Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2108.03223 · Physical Review A

Mitigating off-resonant error in the cross-resonance gate

Moein Malekakhlagh, Easwar Magesan

Published Jan 4, 2022• 30 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

An off-resonant error for a driven quantum system refers to interactions due to the input drives having nonzero spectral overlap with unwanted system transitions. For the cross-resonance gate, this includes leakage as well as off-diagonal computational interactions that lead to bit-flip error on the control qubit. In this paper, we quantify an off-resonant error, with more focus on the less studied off-diagonal control interactions, for a direct controlled-not (cnot) gate implementation. Our results are based on a numerical simulation of the dynamics while we demonstrate the connection to time-dependent Schrieffer-Wolff and Magnus perturbation theories. We present two methods for suppressing such error terms. First, pulse parameters need to be optimized so off-resonant transition frequencies coincide with the local minima due to the pulse spectrum sidebands. Second, we show the advantage of a $Y$-DRAG pulse on the control qubit in mitigating the off-resonant error. Depending on qubit-qubit detuning, the proposed methods can improve the average off-resonant error from approximately ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$ closer to the ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$ level for a direct cnot calibration.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.105.012602

Related papers

First-principles analysis of cross-resonance gate operation

Moein Malekakhlagh, Easwar Magesan, David C. McKay

We present a comprehensive theoretical study of the cross-resonance gate operation covering estimates for gate parameters and gate error as well as analyzing spectator qubits and multiqubit frequency collisions. Starting from the Josephson nonlinearity and by accounting for the eigenstates renormalization, due to counterrotating terms, we derive a starting model for the cross-resonance gate with modified qubit-qubit interaction and drive matrix elements. Employing time-dependent Schrieffer-Wolff perturbation theory, we derive an effective Hamiltonian for the cross-resonance gate with estimates for the gate parameters calculated up to the fourth order in drive amplitude. The model with renormalized eigenstates lead to 10%--15% relative correction of the effective gate parameters compared to Kerr theory. We find that gate operation is strongly dependent on the ratio of qubit-qubit detuning and anharmonicity. In particular, we characterize five distinct regions of operation, and propose candidate parameter choices for achieving high gate speed and low coherent gate error when the cross-resonance tone is equipped with an echo pulse sequence. Furthermore, we generalize our method to include a third spectator qubit and characterize possible detrimental multiqubit frequency collisions.

arXiv:2005.00133•Physical Review A•Oct 13, 2020•131 citations

Pulse Shaping for Superconducting Qubits

Animesh Patra, Ankur Raina

High-fidelity control of superconducting qubits requires carefully shaped microwave pulses to avoid several different kinds of error at once. This article is a pedagogical bridging text aimed at upper-level undergraduate and early graduate students who have completed an introductory quantum mechanics course and a first course in quantum computing or quantum information, but who have not yet encountered the physical implementation of qubit gates. We integrate physical intuition for pulse design, analytical gate-level descriptions, and practical hardware considerations into a single, derivation-driven narrative, with explicit learning objectives. We begin with simple pulse envelopes and their spectral properties, showing how finite bandwidth produces leakage outside the computational subspace. This motivates the derivative removal by adiabatic gate (DRAG) technique, which we derive explicitly using the Magnus expansion, obtaining a clear, order-by-order account of which physical error channel appears at which order and why DRAG's cancellation is necessarily incomplete. We discuss the practical hardware realities of control pulse generation, focusing on arbitrary waveform generators (AWG), local oscillators (LO), and IQ mixing. Finally, we extend the discussion to two-qubit operation via the cross-resonance gate, and interpret how driving the control qubit at the target qubit's transition frequency necessarily produces several unwanted interaction terms alongside the desired one, and how successive generations of pulse-engineering strategies have been designed to suppress them.

quant-pharXiv:2604.21565•Apr 24, 2026•0 citations

Fast Z Z -free entangling gates for superconducting qubits assisted by a driven resonator

Ziwen Huang, Tae-Yoon Kim, Tanay Roy +4 more

Engineering high-fidelity two-qubit gates is an indispensable step toward practical quantum computing. For superconducting quantum platforms, one important setback is the stray interaction between qubits, which causes significant coherent errors. For transmon qubits, protocols for mitigating such errors usually involve fine-tuning the hardware parameters or introducing usually noisy flux-tunable couplers. In this work, we propose a simple scheme to cancel these stray interactions. The coupler used for such cancelation is a driven high-coherence resonator, where the amplitude and frequency of the drive serve as control knobs. Through the resonator-induced-phase interaction, the static $ZZ$ coupling can be entirely neutralized. We numerically show that such a scheme can enable short and high-fidelity entangling gates, including cross-resonance controlled-not (cnot) gates within 40 ns and adiabatic controlled-$Z$ gates within 140 ns. Our architecture is not only $ZZ$-free, but also contains no extra noisy components, such that it preserves the coherence times of fixed-frequency transmon qubits. With the state-of-the-art coherence times, the error of our cross-resonance cnot gate can be reduced to below ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$.

