Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2204.00340 · Physical Review A

Quantum approximate optimization algorithm for qudit systems

Yannick Deller, Sebastian Schmitt, Maciej Lewenstein, Steve Lenk, Marika Federer, Fred Jendrzejewski, Philipp Hauke, Valentin Kasper

Published Jun 9, 2023• 35 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A frequent starting point of quantum computation platforms is the two-state quantum system, i.e., the qubit. However, in the context of integer optimization problems, relevant to scheduling optimization and operations research, it is often more resource-efficient to employ quantum systems with more than two basis states, so-called qudits. Here, we discuss the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) for qudit systems. We illustrate how the QAOA can be used to formulate a variety of integer optimization problems such as graph coloring problems or electric vehicle charging optimization. In addition, we comment on the implementation of constraints and describe three methods to include these in a quantum circuit of a QAOA by penalty contributions to the cost Hamiltonian, conditional gates using ancilla qubits, and a dynamical decoupling strategy. Finally, as a showcase of qudit-based QAOA, we present numerical results for a charging optimization problem mapped onto a maximum-$k$-graph-coloring problem. Our work illustrates the flexibility of qudit systems to solve integer optimization problems.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.107.062410

Related papers

Exploring the Potential of Qutrits for Quantum Optimization of Graph Coloring

Gabriel Bottrill, Mudit Pandey, Olivia Di Matteo

Recent hardware demonstrations and advances in circuit compilation have made quantum computing with higher- dimensional systems (qudits) on near-term devices an attractive possibility. Some problems have more natural or optimal en- codings using qudits over qubits. We explore this potential by formulating graph 3-coloring, a well-known and difficult problem with practical applications, using qutrits, and solve it using the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). Qutrit- based cost and mixer Hamiltonians are constructed along with appropriate quantum circuits using qutrit gates. We run noiseless simulations using PennyLane to compare the formulation against qubit-based QAOA, and analyze the solution quality and resources required. Preliminary results show that the qutrit encoding finds more accurate solutions with a comparable set of hyperparameters, uses half as many qudits, and has a notably smaller circuit depth per layer than an efficient qubit encoding. This work suggests that qutrits may be useful in solving some problems on near-term devices, however further work is required to assess their potential in a noisy environment.

arXiv:2308.08050•IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 17, 2023•5 citations

Quantum Approximate Optimization of Integer Graph Problems and Surpassing Semidefinite Programming for Max-k-Cut

Anuj Apte, Sami Boulebnane, Yuwei Jin +3 more

Quantum algorithms for binary optimization problems have been the subject of extensive study. However, the application of quantum algorithms to integer optimization problems remains comparatively unexplored. In this paper, we study the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) applied to integer problems on graphs, with each integer variable encoded in a qudit. We derive a general iterative formula for depth-$p$ QAOA expectation on high-girth $d$-regular graphs of arbitrary size. The cost of evaluating the formula is exponential in the QAOA depth $p$ but does not depend on the graph size. Evaluating this formula for Max-$k$-Cut problem for $p\leq 4$, we identify parameter regimes ($k=3$ with degree $d \leq 10$ and $k=4$ with $d \leq 40$) in which QAOA outperforms the Frieze-Jerrum semi-definite programming (SDP) algorithm, which provides the best worst-case guarantee on the approximation ratio. To strengthen the classical baseline, we introduce a new heuristic algorithm based on the degree-of-saturation that achieves strong results on the \texttt{GSet} benchmark with quasi-linear runtime in the number of edges. It empirically outperforms both the Frieze-Jerrum algorithm and shallow-depth QAOA on regular graphs. Nevertheless, we provide numerical evidence that QAOA may overtake this heuristic at depth $p\leq 20$. Our results show that moving beyond binary to integer optimization problems can open up new avenues for quantum advantage.

quant-pharXiv:2602.05956•Feb 6, 2026•0 citations

Comparing Qubit and Qudit Encoding for EV Charging and Trip Assignment Problems

Linus Ekstrøm, Hao Wang, Sebastian Schmitt

Variational quantum algorithms have attracted attention for their potential to solve combinatorial optimization problems. We study how the choice of encoding affects the resource requirements and optimization behavior of a variational quantum optimization algorithm. In order to quantify these effects, realistically inspired constrained electric vehicle (EV) fleet management problems were considered. These problems couple determining the optimal EV battery charging schedule with assigning EVs to trips requested by customers. We compare a conventional binary (qubit) trip encoding with an integer (qudit) encoding that represents assignments more directly. Both encodings guarantee the same feasible solution set, while the qudit encoding exponentially reduces the required Hilbert-space dimension. We solve many random instances of highly constrained uni- and bi-directional charging problems using qudit-based quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) and thoroughly evaluate the performance results. We find that the qudit encoding of customer trips achieves similar or better optimization performance at much reduced resource requirements and shorter simulation runtime. These results highlight qudit-native encodings as a practical route for integer and multi-valued scheduling problems in variational quantum optimization.

Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference Companion (GECCO Companion)•Jul 13, 2026•0 citations

Comparing Qubit and Qudit Encodings for EV Charging and Trip Assignment Problems

Linus Ekstrøm, Hao Wang, Sebastian Schmitt

Variational quantum algorithms have attracted attention for their potential to solve combinatorial optimization problems. We study how the choice of encoding affects the resource requirements and optimization behavior of a variational quantum optimization algorithm. In order to quantify these effects, realistically inspired constrained electric vehicle (EV) fleet management problems were considered. These problems couple determining the optimal EV battery charging schedule with assigning EVs to trips requested by customers. We compare a conventional binary (qubit) trip encoding with an integer (qudit) encoding that represents assignments more directly. Both encodings guarantee the same feasible solution set, while the qudit encoding exponentially reduces the required Hilbert-space dimension. We solve many random instances of highly constrained uni- and bi-directional charging problems using qudit-based quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) and thoroughly evaluate the performance results. We find that the qudit encoding of customer trips achieves similar or better optimization performance at much reduced resource requirements and shorter simulation runtime. These results highlight qudit-native encodings as a practical route for integer and multi-valued scheduling problems in variational quantum optimization.

quant-pharXiv:2605.10255•May 12, 2026•0 citations

A Quantum Framework for K Coloring of Graphs

Lord Sen, Shyamapada Mukherjee

Graph coloring is a well-known NP-complete problem with applications in scheduling, register allocation, frequency assignment, and network optimization. Quantum computing offers the potential for polynomial or even super-polynomial speedups in certain problem instances, yet practical quantum graph coloring methods must carefully balance qubit resources, circuit depth, and constraint enforcement. We proposed a solver agnostic quantum framework for $K$-coloring. Along with a novel encoding and efficient constraint implementation for its exact coloring exploiting Grover search and almost optimal coloring by the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm \emph{(QAOA)}, and \emph{Quantum Annealing}. Unlike using $O(NK)$ qubits as in \emph{SOTA}, we reduced the qubit requirements to $O(N \log_2 K)$, along with optimized comparator circuits enforcing adjacency constraints. Further symmetry-based graph reduction is incorporated as an optional preprocessing step to further reduce the instance size before quantum execution.

quant-pharXiv:2609.32348•International Conference on Computational Intelligence and Communication Networks (CICN)•Sep 29, 2026•0 citations

Prog-QAOA: Framework for resource-efficient quantum optimization through classical programs

Bence Bakó, Adam Glos, Özlem Salehi +1 more

Current state-of-the-art quantum optimization algorithms require representing the original problem as a binary optimization problem, which is then converted into an equivalent cost Hamiltonian suitable for the quantum device. Implementing each term of the cost Hamiltonian separately often results in high redundancy, significantly increasing the resources required. Instead, we propose to design classical programs for computing the objective function and certifying the constraints, and later compile them to quantum circuits, eliminating the reliance on the binary optimization problem representation. This results in a new variant of the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA), which we name the Program-based QAOA (Prog-QAOA). We exploit this idea for optimization tasks like the Travelling Salesman Problem and Max- K -Cut and obtain circuits that are near-optimal with respect to all relevant cost measures, e.g., number of qubits, gates, and circuit depth. While we demonstrate the power of Prog-QAOA only for a particular set of paradigmatic problems, our approach is conveniently applicable to generic optimization problems.

