Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2107.14687 · The European Physical Journal A

Finite-temperature infinite matter with effective-field-theory-inspired energy-density functionals

S. Burrello, M. Grasso

Published Feb 1, 2022• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Finite-temperature infinite matter is analyzed with the recently introduced effective-field-theory(EFT)-inspired YGLO (Yang–Grasso–Lacroix–Orsay) and ELYO (extended Lee–Yang, Orsay) functionals, which are designed to describe very low-density regimes in symmetric (YGLO) and in pure neutron (YGLO and ELYO) matter. The article deals with neutron matter and aims to verify whether the use of these functionals allows us to correctly incorporate finite-temperature effects. We compare our results for some relevant thermodynamical quantities with the corresponding ones computed with a chosen reference ab-initio model, namely the many-body-perturbation-theory scheme. We validate the reliability of both EFT-inspired functionals at least at rather low densities and not too high temperatures and we discuss the effects related to the effective mass. We conclude that, at the present stage, the ELYO functional, having a higher neutron effective mass around saturation (closer to ab-initio values), allows us to describe finite-temperature properties more satisfactorily, in better agreement with ab-initio predictions up to higher densities and temperatures, compared to YGLO.

DOI
10.1140/epja/s10050-022-00665-2

Related papers

Energy-density functionals inspired by effective-field theories: Applications to neutron drops

J. Bonnard, M. Grasso, Denis Lacroix A

New energy-density functionals (EDFs) inspired by effective-field theories have been recently proposed. The present work focuses on three such functionals, which were developed to produce satisfactory equations of state for nuclear matter. We aim to extend these functionals to treat finite systems including a spin-orbit contribution and pairing correlations. We illustrate here a first step toward this direction, namely a generalization of such functionals tailored to perform applications to neutron gases confined in harmonic traps. Sets of available ab initio results are used as benchmark pseudodata for adjusting the additional parameters (with respect to the nuclear matter case) that have to be introduced for finite-size systems. Several quantities are predicted and compared to ab initio and other EDF results such as total energies, potentials, and density profiles. The associated effective masses are also analyzed. Two of these functionals globally provide predictions that are close to one another as well as to ab initio values when available. It is shown that, in general, this is not the case for several currently used Skyrme functionals. Directions for improving the third functional are discussed.

arXiv:1806.01084•Physical Review C•Sep 24, 2018•28 citations

Lattice calculation of thermal properties of low-density neutron matter with pionless NN effective field theory

Takumi Abe, R. Seki

Thermal properties of low-density neutron matter are investigated by determinantal quantum Monte Carlo lattice calculations on 3+1 dimensional cubic lattices. Nuclear effective field theory (EFT) is applied using the pionless single- and two-parameter neutron-neutron interactions, determined from the ${}^{1}{S}_{0}$ scattering length and effective range. The determination of the interactions and the calculations of neutron matter are carried out consistently by applying EFT power counting rules. The thermodynamic limit is taken by the method of finite-size scaling, and the continuum limit is examined in the vanishing lattice filling limit. The ${}^{1}{S}_{0}$ pairing gap at $T\ensuremath{\approx}0$ is computed directly from the off-diagonal long-range order of the spin pair-pair correlation function and is found to be approximately 30% smaller than BCS calculations with the conventional nucleon-nucleon potentials. The critical temperature ${T}_{c}$ of the normal-to-superfluid phase transition and the pairing temperature scale ${T}^{*}$ are determined, and the temperature-density phase diagram is constructed. The physics of low-density neutron matter is clearly identified as being a BCS-Bose-Einstein condensation crossover.

arXiv:0708.2523•Physical Review C•May 11, 2009•56 citations

Many-body approximations to the superfluid gap and critical temperature in pure neutron matter

M. Drissi, Arnau Rios

Abstract We compute singlet pairing gaps and critical temperatures in pure neutron matter with different many-body approximations. Medium effects tend to reduce gaps and critical temperatures compared to the standard BCS ansatz. In the mean-field approximation, the ratio of these two quantities remains constant across a wide range of densities. This constant ratio is close to the universal prediction of BCS theory, whether three-neutron interactions are included or not. Using a more sophisticated many-body approach that incorporates the effect of short-range correlations in pairing properties, we find that the gap to critical temperature ratio in the low-density regime is substantially larger than the BCS prediction, independently of the interaction. In this region, our results are relatively close to experiments and theoretical calculations from the unitary Fermi gas. We also find evidence for a different density dependence of zero-temperature gaps and critical temperatures in neutron matter.

