arXiv:2110.07627 · Classical and Quantum Gravity

Entanglement entropy of disjoint spacetime intervals in causal set theory

Callum Duffy, Joshua Y. L. Jones, Yasaman Kouchekzadeh Yazdi

Published Feb 11, 2022• 4 citations

Abstract

Abstract A more complete understanding of entanglement entropy in a covariant manner could inform the search for quantum gravity. We build on work in this direction by extending previous results to disjoint regions in 1 + 1D. We investigate the entanglement entropy of a scalar field in disjoint intervals within the causal set framework, using the spacetime commutator and correlator, i Δ and W (or the Pauli–Jordan and Wightman functions). A new truncation scheme for disjoint causal diamonds is presented, which follows from the single diamond truncation scheme. We investigate setups including two and three disjoint causal diamonds, as well as a single causal diamond that shares a boundary with a larger global causal diamond. In all the cases that we study, our results agree with the expected area laws. In addition, we study the mutual information in the two disjoint diamond setup. The ease of our calculations indicate our methods to be a useful tool for numerically studying such systems. We end with a discussion of some of the strengths and future applications of the spacetime formulation we use in our entanglement entropy computations, both in causal set theory and in the continuum.

DOI: 10.1088/1361-6382/ac5493

Related papers

Entanglement entropy in causal set theory

Rafael D. Sorkin, Yasaman Kouchekzadeh Yazdi

Abstract Entanglement entropy is now widely accepted as having deep connections with quantum gravity. It is therefore desirable to understand it in the context of causal sets, especially since they provide in a natural manner the UV cutoff needed to render entanglement entropy finite. Formulating a notion of entanglement entropy in a causal set is not straightforward because the type of canonical hypersurface-data on which its definition typically relies is not available. Instead, we appeal to the more global expression given in Sorkin (2012 (arXiv:1205.2953)) which, for a Gaussian scalar field, expresses the entropy of a spacetime region in terms of the field’s correlation function within that region (its ‘Wightman function’ W ( x , x ′ ) ). Carrying this formula over to the causal set, one obtains an entropy which is both finite and of a Lorentz invariant nature. We evaluate this global entropy-expression numerically for certain regions (primarily order-intervals or ‘causal diamonds’) within causal sets of 1 + 1 dimensions. For the causal-set counterpart of the entanglement entropy, we obtain, in the first instance, a result that follows a (spacetime) volume law instead of the expected (spatial) area law. We find, however, that one obtains an area law if one truncates the commutator function (‘Pauli–Jordan operator’) and the Wightman function by projecting out the eigenmodes of the Pauli–Jordan operator whose eigenvalues are too close to zero according to a geometrical criterion which we describe more fully below. In connection with these results and the questions they raise, we also study the ‘entropy of coarse-graining’ generated by thinning out the causal set, and we compare it with what one obtains by similarly thinning out a chain of harmonic oscillators, finding the same, ‘universal’ behaviour in both cases.

arXiv:1611.10281Classical and Quantum GravityFeb 19, 201837 citations

Insights on entanglement entropy in 1 + 1 dimensional causal sets

Théo Keseman, Hans J. Muneesamy, Yasaman Kouchekzadeh Yazdi

Abstract Entanglement entropy in causal sets offers a fundamentally covariant characterisation of quantum field degrees of freedom. A known result in this context is that the degrees of freedom consist of a number of contributions that have continuum-like analogues, in addition to a number of contributions that do not. The latter exhibit features below the discreteness scale and are excluded from the entanglement entropy using a ‘truncation scheme’. This truncation is necessary to recover the standard spatial area law of entanglement entropy. In this paper we build on previous work on the entanglement entropy of a massless scalar field on a causal set approximated by a 1 + 1D causal diamond in Minkowski spacetime. We present new insights into the truncated contributions, including evidence that they behave as fluctuations and encode features specific to a particular causal set sprinkling. We extend previous results in the massless theory to include Rényi entropies and include new results for the massive theory. We also discuss the implications of our work for the treatment of entanglement entropy in causal sets in more general settings.

