Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2107.00884 · SciPost Physics

Quantum local random networks and the statistical robustness of quantum scars

Federica Maria Surace, Marcello Dalmonte, Alessandro Silva

Published Jun 29, 2023• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the emergence of quantum scars in a general ensemble of random Hamiltonians (of which the PXP is a particular realization), that we refer to as quantum local random networks. We find a class of scars, that we call “statistical”, and we identify specific signatures of the localized nature of these eigenstates by analyzing a combination of indicators of quantum ergodicity and properties related to the network structure of the model. Within this parallelism, we associate the emergence of statistical scars to the presence of “motifs” in the network, that reflects how these are associated to links with anomalously small connectivity. Most remarkably, statistical scars appear at well-defined values of energy, predicted solely on the base of network theory. We study the scaling of the number of statistical scars with system size: by continuously changing the connectivity of the system we find that there is a transition from a regime where the constraints are too weak for scars to exist for large systems to a regime where constraints are stronger and the number of statistical scars increases with system size. This allows to define the concept of “statistical robustness” of quantum scars.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphys.14.6.174

Related papers

Stability of scar states in the two-dimensional PXP model against random disorder

Ke Huang, Yu Wang, Xiao Li

Recently a class of quantum systems exhibiting weak ergodicity breaking has attracted much attention. These systems feature in the energy spectrum a special band of eigenstates called quantum many-body scar states. One prototype model that is known to host scar states is the so-called PXP model. In this work we study the fate of quantum many-body scar states in a 2D PXP model against random disorders. We show that in both the square lattice and the honeycomb lattice the scar states can persist up to a finite disorder strength, before eventually being erased by the disorder. We further study the localization properties of the system in the presence of even stronger disorders and show that whether a full localization transition occurs depends on the type of disorder we introduce. Our study thus reveals the fascinating interplay between disorder and quantum many-body scarring in a 2D system.

arXiv:2102.08241•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 13, 2021•10 citations

Weak ergodicity breaking and quantum scars in constrained quantum systems

Christopher J. Turner

The success of statistical mechanics in describing complex quantum systems rests upon typicality properties such as ergodicity. Both integrable systems and the recently discovered many-body localisation show that these assumptions can be strongly violated in either finely tuned cases, or in the presence of quenched disorder. In this thesis, we uncover a qualitatively different form of ergodicity breaking, wherein a small number of atypical eigenstates are embedded throughout an otherwise thermalising spectrum. We call this a many-body quantum scar, in analogy to quantum scars in single-particle quantum chaos, where quantum scarred eigenfunctions concentrate around associated periodic classical trajectories. \nWe demonstrate that many-body quantum scars can be found in an unusual model recently realised in a 51 Rydberg atom quantum simulator. The observed coherent oscillations following in a certain quench experiment are a consequence of the quantum scar. At the same time, the level statistics rules out conventional explanations such as integrability and many-body localisation. We develop an approximate method to construct scarred eigenstates, in order to describe their structure and physical properties. Additionally, we find a local perturbation which makes these non-equilibrium properties much more pronounced, with near perfect quantum revivals. At the same time the other eigenstates remain thermal. Our results suggest that many-body quantum scars forms a new class of quantum dynamics with unusual properties, which are realisable in current experiments.

•Jun 1, 2019•1 citation

Quantum scar states in coupled random graph models

Bhilahari Jeevanesan

We analyze the Hilbert space connectivity of the $L$ site PXP model by constructing the Hamiltonian matrices via a Gray code numbering of basis states. The matrices are all formed out of a single Hamiltonian-path backbone and entries on skew diagonals. Starting from this observation, we construct an ensemble of related Hamiltonians based on random graphs with tunable constraint degree and variable network topology. We study the entanglement structure of their energy eigenstates and find two classes of weakly entangled midspectrum states. The first class contains scars that are approximate products of eigenstates of the subsystems. Their origin can be traced to the near orthogonality of random vectors in high-dimensional spaces. The second class of scars has $log2$ entanglement entropy and is tied to the occurrence of special types of subgraphs. The latter states have some resemblance to the Lin-Motrunich $\sqrt{2}$ scars.

arXiv:2305.08123•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 14, 2023•2 citations

Stability of 2D quantum many-body scar states against random disorder

Ke Huang, Yu Wang, Xiao Li

Recently a class of quantum systems exhibiting weak ergodicity breaking has attracted much attention. These systems feature a special band of eigenstates called quantum many-body scar states in the energy spectrum. In this work we study the fate of quantum many-body scar states in a two-dimensional lattice against random disorders. We show that in both the square lattice and the honeycomb lattice the scar states can persist up to a finite disorder strength, before eventually being killed by the disorder. We further study the localization properties of the system in the presence of even stronger disorders and show that whether a full localization transition occurs depends on the type of disorder we introduce. Our study thus reveals the fascinating interplay between disorder and quantum many-body scarring in a two-dimensional system.