arXiv:2202.07501•The European Physical Journal A•May 12, 2022•14 citations

Quantum Monte Carlo calculations with chiral effective field theory interactions

Ingo Tews

The neutron-matter equation of state connects several physical systems over a wide density range, from cold atomic gases in the unitary limit at low densities, to neutron-rich nuclei at intermediate densities, up to neutron stars which reach supranuclear densities in their core. An accurate description of the neutron-matter equation of state is therefore crucial to describe these systems. To calculate the neutron-matter equation of state reliably, precise many-body methods in combination with a systematic theory for nuclear forces are needed. Chiral effective field theory (EFT) is such a theory. It provides a systematic framework for the description of low-energy hadronic interactions and enables calculations with controlled theoretical uncertainties. Chiral EFT makes use of a momentum-space expansion of nuclear forces based on the symmetries of Quantum Chromodynamics, which is the fundamental theory of strong interactions. In chiral EFT, the description of nuclear forces can be systematically improved by going to higher orders in the chiral expansion. On the other hand, continuum Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods are among the most precise many-body methods available to study strongly interacting systems at finite densities. They treat the Schrödinger equation as a diffusion equation in imaginary time and project out the ground-state wave function of the system starting from a trial wave function by propagating the system in imaginary time. To perform this propagation, continuum QMC methods require as input local interactions. However, chiral EFT, which is naturally formulated in momentum space, contains several sources of nonlocality. In this Thesis, we show how to construct local chiral two-nucleon (NN) and three-nucleon (3N) interactions and discuss results of first QMC calculations for pure neutron systems. We have performed systematic auxiliary-field diffusion Monte Carlo (AFDMC) calculations for neutron matter using local chiral NN interactions. By comparing these results with many-body perturbation theory (MBPT), we can study the perturbative convergence of local chiral interactions. We have shown that soft, low-cutoff potentials converge well and can be reliably used in MBPT, while harder potentials are less perturbative and have to be treated within AFDMC. We have also derived consistent local chiral 3N interactions and study these forces in detail. Our results show that local regulators lead to less repulsion from 3N forces compared to nonlocal 3N forces. Finally, we present the neutron-matter equation of state based on local chiral NN and 3N interactions using the AFDMC method as well as results for light nuclei and neutron drops. This work paves the way for systematic QMC calculations with chiral EFT interactions for nuclei and nucleonic matter.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

From bare interactions, low-energy constants, and unitary gas to nuclear density functionals without free parameters: Application to neutron matter

Denis Lacroix A, Antoine Boulet, M. Grasso +1 more

We further progress along the line of Ref. [D. Lacroix, Phys. Rev. A 94, 043614 (2016)] where a functional for Fermi systems with anomalously large $s$-wave scattering length ${a}_{s}$ was proposed that has no free parameters. The functional is designed to correctly reproduce the unitary limit in Fermi gases together with the leading-order contributions in the $s$- and $p$-wave channels at low density. The functional is shown to be predictive up to densities $\ensuremath{\sim}0.01 {\mathrm{fm}}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$ that is much higher densities compared to the Lee-Yang functional, valid for $\ensuremath{\rho}<{10}^{\ensuremath{-}6} {\mathrm{fm}}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$. The form of the functional retained in this work is further motivated. It is shown that the new functional corresponds to an expansion of the energy in $({a}_{s}{k}_{F})$ and $({r}_{e}{k}_{F})$ to all orders, where ${r}_{e}$ is the effective range and ${k}_{F}$ is the Fermi momentum. One conclusion from the present work is that, except in the extremely low-density regime, nuclear systems can be treated perturbatively in $\ensuremath{-}{({a}_{s}{k}_{F})}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ with respect to the unitary limit. Starting from the functional, we introduce density-dependent scales and show that scales associated with the bare interaction are strongly renormalized by medium effects. As a consequence, some of the scales at play around saturation are dominated by the unitary gas properties and not directly by low-energy constants. For instance, we show that the scale in the $s$-wave channel around saturation is proportional to the so-called Bertsch parameter ${\ensuremath{\xi}}_{0}$ and becomes independent of ${a}_{s}$. We also point out that these scales are of the same order of magnitude than those empirically obtained in the Skyrme energy density functional. We finally propose a slight modification of the functional such that it becomes accurate up to the saturation density $\ensuremath{\rho}\ensuremath{\simeq}0.16 {\mathrm{fm}}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$.