arXiv:2209.03386•Quantum•Mar 20, 2025•15 citations
A frequent starting point of quantum computation platforms is the two-state quantum system, i.e., the qubit. However, in the context of integer optimization problems, relevant to scheduling optimization and operations research, it is often more resource-efficient to employ quantum systems with more than two basis states, so-called qudits. Here, we discuss the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) for qudit systems. We illustrate how the QAOA can be used to formulate a variety of integer optimization problems such as graph coloring problems or electric vehicle charging optimization. In addition, we comment on the implementation of constraints and describe three methods to include these in a quantum circuit of a QAOA by penalty contributions to the cost Hamiltonian, conditional gates using ancilla qubits, and a dynamical decoupling strategy. Finally, as a showcase of qudit-based QAOA, we present numerical results for a charging optimization problem mapped onto a maximum-kkk-graph-coloring problem. Our work illustrates the flexibility of qudit systems to solve integer optimization problems.
Recent hardware demonstrations and advances in circuit compilation have made quantum computing with higher- dimensional systems (qudits) on near-term devices an attractive possibility. Some problems have more natural or optimal en- codings using qudits over qubits. We explore this potential by formulating graph 3-coloring, a well-known and difficult problem with practical applications, using qutrits, and solve it using the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). Qutrit- based cost and mixer Hamiltonians are constructed along with appropriate quantum circuits using qutrit gates. We run noiseless simulations using PennyLane to compare the formulation against qubit-based QAOA, and analyze the solution quality and resources required. Preliminary results show that the qutrit encoding finds more accurate solutions with a comparable set of hyperparameters, uses half as many qudits, and has a notably smaller circuit depth per layer than an efficient qubit encoding. This work suggests that qutrits may be useful in solving some problems on near-term devices, however further work is required to assess their potential in a noisy environment.
Quantum algorithms for binary optimization problems have been the subject of extensive study. However, the application of quantum algorithms to integer optimization problems remains comparatively unexplored. In this paper, we study the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) applied to integer problems on graphs, with each integer variable encoded in a qudit. We derive a general iterative formula for depth-ppp QAOA expectation on high-girth ddd-regular graphs of arbitrary size. The cost of evaluating the formula is exponential in the QAOA depth ppp but does not depend on the graph size. Evaluating this formula for Max-kkk-Cut problem for p≤4p\leq 4p≤4, we identify parameter regimes (k=3k=3k=3 with degree d≤10d \leq 10d≤10 and k=4k=4k=4 with d≤40d \leq 40d≤40) in which QAOA outperforms the Frieze-Jerrum semi-definite programming (SDP) algorithm, which provides the best worst-case guarantee on the approximation ratio. To strengthen the classical baseline, we introduce a new heuristic algorithm based on the degree-of-saturation that achieves strong results on the \texttt{GSet} benchmark with quasi-linear runtime in the number of edges. It empirically outperforms both the Frieze-Jerrum algorithm and shallow-depth QAOA on regular graphs. Nevertheless, we provide numerical evidence that QAOA may overtake this heuristic at depth p≤20p\leq 20p≤20. Our results show that moving beyond binary to integer optimization problems can open up new avenues for quantum advantage.
Variational quantum algorithms have attracted attention for their potential to solve combinatorial optimization problems. We study how the choice of encoding affects the resource requirements and optimization behavior of a variational quantum optimization algorithm. In order to quantify these effects, realistically inspired constrained electric vehicle (EV) fleet management problems were considered. These problems couple determining the optimal EV battery charging schedule with assigning EVs to trips requested by customers. We compare a conventional binary (qubit) trip encoding with an integer (qudit) encoding that represents assignments more directly. Both encodings guarantee the same feasible solution set, while the qudit encoding exponentially reduces the required Hilbert-space dimension. We solve many random instances of highly constrained uni- and bi-directional charging problems using qudit-based quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) and thoroughly evaluate the performance results. We find that the qudit encoding of customer trips achieves similar or better optimization performance at much reduced resource requirements and shorter simulation runtime. These results highlight qudit-native encodings as a practical route for integer and multi-valued scheduling problems in variational quantum optimization.
Variational quantum algorithms have attracted attention for their potential to solve combinatorial optimization problems. We study how the choice of encoding affects the resource requirements and optimization behavior of a variational quantum optimization algorithm. In order to quantify these effects, realistically inspired constrained electric vehicle (EV) fleet management problems were considered. These problems couple determining the optimal EV battery charging schedule with assigning EVs to trips requested by customers. We compare a conventional binary (qubit) trip encoding with an integer (qudit) encoding that represents assignments more directly. Both encodings guarantee the same feasible solution set, while the qudit encoding exponentially reduces the required Hilbert-space dimension. We solve many random instances of highly constrained uni- and bi-directional charging problems using qudit-based quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) and thoroughly evaluate the performance results. We find that the qudit encoding of customer trips achieves similar or better optimization performance at much reduced resource requirements and shorter simulation runtime. These results highlight qudit-native encodings as a practical route for integer and multi-valued scheduling problems in variational quantum optimization.
Graph coloring is a well-known NP-complete problem with applications in scheduling, register allocation, frequency assignment, and network optimization. Quantum computing offers the potential for polynomial or even super-polynomial speedups in certain problem instances, yet practical quantum graph coloring methods must carefully balance qubit resources, circuit depth, and constraint enforcement. We proposed a solver agnostic quantum framework for KKK-coloring. Along with a novel encoding and efficient constraint implementation for its exact coloring exploiting Grover search and almost optimal coloring by the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm \emph{(QAOA)}, and \emph{Quantum Annealing}. Unlike using O(NK)O(NK)O(NK) qubits as in \emph{SOTA}, we reduced the qubit requirements to O(Nlog⁡2K)O(N \log_2 K)O(Nlog2​K), along with optimized comparator circuits enforcing adjacency constraints. Further symmetry-based graph reduction is incorporated as an optional preprocessing step to further reduce the instance size before quantum execution.
Current state-of-the-art quantum optimization algorithms require representing the original problem as a binary optimization problem, which is then converted into an equivalent cost Hamiltonian suitable for the quantum device. Implementing each term of the cost Hamiltonian separately often results in high redundancy, significantly increasing the resources required. Instead, we propose to design classical programs for computing the objective function and certifying the constraints, and later compile them to quantum circuits, eliminating the reliance on the binary optimization problem representation. This results in a new variant of the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA), which we name the Program-based QAOA (Prog-QAOA). We exploit this idea for optimization tasks like the Travelling Salesman Problem and Max- K -Cut and obtain circuits that are near-optimal with respect to all relevant cost measures, e.g., number of qubits, gates, and circuit depth. While we demonstrate the power of Prog-QAOA only for a particular set of paradigmatic problems, our approach is conveniently applicable to generic optimization problems.