Physical Review Applied•Sep 4, 2024•6 citations

Ultrafast Single Qubit Gates through Multi-Photon Transition Removal

Y. Gao, A. Galicia, J. D. Da Costa Jesus +12 more

One of the main enablers in quantum computing is having qubit control that is precise and fast. However, qubits typically have multilevel structures making them prone to unwanted transitions from fast gates. This leakage out of the computational subspace is especially detrimental to algorithms as it has been observed to cause long-lived errors, such as in quantum error correction. This forces a choice between either achieving fast gates or having low leakage. Previous works focus on suppressing leakage by mitigating the first to second excited state transition, overlooking multi-photon transitions, and achieving faster gates with further reductions in leakage has remained elusive. Here, we demonstrate single qubit gates with a total leakage error consistently below $2.0\times10^{-5}$, and obtain fidelities above $99.98\%$ for pulse durations down to 6.8 ns for both $X$ and $X/2$ gates. This is achieved by removing direct transitions beyond nearest-neighbor levels using a double recursive implementation of the Derivative Removal by Adiabatic Gate (DRAG) method, which we name the R2D method. Moreover, we find that at such short gate durations and strong driving strengths the main error source is from these higher order transitions. This is all shown in the widely-used superconducting transmon qubit, which has a weakly anharmonic level structure and suffers from higher order transitions significantly. We also introduce an approach for amplifying leakage error that can precisely quantify leakage rates below $10^{-6}$. The presented approach can be readily applied to other qubit types as well.

quant-pharXiv:2511.22365•Nature Communications•Nov 28, 2025•0 citations

Robust Optimal Control of the Cross-Resonance Gate in Superconducting Qubits

Allen, Joseph

Superconducting circuits are one of the leading architectures in quantum computing. To undertake quantum computing one must be able to perform quantum gates; however, two-qubit gates are still limited in fidelity and gate time. The cross-resonance gate is a two-qubit gate that uses direct microwave drives and has seen much success in its implementation; but, there are theoretical indications that it has not yet reached the coherence limited fidelity value and its gate time is still relatively long compared with other quantum gate methods. Quantum optimal control theory is a powerful tool in the design of controls for quantum operations and has shown the capability to improve gate fidelities and reduce gate times. Robust quantum optimal control methodologies have further built on this to develop high fidelity quantum gates that are robust to uncertainties and noise in the system. In this thesis we use robust quantum optimal control theory to achieve these goals for the cross-resonance gate in a variety of superconducting qubit architectures. First, we investigate two superconducting qubits embedded in a common 3D microwave cavity in which the control drive is implemented via the common cavity mode of the cavity. We determine pulse shapes that implement the cross-resonance gate that are robust to uncertainty in the qubit transition frequencies for both a strictly two-level superconducting qubit and a three-level qubit. Second, we look at the cross-resonance gate with direct drives on each qubit, finding the minimal time to perform the cross-resonance gate with pulses that are robust to uncertainty in a measured system parameter for three cases: two three-level qubits with no drive crosstalk, two three-level qubits with some drive crosstalk, and two two-level qubits. Lastly, we report on simulations undertaken towards implementing a robust, high fidelity cross-resonance gate in a novel superconducting quantum device known as the coaxmon.

•Jul 15, 2019•1 citation

Reducing Leakage of Single-Qubit Gates for Superconducting Quantum Processors Using Analytical Control Pulse Envelopes

