Reduced density matrix functional theory from an ab initio seniority-zero wave function: Exact and approximate formulations along adiabatic connection paths
Bruno Senjean, Saad Yalouz, Naoki Nakatani, Emmanuel Fromager
Currently, there is a growing interest in the development of a new hierarchy of methods based on the concept of seniority, which has been introduced quite recently in quantum chemistry. Despite the enormous potential of these methods, the accurate description of both dynamical and static correlation effects within a single and in-principle-exact approach remains a challenge. In this work, we propose an alternative formulation of reduced density-matrix functional theory (RDMFT) where the (one-electron reduced) density matrix is mapped onto an ab initio seniority-zero wave function. In this theory, the exact natural orbitals and their occupancies are determined self-consistently from an effective seniority-zero calculation. The latter involves a universal higher seniority density matrix functional for which an adiabatic connection (AC) formula is derived and implemented under specific constraints that are related to the density matrix. The pronounced curvature of the (constrained) AC integrand, which is numerically observed in prototypical hydrogen chains and the helium dimer, indicates that a description of higher seniority correlations within second-order perturbation theory is inadequate in this context. Applying multiple linear interpolations along the AC or connecting second-order perturbation theory to a full-seniority treatment via Pad\'e approximants are better strategies. Such information is expected to serve as a guide in the future design of higher seniority density-matrix functional approximations.
Currently, there is a growing interest in the development of a new hierarchy of methods based on the concept of seniority, which has been introduced quite recently in quantum chemistry. Despite the enormous potential of these methods, the accurate description of both dynamical and static correlation effects within a single and in-principle-exact approach remains a challenge. In this work, we propose an alternative formulation of reduced density-matrix functional theory (RDMFT) where the (one-electron reduced) density matrix is mapped onto an ab initio seniority-zero wave function. In this theory, the exact natural orbitals and their occupancies are determined self-consistently from an effective seniority-zero calculation. The latter involves a universal higher seniority density matrix functional for which an adiabatic connection (AC) formula is derived and implemented under specific constraints that are related to the density matrix. The pronounced curvature of the (constrained) AC integrand, which is numerically observed in prototypical hydrogen chains and the helium dimer, indicates that a description of higher seniority correlations within second-order perturbation theory is inadequate in this context. Applying multiple linear interpolations along the AC or connecting second-order perturbation theory to a full-seniority treatment via Pad'e approximants are better strategies. Such information is expected to serve as a guide in the future design of higher seniority density-matrix functional approximations.
Accurately describing chemical bond breaking requires capturing strong/static electron correlation, a major challenge for single-reference self-consistent-field methods such as Hartree--Fock and Kohn--Sham density-functional theory (DFT). Fractional occupations substantially improve this situation, as demonstrated by information-density-matrix-functional theory (i-DMFT) and thermally-assisted-occupation DFT (TAO-DFT). Although useful, they are formulated within rather different theoretical frameworks, are somewhat semi-empirical, and their relationship remains unclear. Here we introduce finite-temperature adiabatic-connection reduced density-matrix functional theory (FT-AC-RDMFT), in which i-DMFT and TAO-DFT emerge as different reductions of a unified framework. The effective eigenvalue equation for natural orbitals and the Fermi--Dirac occupation numbers follow directly from the variational principle, while a thermal adiabatic connection relates the empirical entropy coefficient of i-DMFT to a characteristic temperature of the auxiliary non-interacting system. Within this framework, i-DMFT is the exact-exchange-based reduction, whereas TAO-DFT results when exact exchange is replaced by a density-based exchange-correlation functional. Numerical calculations confirm that i-DMFT, apart from a constant, coincides with the exact-exchange realization of the framework, and show that the improved dissociation behavior from finite-temperature occupations extends beyond exact exchange to hybrid and semilocal density functionals. For strongly correlated V2O3, finite-temperature occupations substantially reduce the severely overestimated non-magnetic LDA bulk modulus, bringing it close to experiment. These results establish FT-AC-RDMFT as a common theoretical foundation for finite-temperature occupation-based electronic-structure methods in molecular and solid-state systems.
In materials with strong electron correlation the proper treatment of local atomic physics described by orbital occupations is crucial. Reduced density-matrix functional theory is a natural extension of density functional theory for systems that are dominated by orbital physics. We review the current state of reduced density-matrix functional theory (RDMFT). For atomic structure relaxations or ab-initio molecular dynamics the combination of density functional theory (DFT) and dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) possesses a number of disadvantages, like the cumbersome evaluation of forces. We therefore describe a method, DFT+RDMFT, that combines many-particle effects based on reduced density-matrix functional theory with a density functional-like framework. A recent development is the construction of density-matrix functionals directly from many-particle theory such as methods from quantum chemistry or many-particle Green’s functions. We present the underlying exact theorems and describe current progress towards quantitative functionals.
