Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2202.05532

Comment on "Self-Consistent-Field Method for Correlated Many-Electron Systems with an Entropic Cumulant Energy"

Lexin Ding, Julia Liebert, Christian Schilling

Published Feb 11, 2022• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In [Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001 (2022)] a novel ground state method was proposed. It has been suggested that this $i$-DMFT would be a method within one-particle reduced density matrix functional theory (DMFT), capable of describing accurately molecules at various geometries with an information-theoretical nature. We reassess this work and its suggestions from a conceptual and practical point of view, leading to the following conclusions: i) A method which assigns to each molecule $\mathcal{M}$ its own functional $\mathcal{F}_{\!\mathcal{M}}$ is not a functional theory (striking violation of "universality") ii) even for the simplest systems $i$-DMFT yields incorrect one-particle reduced density matrices and iii) the use of an information-theoretical concept to describe molecular dissociation limits was not essential. The latter insight may help to fix the deficiency of $i$-DMFT to not reproduce correctly the smaller occupation numbers and thus to not recover the important dynamic correlations.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2202.05532

Related papers

Reply to Comment on "Self-Consistent-Field Method for Correlated Many-Electron Systems with an Entropic Cumulant Energy", arXiv2202.05532v1

Jian Wang, Evert Jan Baerends

Recently we proposed an information entropy based method for electronic structure calculations within the density-matrix functional theory(DMFT) (Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001), dubbed as $i$-DMFT. Comments have been raised regarding the accuracy of the one-particle density-matrix compared to that from the wave function, and the universality of the functional. We address these questions and the problematic case of HeH$^+$.

arXiv:2207.02616•Jul 6, 2022•2 citations

Self-consistent-field method for correlation calculation within density-matrix-functional theory

Marinela Irimia, Yu Wang, Yifan Fei +1 more

The self-consistent-field method proposed recently [Wang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001 (2022)] is discussed in more detail. The method leads to self-consistent eigenvalue equations for the natural spin orbitals and Fermi-Dirac distribution for the orbital occupation numbers. The entropic functional contains two parameters ($\ensuremath{\kappa}$ and $b$), which can be fitted to various experimental or theoretical data such as the dissociation energy, entropy, and total energy at a given geometry, etc. Calculations are demonstrated on the square ${\mathrm{H}}_{4}$ and hydrogen chains of ${\mathrm{H}}_{50}$, which are representative cases of degenerate or nondynamically correlated systems.

Physical Review A•Nov 17, 2023•11 citations

Capturing electron correlation at mean-field cost: Assessment of i-DMFT and the underlying correlation conjecture

Paul G. Graf, Florian Matz, Lexin Ding +3 more

Accurately treating strong electron correlation in quantum chemistry typically requires multireference wave-function methods with steep computational scaling. The recently proposed i-DMFT method promises near configuration-interaction accuracy at mean-field cost by invoking an empirical linear relation between correlation energy and entropy (Collins' conjecture), whose validity remains unclear. We systematically assess this relation across a range of di- and polyatomic molecules, including diverse bond types, third-row elements, different types of geometric distortions, and excited states. We find that the conjectured linearity holds for bond-breaking processes dominated by electron redistribution within orbital pairs, but breaks down for heterolytic dissociation and excited states. In simple molecules, i-DMFT provides a reasonable description of total energies, but does not reliably reproduce reduced density matrices or individual energy components. It further degrades in more complex cases such as ethylene. Based on these results, we formulate criteria for the validity of the conjecture and outline implications for entropy-based reduced density matrix functionals.

physics.chem-phCross-listedarXiv:2604.19804•Apr 14, 2026

Unbiased evaluation and development of Green's-function-based density-matrix functionals

Ebad Kamil

Ab-initio calculations are dominated by density functional theory (DFT), which provides an efficient and accurate description of the electronic structure for most materials. For materials with strong correlations, however, many of the available density functionals yield poor results. Most well known is the case of transition metal oxides, for which most density functionals produce a qualitatively incorrect description. There is a quest to improve the description by borrowing from methods specifically designed for strongly correlated materials. One of the method which is widely used to study strongly correlated electron system in the thermodynamic limit is the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). For calculations pertaining to real materials, hybrid approaches like DFT+DMFT are commonly used. We consider reduced density-matrix functional theory (rDMFT) to be a useful framework for a rigorous formulation of such hybrid theories. The link from rDMFT to many-particle wave functions has been established by Levy's constrained-search algorithm on the one hand. The link to many-body perturbation theory and Green's function, on the other hand, has been provided via the Luttinger-Ward functional. The development in the field of rDMFT proceeded analogously to the development of DFT. In order to avoid the full complexity of an explicit many-body description, most density-matrix functionals are not extracted from the exact expressions i.e. via Levy's constrained-search or Green's function based methods . Rather, one proceeds analogously to the development of density functionals, namely by searching models for the density-matrix functional, that capture the most essential physical effects while having an algebraic dependence on the density matrix. Among such models, the most prominent ones are the Müller functional, Sharma functional and Marques-Lathiotakis functional. One of the major arguments in favor of density-matrix functionals is that one of the most simple functionals, the Müller functional, seems to provide a correct description of the bond-dissociation problem, for which common density functionals fail. Despite the successes, the common density-matrix functionals also reproduce a number of features in a qualitatively incorrect manner. Several such discrepancies of the standard state of the art density-matrix functionals are discussed in details in this thesis. The objective of this thesis is to study the performance of the class of commonly used model density-matrix functionals and to set the stage for the desire to develop the framework for an approximate scheme to evaluate new class of functionals from exact Green's function based method.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Putting a Temperature on Electron Correlation

