Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2109.11561 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

When entanglement harvesting is not really harvesting

Erickson Tjoa, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

Published Dec 3, 2021• 61 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We revisit the entanglement harvesting protocol when two detectors are in causal contact. We study the role of field-mediated communication in generating entanglement between the two detectors interacting with a quantum field. We provide a quantitative estimator of the relative contribution of communication versus genuine entanglement harvesting. For massless scalar fields in flat spacetime, we show that when two detectors can communicate via the field, the detectors do not really harvest entanglement from the field, and instead they get entangled only via the field-mediated communication channel. In other words, in these scenarios the entanglement harvesting protocol is truly ``harvesting entanglement'' from the field only when the detectors are not able to communicate. In contrast, for massive scalar fields both communication and genuine harvesting contribute equally to the bipartite entanglement when the detectors are causally connected. These results emphasize the importance of taking into account the causal relationships between two parties involved in this relativistic quantum information protocol before we can declare that it is truly entanglement harvesting.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.104.125005

Related papers

Derivative coupling enables genuine entanglement harvesting in causal communication

Adam Teixidó-Bonfill, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

We show that particle detectors coupled to a massless quantum field through its derivative can genuinely harvest entanglement form the field even when they are in causal contact in flat spacetime. This is particularly relevant since the derivative coupling model captures some interesting experimentally realizable systems and since the harvested entanglement peaks at full light contact.

arXiv:2406.14637•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Nov 25, 2024•3 citations

Cosmological Expansion Induces Interference Between Communication and Entanglement Harvesting

Matheus H. Zambianco, Adam Teixidó-Bonfill, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

We investigate the interplay between genuine entanglement harvesting and communication mediated correlations for local particle detectors in expanding cosmological spacetimes. Focusing on a conformally coupled scalar field in de Sitter spacetime, we analyze how spacetime expansion induces interference between these two sources of entanglement when the detectors are in causal contact. We compare two physically distinct detector models: detectors whose spatial profile expands with the Universe, and detectors whose proper size remains fixed despite cosmological expansion. We find that the lack of time-reversal symmetry in cosmological settings generically leads to constructive or destructive interference between communication mediated correlations and harvested field correlations, dramatically affecting the entanglement that detectors can acquire. In particular, rapid expansion can suppress entanglement entirely for expanding detectors through destructive interference, even when both communication and field correlations are individually large, whereas detectors that maintain a fixed proper size remain capable of acquiring significant entanglement. Our results show that cosmological expansion qualitatively reshapes the balance between communication and harvesting, and that the detector internal cohesion (whether it expands with the Universe or not) plays a crucial role in determining whether detectors' entanglement can survive in rapidly expanding universes.

quant-pharXiv:2602.10203•Feb 12, 2026

Correlation and Communication via a Quantum Field

Petar Simidzija

We study the ability of qubit detectors to i) extract correlations from, and ii) transmit quantum information through, a quantum field. \n \nWe start by perturbatively studying the harvesting of correlations from thermal and squeezed coherent field states. We find that an increase in field temperature is detrimental to entanglement harvesting, but beneficial to mutual information harvesting. We also show that entanglement harvesting is independent of the field's coherent amplitude - which we relate to fundamental results regarding the entanglement structure of coherent field states - but strongly dependent on the field's squeezing amplitude. We conclude by analyzing the practical feasibility of entangling qubits using squeezed field states. \n \nWe then go on to study, non-perturbatively, the entanglement extraction by targets A and B from a quantum source S. After proving a general no-go theorem which applies for any A, B and S, we apply this theorem to the entanglement harvesting setup to prove that a wide class of i) degenerate, or ii) point-in-time coupled, detectors cannot harvest entanglement from any field state. We also discuss the role of communication in the process of entanglement extraction, and we end the chapter by presenting the simplest successful example of a non-perturbative entanglement harvesting protocol. \n \nWe conclude by studying the ability of flat spacetime observers Alice and Bob to transmit quantum information through a quantum field. We construct a perfect, field-mediated quantum channel, each use of which allows Alice to transmit a full qubit of information to Bob. This construction provides us with an understanding of how quantum information propagates through a relativistic field, which we find to be consistent with our understanding of the strong Huygens principle. Lastly, we analyze the possibility of simultaneously broadcasting a quantum message through a quantum field to multiple receivers, and discover severe fundamental limitations to such a setup.

