Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2110.00585 · Physical Review Letters

Absolutely Stable Time Crystals at Finite Temperature

Francisco Machado, Quntao Zhuang, Norman Y. Yao, Michael P. Zaletel

Published Nov 1, 2023• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that locally interacting, periodically driven (Floquet) Hamiltonian dynamics coupled to a Langevin bath support finite-temperature discrete time crystals (DTCs) with an infinite autocorrelation time. By contrast to both prethermal and many-body localized DTCs, the time crystalline order we uncover is stable to arbitrary perturbations, including those that break the time translation symmetry of the underlying drive. Our approach utilizes a general mapping from probabilistic cellular automata to open classical Floquet systems undergoing continuous-time Langevin dynamics. Applying this mapping to a variant of the Toom cellular automaton, which we dub the "π-Toom time crystal," leads to a 2D Floquet Hamiltonian with a finite-temperature DTC phase transition. We provide numerical evidence for the existence of this transition, and analyze the statistics of the finite temperature fluctuations. Finally, we discuss how general results from the field of probabilistic cellular automata imply the existence of discrete time crystals (with an infinite autocorrelation time) in all dimensions, d≥1.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.131.180402

Related papers

Prethermal time crystals in a one-dimensional periodically driven Floquet system

Tian-Sheng Zeng, D. N. Sheng

Motivated by experimental observations of time-symmetry breaking behavior in a periodically driven (Floquet) system, we study a one-dimensional spin model to explore the stability of such Floquet discrete time crystals (DTCs) under the interplay between interaction and the microwave driving. For intermediate interactions and high drivings, from the time evolution of both stroboscopic spin polarization and mutual information between two ends, we show that Floquet DTCs can exist in a prethermal time regime without the tuning of strong disorder. For much weak interactions the system is a symmetry-unbroken phase, while for strong interactions it gives its way to a thermal phase. Through analyzing the entanglement dynamics, we show that large driving fields protect the prethermal DTCs from many-body localization and thermalization. Our results suggest that by increasing the spin interaction, one can drive the experimental system into optimal regime for observing a robust prethermal DTC phase.

arXiv:1707.00404•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 18, 2017•57 citations

Floquet Phases of Matter via Classical Prethermalization

Bingtian Ye, Francisco Machado, Norman Y. Yao

We demonstrate that the prethermal regime of periodically driven (Floquet), classical many-body systems can host nonequilibrium phases of matter. In particular, we show that there exists an effective Hamiltonian that captures the dynamics of ensembles of classical trajectories despite the breakdown of this description at the single trajectory level. In addition, we prove that the effective Hamiltonian can host emergent symmetries protected by the discrete time-translation symmetry of the drive. The spontaneous breaking of such an emergent symmetry leads to a subharmonic response, characteristic of time crystalline order, that survives to exponentially late times in the frequency of the drive. To this end, we numerically demonstrate the existence of classical prethermal time crystals in systems with different dimensionalities and ranges of interaction. Extensions to higher order and fractional time crystals are also discussed.

arXiv:2104.13927•Physical Review Letters•Sep 27, 2021•57 citations

Quantum Time Crystals from Hamiltonians with Long-Range Interactions

Valerii K. Kozin, Oleksandr Kyriienko

Time crystals correspond to a phase of matter where time-translational symmetry (TTS) is broken. Up to date, they are well studied in open quantum systems, where an external drive allows us to break discrete TTS, ultimately leading to Floquet time crystals. At the same time, genuine time crystals for closed quantum systems are believed to be impossible. In this study we propose a form of a Hamiltonian for which the unitary dynamics exhibits the time crystalline behavior and breaks continuous TTS. This is based on a spin-1/2 many-body Hamiltonian which has long-range multispin interactions in the form of spin strings, thus bypassing previously known no-go theorems. We show that quantum time crystals are stable to local perturbations at zero temperature. Finally, we reveal the intrinsic connection between continuous and discrete TTS, thus linking the two realms.

arXiv:1907.07215•Physical Review Letters•Nov 20, 2019•125 citations

Clean two-dimensional Floquet time crystal

Alessandro Santini, Giuseppe E. Santoro, Mario Collura

We consider the two-dimensional quantum Ising model, in absence of disorder, subject to periodic imperfect global spin flips. We show by a combination of exact diagonalization and tensor-network methods that the system can sustain a spontaneously broken discrete time-translation symmetry. Employing careful scaling analysis, we show the feasibility of a two-dimensional discrete time-crystal (DTC) prethermal phase. Despite an unbounded energy pumped into the system, in the high-frequency limit, a well-defined effective Hamiltonian controls a finite-temperature intermediate regime, wherein local time averages are described by thermal averages. As a consequence, the long-lived stability of the DTC relies on the existence of a long-range ordered phase at finite temperature. Interestingly, even for large deviations from the perfect spin flip, we observe a nonperturbative change in the decay rate of the order parameter, which is related to the long-lived stability of the magnetic domains in 2D.