Paul G. Graf, Florian Matz, Markus Penz +1 more

It is common wisdom that a better understanding of how to quantify electron correlation should lead to more efficient treatments of the correlation problem. Here, we not only substantiate this view but turn it into a concrete, systematic framework for ground states. Since prominent correlation measures such as the nonfreeness depend only on the one-particle reduced density matrix, modeling the correlation energy as a function of such a measure naturally places the framework within reduced density matrix functional theory, while keeping the cost at mean-field level. Strikingly, the variable conjugate to the measure emerges as a ``correlation temperature'', thereby connecting correlation measures, functional theory, and effective temperatures. The framework rationalizes methods such as i-DMFT, and we illustrate its key concepts analytically for the Hubbard dimer and numerically for small molecular systems. This brings a fundamental question within reach: how much of the correlation problem can be solved at mean-field cost?

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2610.22134•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations

Finite-temperature adiabatic-connection reduced density-matrix functional theory: a unified framework for i-DMFT and TAO-DFT

Jingang Han, Huanjing Gong, Kai Luo +2 more

Accurately describing chemical bond breaking requires capturing strong/static electron correlation, a major challenge for single-reference self-consistent-field methods such as Hartree--Fock and Kohn--Sham density-functional theory (DFT). Fractional occupations substantially improve this situation, as demonstrated by information-density-matrix-functional theory (i-DMFT) and thermally-assisted-occupation DFT (TAO-DFT). Although useful, they are formulated within rather different theoretical frameworks, are somewhat semi-empirical, and their relationship remains unclear. Here we introduce finite-temperature adiabatic-connection reduced density-matrix functional theory (FT-AC-RDMFT), in which i-DMFT and TAO-DFT emerge as different reductions of a unified framework. The effective eigenvalue equation for natural orbitals and the Fermi--Dirac occupation numbers follow directly from the variational principle, while a thermal adiabatic connection relates the empirical entropy coefficient of i-DMFT to a characteristic temperature of the auxiliary non-interacting system. Within this framework, i-DMFT is the exact-exchange-based reduction, whereas TAO-DFT results when exact exchange is replaced by a density-based exchange-correlation functional. Numerical calculations confirm that i-DMFT, apart from a constant, coincides with the exact-exchange realization of the framework, and show that the improved dissociation behavior from finite-temperature occupations extends beyond exact exchange to hybrid and semilocal density functionals. For strongly correlated V2O3, finite-temperature occupations substantially reduce the severely overestimated non-magnetic LDA bulk modulus, bringing it close to experiment. These results establish FT-AC-RDMFT as a common theoretical foundation for finite-temperature occupation-based electronic-structure methods in molecular and solid-state systems.