•Jul 15, 2019•0 citations

Fully relativistic entanglement harvesting

Tales Rick Perche, José Polo-Gómez, Bruno de S. L. Torres +1 more

We study the protocol of entanglement harvesting when the particle detectors that harvest entanglement from the field are replaced by fully relativistic quantum field theories. We show that two localized modes of the quantum field theories are able to harvest the same amount of leading order entanglement as two nonrelativistic particle detectors, thus implying that quantum field theoretical probes can generally harvest more entanglement than particle detectors. These results legitimize the use of particle detectors to study entanglement harvesting regardless of their internally nonrelativistic nature.

arXiv:2310.18432•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Feb 28, 2024•25 citations

Interference of communication and field correlations in entanglement harvesting

Matheus H. Zambianco, Adam Teixidó-Bonfill, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

We reveal that the information exchange between particle detectors and their ability to harvest correlations from a quantum field can interfere constructively and destructively. This allows for scenarios where the presence of entanglement in the quantum field is actually detrimental to the process of getting the two detectors entangled.

arXiv:2404.08063•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 19, 2024•6 citations

Harvesting correlations from vacuum quantum fields in the presence of a reflecting boundary

Zhihong Liu, Jialin Zhang, Hongwei Yu

Abstract We explore correlations harvesting by two static detectors locally interacting with vacuum massless scalar fields in the presence of an infinite perfectly reflecting boundary. We study the phenomena of mutual information harvesting and entanglement harvesting for two detector-boundary alignments, i.e., parallel-to-boundary and orthogonal-to-boundary alignments. Our results show that the presence of the boundary generally inhibits mutual information harvesting relative to that in flat spacetime without any boundaries. In contrast, the boundary may play a doubled-edged role in entanglement harvesting, i.e., inhibiting entanglement harvesting in the near zone of the boundary while assisting it in the far zone of the boundary. Moreover, there exists an optimal detector energy gap difference between two nonidentical detectors that makes such detectors advantageous in correlations harvesting as long as the interdetector separation is large enough. The value of the optimal detector energy gap difference depends on both the interdetector separation and the detector-to-boundary distance. A comparison of the correlations harvesting in two different alignments shows that although correlations harvesting share qualitatively the same properties, they also display quantitative differences in that the detectors in orthogonal-to-boundary alignment always harvest comparatively more mutual information than the parallel-to-boundary ones, while they harvest comparatively more entanglement only near the boundary.