arXiv:2111.05879Classical and Quantum GravityMar 22, 20226 citations

On the entanglement entropy of quantum fields in causal sets

Alessio Belenchia, Dionigi M. T. Benincasa, Marco Letizia +1 more

Abstract In order to understand the detailed mechanism by which a fundamental discreteness can provide a finite entanglement entropy, we consider the entanglement entropy of two classes of free massless scalar fields on causal sets that are well approximated by causal diamonds in Minkowski spacetime of dimensions 2, 3 and 4. The first class is defined from discretised versions of the continuum retarded Green functions, while the second uses the causal set’s retarded nonlocal d’Alembertians parametrised by a length scale l k . In both cases we provide numerical evidence that the area law is recovered when the double-cutoff prescription proposed in Sorkin and Yazdi (2016 Entanglement entropy in causal set theory (arXiv:1611.10281)) is imposed. We discuss in detail the need for this double cutoff by studying the effect of two cutoffs on the quantum field and, in particular, on the entanglement entropy, in isolation. In so doing, we get a novel interpretation for why these two cutoff are necessary, and the different roles they play in making the entanglement entropy on causal sets finite.

arXiv:1712.04227Classical and Quantum GravityFeb 9, 201810 citations

Spacetime entanglement entropy in 1 + 1 dimensions

Mehdi Saravani, Rafael D Sorkin, Yasaman K Yazdi

Sorkin (Expressing entropy globally in terms of (4D) field-correlations arXiv: 1205.2953 ) defines an entropy for a Gaussian scalar field ϕ in an arbitrary region of either a continuous spacetime or a causal set, given only the correlator within the region. The definition is global and independent of any choice of spacelike hypersurface. As a first application, we compute numerically the entanglement entropy in two cases where the asymptotic form is known or suspected from conformal field theory, finding excellent agreement when the required ultraviolet cutoff is implemented as a truncation on spacetime mode sums. We also show how the symmetry of entanglement entropy reflects the fact that RS and SR share the same eigenvalues, with R and S being arbitrary matrices.

arXiv:1311.7146Classical and Quantum GravityOct 21, 201430 citations

Entanglement Entropy in Quantum Gravity

William Donnelly

We study a proposed statistical explanation for the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy of a black hole in which entropy arises quantum-mechanically as a result of entanglement. Arguments for the identification of black hole entropy with entanglement entropy are reviewed in the framework of quantum field theory, emphasizing the role of renormalization and the need for a physical short-distance cutoff. \n \nOur main novel contribution is a calculation of entanglement entropy in loop quantum gravity. The kinematical Hilbert space and spin network states are introduced, and the entanglement entropy of these states is calculated using methods from quantum information theory. The entanglement entropy is compared with the density of states previously computed for isolated horizons in loop quantum gravity, and the two are found to agree up to a topological term. \n \nWe investigate a conjecture due to Sorkin that the entanglement entropy must be a monotonically increasing function of time under the assumption of causality. For a system described by a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, the conjecture is found to be trivial, and for a system described by an infinite-dimensional Hilbert space a counterexample is provided. \n \nFor quantum states with Euclidean symmetry, the area scaling of the entanglement entropy is shown to be equivalent to the strong additivity condition on the entropy. The strong additivity condition is naturally interpreted in information-theoretic terms as a continuous analog of the Markov property for a classical random variable. We explicitly construct states of a quantum field theory on the one-dimensional real line in which the area law is exactly satisfied.

May 22, 20080 citations

Entanglement entropy in quantum field theory and entanglement entropic force between black holes

Noburo Shiba, ノブロウシバ, 暢郎芝

First, we study the entanglement entropy S AB of a d + 1 dimensional massless free scalar field on two disjoint compact spatial regions A and B whose sizes are R 1 and R 2 , respectively, and the distance between them is r.The state of the massless free scalar field is the vacuum state.We consider the mutual information S A;B ≡ S A + S B -S AB where S A and S B are the entanglement entropy on the inside region of A and B, respectively.We develop the computational method based on that of Bombelli et al and obtain the result thatWhen A and B are spheres in d = 2 and 3, we obtain explicit resultsBy using the method used in the Minkowski spacetime case with some modifications, we study the entanglement entropy, S C , of the massless free scalar field on the outside region C of two black holes A and B whose radii are R 1 and R 2 and how it depends on the distance, r( R 1 , R 2 ) , between two black holes.If we can consider the entanglement entropy as thermodynamic entropy, we can see the entropic force (we call this entanglement entropic force) acting on the two black holes from the r dependence of S C .We consider the property of the entropic force.

Sep 25, 20130 citations