arXiv:2205.04865•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 3, 2022•7 citations

Robustness condition for general disordered discrete time crystals: Subspace-thermal discrete time crystals from phase transitions between different n -tuple discrete time crystals

Hongye Yu, Tzu-Chieh Wei

We propose a Floquet time crystal model that responds in arbitrary multiples of the driving period. Such an $n$-tuple discrete time crystal is theoretically constructed by permutations in a disordered spin chain and is well suited for experimental implementations. Transitions between these time crystals with different periods give rise to a novel phase of matter that we call subspace-thermal discrete time crystals, where states within subspaces of definite charges are fully thermalized at an early time. However, the whole system still robustly responds to the periodic driving subharmonically, with a period being the greatest common divisor of the original two periods. Existing theoretical analysis from many-body localization cannot be used to understand the rigidity of such subspace-thermal time crystal phases. To resolve this, we develop a theoretical framework for the robustness of DTCs from the perspective of the robust $2\ensuremath{\pi}/n$ quasi-energy gap. Its robustness is rigorously proved if the system satisfies a certain condition where the mixing length, defined by the Hamming distance of the symmetry charges, does not exceed a global threshold. Although whether the condition is satisfied in generic disordered systems is unclear, the rigorous proof for DTC properties applies beyond the models considered here and extends to other existing DTCs realized by kicking disordered MBL systems, where the condition is automatically satisfied and conventional MBL-DTCs can be regarded as a special case of the subspace-thermal DTC with the subspace dimension being one, thus offering a systematic way to construct discrete time crystal models. We also introduce the notion of DTC charges that allow us to probe observables that spontaneously break the time-translation symmetry in both regular discrete time crystals and subspace-thermal discrete time crystals. Moreover, our discrete time crystal models can be generalized to systems with higher spin magnitudes or qudits, as well as to higher spatial dimensions.

arXiv:2409.02848•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 30, 2025•2 citations

Discrete time crystal in periodically driven quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model

Anonymous, Arti Garg

Discrete time crystals (DTC) have emerged as a significant phase of matter for out-of-equilibrium many-body systems. In this work, we study how random long-range interactions contribute to the stability of the DTC phase. Generally, a stable DTC phase is believed to be realized in disordered systems with short-range interactions. Here, we explore a periodically driven quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) model of Ising spin-glass in which all spins are coupled to each other randomly. We investigate the possibilities of the DTC phase in the SK model within three different driving protocols and found that the quantum SK model exhibits a robust DTC phase, although systems with uniform long-range interactions can exhibit only prethermal DTC phase. Further, we demonstrate that disorder in the local $XY$ term or transverse field is crucial for stabilizing a broad DTC phase, despite random couplings in the SK model. Our analysis shows that the stability of the DTC phase is determined by the non-ergodic nature of the Floquet eigenstates.