arXiv:2610.14706•Oct 10, 2026•0 citations
In [Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001 (2022)] a novel ground state method was proposed. It has been suggested that this iii-DMFT would be a method within one-particle reduced density matrix functional theory (DMFT), capable of describing accurately molecules at various geometries with an information-theoretical nature. We reassess this work and its suggestions from a conceptual and practical point of view, leading to the following conclusions: i) A method which assigns to each molecule M\mathcal{M}M its own functional F ⁣M\mathcal{F}_{\!\mathcal{M}}FM​ is not a functional theory (striking violation of "universality") ii) even for the simplest systems iii-DMFT yields incorrect one-particle reduced density matrices and iii) the use of an information-theoretical concept to describe molecular dissociation limits was not essential. The latter insight may help to fix the deficiency of iii-DMFT to not reproduce correctly the smaller occupation numbers and thus to not recover the important dynamic correlations.
Recently we proposed an information entropy based method for electronic structure calculations within the density-matrix functional theory(DMFT) (Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001), dubbed as iii-DMFT. Comments have been raised regarding the accuracy of the one-particle density-matrix compared to that from the wave function, and the universality of the functional. We address these questions and the problematic case of HeH+^++.
The self-consistent-field method proposed recently [Wang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001 (2022)] is discussed in more detail. The method leads to self-consistent eigenvalue equations for the natural spin orbitals and Fermi-Dirac distribution for the orbital occupation numbers. The entropic functional contains two parameters ($\ensuremath{\kappa}$ and bbb), which can be fitted to various experimental or theoretical data such as the dissociation energy, entropy, and total energy at a given geometry, etc. Calculations are demonstrated on the square H4{\mathrm{H}}_{4}H4​ and hydrogen chains of H50{\mathrm{H}}_{50}H50​, which are representative cases of degenerate or nondynamically correlated systems.
Accurately treating strong electron correlation in quantum chemistry typically requires multireference wave-function methods with steep computational scaling. The recently proposed i-DMFT method promises near configuration-interaction accuracy at mean-field cost by invoking an empirical linear relation between correlation energy and entropy (Collins' conjecture), whose validity remains unclear. We systematically assess this relation across a range of di- and polyatomic molecules, including diverse bond types, third-row elements, different types of geometric distortions, and excited states. We find that the conjectured linearity holds for bond-breaking processes dominated by electron redistribution within orbital pairs, but breaks down for heterolytic dissociation and excited states. In simple molecules, i-DMFT provides a reasonable description of total energies, but does not reliably reproduce reduced density matrices or individual energy components. It further degrades in more complex cases such as ethylene. Based on these results, we formulate criteria for the validity of the conjecture and outline implications for entropy-based reduced density matrix functionals.
Ab-initio calculations are dominated by density functional theory (DFT), which provides an efficient and accurate description of the electronic structure for most materials. For materials with strong correlations, however, many of the available density functionals yield poor results. Most well known is the case of transition metal oxides, for which most density functionals produce a qualitatively incorrect description. There is a quest to improve the description by borrowing from methods specifically designed for strongly correlated materials. One of the method which is widely used to study strongly correlated electron system in the thermodynamic limit is the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). For calculations pertaining to real materials, hybrid approaches like DFT+DMFT are commonly used. We consider reduced density-matrix functional theory (rDMFT) to be a useful framework for a rigorous formulation of such hybrid theories. The link from rDMFT to many-particle wave functions has been established by Levy's constrained-search algorithm on the one hand. The link to many-body perturbation theory and Green's function, on the other hand, has been provided via the Luttinger-Ward functional. The development in the field of rDMFT proceeded analogously to the development of DFT. In order to avoid the full complexity of an explicit many-body description, most density-matrix functionals are not extracted from the exact expressions i.e. via Levy's constrained-search or Green's function based methods . Rather, one proceeds analogously to the development of density functionals, namely by searching models for the density-matrix functional, that capture the most essential physical effects while having an algebraic dependence on the density matrix. Among such models, the most prominent ones are the Müller functional, Sharma functional and Marques-Lathiotakis functional. One of the major arguments in favor of density-matrix functionals is that one of the most simple functionals, the Müller functional, seems to provide a correct description of the bond-dissociation problem, for which common density functionals fail. Despite the successes, the common density-matrix functionals also reproduce a number of features in a qualitatively incorrect manner. Several such discrepancies of the standard state of the art density-matrix functionals are discussed in details in this thesis. The objective of this thesis is to study the performance of the class of commonly used model density-matrix functionals and to set the stage for the desire to develop the framework for an approximate scheme to evaluate new class of functionals from exact Green's function based method.
It is common wisdom that a better understanding of how to quantify electron correlation should lead to more efficient treatments of the correlation problem. Here, we not only substantiate this view but turn it into a concrete, systematic framework for ground states. Since prominent correlation measures such as the nonfreeness depend only on the one-particle reduced density matrix, modeling the correlation energy as a function of such a measure naturally places the framework within reduced density matrix functional theory, while keeping the cost at mean-field level. Strikingly, the variable conjugate to the measure emerges as a ``correlation temperature'', thereby connecting correlation measures, functional theory, and effective temperatures. The framework rationalizes methods such as i-DMFT, and we illustrate its key concepts analytically for the Hubbard dimer and numerically for small molecular systems. This brings a fundamental question within reach: how much of the correlation problem can be solved at mean-field cost?
Accurately describing chemical bond breaking requires capturing strong/static electron correlation, a major challenge for single-reference self-consistent-field methods such as Hartree--Fock and Kohn--Sham density-functional theory (DFT). Fractional occupations substantially improve this situation, as demonstrated by information-density-matrix-functional theory (i-DMFT) and thermally-assisted-occupation DFT (TAO-DFT). Although useful, they are formulated within rather different theoretical frameworks, are somewhat semi-empirical, and their relationship remains unclear. Here we introduce finite-temperature adiabatic-connection reduced density-matrix functional theory (FT-AC-RDMFT), in which i-DMFT and TAO-DFT emerge as different reductions of a unified framework. The effective eigenvalue equation for natural orbitals and the Fermi--Dirac occupation numbers follow directly from the variational principle, while a thermal adiabatic connection relates the empirical entropy coefficient of i-DMFT to a characteristic temperature of the auxiliary non-interacting system. Within this framework, i-DMFT is the exact-exchange-based reduction, whereas TAO-DFT results when exact exchange is replaced by a density-based exchange-correlation functional. Numerical calculations confirm that i-DMFT, apart from a constant, coincides with the exact-exchange realization of the framework, and show that the improved dissociation behavior from finite-temperature occupations extends beyond exact exchange to hybrid and semilocal density functionals. For strongly correlated V2O3, finite-temperature occupations substantially reduce the severely overestimated non-magnetic LDA bulk modulus, bringing it close to experiment. These results establish FT-AC-RDMFT as a common theoretical foundation for finite-temperature occupation-based electronic-structure methods in molecular and solid-state systems.