Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2107.10508

Multiple Query Optimization using a Hybrid Approach of Classical and Quantum Computing

Tobias Fankhauser, Marc E. Solèr, Rudolf Marcel Füchslin, Kurt Stockinger

Published Jul 22, 2021• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum computing promises to solve difficult optimization problems in chemistry, physics and mathematics more efficiently than classical computers, but requires fault-tolerant quantum computers with millions of qubits. To overcome errors introduced by today's quantum computers, hybrid algorithms combining classical and quantum computers are used. In this paper we tackle the multiple query optimization problem (MQO) which is an important NP-hard problem in the area of data-intensive problems. We propose a novel hybrid classical-quantum algorithm to solve the MQO on a gate-based quantum computer. We perform a detailed experimental evaluation of our algorithm and compare its performance against a competing approach that employs a quantum annealer -- another type of quantum computer. Our experimental results demonstrate that our algorithm currently can only handle small problem sizes due to the limited number of qubits available on a gate-based quantum computer compared to a quantum computer based on quantum annealing. However, our algorithm shows a qubit efficiency of close to 99% which is almost a factor of 2 higher compared to the state of the art implementation. Finally, we analyze how our algorithm scales with larger problem sizes and conclude that our approach shows promising results for near-term quantum computers.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2107.10508

Related papers

Multiple Query Optimization Using a Gate-Based Quantum Computer

Tobias Fankhauser, Marc E. Solèr, Rudolf Marcel Füchslin +1 more

Quantum computing promises to solve difficult optimization problems in chemistry, physics and mathematics more efficiently than classical computers. However, it requires fault-tolerant quantum computers with millions of qubits; a technological challenge still not mastered by engineers. To lower the barrier, hybrid algorithms combining classical and quantum computers are used, where quantum computing is only used for those parts of computation that cannot be solved efficiently otherwise. In this paper, we tackle the multiple query optimization problem (MQO), an important NP-hard problem in database research. We present an implementation based on a scheme called quantum approximate optimization algorithm to solve the MQO on a gate-based quantum computer. We perform a detailed experimental evaluation of our implementation and compare its performance against a competing approach that employs a quantum annealer – another type of quantum computer. Our implementation shows a qubit efficiency of close to 99%, which is almost a factor of 2 higher than the state-of-the-art implementation. We emphasize that the problems we can solve with current gate-based quantum technology are fairly small and might not seem practical yet compared to state-of-the-art classical query optimizers. However, our experiments on using a hybrid approach of classical and quantum computing show that our implementation scales favourably with larger problem sizes. Hence, we conclude that our approach shows promising results for near-term quantum computers and thus sets the stage for a challenging avenue of novel database research.

IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2023•17 citations

Multiple Query Optimization on the D-Wave 2X Adiabatic Quantum Computer

Immanuel Trummer, Christoph E. Koch

The D-Wave adiabatic quantum annealer solves hard combinatorial optimization problems leveraging quantum physics. The newest version features over 1000 qubits and was released in August 2015. We were given access to such a machine, currently hosted at NASA Ames Research Center in California, to explore the potential for hard optimization problems that arise in the context of databases. In this paper, we tackle the problem of multiple query optimization (MQO). We show how an MQO problem instance can be transformed into a mathematical formula that complies with the restrictive input format accepted by the quantum annealer. This formula is translated into weights on and between qubits such that the configuration minimizing the input formula can be found via a process called adiabatic quantum annealing. We analyze the asymptotic growth rate of the number of required qubits in the MQO problem dimensions as the number of qubits is currently the main factor restricting applicability. We experimentally compare the performance of the quantum annealer against other MQO algorithms executed on a traditional computer. While the problem sizes that can be treated are currently limited, we already find a class of problem instances where the quantum annealer is three orders of magnitude faster than other approaches.

