Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2204.00844 · Physics of Plasmas

Electron temperature relaxation in the clusterized ultracold plasmas

Yurii V. Dumin, A. T. Lukashenko

Published Nov 1, 2022• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Ultracold plasmas are a promising candidate for the creation of strongly coupled Coulomb systems. Unfortunately, the values of the coupling parameter Γe actually achieved after photoionization of the neutral atoms remain relatively small because of the considerable intrinsic heating of the electrons. A conceivable way to get around this obstacle might be to utilize a spontaneous ionization of the ultracold Rydberg gas, where the initial kinetic energies could be much less. However, the spontaneous avalanche ionization will result in a very inhomogeneous distribution (clusterization) of the ions, which can change the efficiency of the electron relaxation in the vicinity of such clusters substantially. In the present work, this hypothesis is tested by an extensive set of numerical simulations. As a result, it is found that despite a less initial kinetic energy, the subsequent relaxation of the electron velocities in the clusterized plasmas proceeds much more violently than in the case of the statistically uniform ionic distribution. The electron temperature, first, experiences a sharp initial jump (presumably, caused by the “virialization” of energies of the charged particles) and, second, exhibits a gradual subsequent increase (presumably, associated with a multi-particle recombination of the electrons at the ionic clusters). As a possible tool to reduce the anomalous temperature increase, we also considered a two-step plasma formation, involving the blockaded Rydberg states. This leads to a suppression of the clusterization due to a quasi-regular distribution of ions. In such a case, according to the numerical simulations, the subsequent evolution of the electron temperature proceeds more gently, approximately with the same rate as in the statistically uniform ionic distribution.

DOI
10.1063/5.0093840

Related papers

Effects of disorder on electron heating in ultracold plasmas

Yurii V. Dumin, A. T. Lukashenko

Starting from the beginning of their research in the early 2000s, the ultracold plasmas were considered as a promising tool to achieve considerable values of the Coulomb coupling parameter for electrons. Unfortunately, this was found to be precluded by a sharp spontaneous increase in temperature, which was often attributed to the so-called disorder-induced heating. It is the aim of the present paper to quantify the effect of spontaneous heating as a function of the initial ionic disorder and, thereby, to estimate the efficiency of its mitigation, e.g., by the Rydberg blockade. As a result of the performed simulations, we found that the dynamics of electrons exhibited a well-expressed transition from the case of the quasi-regular arrangement of ions to the disordered one; the magnitude of the effect being about 30%. Thereby, we can conclude that the two-step formation of ultracold plasmas—involving the intermediate stage of the blockaded Rydberg gas—can really serve as a tool to increase the degree of Coulomb coupling, but the efficiency of this method is moderate.

arXiv:2308.15967•Physics of Plasmas•Jan 1, 2024•2 citations

Ultracold neutral plasmas

Mary Lyon, S. L. Rolston

By photoionizing samples of laser-cooled atoms with laser light tuned just above the ionization limit, plasmas can be created with electron and ion temperatures below 10 K. These ultracold neutral plasmas have extended the temperature bounds of plasma physics by two orders of magnitude. Table-top experiments, using many of the tools from atomic physics, allow for the study of plasma phenomena in this new regime with independent control over the density and temperature of the plasma through the excitation process. Characteristic of these systems is an inhomogeneous density profile, inherited from the density distribution of the laser-cooled neutral atom sample. Most work has dealt with unconfined plasmas in vacuum, which expand outward at velocities of order 100 m/s, governed by electron pressure, and with lifetimes of order 100 μs, limited by stray electric fields. Using detection of charged particles and optical detection techniques, a wide variety of properties and phenomena have been observed, including expansion dynamics, collective excitations in both the electrons and ions, and collisional properties. Through three-body recombination collisions, the plasmas rapidly form Rydberg atoms, and clouds of cold Rydberg atoms have been observed to spontaneously avalanche ionize to form plasmas. Of particular interest is the possibility of the formation of strongly coupled plasmas, where Coulomb forces dominate thermal motion and correlations become important. The strongest impediment to strong coupling is disorder-induced heating, a process in which Coulomb energy from an initially disordered sample is converted into thermal energy. This restricts electrons to a weakly coupled regime and leaves the ions barely within the strongly coupled regime. This review will give an overview of the field of ultracold neutral plasmas, from its inception in 1999 to current work, including efforts to increase strong coupling and effects on plasma properties due to strong coupling.

