Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2203.07263

Logical shadow tomography: Efficient estimation of error-mitigated observables

Hong-Ye Hu, Ryan LaRose, Yi‐Zhuang You, Eleanor Gilbert Rieffel, Wang, Zhihui

Published Mar 14, 2022• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce a technique to estimate error-mitigated expectation values on noisy quantum computers. Our technique performs shadow tomography on a logical state to produce a memory-efficient classical reconstruction of the noisy density matrix. Using efficient classical post-processing, one can mitigate errors by projecting a general nonlinear function of the noisy density matrix into the codespace. The subspace expansion and virtual distillation can be viewed as special cases of the new framekwork. We show our method is favorable in the quantum and classical resources overhead. Relative to subspace expansion which requires $O\left(2^{N} \right)$ samples to estimate a logical Pauli observable with $[[N, k]]$ error correction code, our technique requires only $O\left(4^{k} \right)$ samples. Relative to virtual distillation, our technique can compute powers of the density matrix without additional copies of quantum states or quantum memory. We present numerical evidence using logical states encoded with up to sixty physical qubits and show fast convergence to error-free expectation values with only $10^5$ samples under 1% depolarizing noise.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2203.07263

Related papers

Partial Quantum Shadow Tomography for Structured Operators and its Experimental Demonstration using NMR

Aniket Sengupta, Arijit Chatterjee, G. J. Sreejith +1 more

Quantum shadow tomography based on the classical shadow representation provides an efficient way to estimate properties of an unknown quantum state without performing a full quantum state tomography. In scenarios where estimating the expectation values for only certain classes of observables is required, obtaining information about the entire density matrix is unnecessary. We propose a partial quantum shadow tomography protocol that estimates a subset of density matrix elements relevant to the expectation values of structured observables. Specifically, we identify specific subsets of the tomographically complete set ${\mathrm{Cl}}(2)^{\otimes n}$ and a simple pseudo-inverse of the associated channel, which can be used to estimate all elements of the density matrix with the same active order. By restricting the protocol to smaller subsets of single-qubit Pauli measurements, it becomes experimentally more efficient. We demonstrate the advantage over unitary designs, such as the Clifford, full Pauli basis, and methods utilizing mutually unbiased bases, by analytically deriving error bounds and numerically evaluating the protocol on structured operators. We experimentally demonstrate the partial shadow estimation scheme for a wide class of two-qubit states (pure, entangled, and mixed) in the nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) platform. The full density matrix, reconstructed experimentally by combining different partial estimators, achieves fidelities around 99%.

arXiv:2503.14491•Mar 18, 2025•0 citations

Shadow tomography with noisy readouts

H. Chau Nguyen

Shadow tomography is a scalable technique to characterise the quantum state of a quantum computer or quantum simulator. The protocol is based on the transformation of the outcomes of random measurements into the so-called classical shadows, which can later be transformed into samples of expectation values of the observables of interest. By construction, classical shadows are intrinsically sensitive to readout noise. In fact, the complicated structure of the readout noise due to crosstalk appears to be detrimental to its scalability. We show that classical shadows accept much more flexible constructions beyond the standard ones, which can eventually be made more conformable with readout noise. With this construction, we show that readout errors in classical shadows can be efficiently mitigated by randomly flipping the qubit before, and the classical outcome bit after the measurement, referred to as $X$-twirling. That a single $X$-gate is sufficient for mitigating readout noise for classical shadows is in contrast to Clifford-twirling, where the implementation of random Clifford gates is required.

arXiv:2310.17328•Oct 26, 2023•1 citation

Error mitigated shadow estimation based on virtual distillation

Ruyu Yang, Sun, Xiaoming, Hongyi Zhou

Shadow estimation is a method for deducing numerous properties of an unknown quantum state through a limited set of measurements, which suffers from noises in quantum devices. In this paper, we introduce an error-mitigated shadow estimation approach based on virtual distillation, tailored for applications in near-term quantum devices. Our methodology leverages the qubit reset technique, thereby reducing the associated qubit overhead. Crucially, our approach ensures that the required qubit resources remain independent of the desired accuracy and avoid an exponential measurement overhead, marking a substantial advancement in practical applications. Furthermore, our technique accommodates a mixed Clifford and Pauli-type shadow, which can result in a reduction in the number of required measurements across various scenarios. We also study the trade-off between circuit depth and measurement overhead quantitatively. Through numerical simulations, we substantiate the efficacy of our error mitigation method, establishing its utility in enhancing the robustness of shadow estimations on near-term quantum devices.

