© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:2201.01568 · Photonics

Stability of the Discrete Time-Crystalline Order in Spin-Optomechanical and Open Cavity QED Systems

Zheng-Da Hu, Xingyu Gao, Tongcang Li

Published Jan 24, 2022• 1 citation

Abstract

Discrete time crystals (DTC) have been demonstrated experimentally in several different quantum systems in the past few years. Spin couplings and cavity losses have been shown to play crucial roles for realizing DTC order in open many-body systems out of equilibrium. Recently, it has been proposed that eternal and transient DTC can be present with an open Floquet setup in the thermodynamic limit and in the deep quantum regime with few qubits, respectively. In this work, we consider the effects of spin damping and spin dephasing on the DTC order in spin-optomechanical and open cavity systems in which the spins can be all-to-all coupled. In the thermodynamic limit, it is shown that the existence of dephasing can destroy the coherence of the system and finally lead the system to its trivial steady state. Without dephasing, eternal DTC is displayed in the weak damping regime, which may be destroyed by increasing the all-to-all spin coupling or the spin damping. By contrast, the all-to-all coupling is constructive to the DTC in the moderate damping regime. We also focus on a model which can be experimentally realized by a suspended hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) membrane with a few spin color centers under microwave drive and Floquet magnetic field. Signatures of transient DTC behavior are demonstrated in both weak and moderate dissipation regimes without spin dephasing. Relevant experimental parameters are also discussed for realizing transient DTC order in such an hBN optomechanical system.

DOI: 10.3390/photonics9020061

Related papers

Discrete Time-Crystalline Order in Cavity and Circuit QED Systems

Zongping Gong, Ryusuke Hamazaki, Masahito Ueda

Discrete time crystals are a recently proposed and experimentally observed out-of-equilibrium dynamical phase of Floquet systems, where the stroboscopic dynamics of a local observable repeats itself at an integer multiple of the driving period. We address this issue in a driven-dissipative setup, focusing on the modulated open Dicke model, which can be implemented by cavity or circuit QED systems. In the thermodynamic limit, we employ semiclassical approaches and find rich dynamical phases on top of the discrete time-crystalline order. In a deep quantum regime with few qubits, we find clear signatures of a transient discrete time-crystalline behavior, which is absent in the isolated counterpart. We establish a phenomenology of dissipative discrete time crystals by generalizing the Landau theory of phase transitions to Floquet open systems.

arXiv:1708.01472•Physical Review Letters•Jan 25, 2018•240 citations

Dissipative discrete time crystals

James O’Sullivan, Oliver Lunt, Christoph W. Zollitsch +3 more

Periodically driven quantum systems host a range of non-equilibrium phenomena which are unrealizable at equilibrium. Discrete time-translational symmetry in a periodically driven many-body system can be spontaneously broken to form a discrete time crystal, a putative quantum phase of matter. We present the observation of discrete time crystalline order in a driven system of paramagnetic $P$ -donor impurities in isotopically enriched $^{28}Si$ cooled below $10$ K. The observations exhibit a stable subharmonic peak at half the drive frequency which remains pinned even in the presence of pulse error, a signature of DTC order. We propose a theoretical model based on the paradigmatic central spin model which is in good agreement with experimental observations, and investigate the role of dissipation in the stabilisation of the DTC. Both experiment and theory indicate that the order in this system is primarily a dissipative effect, and which persists in the presence of spin-spin interactions. We present a theoretical phase diagram as a function of interactions and dissipation for the central spin model which is consistent with the experiments. This opens up questions about the interplay of coherent interaction and dissipation for time-translation symmetry breaking in many-body Floquet systems.

arXiv:1807.09884•Jul 25, 2018•13 citations

Fate of Discrete Time Crystals in Finite-Size Cavity QED Systems

Haimi Nguyen, David R. Reichman

It has been shown that Discrete Time Crystal (DTC) behavior may arise in the periodically driven, open Dicke model in the thermodynamic limit ($N \rightarrow \infty$). In this work, we demonstrate that finite $N$ non-mean-field fluctuations in this model can lead to decay rates and amplitudes of transient DTCs that display a non-trivial non-monotonic behavior with an increasing number of atoms. We show that the second-order cumulant expansion fails to capture the finite-size dynamics, while a stochastic version of the Truncated Wigner Approximation (TWA) is remarkably accurate, particularly in the large atom ensemble limit. Using the TWA and the Monte Carlo Wave Function (MCWF) approach, we identify three distinct dynamical regimes of transient DTC behavior in the finite-size Dicke model. We outline the mechanism behind the non-monotonic finite size dynamical decay of DTC order and discuss the implications for experiments performed on finite-sized atomic assemblies.

