Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2203.11083 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Cutting rules and positivity in finite temperature many-body theory

M J Hyrkäs, D Karlsson, Robert van Leeuwen

Published Jul 11, 2022• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract For a given diagrammatic approximation in many-body perturbation theory it is not guaranteed that positive observables, such as the density or the spectral function, retain their positivity. For zero-temperature systems we developed a method [2014 Phys. Rev. B 90 115134] based on so-called cutting rules for Feynman diagrams that enforces these properties diagrammatically, thus solving the problem of negative spectral densities observed for various vertex approximations. In this work we extend this method to systems at finite temperature by formulating the cutting rules in terms of retarded N -point functions, thereby simplifying earlier approaches and simultaneously solving the issue of non-vanishing vacuum diagrams that has plagued finite temperature expansions. Our approach is moreover valid for nonequilibrium systems in initial equilibrium and allows us to show that important commonly used approximations, namely the GW , second Born and T -matrix approximation, retain positive spectral functions at finite temperature. Finally we derive an analytic continuation relation between the spectral forms of retarded N -point functions and their Matsubara counterparts and a set of Feynman rules to evaluate them.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8121/ac802d

Related papers

Approximate energy functionals for one-body reduced density matrix functional theory from many-body perturbation theory

Klaas J. H. Giesbertz, Anna-Maija Uimonen, Robert van Leeuwen

We develop a systematic approach to construct energy functionals of the one-particle reduced density matrix (1RDM) for equilibrium systems at finite temperature. The starting point of our formulation is the grand potential Ω [ G ] regarded as variational functional of the Green’s function G based on diagrammatic many-body perturbation theory and for which we consider either the Klein or Luttinger–Ward form. By restricting the input Green’s function to be one-to-one related to a set on one-particle reduced density matrices (1RDM) this functional becomes a functional of the 1RDM. To establish the one-to-one mapping we use that, at any finite temperature and for a given 1RDM γ in a finite basis, there exists a non-interacting system with a spatially non-local potential v [ γ ] which reproduces the given 1RDM. The corresponding set of non-interacting Green’s functions defines the variational domain of the functional Ω . In the zero temperature limit we obtain an energy functional E [ γ ] which by minimisation yields an approximate ground state 1RDM and energy. As an application of the formalism we use the Klein and Luttinger–Ward functionals in the GW-approximation to compute the binding curve of a model hydrogen molecule using an extended Hubbard Hamiltonian. We compare further to the case in which we evaluate the functionals on a Hartree–Fock and a Kohn–Sham Green’s function. We find that the Luttinger–Ward version of the functionals performs the best and is able to reproduce energies close to the GW energy which corresponds to the stationary point.

arXiv:1804.09921•The European Physical Journal B•Nov 1, 2018•16 citations

Exact theory of the finite-temperature spectral function of Fermi polarons with multiple particle-hole excitations: diagrammatic theory versus Chevy ansatz

Hui Hu, Jia Wang, Xia-Ji Liu

Abstract By using both diagrammatic theory and Chevy ansatz approach, we derive an exact set of equations, which determines the spectral function of Fermi polarons with multiple particle-hole excitations at nonzero temperature. In the diagrammatic theory, we find out the complete series of Feynman diagrams for the multi-particle vertex functions, when the unregularized contact interaction strength becomes infinitesimal, a typical situation occurring in two- or three-dimensional free space. The latter Chevy ansatz approach is more widely applicable, allowing a nonzero interaction strength. We clarify the equivalence of the two approaches for an infinitesimal interaction strength and show that the variational coefficients in the Chevy ansatz are precisely the on-shell multi-particle vertex functions divided by an excitation energy. Truncated to a particular order of particle-hole excitations, the set of equations can be used to approximately calculate the finite-temperature polaron spectral function, once the numerical singularities in the equations are appropriately treated. As a concrete example, we calculate the finite-temperature spectral function of Fermi polarons in one-dimensional lattices, taking into account all the two-particle-hole excitations. We show that the inclusion of two-particle-hole excitations quantitatively improve the predictions on the polaron spectral function. Our results provide a useful way to solve the challenge problem of accurately predicting the finite-temperature spectral function of Fermi polarons in three-dimensional free space. In addition, our clarification of the complete set of Feynman diagrams for the multi-particle polaron vertex functions may inspire the development of more accurate diagrammatic theories of population-imbalanced strongly interacting Fermi gases, beyond the conventional many-body T-matrix approximation.