arXiv:2402.18829•Feb 29, 2024•0 citations

Quantum Error Mitigated Classical Shadows

Hamza Jnane, Jonathan Steinberg, Zhenyu Cai +2 more

Classical shadows enable us to learn many properties of a quantum state ρ with very few measurements. However, near-term and early fault-tolerant quantum computers will only be able to prepare noisy quantum states ρ and it is thus a considerable challenge to efficiently learn properties of an ideal, noise-free state ρ id . We consider error mitigation techniques, such as probabilistic error cancelation (PEC), zero noise extrapolation (ZNE), and symmetry verification (SV), which have been developed for mitigating errors in single expected value measurements and generalize them for mitigating errors in classical shadows. We find that PEC is the most natural candidate and thus develop a thorough theoretical framework for PEC shadows with the following rigorous theoretical guarantees: PEC shadows are an unbiased estimator for the ideal quantum state ρ id ; the sample complexity for simultaneously predicting many linear properties of ρ id is identical to that of the conventional shadows approach up to a multiplicative factor, which is the sample overhead due to error mitigation. Due to efficient postprocessing of shadows, this overhead does not depend directly on the number of qubits but rather grows exponentially with the number of noisy gates. The broad set of tools introduced in this work may be instrumental in exploiting near-term and early fault-tolerant quantum computers: we demonstrate in detailed numerical simulations a range of practical applications of quantum computers that will significantly benefit from our techniques. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2305.04956•PRX Quantum•Feb 9, 2024•37 citations

Triply Efficient Shadow Tomography

Robbie King, David Gosset, Robin Kothari +1 more

We investigate the problem of efficiently estimating expectation values of large sets of observables from copies of an unknown many-body quantum state. This task, known as shadow tomography, is crucial for quantum simulation and quantum chemistry, where the relevant observables often include k -body fermionic or k -local Pauli operators. A key goal is to achieve sample efficiency, computational efficiency, and few-copy measurements. We introduce the notion of triply efficient shadow tomography to formalize these requirements. Prior work has shown that single-copy measurements suffice for k -local Pauli operators with constant k . However, we prove that for k -body fermionic observables and the full set of n -qubit Pauli operators, single-copy protocols fail to achieve sample-efficient tomography. We then present new protocols based on measuring two copies of the state at a time that overcome these lower bounds, providing a triply efficient protocol.

arXiv:2404.19211•PRX Quantum•Feb 27, 2025•23 citations

A computationally efficient approach to quantum state reconstruction using robust classical shadows

Sanjay Sharma, Shyam Akashe, Govind Murari Upadhyay +1 more

Quantum state tomography is a fundamental technique for characterizing quantum systems, but its scalability remains a significant challenge. This paper investigates an efficient alternative using classical shadows to reconstruct a Bell state with high fidelity. Classical shadows provide a compressed representation of a quantum state using randomized measurements, reducing the measurement complexity compared to full quantum tomography when full state reconstruction is not required. We employed a quantum circuit to generate a Bell state and utilize 1000 snapshots to construct its classical shadow. The reconstructed density matrix is evaluated using fidelity and norm difference metrics against the ideal Bell state. Our analysis demonstrates that as the number of snapshots increases, the fidelity of reconstruction stabilizes around 0.98-1.0, with the norm difference decreasing accordingly. The results also confirm the convergence of reconstructed states towards the ideal Bell state, highlighting the efficiency and accuracy of classical shadows in quantum state estimation. Shallow shadow tomography uses shallow random circuits to estimate global quantum state properties on noisy hardware. By combining low-depth entangling gates with randomized measurements and noise-aware postprocessing, it reduces sample complexity compared to Pauli shadows while remaining experimentally feasible. Recent experiments on superconducting processors confirmed up to fivefold measurement savings.