quant-pharXiv:2610.27589•Oct 21, 2026•0 citations

Dephasing-induced growth of discrete time-crystalline order in spin networks

Akitada Sakurai, V. M. Bastidas, Marta P. Estarellas +2 more

A discrete time crystal (DTC) is a quantum phase of matter related to the symmetries of a periodically driven system. It can appear when the initial state breaks these symmetries, and hence the observation of DTCs is intimately related to the symmetry of the initial state. In this paper, we investigate a nontrivial situation in which two interacting regions are simultaneously prepared in two initial states that preserve and break this symmetry. Specifically, we discuss the behavior of such a system under the influence of an environment by extending Floquet theory to the Liouvillian dynamics. Our analysis shows that the entire system evolves toward a DTC phase and is stabilized by the effect of dephasing. Our results provide a new understanding of quantum phases emerging from the competition between the coherent and incoherent dynamics in dissipative nonequilibrium quantum systems.

arXiv:2106.02765•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 20, 2021•3 citations

Discrete time crystal in periodically driven quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model

Anonymous, Arti Garg

Discrete time crystals (DTC) have emerged as a significant phase of matter for out-of-equilibrium many-body systems. In this work, we study how random long-range interactions contribute to the stability of the DTC phase. Generally, a stable DTC phase is believed to be realized in disordered systems with short-range interactions. Here, we explore a periodically driven quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) model of Ising spin-glass in which all spins are coupled to each other randomly. We investigate the possibilities of the DTC phase in the SK model within three different driving protocols and found that the quantum SK model exhibits a robust DTC phase, although systems with uniform long-range interactions can exhibit only prethermal DTC phase. Further, we demonstrate that disorder in the local $XY$ term or transverse field is crucial for stabilizing a broad DTC phase, despite random couplings in the SK model. Our analysis shows that the stability of the DTC phase is determined by the non-ergodic nature of the Floquet eigenstates.

arXiv:2504.19378•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 22, 2026•0 citations

Observation of time-crystalline eigenstate order on a quantum processor

Xiao Mi

We report on the first experimental observation of a non-equilibrium phase of matter, the discrete time crystal (DTC). A DTC breaks time-translational symmetry and displays spatio-temporal quantum order in all of its eigenstates, a feature dubbed “eigenstate order”. We implement Floquet dynamics on a 1D chain of 20 superconducting qubits [2]. Engineered disorders in the two-qubit couplings allow many-body localization (MBL) to occur despite strong external drive, thereby stabilizing the non-equilibrium phase [3]. We carefully validate the phase structure of the DTC by probing the average response of all eigenstates belonging to the Floquet unitary. Using a suitable choice of order parameter, we further identify the location of the MBL-ergodicity crossover via experimentally observed finite-size effects. These results open a direct path to studying quantum phase transitions and critical phenomena on NISQ quantum processors.

Quantum Computing, Communication, and Simulation•Mar 9, 2022•17 citations

Discrete time crystals (DTC) have been demonstrated experimentally in several different quantum systems in the past few years. Spin couplings and cavity losses have been shown to play crucial roles for realizing DTC order in open many-body systems out of equilibrium. Recently, it has been proposed that eternal and transient DTC can be present with an open Floquet setup in the thermodynamic limit and in the deep quantum regime with few qubits, respectively. In this work, we consider the effects of spin damping and spin dephasing on the DTC order in spin-optomechanical and open cavity systems in which the spins can be all-to-all coupled. In the thermodynamic limit, it is shown that the existence of dephasing can destroy the coherence of the system and finally lead the system to its trivial steady state. Without dephasing, eternal DTC is displayed in the weak damping regime, which may be destroyed by increasing the all-to-all spin coupling or the spin damping. By contrast, the all-to-all coupling is constructive to the DTC in the moderate damping regime. We also focus on a model which can be experimentally realized by a suspended hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) membrane with a few spin color centers under microwave drive and Floquet magnetic field. Signatures of transient DTC behavior are demonstrated in both weak and moderate dissipation regimes without spin dephasing. Relevant experimental parameters are also discussed for realizing transient DTC order in such an hBN optomechanical system.