Reports on Progress in Physics•Nov 17, 2016•77 citations

Star cluster dynamics in a laboratory: electrons in an ultracold plasma

D. Comparat, Thibault Vogt, Nassim Zahzam +2 more

Electrons in a spherical ultracold, quasi-neutral plasma at temperature in the Kelvin range can be created by laser excitation of an ultracold, laser-cooled atomic cloud. The dynamical behaviour of the electrons is similar to the one described by conventional models of star cluster dynamics. The single mass component, the spherical symmetry and no star evolution are here accurate assumptions. The analogue of binary star formations in the cluster case is a three-body recombination in Rydberg atoms in the plasma case with the same Heggie's law: soft binaries get softer and hard binaries get harder. We demonstrate that the evolution of such an ultracold plasma is dominated by Fokker—Planck kinetics equations formally identical to the ones controlling the evolution of a star cluster. The Virial theorem leads to a link between the plasma temperature and the ions and electron numbers. The Fokker—Planck equation is approximate using gaseous and fluid models. We found that the electrons are in a Kramers—Michie—King type quasi-equilibrium distribution as stars in clusters. We suggest that the evaporation rate can be used to determine the temperature. As an example, knowing the electron distribution and using forced fast electron extraction, in a ‘violent extraction’ way, we are able to determine the plasma temperature knowing the trapping potential depth.

arXiv:quant-ph/0501059•Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society•Aug 3, 2005•25 citations

Numerical simulation of ultracold plasmas

S. G. Kuzmin, Thomas M. O’Neil

In recent experiments ultracold plasmas were produced by photoionizing small clouds of laser cooled atoms. This paper presents the results of molecular dynamic simulations for the early time evolution of such plasmas. Contrary to earlier speculation, no evidence of strong electron–electron correlations is observed in the simulations even if the initial value of the coupling parameter (Γe=e2/akTe) is much larger than unity. As electron–electron correlations begin to develop, the correlation energy is released to heat the electrons, raising the electron temperature to the point where Γe∼1 and limiting further development of correlation. Further heating of the electrons occurs as a by-product of three-body recombination. When a model of laser cooling is added to the simulation, the formation of strong ion–ion correlation is observed. Contrary to earlier suggestion, the rate of three-body recombination is observed to be in reasonable agreement with the traditional formula, R=3.9×10−9 s−1[n(cm−3)]2[Te(K)]−9/2, but care must be taken to use the correct temporally evolving temperature, Te. The simulations are challenging because it is necessary to follow three-body recombination into weakly bound (high n quasiclassical) Rydberg states, and the time scale for such states is short compared to that for the plasma dynamics. This kind of problem was faced earlier in computational astrophysics when studying binary star formation in globular clusters and the simulation method used here is adapted from such studies.

Physics of Plasmas•Aug 30, 2002•101 citations

Towards Stronger Coulomb Coupling in an Ultracold Neutral Plasma

Mary Lyon

Ultracold neutral plasmas are created by photoionizing laser-cooled atoms in a magneto-optical trap (MOT). Due to their large electrical potential energies and comparatively small kinetic energies, ultracold plasmas fall into a regime of plasma systems which are called “strongly coupled.” A priority in the field of ultracold plasmas is to generate plasmas with higher values of the strong coupling parameter Γ, which is given as the ratio of the nearest-neighbor Coulomb potential energy to the average kinetic energy. The equilibrium strong coupling in ultracold plasmas is limited by the ultrafast relaxation of the ions due to spatial disorder in the initial system. This heating mechanism is called “disorder-induced heating” (DIH) and it limits the ion strong coupling in ultracold plasmas to order unity. This thesis describes experiments that explore ways to generate higher values of the strong coupling parameter in an ultracold neutral calcium plasma.One way to increase Γ is to mitigate the effects of DIH using electron screening. This thesis describes an experiment in which the initial electron temperature was systematically changed to determine the effect that electron screening has on the ion thermalization. At lower initial electron temperatures, corresponding to a higher degree of electron shielding, it was found that the screening slows the ion thermalization and reduces the equilibrium ion temperature by as much as a factor of two. However, electron screening also reduces the ion interaction strength by the same amount, which has the net effect of leaving the effective Γ unchanged.Another method for increasing the strong coupling of an ultracold plasma is to excite the plasma ions to a higher ionization state. Simulations predict that doubly ionizing the plasma ions can increase the strong coupling in an ultracold plasma by as much as a factor of 4, with the maximum value of Γ depending on the timing of the second ionization relative to the DIH process. This thesis describes an experiment designed to test these predictions in a Ca2+ plasma. Measurements of the change in the Ca+ ion temperature as a function of the timing of the second ionization pulses were made using laser-induced fluorescence. Results of these measurements show that the heating of the Ca+ ions due to the second ionization depends on the timing of the second ionization pulses, as predicted by MD simulations.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Plasma formation from ultracold Rydberg gases

