arXiv:2203.11436 · Optics Express

Evaluating the quantum Ziv–Zakai bound for phase estimation in noisy environments

Shoukang Chang, Wei Ye, Xuan Rao, Huan Zhang, Liqing Huang, Mengmeng Luo, Yuetao Chen, Shaoyan Gao, Liyun Hu

Published Jun 13, 2022• 8 citations

Abstract

In the highly non-Gaussian regime, the quantum Ziv-Zakai bound (QZZB) provides a lower bound on the available precision, demonstrating the better performance compared with the quantum Cramér-Rao bound. However, evaluating the impact of a noisy environment on the QZZB without applying certain approximations proposed by Tsang [Phys. Rev. Lett.108, 230401 (2012)10.1103/PhysRevLett.108.230401] remains a difficult challenge. In this paper, we not only derive the asymptotically tight QZZB for phase estimation with the photon loss and the phase diffusion by invoking the variational method and the technique of integration within an ordered product of operators, but also show its estimation performance for several different Gaussian resources, such as a coherent state (CS), a single-mode squeezed vacuum state (SMSVS) and a two-mode squeezed vacuum state (TMSVS). In this asymptotically tight situation, our results indicate that compared with the SMSVS and the TMSVS, the QZZB for the CS always shows the better estimation performance under the photon-loss environment. More interestingly, for the phase-diffusion environment, the estimation performance of the QZZB for the TMSVS can be better than that for the CS throughout a wide range of phase-diffusion strength. Our findings will provide an useful guidance for investigating the noisy quantum parameter estimation.

DOI: 10.1364/oe.459659

Related papers

Tighter Heisenberg limits for phase estimation in noisy environments based on the quantum Ziv-Zakai bound

Wei Ye, Peng Xiao, Yunbin Yan +8 more

In exploring the precision limits of quantum metrology, the quest for a tighter Heisenberg limit in real-world environments becomes a key challenge. For this reason, in this paper, we propose a tighter Heisenberg limit for phase estimation, called the photon loss (PL)-type bound and the photon diffusion (PD)-type bound in realistic scenarios under the framework of quantum Ziv-Zakai bound (QZZB). In order to demonstrate the superiority of the proposed Heisenberg limits for phase estimation, as a comparison, we also introduce the Margolus-Levitin (ML)-type and Mandelstam-Tamm (MT)-type bounds [Phys. Rev. A90, 043818 (2014)10.1103/PhysRevA.90.043818] based on the QZZB framework when considering the same initial states, i.e., a coherent state, a superposition state of the vacuum and general Fock states, and an even coherent state. The simulation results show that for photon-loss scenario, the PL-type bounds for all given initial states are closer to the QZZB than the ML-type and MT-type bounds, thereby exhibiting a tighter Heisenberg limit. In contrast, for the phase-diffusion scenario, when the phase diffusion strength exceeds a certain threshold, the tightness of PD-type bounds for the coherent state and superposition state can present better than that of the ML-type and MT-type bounds. Furthermore, the tighter QZZB over the QCRB can be achieved using the superposition state in photon loss or the even coherent state in phase diffusion.

Optics ExpressJan 15, 20252 citations

Noiseless linear amplification-based quantum Ziv-Zakai bound for phase estimation and its Heisenberg error limits in noisy scenarios

Wei Ye, Peng Xiao, Xiaofan Xu +8 more

In this work, we address the central problem about how to effectively find the available precision limit of unknown parameters. In the framework of the quantum Ziv-Zakai bound (QZZB), we employ noiseless linear amplification (NLA)techniques to an initial coherent state (CS) as the probe state, and focus on whether the phase estimation performance is improved significantly in noisy scenarios, involving the photon-loss and phase-diffusion cases. More importantly, we also obtain two kinds of Heisenberg error limits of the QZZB with the NLA-based CS in these noisy scenarios, making comparisons with both the Margolus-Levitin (ML) type bound and the Mandelstam-Tamm (MT) type bound. Our analytical results show that in cases of photon loss and phase diffusion, the phase estimation performance of the QZZB can be improved remarkably by increasing the NLA gain factor. Particularly, the improvement is more pronounced with severe photon losses. Furthermore in minimal photon losses, our Heisenberg error limit shows better compactness than the cases of the ML-type and MT-type bounds. Our findings will provide an useful guidance for accomplishing more complex quantum information processing tasks.