arXiv:2403.09064•AAPPS bulletin•Jul 31, 2025•3 citations

Partial self-consistency and analyticity in many-body perturbation theory: Particle number conservation and a generalized sum rule

Daniel Karlsson, Robert van Leeuwen

We consider a general class of approximations which guarantees the conservation of particle number in many-body perturbation theory. To do this we extend the concept of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ derivability for the self-energy $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ to a larger class of diagrammatic terms in which only some of the Green's function lines contain the fully dressed Green's function $G$. We call the corresponding approximations for $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ partially $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ derivable. A special subclass of such approximations, which are gauge invariant, is obtained by dressing loops in the diagrammatic expansion of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ consistently with $G$. These approximations are number conserving but do not have to fulfill other conservation laws, such as the conservation of energy and momentum. From our formalism we can easily deduce whether commonly used approximations will fulfill the continuity equation, which implies particle number conservation. We further show how the concept of partial $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ derivability plays an important role in the derivation of a generalized sum rule for the particle number, which reduces to the Luttinger-Ward theorem in the case of a homogeneous electron gas, and the Friedel sum rule in the case of the Anderson model. To do this we need to ensure that the Green's function has certain complex analytic properties, which can be guaranteed if the spectral function is positive-semidefinite. The latter property can be ensured for a subset of partially $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$-derivable approximations for the self-energy, namely those that can be constructed from squares of so-called half diagrams. For the case in which the analytic requirements are not fulfilled we highlight a number of subtle issues related to branch cuts, pole structure, and multivaluedness. We also show that various schemes of computing the particle number are consistent for particle number conserving approximations.

arXiv:1606.07486•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 13, 2016•14 citations

Positivity of the Spectral Densities of Retarded Floquet Green Functions

Götz Silvester Uhrig, Mona H. Kalthoff, James K. Freericks

Periodically driven nonequilibrium many-body systems are interesting because they have quasi-energy spectra, which can be tailored by controlling the external driving fields. We derive the general spectral representation of retarded Green functions in the Floquet regime, thereby generalizing the well-known Lehmann representation from equilibrium many-body physics. The derived spectral Floquet representation allows us to prove the non-negativity of spectral densities and to determine exact spectral sum rules, which can be employed to benchmark the accuracy of approximations to the exact Floquet many-body Green functions.

arXiv:1808.10199•Physical Review Letters•Apr 5, 2019•32 citations

Feynman Diagrams for Matsubara Green’s Functions

Lev N Kantorovich

Feynman diagrams for one- and two-particle Green’s functions for electron–electron interactions are considered in detail, starting from the interaction representation and Wick’s theorem in the general non-zero-temperature case. It is shown that the perturbation expansion can be written via determinants of increasing order built from non-inetracting Green’s functions. We prove general linked cluster theorem, enabling one to drop the normalising denominator and use only connected diagrams in the expansion of the Green’s function. Next we clearly explain why only topologically equivalent diagrams need to be considered, before formulating general diagrammatic rules for the Green’s function and the self-energy. The ideas of a partial summation via skeleton diagrams and the vertex function are then discussed. Random phase approximation and the grand potential are studied for the uniform system within the jellium model. Finally, a diagrammatic technique for the two-particle Green’s functions is discussed, leading to the kernels and Bethe–Salpeter equation. As an example, the diagrammatic expansion for the dielectric response within the jellium model is developed.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 6, 2026•0 citations

Multipoint Correlation Functions: Spectral Representation and Numerical Evaluation