Thomas Pohl, Thomas Pattard, Jan Michael Rost

Recent experiments have demonstrated the spontaneous evolution of a gas of ultracold Rydberg atoms into an expanding ultracold plasma, as well as the reverse process of plasma recombination into highly excited atomic states. Treating the evolution of the plasma on the basis of kinetic equations, while ionization/excitation and recombination are incorporated using rate equations, we have investigated theoretically the Rydberg-to-plasma transition. Including the influence of spatial correlations on the plasma dynamics in an approximate way, we find that ionic correlations change the results quantitatively but not qualitatively.

arXiv:physics/0303052•Physical Review A•Jul 25, 2003•67 citations
Ultracold plasmas are a promising candidate for the creation of strongly coupled Coulomb systems. Unfortunately, the values of the coupling parameter Γe actually achieved after photoionization of the neutral atoms remain relatively small because of the considerable intrinsic heating of the electrons. A conceivable way to get around this obstacle might be to utilize a spontaneous ionization of the ultracold Rydberg gas, where the initial kinetic energies could be much less. However, the spontaneous avalanche ionization will result in a very inhomogeneous distribution (clusterization) of the ions, which can change the efficiency of the electron relaxation in the vicinity of such clusters substantially. In the present work, this hypothesis is tested by an extensive set of numerical simulations. As a result, it is found that despite a less initial kinetic energy, the subsequent relaxation of the electron velocities in the clusterized plasmas proceeds much more violently than in the case of the statistically uniform ionic distribution. The electron temperature, first, experiences a sharp initial jump (presumably, caused by the “virialization” of energies of the charged particles) and, second, exhibits a gradual subsequent increase (presumably, associated with a multi-particle recombination of the electrons at the ionic clusters). As a possible tool to reduce the anomalous temperature increase, we also considered a two-step plasma formation, involving the blockaded Rydberg states. This leads to a suppression of the clusterization due to a quasi-regular distribution of ions. In such a case, according to the numerical simulations, the subsequent evolution of the electron temperature proceeds more gently, approximately with the same rate as in the statistically uniform ionic distribution.
Starting from the beginning of their research in the early 2000s, the ultracold plasmas were considered as a promising tool to achieve considerable values of the Coulomb coupling parameter for electrons. Unfortunately, this was found to be precluded by a sharp spontaneous increase in temperature, which was often attributed to the so-called disorder-induced heating. It is the aim of the present paper to quantify the effect of spontaneous heating as a function of the initial ionic disorder and, thereby, to estimate the efficiency of its mitigation, e.g., by the Rydberg blockade. As a result of the performed simulations, we found that the dynamics of electrons exhibited a well-expressed transition from the case of the quasi-regular arrangement of ions to the disordered one; the magnitude of the effect being about 30%. Thereby, we can conclude that the two-step formation of ultracold plasmas—involving the intermediate stage of the blockaded Rydberg gas—can really serve as a tool to increase the degree of Coulomb coupling, but the efficiency of this method is moderate.
By photoionizing samples of laser-cooled atoms with laser light tuned just above the ionization limit, plasmas can be created with electron and ion temperatures below 10 K. These ultracold neutral plasmas have extended the temperature bounds of plasma physics by two orders of magnitude. Table-top experiments, using many of the tools from atomic physics, allow for the study of plasma phenomena in this new regime with independent control over the density and temperature of the plasma through the excitation process. Characteristic of these systems is an inhomogeneous density profile, inherited from the density distribution of the laser-cooled neutral atom sample. Most work has dealt with unconfined plasmas in vacuum, which expand outward at velocities of order 100 m/s, governed by electron pressure, and with lifetimes of order 100 μs, limited by stray electric fields. Using detection of charged particles and optical detection techniques, a wide variety of properties and phenomena have been observed, including expansion dynamics, collective excitations in both the electrons and ions, and collisional properties. Through three-body recombination collisions, the plasmas rapidly form Rydberg atoms, and clouds of cold Rydberg atoms have been observed to spontaneously avalanche ionize to form plasmas. Of particular interest is the possibility of the formation of strongly coupled plasmas, where Coulomb forces dominate thermal motion and correlations become important. The strongest impediment to strong coupling is disorder-induced heating, a process in which Coulomb energy from an initially disordered sample is converted into thermal energy. This restricts electrons to a weakly coupled regime and leaves the ions barely within the strongly coupled regime. This review will give an overview of the field of ultracold neutral plasmas, from its inception in 1999 to current work, including efforts to increase strong coupling and effects on plasma properties due to strong coupling.