arXiv:1704.08454•Physical Review C•May 9, 2017•25 citations

Finite-Temperature Green's Function Methods for ab-initio Quantum Chemistry: Thermodynamics, Spectra, and Quantum Embedding

Alicia Welden

Description of electron correlation is crucial to chemical accuracy in quantum chemical calculations. However, the interaction of electrons in a system is an insoluble many-body problem. Constructing approximations to describe electron correlation is a challenging task, but there has been success in the quantum chemistry community using wavefunction methods and density functional theory. However, there are still challenges to be overcome in areas such as theoretical solid state chemistry, which requires description of large systems and the use of finite temperature. Large system sizes and finite temperature can be difficult to treat solely with the currently available methods. Therefore, a new class of methods, based on the temperature-dependent Green's function, is implemented and explored. This thesis is toward investigating the use of temperature-dependent Green's functions for ab-initio quantum chemistry. That is, we are treating a quantum chemical Hamiltonian with realistic electron interactions. While this formalism has been applied to model systems in the condensed matter community, its has been used much less by the quantum chemistry community. Therefore, the numerical behavior and accuracy of Green's function methods for quantum chemical calculations is relatively unknown. This work investigates the ability of the temperature-dependent Green's function, which is an ensemble formalism, to give access to temperature dependent thermodynamic quantities such as free energy and entropy when calculated in a second-order and perturbative manner (GF2). We find that this method is able to give good accuracy for lower temperatures and excellent accuracy for higher temperatures for a molecular case and is able to qualitatively describe a simple model of a solid. The results of this work are presented in chapter 3. Although Green's functions have a clear connection with spectra at zero temperature, it is not straight forward to obtain spectra from the finite temperature Green's function, which is calculated on the imaginary frequency axis. Therefore, we must investigate methods to obtain spectral quantities in a consistent and reliable manner from the imaginary axis. Chapter 4 investigates several methods to do so and we compare our results with experimental and highly accurate benchmark data. We find that it is possible to obtain spectral quantities that can differ by several electron volts, even if the same level of theory is used to obtain the Green's function. This reiterates that finding a spectrum from the imaginary axis is nontrivial and that one must exercise caution when comparing spectral quantities that were calculated using different techniques, even if they are treated with the same theoretical accuracy. Accessing larger systems with the Green's function requires the use of quantum embedding. Quantum embedding describes nontrivial electron interaction between a highly accurate ``active space'' or ``impurity'' and a larger, lower level ``environment''. It is challenging to construct an impurity solver that is reliable at low temperatures. In chapter 5 of this work, we implement and test a temperature dependent configuration interaction impurity solver for quantum embedding. This solver can be used in quantum embedding schemes such as dynamical mean field theory and self-energy embedding theory for larger systems. Overall, this thesis has made progress toward using Green's functions for ab-initio quantum chemistry at finite temperature. Groundwork has been laid for using this formalism to calculate thermodynamics and spectra using a Green's function with realistic electron interactions and to explore quantum embedding using an impurity solver at low temperatures.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations
Abstract Finite-temperature infinite matter is analyzed with the recently introduced effective-field-theory(EFT)-inspired YGLO (Yang–Grasso–Lacroix–Orsay) and ELYO (extended Lee–Yang, Orsay) functionals, which are designed to describe very low-density regimes in symmetric (YGLO) and in pure neutron (YGLO and ELYO) matter. The article deals with neutron matter and aims to verify whether the use of these functionals allows us to correctly incorporate finite-temperature effects. We compare our results for some relevant thermodynamical quantities with the corresponding ones computed with a chosen reference ab-initio model, namely the many-body-perturbation-theory scheme. We validate the reliability of both EFT-inspired functionals at least at rather low densities and not too high temperatures and we discuss the effects related to the effective mass. We conclude that, at the present stage, the ELYO functional, having a higher neutron effective mass around saturation (closer to ab-initio values), allows us to describe finite-temperature properties more satisfactorily, in better agreement with ab-initio predictions up to higher densities and temperatures, compared to YGLO.
New energy-density functionals (EDFs) inspired by effective-field theories have been recently proposed. The present work focuses on three such functionals, which were developed to produce satisfactory equations of state for nuclear matter. We aim to extend these functionals to treat finite systems including a spin-orbit contribution and pairing correlations. We illustrate here a first step toward this direction, namely a generalization of such functionals tailored to perform applications to neutron gases confined in harmonic traps. Sets of available ab initio results are used as benchmark pseudodata for adjusting the additional parameters (with respect to the nuclear matter case) that have to be introduced for finite-size systems. Several quantities are predicted and compared to ab initio and other EDF results such as total energies, potentials, and density profiles. The associated effective masses are also analyzed. Two of these functionals globally provide predictions that are close to one another as well as to ab initio values when available. It is shown that, in general, this is not the case for several currently used Skyrme functionals. Directions for improving the third functional are discussed.
