Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2110.15506 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Thermal melting of discrete time crystals: A dynamical phase transition induced by thermal fluctuations

Mingxi Yue, Xiaoqin Yang, Zi Cai

Published Mar 22, 2022• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The stability of a discrete time crystal against thermal fluctuations has been studied numerically by solving a stochastic Landau-Lifshitz-Gilbert equation of a periodically driven classical system composed of interacting spins, each of which couples to a thermal bath. It is shown that in the thermodynamic limit, even though the long-range temporal crystalline order is stable at low temperature, it is melting above a critical temperature, at which the system experiences a nonequilibrium phase transition. The critical behaviors of the continuous phase transition have been systematically investigated, and it is shown that despite the genuine nonequilibrium feature of such a periodically driven system, its critical properties fall into the three-dimensional Ising universality class with a dynamical exponent ($z=2$) identical to that in the critical dynamics of a kinetic Ising model without driving.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.105.l100303

Related papers

Classical stochastic discrete time crystals

Filippo Maria Gambetta, Federico Carollo, Achilleas Lazarides +2 more

We describe a general and simple paradigm for discrete time crystals (DTCs), systems with a stable subharmonic response to an external driving field, in a classical thermal setting. We consider, specifically, an Ising model in two dimensions, as a prototypical system with a phase transition into stable phases distinguished by a local order parameter, driven by thermal dynamics and periodically kicked with a noisy protocol. By means of extensive numerical simulations for large sizes-allowed by the classical nature of our model-we show that the system features a true disorder-DTC order phase transition as a function of the noise strength, with a robust DTC phase extending over a wide parameter range. We demonstrate that, when the dynamics is observed stroboscopically, the phase transition to the DTC state appears to be in the equilibrium two-dimensional Ising universality class. However, we explicitly show that the DTC is a genuine nonequilibrium state. More generally, we speculate that systems with thermal phase transitions to multiple competing phases can give rise to DTCs when appropriately driven.

arXiv:1905.08826•Physical review. E•Dec 24, 2019•50 citations

A discrete time crystal order in the driven Ising model: thermal effects, jamming analogy and quench dynamics

Kangeun Jeong, Bongsoo Kim, Sung Jong Lee

Abstract We explore the emergence of a discrete time crystalline (DTC) order and its stability against thermal fluctuations in a driven kinetic Ising model on a two-dimensional square lattice using the drive protocol invented in a recent work (Gambetta et al 2019 Phys. Rev. E 100 060105(R)). The DTC order is found to be quite robust in the presence of thermal fluctuations. We construct the resulting three-dimensional phase diagram for the DTC order, which manifests a striking resemblance to the jamming phase diagram proposed by Liu and Nagel. This finding may suggest a new way to view the DTC order as a new type of nonequilibrium soft matter. The quench dynamics exhibits a unique feature due to the nature of the employed drive protocol, namely, breakdown of the inverse relationship between the domain growth and defect relaxation, which holds in the usual quench dynamics of the kinetic Ising model.

Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Apr 24, 2024•0 citations

Emergence of Time Semicrystals in Holographic Driven-Dissipative Systems

Yu-Qi Lei, Xian-Hui Ge, Yu Tian +1 more

Understanding how temporal order degrades in quantum systems remains a central issue in nonequilibrium physics. Here we study the melting of discrete time crystals in a periodically driven holographic system, where a distinct (discrete) time semicrystal phase emerges with persistent temporal order in disorder, bridging discrete time crystals and fully disordered regimes. This phase exhibits a periodic skeleton, with discrete subharmonic peaks persisting atop a continuous spectrum. We extract a critical scaling behavior across the discrete time crystal to time semicrystal transition. Furthermore, even dynamical transitions between distinct periodic skeletons can be clearly identified with systematic log-periodic corrections to power-law scaling, revealing discrete scale invariance. These findings in holography significantly enrich the platforms for studying nonequilibrium phases of matter.

arXiv:2604.14131•Apr 15, 2026•0 citations

Criticality and rigidity of dissipative discrete time crystals in solids

Koki Chinzei, Tatsuhiko N. Ikeda

We consider a dissipative quantum Ising model periodically driven by a train of $\ensuremath{\pi}$ pulses and investigate dissipative discrete time crystals (DTCs) in solids. In this model, the interaction between the spins spontaneously breaks the discrete time translation symmetry, giving rise to a dissipative DTC, where two ferromagnetic states are switched alternately by each pulse. We microscopically describe the generic dissipation due to thermal contact to an equilibrium heat bath using the Bloch-Redfield equation. In contrast to other DTC studies, this dissipation stabilizes, rather than destroys, the DTC order without fine-tuning as long as the temperature is low enough. Invoking the time-dependent mean-field theory and solving self-consistently the periodic drive, dissipation, and DTC order parameter, we investigate the nonequilibrium DTC phase transition and determine the critical exponents, including a dynamical one. We also find phase transitions without an equilibrium counterpart: a nontrivial interplay of the periodic drive and dissipation gives rise to reentrant DTC transition when changing the pulse interval at a fixed temperature. Also, to demonstrate the rigidity of the DTC, we consider imperfect $\ensuremath{\pi}$ pulses, showing that the DTC is robust against the small imperfections and finding that discrete time quasicrystals can appear for the larger imperfections. Together with experimental proposals in magnetic materials, our results pave the way for realizing the DTC and for uncovering nonequilibrium critical phenomena in real solid-state materials.