Discrete time crystals are a recently proposed and experimentally observed out-of-equilibrium dynamical phase of Floquet systems, where the stroboscopic dynamics of a local observable repeats itself at an integer multiple of the driving period. We address this issue in a driven-dissipative setup, focusing on the modulated open Dicke model, which can be implemented by cavity or circuit QED systems. In the thermodynamic limit, we employ semiclassical approaches and find rich dynamical phases on top of the discrete time-crystalline order. In a deep quantum regime with few qubits, we find clear signatures of a transient discrete time-crystalline behavior, which is absent in the isolated counterpart. We establish a phenomenology of dissipative discrete time crystals by generalizing the Landau theory of phase transitions to Floquet open systems.

Periodically driven quantum systems host a range of non-equilibrium phenomena which are unrealizable at equilibrium. Discrete time-translational symmetry in a periodically driven many-body system can be spontaneously broken to form a discrete time crystal, a putative quantum phase of matter. We present the observation of discrete time crystalline order in a driven system of paramagnetic

P

-donor impurities in isotopically enriched

^{28}Si

cooled below

10

K. The observations exhibit a stable subharmonic peak at half the drive frequency which remains pinned even in the presence of pulse error, a signature of DTC order. We propose a theoretical model based on the paradigmatic central spin model which is in good agreement with experimental observations, and investigate the role of dissipation in the stabilisation of the DTC. Both experiment and theory indicate that the order in this system is primarily a dissipative effect, and which persists in the presence of spin-spin interactions. We present a theoretical phase diagram as a function of interactions and dissipation for the central spin model which is consistent with the experiments. This opens up questions about the interplay of coherent interaction and dissipation for time-translation symmetry breaking in many-body Floquet systems.

It has been shown that Discrete Time Crystal (DTC) behavior may arise in the periodically driven, open Dicke model in the thermodynamic limit (

N \rightarrow \infty

). In this work, we demonstrate that finite

N

non-mean-field fluctuations in this model can lead to decay rates and amplitudes of transient DTCs that display a non-trivial non-monotonic behavior with an increasing number of atoms. We show that the second-order cumulant expansion fails to capture the finite-size dynamics, while a stochastic version of the Truncated Wigner Approximation (TWA) is remarkably accurate, particularly in the large atom ensemble limit. Using the TWA and the Monte Carlo Wave Function (MCWF) approach, we identify three distinct dynamical regimes of transient DTC behavior in the finite-size Dicke model. We outline the mechanism behind the non-monotonic finite size dynamical decay of DTC order and discuss the implications for experiments performed on finite-sized atomic assemblies.

A discrete time crystal (DTC) is a quantum phase of matter related to the symmetries of a periodically driven system. It can appear when the initial state breaks these symmetries, and hence the observation of DTCs is intimately related to the symmetry of the initial state. In this paper, we investigate a nontrivial situation in which two interacting regions are simultaneously prepared in two initial states that preserve and break this symmetry. Specifically, we discuss the behavior of such a system under the influence of an environment by extending Floquet theory to the Liouvillian dynamics. Our analysis shows that the entire system evolves toward a DTC phase and is stabilized by the effect of dephasing. Our results provide a new understanding of quantum phases emerging from the competition between the coherent and incoherent dynamics in dissipative nonequilibrium quantum systems.

Discrete time crystals (DTC) have emerged as a significant phase of matter for out-of-equilibrium many-body systems. In this work, we study how random long-range interactions contribute to the stability of the DTC phase. Generally, a stable DTC phase is believed to be realized in disordered systems with short-range interactions. Here, we explore a periodically driven quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) model of Ising spin-glass in which all spins are coupled to each other randomly. We investigate the possibilities of the DTC phase in the SK model within three different driving protocols and found that the quantum SK model exhibits a robust DTC phase, although systems with uniform long-range interactions can exhibit only prethermal DTC phase. Further, we demonstrate that disorder in the local

XY

term or transverse field is crucial for stabilizing a broad DTC phase, despite random couplings in the SK model. Our analysis shows that the stability of the DTC phase is determined by the non-ergodic nature of the Floquet eigenstates.

We report on the first experimental observation of a non-equilibrium phase of matter, the discrete time crystal (DTC). A DTC breaks time-translational symmetry and displays spatio-temporal quantum order in all of its eigenstates, a feature dubbed “eigenstate order”. We implement Floquet dynamics on a 1D chain of 20 superconducting qubits [2]. Engineered disorders in the two-qubit couplings allow many-body localization (MBL) to occur despite strong external drive, thereby stabilizing the non-equilibrium phase [3]. We carefully validate the phase structure of the DTC by probing the average response of all eigenstates belonging to the Floquet unitary. Using a suitable choice of order parameter, we further identify the location of the MBL-ergodicity crossover via experimentally observed finite-size effects. These results open a direct path to studying quantum phase transitions and critical phenomena on NISQ quantum processors.