arXiv:2404.14173Apr 22, 20240 citations

Ziv-Zakai Error Bounds for Quantum Parameter Estimation

Mankei Tsang

I propose quantum versions of the Ziv-Zakai bounds as alternatives to the widely used quantum Cramér-Rao bounds for quantum parameter estimation. From a simple form of the proposed bounds, I derive both a Heisenberg error limit that scales with the average energy and a limit similar to the quantum Cramér-Rao bound that scales with the energy variance. These results are further illustrated by applying the bound to a few examples of optical phase estimation, which show that a quantum Ziv-Zakai bound can be much higher and thus tighter than a quantum Cramér-Rao bound for states with highly non-gaussian photon-number statistics in certain regimes and also stay close to the latter where the latter is expected to be tight.

arXiv:1111.3568Physical Review LettersJun 6, 2012137 citations

Quantum Metrology Via Quantum Non-Gaussian States Under Noise

Sang Woo Park, Changsuk Noh, Hyunchul Nha

Quantum metrology aims to achieve measurement precision that surpasses classical limits in the estimation of physical parameters. In realistic conditions, however, its advantage can be diminished by interactions between a quantum system and its environment. This necessitates careful design of quantum resources that can sustain enhanced performance even under noise. Here, we investigate how a quantum non-Gaussian operation can provide an advantage in noisy quantum metrology. Specifically, we examine the effect of single-photon subtraction applied to a two-mode squeezed vacuum state in the task of phase estimation using a Mach–Zehnder interferometer under photon loss. The single-photon subtraction can be implemented either before or after the first beam splitter in the interferometer. By evaluating the quantum Fisher information for both the original and the photon-subtracted states, we assess the potential enhancement in sensing precision. We show that the enhancement occurs when photon subtraction is performed before the first beam splitter, provided that loss acts only on the signal mode. Our findings shed light on the role of non-Gaussian operations in noisy quantum metrology, clarifying when photon subtraction can yield a genuine advantage over Gaussian resources.

Fluctuation and Noise LettersJan 10, 20260 citations

Practical resources and measurements for lossy optical quantum metrology

Changhun Oh, Su-Yong Lee, Hyunchul Nha +1 more

We study the sensitivity of phase estimation in a lossy Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) using two general, and practical, resources generated by a laser and a nonlinear optical medium with passive optimal elements, which are readily available in the laboratory: One is a two-mode separable coherent and squeezed vacuum state at a beam splitter and the other is a two-mode squeezed vacuum state. In view of the ultimate precision given by quantum Fisher information, we show that the two-mode squeezed vacuum state can achieve a lower bound of estimation error than the coherent and squeezed vacuum state under a photon-loss channel. We further consider practical measurement schemes, homodyne detection and photon number resolving detection (PNRD), to characterize the accuracy of phase estimation in reality and find that the coherent and squeezed vacuum state largely achieves a lower bound than the two-mode squeezed vacuum in the lossy MZI while maintaining quantum enhancement over the shot-noise limit. By comparing homodyne detection and PNRD, we demonstrate that quadrature measurement with homodyne detection is more robust against photon loss than parity measurement with PNRD. We also show that double homodyne detection can provide a better tool for phase estimation than single homodyne detection against photon loss.

arXiv:1707.03210Physical Review ADec 4, 201737 citations

Global Precision Limits in Critical Quantum Metrology: From Cramér-Rao to Ziv-Zakai

Neng Zeng, Tao Liu, Yu-Ran Zhang

Critical quantum metrology with equilibrium states predicts quantum-enhanced sensitivity only in the vicinity of criticality, where large prior information about the parameter is required. By employing quantum Ziv-Zakai bounds, we derive a limit on the mean-square error in critical quantum metrology. For second-order quantum phase transitions, we show that the precision predicted by the Cramér-Rao bound offers no substantial improvement over the prior standard deviation. Thus, the critical quantum sensor's precision can only achieve a constant gain compared to the prior standard deviation, even without performing any measurement. We elucidate the fundamental limitation on the achievable precision in critical quantum metrology in the context of local sensing, even without considering state-preparation costs or noise. Thus, the super-Heisenberg-limited sensitivity at criticality arises from precise prior knowledge rather than a genuine gain due to criticality. Our work provides a practical framework for assessing critical quantum metrology and a routine for studying quantum sensing with many-body systems.

quant-pharXiv:2607.08431Jul 10, 20260 citations