arXiv:2110.00591•Physical Review Research•Apr 8, 2022•9 citations

Theory of phase transitions from quantum glasses to thermal fluids

Andrew C. Potter, Romain Vasseur, S. A. Parameswaran

We study the dynamical melting of hot one-dimensional quantum glasses. We focus on quantum glasses that emerge at strong disorder: specifically, many-body localized systems and their critical variants. The latter category includes disordered Ising, Potts, and anyonic chains whose excited-state properties and dynamics can be accessed via real-space renormalization group methods. As disorder is weakened below a critical value these non-thermal quantum glasses melt via a continuous dynamical phase transition into a classical thermal liquid. By accounting for resonant tunneling of energy, we derive and solve an effective model for such quantum-to-classical transitions and compute their universal critical properties. Notably, the classical thermal liquid exhibits a broad regime of anomalously slow sub-diffusive equilibration dynamics and energy transport, crossing over to ordinary classical diffusion at asymptotically long length scales for critical glasses. The subdiffusive regime is characterized by a continuously evolving dynamical critical exponent that diverges with a universal power at the transition. For non-critical, many-body localized glasses, the crossover scale diverges and subdiffusion persists to the thermodynamic limit. Our approach provides a firm microscopic basis for understanding the generic structure of many-body delocalization transitions in one dimension, and also reveals a general scaling relation among the critical exponents of the transition.

•Jan 14, 2015•2 citations

Discrete time crystal in periodically driven quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model

Anonymous, Arti Garg

Discrete time crystals (DTC) have emerged as a significant phase of matter for out-of-equilibrium many-body systems. In this work, we study how random long-range interactions contribute to the stability of the DTC phase. Generally, a stable DTC phase is believed to be realized in disordered systems with short-range interactions. Here, we explore a periodically driven quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) model of Ising spin-glass in which all spins are coupled to each other randomly. We investigate the possibilities of the DTC phase in the SK model within three different driving protocols and found that the quantum SK model exhibits a robust DTC phase, although systems with uniform long-range interactions can exhibit only prethermal DTC phase. Further, we demonstrate that disorder in the local $XY$ term or transverse field is crucial for stabilizing a broad DTC phase, despite random couplings in the SK model. Our analysis shows that the stability of the DTC phase is determined by the non-ergodic nature of the Floquet eigenstates.