Thermal properties of low-density neutron matter are investigated by determinantal quantum Monte Carlo lattice calculations on 3+1 dimensional cubic lattices. Nuclear effective field theory (EFT) is applied using the pionless single- and two-parameter neutron-neutron interactions, determined from the 1S0{}^{1}{S}_{0}1S0​ scattering length and effective range. The determination of the interactions and the calculations of neutron matter are carried out consistently by applying EFT power counting rules. The thermodynamic limit is taken by the method of finite-size scaling, and the continuum limit is examined in the vanishing lattice filling limit. The 1S0{}^{1}{S}_{0}1S0​ pairing gap at $T\ensuremath{\approx}0$ is computed directly from the off-diagonal long-range order of the spin pair-pair correlation function and is found to be approximately 30% smaller than BCS calculations with the conventional nucleon-nucleon potentials. The critical temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ of the normal-to-superfluid phase transition and the pairing temperature scale T∗{T}^{*}T∗ are determined, and the temperature-density phase diagram is constructed. The physics of low-density neutron matter is clearly identified as being a BCS-Bose-Einstein condensation crossover.
Abstract We compute singlet pairing gaps and critical temperatures in pure neutron matter with different many-body approximations. Medium effects tend to reduce gaps and critical temperatures compared to the standard BCS ansatz. In the mean-field approximation, the ratio of these two quantities remains constant across a wide range of densities. This constant ratio is close to the universal prediction of BCS theory, whether three-neutron interactions are included or not. Using a more sophisticated many-body approach that incorporates the effect of short-range correlations in pairing properties, we find that the gap to critical temperature ratio in the low-density regime is substantially larger than the BCS prediction, independently of the interaction. In this region, our results are relatively close to experiments and theoretical calculations from the unitary Fermi gas. We also find evidence for a different density dependence of zero-temperature gaps and critical temperatures in neutron matter.
The neutron-matter equation of state connects several physical systems over a wide density range, from cold atomic gases in the unitary limit at low densities, to neutron-rich nuclei at intermediate densities, up to neutron stars which reach supranuclear densities in their core. An accurate description of the neutron-matter equation of state is therefore crucial to describe these systems. To calculate the neutron-matter equation of state reliably, precise many-body methods in combination with a systematic theory for nuclear forces are needed. Chiral effective field theory (EFT) is such a theory. It provides a systematic framework for the description of low-energy hadronic interactions and enables calculations with controlled theoretical uncertainties. Chiral EFT makes use of a momentum-space expansion of nuclear forces based on the symmetries of Quantum Chromodynamics, which is the fundamental theory of strong interactions. In chiral EFT, the description of nuclear forces can be systematically improved by going to higher orders in the chiral expansion. On the other hand, continuum Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods are among the most precise many-body methods available to study strongly interacting systems at finite densities. They treat the Schrödinger equation as a diffusion equation in imaginary time and project out the ground-state wave function of the system starting from a trial wave function by propagating the system in imaginary time. To perform this propagation, continuum QMC methods require as input local interactions. However, chiral EFT, which is naturally formulated in momentum space, contains several sources of nonlocality. In this Thesis, we show how to construct local chiral two-nucleon (NN) and three-nucleon (3N) interactions and discuss results of first QMC calculations for pure neutron systems. We have performed systematic auxiliary-field diffusion Monte Carlo (AFDMC) calculations for neutron matter using local chiral NN interactions. By comparing these results with many-body perturbation theory (MBPT), we can study the perturbative convergence of local chiral interactions. We have shown that soft, low-cutoff potentials converge well and can be reliably used in MBPT, while harder potentials are less perturbative and have to be treated within AFDMC. We have also derived consistent local chiral 3N interactions and study these forces in detail. Our results show that local regulators lead to less repulsion from 3N forces compared to nonlocal 3N forces. Finally, we present the neutron-matter equation of state based on local chiral NN and 3N interactions using the AFDMC method as well as results for light nuclei and neutron drops. This work paves the way for systematic QMC calculations with chiral EFT interactions for nuclei and nucleonic matter.