Eric Hyyppä, Antti P. Vepsäläinen, Miha Papič +10 more

Improving the speed and fidelity of quantum logic gates is essential to reach quantum advantage with future quantum computers. However, fast logic gates lead to increased leakage errors in superconducting quantum processors based on qubits with low anharmonicity, such as transmons. To reduce leakage errors, we propose and experimentally demonstrate two new analytical methods, Fourier ansatz spectrum tuning derivative removal by adiabatic gate (FAST DRAG) and higher-derivative (HD) DRAG, both of which enable shaping single-qubit control pulses in the frequency domain to achieve stronger suppression of leakage transitions compared to previously demonstrated pulse shapes. Using the new methods to suppress the e f transition of a transmon qubit with an anharmonicity of − 212 MHz, we implement R X ( π / 2 ) gates achieving a leakage error below 3.0 × 10 − 5 down to a gate duration of 6.25 ns without the need for iterative closed-loop optimization. The obtained leakage error represents a 20-fold reduction in leakage compared to a conventional cosine DRAG pulse. Employing the FAST DRAG method, we further achieve an error per gate of ( 1.56 ± 0.07 ) × 10 − 4 at a 7.9-ns gate duration, outperforming conventional pulse shapes both in terms of error and gate speed. Furthermore, we study error-amplifying measurements for the characterization of temporal microwave control-pulse distortions, and demonstrate that non-Markovian coherent errors caused by such distortions may be a significant source of error for sub-10-ns single-qubit gates unless corrected using predistortion. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2402.17757•PRX Quantum•Sep 19, 2024•67 citations
An off-resonant error for a driven quantum system refers to interactions due to the input drives having nonzero spectral overlap with unwanted system transitions. For the cross-resonance gate, this includes leakage as well as off-diagonal computational interactions that lead to bit-flip error on the control qubit. In this paper, we quantify an off-resonant error, with more focus on the less studied off-diagonal control interactions, for a direct controlled-not (cnot) gate implementation. Our results are based on a numerical simulation of the dynamics while we demonstrate the connection to time-dependent Schrieffer-Wolff and Magnus perturbation theories. We present two methods for suppressing such error terms. First, pulse parameters need to be optimized so off-resonant transition frequencies coincide with the local minima due to the pulse spectrum sidebands. Second, we show the advantage of a YYY-DRAG pulse on the control qubit in mitigating the off-resonant error. Depending on qubit-qubit detuning, the proposed methods can improve the average off-resonant error from approximately 10\ensuremath−3{10}^{\ensuremath{-}3}10\ensuremath−3 closer to the 10\ensuremath−4{10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}10\ensuremath−4 level for a direct cnot calibration.
We present a comprehensive theoretical study of the cross-resonance gate operation covering estimates for gate parameters and gate error as well as analyzing spectator qubits and multiqubit frequency collisions. Starting from the Josephson nonlinearity and by accounting for the eigenstates renormalization, due to counterrotating terms, we derive a starting model for the cross-resonance gate with modified qubit-qubit interaction and drive matrix elements. Employing time-dependent Schrieffer-Wolff perturbation theory, we derive an effective Hamiltonian for the cross-resonance gate with estimates for the gate parameters calculated up to the fourth order in drive amplitude. The model with renormalized eigenstates lead to 10%--15% relative correction of the effective gate parameters compared to Kerr theory. We find that gate operation is strongly dependent on the ratio of qubit-qubit detuning and anharmonicity. In particular, we characterize five distinct regions of operation, and propose candidate parameter choices for achieving high gate speed and low coherent gate error when the cross-resonance tone is equipped with an echo pulse sequence. Furthermore, we generalize our method to include a third spectator qubit and characterize possible detrimental multiqubit frequency collisions.
High-fidelity control of superconducting qubits requires carefully shaped microwave pulses to avoid several different kinds of error at once. This article is a pedagogical bridging text aimed at upper-level undergraduate and early graduate students who have completed an introductory quantum mechanics course and a first course in quantum computing or quantum information, but who have not yet encountered the physical implementation of qubit gates. We integrate physical intuition for pulse design, analytical gate-level descriptions, and practical hardware considerations into a single, derivation-driven narrative, with explicit learning objectives. We begin with simple pulse envelopes and their spectral properties, showing how finite bandwidth produces leakage outside the computational subspace. This motivates the derivative removal by adiabatic gate (DRAG) technique, which we derive explicitly using the Magnus expansion, obtaining a clear, order-by-order account of which physical error channel appears at which order and why DRAG's cancellation is necessarily incomplete. We discuss the practical hardware realities of control pulse generation, focusing on arbitrary waveform generators (AWG), local oscillators (LO), and IQ mixing. Finally, we extend the discussion to two-qubit operation via the cross-resonance gate, and interpret how driving the control qubit at the target qubit's transition frequency necessarily produces several unwanted interaction terms alongside the desired one, and how successive generations of pulse-engineering strategies have been designed to suppress them.