arXiv:2504.19378•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 22, 2026•0 citations
The stability of a discrete time crystal against thermal fluctuations has been studied numerically by solving a stochastic Landau-Lifshitz-Gilbert equation of a periodically driven classical system composed of interacting spins, each of which couples to a thermal bath. It is shown that in the thermodynamic limit, even though the long-range temporal crystalline order is stable at low temperature, it is melting above a critical temperature, at which the system experiences a nonequilibrium phase transition. The critical behaviors of the continuous phase transition have been systematically investigated, and it is shown that despite the genuine nonequilibrium feature of such a periodically driven system, its critical properties fall into the three-dimensional Ising universality class with a dynamical exponent (z=2z=2z=2) identical to that in the critical dynamics of a kinetic Ising model without driving.
We describe a general and simple paradigm for discrete time crystals (DTCs), systems with a stable subharmonic response to an external driving field, in a classical thermal setting. We consider, specifically, an Ising model in two dimensions, as a prototypical system with a phase transition into stable phases distinguished by a local order parameter, driven by thermal dynamics and periodically kicked with a noisy protocol. By means of extensive numerical simulations for large sizes-allowed by the classical nature of our model-we show that the system features a true disorder-DTC order phase transition as a function of the noise strength, with a robust DTC phase extending over a wide parameter range. We demonstrate that, when the dynamics is observed stroboscopically, the phase transition to the DTC state appears to be in the equilibrium two-dimensional Ising universality class. However, we explicitly show that the DTC is a genuine nonequilibrium state. More generally, we speculate that systems with thermal phase transitions to multiple competing phases can give rise to DTCs when appropriately driven.
Abstract We explore the emergence of a discrete time crystalline (DTC) order and its stability against thermal fluctuations in a driven kinetic Ising model on a two-dimensional square lattice using the drive protocol invented in a recent work (Gambetta et al 2019 Phys. Rev. E 100 060105(R)). The DTC order is found to be quite robust in the presence of thermal fluctuations. We construct the resulting three-dimensional phase diagram for the DTC order, which manifests a striking resemblance to the jamming phase diagram proposed by Liu and Nagel. This finding may suggest a new way to view the DTC order as a new type of nonequilibrium soft matter. The quench dynamics exhibits a unique feature due to the nature of the employed drive protocol, namely, breakdown of the inverse relationship between the domain growth and defect relaxation, which holds in the usual quench dynamics of the kinetic Ising model.
Understanding how temporal order degrades in quantum systems remains a central issue in nonequilibrium physics. Here we study the melting of discrete time crystals in a periodically driven holographic system, where a distinct (discrete) time semicrystal phase emerges with persistent temporal order in disorder, bridging discrete time crystals and fully disordered regimes. This phase exhibits a periodic skeleton, with discrete subharmonic peaks persisting atop a continuous spectrum. We extract a critical scaling behavior across the discrete time crystal to time semicrystal transition. Furthermore, even dynamical transitions between distinct periodic skeletons can be clearly identified with systematic log-periodic corrections to power-law scaling, revealing discrete scale invariance. These findings in holography significantly enrich the platforms for studying nonequilibrium phases of matter.
We consider a dissipative quantum Ising model periodically driven by a train of $\ensuremath{\pi}$ pulses and investigate dissipative discrete time crystals (DTCs) in solids. In this model, the interaction between the spins spontaneously breaks the discrete time translation symmetry, giving rise to a dissipative DTC, where two ferromagnetic states are switched alternately by each pulse. We microscopically describe the generic dissipation due to thermal contact to an equilibrium heat bath using the Bloch-Redfield equation. In contrast to other DTC studies, this dissipation stabilizes, rather than destroys, the DTC order without fine-tuning as long as the temperature is low enough. Invoking the time-dependent mean-field theory and solving self-consistently the periodic drive, dissipation, and DTC order parameter, we investigate the nonequilibrium DTC phase transition and determine the critical exponents, including a dynamical one. We also find phase transitions without an equilibrium counterpart: a nontrivial interplay of the periodic drive and dissipation gives rise to reentrant DTC transition when changing the pulse interval at a fixed temperature. Also, to demonstrate the rigidity of the DTC, we consider imperfect $\ensuremath{\pi}$ pulses, showing that the DTC is robust against the small imperfections and finding that discrete time quasicrystals can appear for the larger imperfections. Together with experimental proposals in magnetic materials, our results pave the way for realizing the DTC and for uncovering nonequilibrium critical phenomena in real solid-state materials.
We study the dynamical melting of hot one-dimensional quantum glasses. We focus on quantum glasses that emerge at strong disorder: specifically, many-body localized systems and their critical variants. The latter category includes disordered Ising, Potts, and anyonic chains whose excited-state properties and dynamics can be accessed via real-space renormalization group methods. As disorder is weakened below a critical value these non-thermal quantum glasses melt via a continuous dynamical phase transition into a classical thermal liquid. By accounting for resonant tunneling of energy, we derive and solve an effective model for such quantum-to-classical transitions and compute their universal critical properties. Notably, the classical thermal liquid exhibits a broad regime of anomalously slow sub-diffusive equilibration dynamics and energy transport, crossing over to ordinary classical diffusion at asymptotically long length scales for critical glasses. The subdiffusive regime is characterized by a continuously evolving dynamical critical exponent that diverges with a universal power at the transition. For non-critical, many-body localized glasses, the crossover scale diverges and subdiffusion persists to the thermodynamic limit. Our approach provides a firm microscopic basis for understanding the generic structure of many-body delocalization transitions in one dimension, and also reveals a general scaling relation among the critical exponents of the transition.
Discrete time crystals (DTC) have emerged as a significant phase of matter for out-of-equilibrium many-body systems. In this work, we study how random long-range interactions contribute to the stability of the DTC phase. Generally, a stable DTC phase is believed to be realized in disordered systems with short-range interactions. Here, we explore a periodically driven quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) model of Ising spin-glass in which all spins are coupled to each other randomly. We investigate the possibilities of the DTC phase in the SK model within three different driving protocols and found that the quantum SK model exhibits a robust DTC phase, although systems with uniform long-range interactions can exhibit only prethermal DTC phase. Further, we demonstrate that disorder in the local XYXYXY term or transverse field is crucial for stabilizing a broad DTC phase, despite random couplings in the SK model. Our analysis shows that the stability of the DTC phase is determined by the non-ergodic nature of the Floquet eigenstates.