Recently, an approximate theoretical framework was introduced, called local reduced density matrix functional theory (local-RDMFT), where functionals of the one-body reduced density matrix (1-RDM) are minimized under the additional condition that the optimal orbitals satisfy a single electron Schrödinger equation with a local potential. In the present work, we focus on the character of these optimal orbitals. In particular, we compare orbitals obtained by local-RDMFT with those obtained with the full minimization (without the extra condition) by contrasting them against the exact NOs and orbitals from a density functional calculation using the local density approximation (LDA). We find that the orbitals from local-RMDFT are very close to LDA orbitals, contrary to those of the full minimization that resemble the exact NOs. Since local RDMFT preserves the good quality of the description of strong static correlation, this finding opens the way to a mixed density/density matrix scheme, where Kohn-Sham orbitals obtain fractional occupations from a minimization of the occupation numbers using 1-RDM functionals. This will allow for a description of strong correlation at a cost only minimally higher than a density functional calculation.
Recently, an approximate theoretical framework was introduced, called local reduced density matrix functional theory (local-RDMFT), where functionals of the one-body reduced density matrix (1-RDM) are minimized under the additional condition that the optimal orbitals satisfy a single electron Schrödinger equation with a local potential. In the present work, we focus on the character of these optimal orbitals. In particular, we compare orbitals obtained by local-RDMFT with those obtained with the full minimization (without the extra condition) by contrasting them against the exact NOs and orbitals from a density functional calculation using the local density approximation (LDA). We find that the orbitals from local-RMDFT are very close to LDA orbitals, contrary to those of the full minimization that resemble the exact NOs. Since local RDMFT preserves the good quality of the description of strong static correlation, this finding opens the way to a mixed density/density matrix scheme, where Kohn-Sham orbitals obtain fractional occupations from a minimization of the occupation numbers using 1-RDM functionals. This will allow for a description of strong correlation at a cost only minimally higher than a density functional calculation.
Ab-initio calculations are dominated by density functional theory (DFT), which provides an efficient and accurate description of the electronic structure for most materials. For materials with strong correlations, however, many of the available density functionals yield poor results. Most well known is the case of transition metal oxides, for which most density functionals produce a qualitatively incorrect description. There is a quest to improve the description by borrowing from methods specifically designed for strongly correlated materials. One of the method which is widely used to study strongly correlated electron system in the thermodynamic limit is the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). For calculations pertaining to real materials, hybrid approaches like DFT+DMFT are commonly used. We consider reduced density-matrix functional theory (rDMFT) to be a useful framework for a rigorous formulation of such hybrid theories. The link from rDMFT to many-particle wave functions has been established by Levy's constrained-search algorithm on the one hand. The link to many-body perturbation theory and Green's function, on the other hand, has been provided via the Luttinger-Ward functional. The development in the field of rDMFT proceeded analogously to the development of DFT. In order to avoid the full complexity of an explicit many-body description, most density-matrix functionals are not extracted from the exact expressions i.e. via Levy's constrained-search or Green's function based methods . Rather, one proceeds analogously to the development of density functionals, namely by searching models for the density-matrix functional, that capture the most essential physical effects while having an algebraic dependence on the density matrix. Among such models, the most prominent ones are the Müller functional, Sharma functional and Marques-Lathiotakis functional. One of the major arguments in favor of density-matrix functionals is that one of the most simple functionals, the Müller functional, seems to provide a correct description of the bond-dissociation problem, for which common density functionals fail. Despite the successes, the common density-matrix functionals also reproduce a number of features in a qualitatively incorrect manner. Several such discrepancies of the standard state of the art density-matrix functionals are discussed in details in this thesis. The objective of this thesis is to study the performance of the class of commonly used model density-matrix functionals and to set the stage for the desire to develop the framework for an approximate scheme to evaluate new class of functionals from exact Green's function based method.
Density-Functional Theory (DFT), although widely used and very successful in the calculation of several observables, fails to correctly describe strongly correlated materials. In the first part of this work we, therefore, introduce reduced-density-matrix-functional theory (RDMFT) which is one possible way to treat electron correlation beyond DFT. Within this theory the one-body reduced density matrix (1-RDM) is used as the basic variable. Our main interest is the calculation of the fundamental gap which proves very problematic within DFT. In order to calculate the fundamental gap we generalize RDMFT to fractional particle numbers M by describing the system as an ensemble of an N and an N+1 particle system (with N≤ M≤N+1). For each fixed particle number, M, the total energy is minimized with respect to the natural orbitals and their occupation numbers. This leads to the total energy as a function of M. The derivative of this function with respect to the particle number has a discontinuity at integer particle number which is identical to the gap. In addition, we investigate the necessary and sufficient conditions for the 1-RDM of a system with fractional particle number to be N-representable. Numerical results are presented for alkali atoms, small molecules, and periodic systems. Another problem within DFT is the description of non-relativistic many- electron systems in the presence of magnetic fields. It requires the paramagnetic current density and the spin magnetization to be used as basic variables besides the electron density. However, electron-gas-based functionals of current-spin-density-functional Theory (CSDFT) exhibit derivative discontinuities as a function of the magnetic field whenever a new Landau level is occupied, which makes them difficult to use in practice. Since the appearance of Landau levels is, intrinsically, an orbital effect it is appealing to use orbital-dependent functionals. We have developed a CSDFT version of the optimized effective potential (OEP) method which allows for the use of explicitly orbital-dependent functionals in the context of CSDFT. We present the derivation of corresponding equations and show results for a quantum dot in external magnetic fields in the second part of this thesis.