative and dephasing non-Markovian open system dynamics.