Electrons in a spherical ultracold, quasi-neutral plasma at temperature in the Kelvin range can be created by laser excitation of an ultracold, laser-cooled atomic cloud. The dynamical behaviour of the electrons is similar to the one described by conventional models of star cluster dynamics. The single mass component, the spherical symmetry and no star evolution are here accurate assumptions. The analogue of binary star formations in the cluster case is a three-body recombination in Rydberg atoms in the plasma case with the same Heggie's law: soft binaries get softer and hard binaries get harder. We demonstrate that the evolution of such an ultracold plasma is dominated by Fokker—Planck kinetics equations formally identical to the ones controlling the evolution of a star cluster. The Virial theorem leads to a link between the plasma temperature and the ions and electron numbers. The Fokker—Planck equation is approximate using gaseous and fluid models. We found that the electrons are in a Kramers—Michie—King type quasi-equilibrium distribution as stars in clusters. We suggest that the evaporation rate can be used to determine the temperature. As an example, knowing the electron distribution and using forced fast electron extraction, in a ‘violent extraction’ way, we are able to determine the plasma temperature knowing the trapping potential depth.
In recent experiments ultracold plasmas were produced by photoionizing small clouds of laser cooled atoms. This paper presents the results of molecular dynamic simulations for the early time evolution of such plasmas. Contrary to earlier speculation, no evidence of strong electron–electron correlations is observed in the simulations even if the initial value of the coupling parameter (Γe=e2/akTe) is much larger than unity. As electron–electron correlations begin to develop, the correlation energy is released to heat the electrons, raising the electron temperature to the point where Γe∼1 and limiting further development of correlation. Further heating of the electrons occurs as a by-product of three-body recombination. When a model of laser cooling is added to the simulation, the formation of strong ion–ion correlation is observed. Contrary to earlier suggestion, the rate of three-body recombination is observed to be in reasonable agreement with the traditional formula, R=3.9×10−9 s−1[n(cm−3)]2[Te(K)]−9/2, but care must be taken to use the correct temporally evolving temperature, Te. The simulations are challenging because it is necessary to follow three-body recombination into weakly bound (high n quasiclassical) Rydberg states, and the time scale for such states is short compared to that for the plasma dynamics. This kind of problem was faced earlier in computational astrophysics when studying binary star formation in globular clusters and the simulation method used here is adapted from such studies.
Ultracold neutral plasmas are created by photoionizing laser-cooled atoms in a magneto-optical trap (MOT). Due to their large electrical potential energies and comparatively small kinetic energies, ultracold plasmas fall into a regime of plasma systems which are called “strongly coupled.” A priority in the field of ultracold plasmas is to generate plasmas with higher values of the strong coupling parameter Γ, which is given as the ratio of the nearest-neighbor Coulomb potential energy to the average kinetic energy. The equilibrium strong coupling in ultracold plasmas is limited by the ultrafast relaxation of the ions due to spatial disorder in the initial system. This heating mechanism is called “disorder-induced heating” (DIH) and it limits the ion strong coupling in ultracold plasmas to order unity. This thesis describes experiments that explore ways to generate higher values of the strong coupling parameter in an ultracold neutral calcium plasma.One way to increase Γ is to mitigate the effects of DIH using electron screening. This thesis describes an experiment in which the initial electron temperature was systematically changed to determine the effect that electron screening has on the ion thermalization. At lower initial electron temperatures, corresponding to a higher degree of electron shielding, it was found that the screening slows the ion thermalization and reduces the equilibrium ion temperature by as much as a factor of two. However, electron screening also reduces the ion interaction strength by the same amount, which has the net effect of leaving the effective Γ unchanged.Another method for increasing the strong coupling of an ultracold plasma is to excite the plasma ions to a higher ionization state. Simulations predict that doubly ionizing the plasma ions can increase the strong coupling in an ultracold plasma by as much as a factor of 4, with the maximum value of Γ depending on the timing of the second ionization relative to the DIH process. This thesis describes an experiment designed to test these predictions in a Ca2+ plasma. Measurements of the change in the Ca+ ion temperature as a function of the timing of the second ionization pulses were made using laser-induced fluorescence. Results of these measurements show that the heating of the Ca+ ions due to the second ionization depends on the timing of the second ionization pulses, as predicted by MD simulations.
Recent experiments have demonstrated the spontaneous evolution of a gas of ultracold Rydberg atoms into an expanding ultracold plasma, as well as the reverse process of plasma recombination into highly excited atomic states. Treating the evolution of the plasma on the basis of kinetic equations, while ionization/excitation and recombination are incorporated using rate equations, we have investigated theoretically the Rydberg-to-plasma transition. Including the influence of spatial correlations on the plasma dynamics in an approximate way, we find that ionic correlations change the results quantitatively but not qualitatively.