We further progress along the line of Ref. [D. Lacroix, Phys. Rev. A 94, 043614 (2016)] where a functional for Fermi systems with anomalously large sss-wave scattering length as{a}_{s}as​ was proposed that has no free parameters. The functional is designed to correctly reproduce the unitary limit in Fermi gases together with the leading-order contributions in the sss- and ppp-wave channels at low density. The functional is shown to be predictive up to densities $\ensuremath{\sim}0.01 {\mathrm{fm}}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$ that is much higher densities compared to the Lee-Yang functional, valid for $\ensuremath{\rho}<{10}^{\ensuremath{-}6} {\mathrm{fm}}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$. The form of the functional retained in this work is further motivated. It is shown that the new functional corresponds to an expansion of the energy in (askF)({a}_{s}{k}_{F})(as​kF​) and (rekF)({r}_{e}{k}_{F})(re​kF​) to all orders, where re{r}_{e}re​ is the effective range and kF{k}_{F}kF​ is the Fermi momentum. One conclusion from the present work is that, except in the extremely low-density regime, nuclear systems can be treated perturbatively in $\ensuremath{-}{({a}_{s}{k}_{F})}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ with respect to the unitary limit. Starting from the functional, we introduce density-dependent scales and show that scales associated with the bare interaction are strongly renormalized by medium effects. As a consequence, some of the scales at play around saturation are dominated by the unitary gas properties and not directly by low-energy constants. For instance, we show that the scale in the sss-wave channel around saturation is proportional to the so-called Bertsch parameter ${\ensuremath{\xi}}_{0}$ and becomes independent of as{a}_{s}as​. We also point out that these scales are of the same order of magnitude than those empirically obtained in the Skyrme energy density functional. We finally propose a slight modification of the functional such that it becomes accurate up to the saturation density $\ensuremath{\rho}\ensuremath{\simeq}0.16 {\mathrm{fm}}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$.
Description of electron correlation is crucial to chemical accuracy in quantum chemical calculations. However, the interaction of electrons in a system is an insoluble many-body problem. Constructing approximations to describe electron correlation is a challenging task, but there has been success in the quantum chemistry community using wavefunction methods and density functional theory. However, there are still challenges to be overcome in areas such as theoretical solid state chemistry, which requires description of large systems and the use of finite temperature. Large system sizes and finite temperature can be difficult to treat solely with the currently available methods. Therefore, a new class of methods, based on the temperature-dependent Green's function, is implemented and explored. This thesis is toward investigating the use of temperature-dependent Green's functions for ab-initio quantum chemistry. That is, we are treating a quantum chemical Hamiltonian with realistic electron interactions. While this formalism has been applied to model systems in the condensed matter community, its has been used much less by the quantum chemistry community. Therefore, the numerical behavior and accuracy of Green's function methods for quantum chemical calculations is relatively unknown. This work investigates the ability of the temperature-dependent Green's function, which is an ensemble formalism, to give access to temperature dependent thermodynamic quantities such as free energy and entropy when calculated in a second-order and perturbative manner (GF2). We find that this method is able to give good accuracy for lower temperatures and excellent accuracy for higher temperatures for a molecular case and is able to qualitatively describe a simple model of a solid. The results of this work are presented in chapter 3. Although Green's functions have a clear connection with spectra at zero temperature, it is not straight forward to obtain spectra from the finite temperature Green's function, which is calculated on the imaginary frequency axis. Therefore, we must investigate methods to obtain spectral quantities in a consistent and reliable manner from the imaginary axis. Chapter 4 investigates several methods to do so and we compare our results with experimental and highly accurate benchmark data. We find that it is possible to obtain spectral quantities that can differ by several electron volts, even if the same level of theory is used to obtain the Green's function. This reiterates that finding a spectrum from the imaginary axis is nontrivial and that one must exercise caution when comparing spectral quantities that were calculated using different techniques, even if they are treated with the same theoretical accuracy. Accessing larger systems with the Green's function requires the use of quantum embedding. Quantum embedding describes nontrivial electron interaction between a highly accurate ``active space'' or ``impurity'' and a larger, lower level ``environment''. It is challenging to construct an impurity solver that is reliable at low temperatures. In chapter 5 of this work, we implement and test a temperature dependent configuration interaction impurity solver for quantum embedding. This solver can be used in quantum embedding schemes such as dynamical mean field theory and self-energy embedding theory for larger systems. Overall, this thesis has made progress toward using Green's functions for ab-initio quantum chemistry at finite temperature. Groundwork has been laid for using this formalism to calculate thermodynamics and spectra using a Green's function with realistic electron interactions and to explore quantum embedding using an impurity solver at low temperatures.