arXiv:2310.07164•Journal of High Energy Physics•Nov 24, 2023•18 citations
We revisit the entanglement harvesting protocol when two detectors are in causal contact. We study the role of field-mediated communication in generating entanglement between the two detectors interacting with a quantum field. We provide a quantitative estimator of the relative contribution of communication versus genuine entanglement harvesting. For massless scalar fields in flat spacetime, we show that when two detectors can communicate via the field, the detectors do not really harvest entanglement from the field, and instead they get entangled only via the field-mediated communication channel. In other words, in these scenarios the entanglement harvesting protocol is truly ``harvesting entanglement'' from the field only when the detectors are not able to communicate. In contrast, for massive scalar fields both communication and genuine harvesting contribute equally to the bipartite entanglement when the detectors are causally connected. These results emphasize the importance of taking into account the causal relationships between two parties involved in this relativistic quantum information protocol before we can declare that it is truly entanglement harvesting.
We investigate the interplay between genuine entanglement harvesting and communication mediated correlations for local particle detectors in expanding cosmological spacetimes. Focusing on a conformally coupled scalar field in de Sitter spacetime, we analyze how spacetime expansion induces interference between these two sources of entanglement when the detectors are in causal contact. We compare two physically distinct detector models: detectors whose spatial profile expands with the Universe, and detectors whose proper size remains fixed despite cosmological expansion. We find that the lack of time-reversal symmetry in cosmological settings generically leads to constructive or destructive interference between communication mediated correlations and harvested field correlations, dramatically affecting the entanglement that detectors can acquire. In particular, rapid expansion can suppress entanglement entirely for expanding detectors through destructive interference, even when both communication and field correlations are individually large, whereas detectors that maintain a fixed proper size remain capable of acquiring significant entanglement. Our results show that cosmological expansion qualitatively reshapes the balance between communication and harvesting, and that the detector internal cohesion (whether it expands with the Universe or not) plays a crucial role in determining whether detectors' entanglement can survive in rapidly expanding universes.
We study the ability of qubit detectors to i) extract correlations from, and ii) transmit quantum information through, a quantum field. \n \nWe start by perturbatively studying the harvesting of correlations from thermal and squeezed coherent field states. We find that an increase in field temperature is detrimental to entanglement harvesting, but beneficial to mutual information harvesting. We also show that entanglement harvesting is independent of the field's coherent amplitude - which we relate to fundamental results regarding the entanglement structure of coherent field states - but strongly dependent on the field's squeezing amplitude. We conclude by analyzing the practical feasibility of entangling qubits using squeezed field states. \n \nWe then go on to study, non-perturbatively, the entanglement extraction by targets A and B from a quantum source S. After proving a general no-go theorem which applies for any A, B and S, we apply this theorem to the entanglement harvesting setup to prove that a wide class of i) degenerate, or ii) point-in-time coupled, detectors cannot harvest entanglement from any field state. We also discuss the role of communication in the process of entanglement extraction, and we end the chapter by presenting the simplest successful example of a non-perturbative entanglement harvesting protocol. \n \nWe conclude by studying the ability of flat spacetime observers Alice and Bob to transmit quantum information through a quantum field. We construct a perfect, field-mediated quantum channel, each use of which allows Alice to transmit a full qubit of information to Bob. This construction provides us with an understanding of how quantum information propagates through a relativistic field, which we find to be consistent with our understanding of the strong Huygens principle. Lastly, we analyze the possibility of simultaneously broadcasting a quantum message through a quantum field to multiple receivers, and discover severe fundamental limitations to such a setup.
We study the protocol of entanglement harvesting when the particle detectors that harvest entanglement from the field are replaced by fully relativistic quantum field theories. We show that two localized modes of the quantum field theories are able to harvest the same amount of leading order entanglement as two nonrelativistic particle detectors, thus implying that quantum field theoretical probes can generally harvest more entanglement than particle detectors. These results legitimize the use of particle detectors to study entanglement harvesting regardless of their internally nonrelativistic nature.
Abstract We explore correlations harvesting by two static detectors locally interacting with vacuum massless scalar fields in the presence of an infinite perfectly reflecting boundary. We study the phenomena of mutual information harvesting and entanglement harvesting for two detector-boundary alignments, i.e., parallel-to-boundary and orthogonal-to-boundary alignments. Our results show that the presence of the boundary generally inhibits mutual information harvesting relative to that in flat spacetime without any boundaries. In contrast, the boundary may play a doubled-edged role in entanglement harvesting, i.e., inhibiting entanglement harvesting in the near zone of the boundary while assisting it in the far zone of the boundary. Moreover, there exists an optimal detector energy gap difference between two nonidentical detectors that makes such detectors advantageous in correlations harvesting as long as the interdetector separation is large enough. The value of the optimal detector energy gap difference depends on both the interdetector separation and the detector-to-boundary distance. A comparison of the correlations harvesting in two different alignments shows that although correlations harvesting share qualitatively the same properties, they also display quantitative differences in that the detectors in orthogonal-to-boundary alignment always harvest comparatively more mutual information than the parallel-to-boundary ones, while they harvest comparatively more entanglement only near the boundary.