Engineering high-fidelity two-qubit gates is an indispensable step toward practical quantum computing. For superconducting quantum platforms, one important setback is the stray interaction between qubits, which causes significant coherent errors. For transmon qubits, protocols for mitigating such errors usually involve fine-tuning the hardware parameters or introducing usually noisy flux-tunable couplers. In this work, we propose a simple scheme to cancel these stray interactions. The coupler used for such cancelation is a driven high-coherence resonator, where the amplitude and frequency of the drive serve as control knobs. Through the resonator-induced-phase interaction, the static ZZZZZZ coupling can be entirely neutralized. We numerically show that such a scheme can enable short and high-fidelity entangling gates, including cross-resonance controlled-not (cnot) gates within 40 ns and adiabatic controlled-ZZZ gates within 140 ns. Our architecture is not only ZZZZZZ-free, but also contains no extra noisy components, such that it preserves the coherence times of fixed-frequency transmon qubits. With the state-of-the-art coherence times, the error of our cross-resonance cnot gate can be reduced to below ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$.
One of the main enablers in quantum computing is having qubit control that is precise and fast. However, qubits typically have multilevel structures making them prone to unwanted transitions from fast gates. This leakage out of the computational subspace is especially detrimental to algorithms as it has been observed to cause long-lived errors, such as in quantum error correction. This forces a choice between either achieving fast gates or having low leakage. Previous works focus on suppressing leakage by mitigating the first to second excited state transition, overlooking multi-photon transitions, and achieving faster gates with further reductions in leakage has remained elusive. Here, we demonstrate single qubit gates with a total leakage error consistently below 2.0×10−52.0\times10^{-5}2.0×10−5, and obtain fidelities above 99.98%99.98\%99.98% for pulse durations down to 6.8 ns for both XXX and X/2X/2X/2 gates. This is achieved by removing direct transitions beyond nearest-neighbor levels using a double recursive implementation of the Derivative Removal by Adiabatic Gate (DRAG) method, which we name the R2D method. Moreover, we find that at such short gate durations and strong driving strengths the main error source is from these higher order transitions. This is all shown in the widely-used superconducting transmon qubit, which has a weakly anharmonic level structure and suffers from higher order transitions significantly. We also introduce an approach for amplifying leakage error that can precisely quantify leakage rates below 10−610^{-6}10−6. The presented approach can be readily applied to other qubit types as well.
Superconducting circuits are one of the leading architectures in quantum computing. To undertake quantum computing one must be able to perform quantum gates; however, two-qubit gates are still limited in fidelity and gate time. The cross-resonance gate is a two-qubit gate that uses direct microwave drives and has seen much success in its implementation; but, there are theoretical indications that it has not yet reached the coherence limited fidelity value and its gate time is still relatively long compared with other quantum gate methods. Quantum optimal control theory is a powerful tool in the design of controls for quantum operations and has shown the capability to improve gate fidelities and reduce gate times. Robust quantum optimal control methodologies have further built on this to develop high fidelity quantum gates that are robust to uncertainties and noise in the system. In this thesis we use robust quantum optimal control theory to achieve these goals for the cross-resonance gate in a variety of superconducting qubit architectures. First, we investigate two superconducting qubits embedded in a common 3D microwave cavity in which the control drive is implemented via the common cavity mode of the cavity. We determine pulse shapes that implement the cross-resonance gate that are robust to uncertainty in the qubit transition frequencies for both a strictly two-level superconducting qubit and a three-level qubit. Second, we look at the cross-resonance gate with direct drives on each qubit, finding the minimal time to perform the cross-resonance gate with pulses that are robust to uncertainty in a measured system parameter for three cases: two three-level qubits with no drive crosstalk, two three-level qubits with some drive crosstalk, and two two-level qubits. Lastly, we report on simulations undertaken towards implementing a robust, high fidelity cross-resonance gate in a novel superconducting quantum device known as the coaxmon.
Improving the speed and fidelity of quantum logic gates is essential to reach quantum advantage with future quantum computers. However, fast logic gates lead to increased leakage errors in superconducting quantum processors based on qubits with low anharmonicity, such as transmons. To reduce leakage errors, we propose and experimentally demonstrate two new analytical methods, Fourier ansatz spectrum tuning derivative removal by adiabatic gate (FAST DRAG) and higher-derivative (HD) DRAG, both of which enable shaping single-qubit control pulses in the frequency domain to achieve stronger suppression of leakage transitions compared to previously demonstrated pulse shapes. Using the new methods to suppress the e f transition of a transmon qubit with an anharmonicity of − 212 MHz, we implement R X ( π / 2 ) gates achieving a leakage error below 3.0 × 10 − 5 down to a gate duration of 6.25 ns without the need for iterative closed-loop optimization. The obtained leakage error represents a 20-fold reduction in leakage compared to a conventional cosine DRAG pulse. Employing the FAST DRAG method, we further achieve an error per gate of ( 1.56 ± 0.07 ) × 10 − 4 at a 7.9-ns gate duration, outperforming conventional pulse shapes both in terms of error and gate speed. Furthermore, we study error-amplifying measurements for the characterization of temporal microwave control-pulse distortions, and demonstrate that non-Markovian coherent errors caused by such distortions may be a significant source of error for sub-10-ns single-qubit gates unless corrected using predistortion. Published by the American Physical Society 2024