Fabian B. Kugler, Seung‐Sup B. Lee, Jan von Delft

The many-body problem is usually approached from one of two perspectives: the first originates from an action and is based on Feynman diagrams, the second is centered around a Hamiltonian and deals with quantum states and operators.The connection between results obtained in either way is made through spectral (or Lehmann) representations, well known for two-point correlation functions.Here, we complete this picture by deriving generalized spectral representations for multipoint correlation functions that apply in all of the commonly used many-body frameworks: the imaginary-frequency Matsubara and the realfrequency zero-temperature and Keldysh formalisms.Our approach separates spectral from time-ordering properties and thereby elucidates the relation between the three formalisms.The spectral representations of multipoint correlation functions consist of partial spectral functions and convolution kernels.The former are formalism independent but system specific; the latter are system independent but formalism specific.Using a numerical renormalization group method described in the accompanying paper, we present numerical results for selected quantum impurity models.We focus on the four-point vertex (effective interaction) obtained for the single-impurity Anderson model and for the dynamical mean-field theory solution of the one-band Hubbard model.In the Matsubara formalism, we analyze the evolution of the vertex down to very low temperatures and describe the crossover from strongly interacting particles to weakly interacting quasiparticles.In the Keldysh formalism, we first benchmark our results at weak and infinitely strong interaction and then reveal the rich real-frequency structure of the dynamical mean-field theory vertex in the coexistence regime of a metallic and insulating solution.