arXiv:1510.06437•Oct 21, 2015•8 citations

Multiple query optimization on the D-Wave 2X adiabatic quantum computer

Immanuel Trummer, Christoph E. Koch

The D-Wave adiabatic quantum annealer solves hard combinatorial optimization problems leveraging quantum physics. The newest version features over 1000 qubits and was released in August 2015. We were given access to such a machine, currently hosted at NASA Ames Research Center in California, to explore the potential for hard optimization problems that arise in the context of databases. In this paper, we tackle the problem of multiple query optimization (MQO). We show how an MQO problem instance can be transformed into a mathematical formula that complies with the restrictive input format accepted by the quantum annealer. This formula is translated into weights on and between qubits such that the configuration minimizing the input formula can be found via a process called adiabatic quantum annealing. We analyze the asymptotic growth rate of the number of required qubits in the MQO problem dimensions as the number of qubits is currently the main factor restricting applicability. We experimentally compare the performance of the quantum annealer against other MQO algorithms executed on a traditional computer. While the problem sizes that can be treated are currently limited, we already find a class of problem instances where the quantum annealer is three orders of magnitude faster than other approaches.

Proceedings of the VLDB Endowment•May 1, 2016•75 citations

Large-Scale Multiple Query Optimisation with Incremental Quantum(-Inspired) Annealing

Manuel Schönberger, Immanuel Trummer, Wolfgang Mauerer

Multiple-query optimization (MQO) seeks to reduce redundant work across query batches. While MQO offers opportunities for dramatic performance improvements, the problem is NP-hard, limiting the sizes of problems that can be solved on generic hardware. We propose to leverage specialized hardware solvers for optimization, such as Fujitsu's Digital Annealer (DA), to scale up MQO to problem sizes formerly out of reach. We present a novel incremental processing approach that combines classical computation with DA acceleration. By efficiently partitioning MQO problems into sets of partial problems, and by applying a dynamic search steering strategy that reapplies initially discarded information to incrementally process individual problems, our method overcomes capacity limitations, and scales to extremely large MQO instances (up to νm1000 queries). A thorough and comprehensive empirical evaluation finds our method substantially outperforms existing approaches. Our generalisable framework lays the ground for other database use-cases on quantum-inspired hardware, and bridges towards future quantum accelerators.

Proceedings of the ACM on Management of Data•Sep 22, 2025•6 citations

Quantum-Classical Hybrid Algorithms for Complex Query Planning: A Scalable Computational Framework for High-Dimensional Decision Optimization in Heterogeneous Data Ecosystems

Parameswara Reddy Nangi, Chaithanya Kumar Reddy Nala Obannagari

The rapidly increasing number of heterogeneous data ecosystems, such as structured databases, semi-structured data lakes, real-time streams, distributed knowledge graphs, has further complicated the issue of query planning and optimization in modern information systems extensively. The optimization of queries is essentially an NP-hard combinatorial problem especially when based on multi-join queries, distributed execution plan, dynamic cost model, and uncertainty in the data access patterns. Even decades of concept and engineering advances, classical database optimizers are rapidly becoming unable to offer a globally optimal execution plan when faced with high-dimensional data, high data volatility, with a very tight latency constraint. Good news Recent breakthroughs in quantum computing propose promising computational paradigms that can be used to solve combinatorial optimization problems via quantum parallelism, superposition, and entanglement. Nevertheless, even the near-term quantum hardware is limited in the number of available qubits, noise, and decoherence, making it impractical to achieve fully quantum database systems in any perceived future. This is also the reason why quantum-classical hybrid algorithms are being developed: designed to add quantum optimization subroutines to classical database architectures is guaranteed without breaking their compatibility with existing execution engines. The following paper presents a framework of scalable quantum-classical hybrid computing of complex query planning in heterogeneous data ecosystems. The framework breaks down query optimization into classical and quantum-amenable optimization, which allows NP-hard subproblems, such as join ordering, operator placement, and cost minimization, to be transformed into quantum optimization models such as Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) and Ising Hamiltonians. Classical elements handle query parsing, semantic analysis, constraint verification, and orchestration, whereas quantum processors are called selectively to solve combinatorial decision-making tasks. The suggested architecture will consist of a layered execution, hybrid execution, cost-model encoding approach, and adaptive fallback mechanisms to make them robust to quantum hardware variability. This has been experimentally tested with simulated quantum annealing and variational quantum algorithms that exhibit a quantifiable improvement in the quality and scalability of optimization and heuristics based on entirely classical algorithms, especially in high-dimensional query plans. The findings confirm the practicability of quantum query optimization and put down a feasible route to implement quantum algorithms in the serving machine of the next-generation data management systems.