Scientific Reports•Feb 2, 2026•0 citations
We introduce a technique to estimate error-mitigated expectation values on noisy quantum computers. Our technique performs shadow tomography on a logical state to produce a memory-efficient classical reconstruction of the noisy density matrix. Using efficient classical post-processing, one can mitigate errors by projecting a general nonlinear function of the noisy density matrix into the codespace. The subspace expansion and virtual distillation can be viewed as special cases of the new framekwork. We show our method is favorable in the quantum and classical resources overhead. Relative to subspace expansion which requires O(2N)O\left(2^{N} \right)O(2N) samples to estimate a logical Pauli observable with [[N,k]][[N, k]][[N,k]] error correction code, our technique requires only O(4k)O\left(4^{k} \right)O(4k) samples. Relative to virtual distillation, our technique can compute powers of the density matrix without additional copies of quantum states or quantum memory. We present numerical evidence using logical states encoded with up to sixty physical qubits and show fast convergence to error-free expectation values with only 10510^5105 samples under 1% depolarizing noise.
Quantum shadow tomography based on the classical shadow representation provides an efficient way to estimate properties of an unknown quantum state without performing a full quantum state tomography. In scenarios where estimating the expectation values for only certain classes of observables is required, obtaining information about the entire density matrix is unnecessary. We propose a partial quantum shadow tomography protocol that estimates a subset of density matrix elements relevant to the expectation values of structured observables. Specifically, we identify specific subsets of the tomographically complete set Cl(2)⊗n{\mathrm{Cl}}(2)^{\otimes n}Cl(2)⊗n and a simple pseudo-inverse of the associated channel, which can be used to estimate all elements of the density matrix with the same active order. By restricting the protocol to smaller subsets of single-qubit Pauli measurements, it becomes experimentally more efficient. We demonstrate the advantage over unitary designs, such as the Clifford, full Pauli basis, and methods utilizing mutually unbiased bases, by analytically deriving error bounds and numerically evaluating the protocol on structured operators. We experimentally demonstrate the partial shadow estimation scheme for a wide class of two-qubit states (pure, entangled, and mixed) in the nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) platform. The full density matrix, reconstructed experimentally by combining different partial estimators, achieves fidelities around 99%.
Shadow tomography is a scalable technique to characterise the quantum state of a quantum computer or quantum simulator. The protocol is based on the transformation of the outcomes of random measurements into the so-called classical shadows, which can later be transformed into samples of expectation values of the observables of interest. By construction, classical shadows are intrinsically sensitive to readout noise. In fact, the complicated structure of the readout noise due to crosstalk appears to be detrimental to its scalability. We show that classical shadows accept much more flexible constructions beyond the standard ones, which can eventually be made more conformable with readout noise. With this construction, we show that readout errors in classical shadows can be efficiently mitigated by randomly flipping the qubit before, and the classical outcome bit after the measurement, referred to as XXX-twirling. That a single XXX-gate is sufficient for mitigating readout noise for classical shadows is in contrast to Clifford-twirling, where the implementation of random Clifford gates is required.
Shadow estimation is a method for deducing numerous properties of an unknown quantum state through a limited set of measurements, which suffers from noises in quantum devices. In this paper, we introduce an error-mitigated shadow estimation approach based on virtual distillation, tailored for applications in near-term quantum devices. Our methodology leverages the qubit reset technique, thereby reducing the associated qubit overhead. Crucially, our approach ensures that the required qubit resources remain independent of the desired accuracy and avoid an exponential measurement overhead, marking a substantial advancement in practical applications. Furthermore, our technique accommodates a mixed Clifford and Pauli-type shadow, which can result in a reduction in the number of required measurements across various scenarios. We also study the trade-off between circuit depth and measurement overhead quantitatively. Through numerical simulations, we substantiate the efficacy of our error mitigation method, establishing its utility in enhancing the robustness of shadow estimations on near-term quantum devices.
Classical shadows enable us to learn many properties of a quantum state ρ with very few measurements. However, near-term and early fault-tolerant quantum computers will only be able to prepare noisy quantum states ρ and it is thus a considerable challenge to efficiently learn properties of an ideal, noise-free state ρ id . We consider error mitigation techniques, such as probabilistic error cancelation (PEC), zero noise extrapolation (ZNE), and symmetry verification (SV), which have been developed for mitigating errors in single expected value measurements and generalize them for mitigating errors in classical shadows. We find that PEC is the most natural candidate and thus develop a thorough theoretical framework for PEC shadows with the following rigorous theoretical guarantees: PEC shadows are an unbiased estimator for the ideal quantum state ρ id ; the sample complexity for simultaneously predicting many linear properties of ρ id is identical to that of the conventional shadows approach up to a multiplicative factor, which is the sample overhead due to error mitigation. Due to efficient postprocessing of shadows, this overhead does not depend directly on the number of qubits but rather grows exponentially with the number of noisy gates. The broad set of tools introduced in this work may be instrumental in exploiting near-term and early fault-tolerant quantum computers: we demonstrate in detailed numerical simulations a range of practical applications of quantum computers that will significantly benefit from our techniques. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We investigate the problem of efficiently estimating expectation values of large sets of observables from copies of an unknown many-body quantum state. This task, known as shadow tomography, is crucial for quantum simulation and quantum chemistry, where the relevant observables often include k -body fermionic or k -local Pauli operators. A key goal is to achieve sample efficiency, computational efficiency, and few-copy measurements. We introduce the notion of triply efficient shadow tomography to formalize these requirements. Prior work has shown that single-copy measurements suffice for k -local Pauli operators with constant k . However, we prove that for k -body fermionic observables and the full set of n -qubit Pauli operators, single-copy protocols fail to achieve sample-efficient tomography. We then present new protocols based on measuring two copies of the state at a time that overcome these lower bounds, providing a triply efficient protocol.
Quantum state tomography is a fundamental technique for characterizing quantum systems, but its scalability remains a significant challenge. This paper investigates an efficient alternative using classical shadows to reconstruct a Bell state with high fidelity. Classical shadows provide a compressed representation of a quantum state using randomized measurements, reducing the measurement complexity compared to full quantum tomography when full state reconstruction is not required. We employed a quantum circuit to generate a Bell state and utilize 1000 snapshots to construct its classical shadow. The reconstructed density matrix is evaluated using fidelity and norm difference metrics against the ideal Bell state. Our analysis demonstrates that as the number of snapshots increases, the fidelity of reconstruction stabilizes around 0.98-1.0, with the norm difference decreasing accordingly. The results also confirm the convergence of reconstructed states towards the ideal Bell state, highlighting the efficiency and accuracy of classical shadows in quantum state estimation. Shallow shadow tomography uses shallow random circuits to estimate global quantum state properties on noisy hardware. By combining low-depth entangling gates with randomized measurements and noise-aware postprocessing, it reduces sample complexity compared to Pauli shadows while remaining experimentally feasible. Recent experiments on superconducting processors confirmed up to fivefold measurement savings.