arXiv:2101.00707•Physical Review X•Oct 11, 2021•56 citations
Abstract For a given diagrammatic approximation in many-body perturbation theory it is not guaranteed that positive observables, such as the density or the spectral function, retain their positivity. For zero-temperature systems we developed a method [2014 Phys. Rev. B 90 115134] based on so-called cutting rules for Feynman diagrams that enforces these properties diagrammatically, thus solving the problem of negative spectral densities observed for various vertex approximations. In this work we extend this method to systems at finite temperature by formulating the cutting rules in terms of retarded N -point functions, thereby simplifying earlier approaches and simultaneously solving the issue of non-vanishing vacuum diagrams that has plagued finite temperature expansions. Our approach is moreover valid for nonequilibrium systems in initial equilibrium and allows us to show that important commonly used approximations, namely the GW , second Born and T -matrix approximation, retain positive spectral functions at finite temperature. Finally we derive an analytic continuation relation between the spectral forms of retarded N -point functions and their Matsubara counterparts and a set of Feynman rules to evaluate them.
We develop a systematic approach to construct energy functionals of the one-particle reduced density matrix (1RDM) for equilibrium systems at finite temperature. The starting point of our formulation is the grand potential Ω [ G ] regarded as variational functional of the Green’s function G based on diagrammatic many-body perturbation theory and for which we consider either the Klein or Luttinger–Ward form. By restricting the input Green’s function to be one-to-one related to a set on one-particle reduced density matrices (1RDM) this functional becomes a functional of the 1RDM. To establish the one-to-one mapping we use that, at any finite temperature and for a given 1RDM γ in a finite basis, there exists a non-interacting system with a spatially non-local potential v [ γ ] which reproduces the given 1RDM. The corresponding set of non-interacting Green’s functions defines the variational domain of the functional Ω . In the zero temperature limit we obtain an energy functional E [ γ ] which by minimisation yields an approximate ground state 1RDM and energy. As an application of the formalism we use the Klein and Luttinger–Ward functionals in the GW-approximation to compute the binding curve of a model hydrogen molecule using an extended Hubbard Hamiltonian. We compare further to the case in which we evaluate the functionals on a Hartree–Fock and a Kohn–Sham Green’s function. We find that the Luttinger–Ward version of the functionals performs the best and is able to reproduce energies close to the GW energy which corresponds to the stationary point.
Abstract By using both diagrammatic theory and Chevy ansatz approach, we derive an exact set of equations, which determines the spectral function of Fermi polarons with multiple particle-hole excitations at nonzero temperature. In the diagrammatic theory, we find out the complete series of Feynman diagrams for the multi-particle vertex functions, when the unregularized contact interaction strength becomes infinitesimal, a typical situation occurring in two- or three-dimensional free space. The latter Chevy ansatz approach is more widely applicable, allowing a nonzero interaction strength. We clarify the equivalence of the two approaches for an infinitesimal interaction strength and show that the variational coefficients in the Chevy ansatz are precisely the on-shell multi-particle vertex functions divided by an excitation energy. Truncated to a particular order of particle-hole excitations, the set of equations can be used to approximately calculate the finite-temperature polaron spectral function, once the numerical singularities in the equations are appropriately treated. As a concrete example, we calculate the finite-temperature spectral function of Fermi polarons in one-dimensional lattices, taking into account all the two-particle-hole excitations. We show that the inclusion of two-particle-hole excitations quantitatively improve the predictions on the polaron spectral function. Our results provide a useful way to solve the challenge problem of accurately predicting the finite-temperature spectral function of Fermi polarons in three-dimensional free space. In addition, our clarification of the complete set of Feynman diagrams for the multi-particle polaron vertex functions may inspire the development of more accurate diagrammatic theories of population-imbalanced strongly interacting Fermi gases, beyond the conventional many-body T-matrix approximation.
We consider a general class of approximations which guarantees the conservation of particle number in many-body perturbation theory. To do this we extend the concept of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ derivability for the self-energy $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ to a larger class of diagrammatic terms in which only some of the Green's function lines contain the fully dressed Green's function GGG. We call the corresponding approximations for $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ partially $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ derivable. A special subclass of such approximations, which are gauge invariant, is obtained by dressing loops in the diagrammatic expansion of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ consistently with GGG. These approximations are number conserving but do not have to fulfill other conservation laws, such as the conservation of energy and momentum. From our formalism we can easily deduce whether commonly used approximations will fulfill the continuity equation, which implies particle number conservation. We further show how the concept of partial $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ derivability plays an important role in the derivation of a generalized sum rule for the particle number, which reduces to the Luttinger-Ward theorem in the case of a homogeneous electron gas, and the Friedel sum rule in the case of the Anderson model. To do this we need to ensure that the Green's function has certain complex analytic properties, which can be guaranteed if the spectral function is positive-semidefinite. The latter property can be ensured for a subset of partially $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$-derivable approximations for the self-energy, namely those that can be constructed from squares of so-called half diagrams. For the case in which the analytic requirements are not fulfilled we highlight a number of subtle issues related to branch cuts, pole structure, and multivaluedness. We also show that various schemes of computing the particle number are consistent for particle number conserving approximations.
Periodically driven nonequilibrium many-body systems are interesting because they have quasi-energy spectra, which can be tailored by controlling the external driving fields. We derive the general spectral representation of retarded Green functions in the Floquet regime, thereby generalizing the well-known Lehmann representation from equilibrium many-body physics. The derived spectral Floquet representation allows us to prove the non-negativity of spectral densities and to determine exact spectral sum rules, which can be employed to benchmark the accuracy of approximations to the exact Floquet many-body Green functions.
Feynman diagrams for one- and two-particle Green’s functions for electron–electron interactions are considered in detail, starting from the interaction representation and Wick’s theorem in the general non-zero-temperature case. It is shown that the perturbation expansion can be written via determinants of increasing order built from non-inetracting Green’s functions. We prove general linked cluster theorem, enabling one to drop the normalising denominator and use only connected diagrams in the expansion of the Green’s function. Next we clearly explain why only topologically equivalent diagrams need to be considered, before formulating general diagrammatic rules for the Green’s function and the self-energy. The ideas of a partial summation via skeleton diagrams and the vertex function are then discussed. Random phase approximation and the grand potential are studied for the uniform system within the jellium model. Finally, a diagrammatic technique for the two-particle Green’s functions is discussed, leading to the kernels and Bethe–Salpeter equation. As an example, the diagrammatic expansion for the dielectric response within the jellium model is developed.
The many-body problem is usually approached from one of two perspectives: the first originates from an action and is based on Feynman diagrams, the second is centered around a Hamiltonian and deals with quantum states and operators.The connection between results obtained in either way is made through spectral (or Lehmann) representations, well known for two-point correlation functions.Here, we complete this picture by deriving generalized spectral representations for multipoint correlation functions that apply in all of the commonly used many-body frameworks: the imaginary-frequency Matsubara and the realfrequency zero-temperature and Keldysh formalisms.Our approach separates spectral from time-ordering properties and thereby elucidates the relation between the three formalisms.The spectral representations of multipoint correlation functions consist of partial spectral functions and convolution kernels.The former are formalism independent but system specific; the latter are system independent but formalism specific.Using a numerical renormalization group method described in the accompanying paper, we present numerical results for selected quantum impurity models.We focus on the four-point vertex (effective interaction) obtained for the single-impurity Anderson model and for the dynamical mean-field theory solution of the one-band Hubbard model.In the Matsubara formalism, we analyze the evolution of the vertex down to very low temperatures and describe the crossover from strongly interacting particles to weakly interacting quasiparticles.In the Keldysh formalism, we first benchmark our results at weak and infinitely strong interaction and then reveal the rich real-frequency structure of the dynamical mean-field theory vertex in the coexistence regime of a metallic and insulating solution.