International Journal of AI BigData Computational and Management Studies•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Applicability of Quantum Computing on Database Query Optimization

Manuel Schönberger

We evaluate the applicability of quantum computing on two fundamental query optimization problems, join order optimization and multi query optimization (MQO). We analyze the problem dimensions that can be solved on current gate-based quantum systems and quantum annealers, the two currently commercially available architectures.

ACM SIGMOD International Conference on Management of Data (SIGMOD)•Jun 10, 2022•25 citations
Quantum computing promises to solve difficult optimization problems in chemistry, physics and mathematics more efficiently than classical computers, but requires fault-tolerant quantum computers with millions of qubits. To overcome errors introduced by today's quantum computers, hybrid algorithms combining classical and quantum computers are used. In this paper we tackle the multiple query optimization problem (MQO) which is an important NP-hard problem in the area of data-intensive problems. We propose a novel hybrid classical-quantum algorithm to solve the MQO on a gate-based quantum computer. We perform a detailed experimental evaluation of our algorithm and compare its performance against a competing approach that employs a quantum annealer -- another type of quantum computer. Our experimental results demonstrate that our algorithm currently can only handle small problem sizes due to the limited number of qubits available on a gate-based quantum computer compared to a quantum computer based on quantum annealing. However, our algorithm shows a qubit efficiency of close to 99% which is almost a factor of 2 higher compared to the state of the art implementation. Finally, we analyze how our algorithm scales with larger problem sizes and conclude that our approach shows promising results for near-term quantum computers.
Quantum computing promises to solve difficult optimization problems in chemistry, physics and mathematics more efficiently than classical computers. However, it requires fault-tolerant quantum computers with millions of qubits; a technological challenge still not mastered by engineers. To lower the barrier, hybrid algorithms combining classical and quantum computers are used, where quantum computing is only used for those parts of computation that cannot be solved efficiently otherwise. In this paper, we tackle the multiple query optimization problem (MQO), an important NP-hard problem in database research. We present an implementation based on a scheme called quantum approximate optimization algorithm to solve the MQO on a gate-based quantum computer. We perform a detailed experimental evaluation of our implementation and compare its performance against a competing approach that employs a quantum annealer – another type of quantum computer. Our implementation shows a qubit efficiency of close to 99%, which is almost a factor of 2 higher than the state-of-the-art implementation. We emphasize that the problems we can solve with current gate-based quantum technology are fairly small and might not seem practical yet compared to state-of-the-art classical query optimizers. However, our experiments on using a hybrid approach of classical and quantum computing show that our implementation scales favourably with larger problem sizes. Hence, we conclude that our approach shows promising results for near-term quantum computers and thus sets the stage for a challenging avenue of novel database research.
The D-Wave adiabatic quantum annealer solves hard combinatorial optimization problems leveraging quantum physics. The newest version features over 1000 qubits and was released in August 2015. We were given access to such a machine, currently hosted at NASA Ames Research Center in California, to explore the potential for hard optimization problems that arise in the context of databases. In this paper, we tackle the problem of multiple query optimization (MQO). We show how an MQO problem instance can be transformed into a mathematical formula that complies with the restrictive input format accepted by the quantum annealer. This formula is translated into weights on and between qubits such that the configuration minimizing the input formula can be found via a process called adiabatic quantum annealing. We analyze the asymptotic growth rate of the number of required qubits in the MQO problem dimensions as the number of qubits is currently the main factor restricting applicability. We experimentally compare the performance of the quantum annealer against other MQO algorithms executed on a traditional computer. While the problem sizes that can be treated are currently limited, we already find a class of problem instances where the quantum annealer is three orders of magnitude faster than other approaches.