arXiv:2504.19378•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 22, 2026•0 citations
We show that locally interacting, periodically driven (Floquet) Hamiltonian dynamics coupled to a Langevin bath support finite-temperature discrete time crystals (DTCs) with an infinite autocorrelation time. By contrast to both prethermal and many-body localized DTCs, the time crystalline order we uncover is stable to arbitrary perturbations, including those that break the time translation symmetry of the underlying drive. Our approach utilizes a general mapping from probabilistic cellular automata to open classical Floquet systems undergoing continuous-time Langevin dynamics. Applying this mapping to a variant of the Toom cellular automaton, which we dub the "π-Toom time crystal," leads to a 2D Floquet Hamiltonian with a finite-temperature DTC phase transition. We provide numerical evidence for the existence of this transition, and analyze the statistics of the finite temperature fluctuations. Finally, we discuss how general results from the field of probabilistic cellular automata imply the existence of discrete time crystals (with an infinite autocorrelation time) in all dimensions, d≥1.
Motivated by experimental observations of time-symmetry breaking behavior in a periodically driven (Floquet) system, we study a one-dimensional spin model to explore the stability of such Floquet discrete time crystals (DTCs) under the interplay between interaction and the microwave driving. For intermediate interactions and high drivings, from the time evolution of both stroboscopic spin polarization and mutual information between two ends, we show that Floquet DTCs can exist in a prethermal time regime without the tuning of strong disorder. For much weak interactions the system is a symmetry-unbroken phase, while for strong interactions it gives its way to a thermal phase. Through analyzing the entanglement dynamics, we show that large driving fields protect the prethermal DTCs from many-body localization and thermalization. Our results suggest that by increasing the spin interaction, one can drive the experimental system into optimal regime for observing a robust prethermal DTC phase.
We demonstrate that the prethermal regime of periodically driven (Floquet), classical many-body systems can host nonequilibrium phases of matter. In particular, we show that there exists an effective Hamiltonian that captures the dynamics of ensembles of classical trajectories despite the breakdown of this description at the single trajectory level. In addition, we prove that the effective Hamiltonian can host emergent symmetries protected by the discrete time-translation symmetry of the drive. The spontaneous breaking of such an emergent symmetry leads to a subharmonic response, characteristic of time crystalline order, that survives to exponentially late times in the frequency of the drive. To this end, we numerically demonstrate the existence of classical prethermal time crystals in systems with different dimensionalities and ranges of interaction. Extensions to higher order and fractional time crystals are also discussed.
Time crystals correspond to a phase of matter where time-translational symmetry (TTS) is broken. Up to date, they are well studied in open quantum systems, where an external drive allows us to break discrete TTS, ultimately leading to Floquet time crystals. At the same time, genuine time crystals for closed quantum systems are believed to be impossible. In this study we propose a form of a Hamiltonian for which the unitary dynamics exhibits the time crystalline behavior and breaks continuous TTS. This is based on a spin-1/2 many-body Hamiltonian which has long-range multispin interactions in the form of spin strings, thus bypassing previously known no-go theorems. We show that quantum time crystals are stable to local perturbations at zero temperature. Finally, we reveal the intrinsic connection between continuous and discrete TTS, thus linking the two realms.
We consider the two-dimensional quantum Ising model, in absence of disorder, subject to periodic imperfect global spin flips. We show by a combination of exact diagonalization and tensor-network methods that the system can sustain a spontaneously broken discrete time-translation symmetry. Employing careful scaling analysis, we show the feasibility of a two-dimensional discrete time-crystal (DTC) prethermal phase. Despite an unbounded energy pumped into the system, in the high-frequency limit, a well-defined effective Hamiltonian controls a finite-temperature intermediate regime, wherein local time averages are described by thermal averages. As a consequence, the long-lived stability of the DTC relies on the existence of a long-range ordered phase at finite temperature. Interestingly, even for large deviations from the perfect spin flip, we observe a nonperturbative change in the decay rate of the order parameter, which is related to the long-lived stability of the magnetic domains in 2D.
We propose a Floquet time crystal model that responds in arbitrary multiples of the driving period. Such an nnn-tuple discrete time crystal is theoretically constructed by permutations in a disordered spin chain and is well suited for experimental implementations. Transitions between these time crystals with different periods give rise to a novel phase of matter that we call subspace-thermal discrete time crystals, where states within subspaces of definite charges are fully thermalized at an early time. However, the whole system still robustly responds to the periodic driving subharmonically, with a period being the greatest common divisor of the original two periods. Existing theoretical analysis from many-body localization cannot be used to understand the rigidity of such subspace-thermal time crystal phases. To resolve this, we develop a theoretical framework for the robustness of DTCs from the perspective of the robust $2\ensuremath{\pi}/n$ quasi-energy gap. Its robustness is rigorously proved if the system satisfies a certain condition where the mixing length, defined by the Hamming distance of the symmetry charges, does not exceed a global threshold. Although whether the condition is satisfied in generic disordered systems is unclear, the rigorous proof for DTC properties applies beyond the models considered here and extends to other existing DTCs realized by kicking disordered MBL systems, where the condition is automatically satisfied and conventional MBL-DTCs can be regarded as a special case of the subspace-thermal DTC with the subspace dimension being one, thus offering a systematic way to construct discrete time crystal models. We also introduce the notion of DTC charges that allow us to probe observables that spontaneously break the time-translation symmetry in both regular discrete time crystals and subspace-thermal discrete time crystals. Moreover, our discrete time crystal models can be generalized to systems with higher spin magnitudes or qudits, as well as to higher spatial dimensions.
Discrete time crystals (DTC) have emerged as a significant phase of matter for out-of-equilibrium many-body systems. In this work, we study how random long-range interactions contribute to the stability of the DTC phase. Generally, a stable DTC phase is believed to be realized in disordered systems with short-range interactions. Here, we explore a periodically driven quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) model of Ising spin-glass in which all spins are coupled to each other randomly. We investigate the possibilities of the DTC phase in the SK model within three different driving protocols and found that the quantum SK model exhibits a robust DTC phase, although systems with uniform long-range interactions can exhibit only prethermal DTC phase. Further, we demonstrate that disorder in the local XYXYXY term or transverse field is crucial for stabilizing a broad DTC phase, despite random couplings in the SK model. Our analysis shows that the stability of the DTC phase is determined by the non-ergodic nature of the Floquet eigenstates.