The D-Wave adiabatic quantum annealer solves hard combinatorial optimization problems leveraging quantum physics. The newest version features over 1000 qubits and was released in August 2015. We were given access to such a machine, currently hosted at NASA Ames Research Center in California, to explore the potential for hard optimization problems that arise in the context of databases. In this paper, we tackle the problem of multiple query optimization (MQO). We show how an MQO problem instance can be transformed into a mathematical formula that complies with the restrictive input format accepted by the quantum annealer. This formula is translated into weights on and between qubits such that the configuration minimizing the input formula can be found via a process called adiabatic quantum annealing. We analyze the asymptotic growth rate of the number of required qubits in the MQO problem dimensions as the number of qubits is currently the main factor restricting applicability. We experimentally compare the performance of the quantum annealer against other MQO algorithms executed on a traditional computer. While the problem sizes that can be treated are currently limited, we already find a class of problem instances where the quantum annealer is three orders of magnitude faster than other approaches.
Multiple-query optimization (MQO) seeks to reduce redundant work across query batches. While MQO offers opportunities for dramatic performance improvements, the problem is NP-hard, limiting the sizes of problems that can be solved on generic hardware. We propose to leverage specialized hardware solvers for optimization, such as Fujitsu's Digital Annealer (DA), to scale up MQO to problem sizes formerly out of reach. We present a novel incremental processing approach that combines classical computation with DA acceleration. By efficiently partitioning MQO problems into sets of partial problems, and by applying a dynamic search steering strategy that reapplies initially discarded information to incrementally process individual problems, our method overcomes capacity limitations, and scales to extremely large MQO instances (up to νm1000 queries). A thorough and comprehensive empirical evaluation finds our method substantially outperforms existing approaches. Our generalisable framework lays the ground for other database use-cases on quantum-inspired hardware, and bridges towards future quantum accelerators.
The rapidly increasing number of heterogeneous data ecosystems, such as structured databases, semi-structured data lakes, real-time streams, distributed knowledge graphs, has further complicated the issue of query planning and optimization in modern information systems extensively. The optimization of queries is essentially an NP-hard combinatorial problem especially when based on multi-join queries, distributed execution plan, dynamic cost model, and uncertainty in the data access patterns. Even decades of concept and engineering advances, classical database optimizers are rapidly becoming unable to offer a globally optimal execution plan when faced with high-dimensional data, high data volatility, with a very tight latency constraint. Good news Recent breakthroughs in quantum computing propose promising computational paradigms that can be used to solve combinatorial optimization problems via quantum parallelism, superposition, and entanglement. Nevertheless, even the near-term quantum hardware is limited in the number of available qubits, noise, and decoherence, making it impractical to achieve fully quantum database systems in any perceived future. This is also the reason why quantum-classical hybrid algorithms are being developed: designed to add quantum optimization subroutines to classical database architectures is guaranteed without breaking their compatibility with existing execution engines. The following paper presents a framework of scalable quantum-classical hybrid computing of complex query planning in heterogeneous data ecosystems. The framework breaks down query optimization into classical and quantum-amenable optimization, which allows NP-hard subproblems, such as join ordering, operator placement, and cost minimization, to be transformed into quantum optimization models such as Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) and Ising Hamiltonians. Classical elements handle query parsing, semantic analysis, constraint verification, and orchestration, whereas quantum processors are called selectively to solve combinatorial decision-making tasks. The suggested architecture will consist of a layered execution, hybrid execution, cost-model encoding approach, and adaptive fallback mechanisms to make them robust to quantum hardware variability. This has been experimentally tested with simulated quantum annealing and variational quantum algorithms that exhibit a quantifiable improvement in the quality and scalability of optimization and heuristics based on entirely classical algorithms, especially in high-dimensional query plans. The findings confirm the practicability of quantum query optimization and put down a feasible route to implement quantum algorithms in the serving machine of the next-generation data management systems.