•Feb 16, 2021•0 citations

Gaussian state approximation of quantum many-body scars

Wouter Buijsman, Yevgeny Bar Lev

Quantum many-body scars are atypical, highly nonthermal eigenstates embedded in a sea of thermal eigenstates that have been observed in, for example, kinetically constrained quantum many-body models. These special eigenstates are characterized by a bipartite entanglement entropy that scales as most logarithmically with the subsystem size. We use numerical optimization techniques to investigate if quantum many-body scars of the experimentally relevant PXP model can be well approximated by Gaussian states. Gaussian states are described by a number of parameters that scales quadratically with system size, thereby having a much lower complexity than generic quantum many-body states, for which this number scales exponentially. We find that while quantum many-body scars can typically be well approximated by (symmetrized) Gaussian states, this is not the case for ergodic (thermal) eigenstates. This observation suggests that the non-ergodic part of the PXP Hamiltonian is related to certain quadratic parent Hamiltonians, thereby hinting on the origin of the quantum many-body scars.

arXiv:2307.11816•SciPost Physics•Aug 15, 2024•0 citations

Theory of Robust Quantum Many-Body Scars in Long-Range Interacting Systems

Alessio Lerose, Tommaso Parolini, Rosario Fazio +2 more

Quantum many-body scars (QMBS) are exceptional energy eigenstates of quantum many-body systems associated with violations of thermalization for special nonequilibrium initial states. Their various systematic constructions require fine-tuning of local Hamiltonian parameters. In this work, we demonstrate that long-range interacting quantum spin systems generically host robust QMBS. We analyze spectral properties upon raising the power-law decay exponent α of spin-spin interactions from the solvable permutationally symmetric limit α = 0 . First, we numerically establish that, despite the fact that spectral signatures of chaos appear for infinitesimal α , the towers of α = 0 energy eigenstates with large collective spin are smoothly deformed as α is increased and exhibit characteristic QMBS features. To elucidate the nature and fate of these states in larger systems, we introduce an analytical approach based on mapping the spin Hamiltonian onto a relativistic quantum rotor nonlinearly coupled to an extensive set of bosonic modes. We analytically solve for the eigenstates of this interacting impurity model by means of a novel polaron-type canonical transformation and show their self-consistent localization in large-spin sectors of the original Hamiltonian for 0 < α < d (with d = spatial dimension of the lattice ). Our theory unveils the stability mechanism of such QMBS for an arbitrary system size and predicts instances of its breakdown, e.g., near dynamical critical points or in the presence of semiclassical chaos, which we verify numerically in long-range quantum Ising chains. As a by-product, we find a predictive criterion for the presence or absence of heating under periodic driving for 0 < α < d , beyond existing Floquet-prethermalization theorems.

arXiv:2309.12504•Physical Review X•Feb 3, 2025•21 citations
We investigate the emergence of quantum scars in a general ensemble of random Hamiltonians (of which the PXP is a particular realization), that we refer to as quantum local random networks. We find a class of scars, that we call “statistical”, and we identify specific signatures of the localized nature of these eigenstates by analyzing a combination of indicators of quantum ergodicity and properties related to the network structure of the model. Within this parallelism, we associate the emergence of statistical scars to the presence of “motifs” in the network, that reflects how these are associated to links with anomalously small connectivity. Most remarkably, statistical scars appear at well-defined values of energy, predicted solely on the base of network theory. We study the scaling of the number of statistical scars with system size: by continuously changing the connectivity of the system we find that there is a transition from a regime where the constraints are too weak for scars to exist for large systems to a regime where constraints are stronger and the number of statistical scars increases with system size. This allows to define the concept of “statistical robustness” of quantum scars.
Recently a class of quantum systems exhibiting weak ergodicity breaking has attracted much attention. These systems feature in the energy spectrum a special band of eigenstates called quantum many-body scar states. One prototype model that is known to host scar states is the so-called PXP model. In this work we study the fate of quantum many-body scar states in a 2D PXP model against random disorders. We show that in both the square lattice and the honeycomb lattice the scar states can persist up to a finite disorder strength, before eventually being erased by the disorder. We further study the localization properties of the system in the presence of even stronger disorders and show that whether a full localization transition occurs depends on the type of disorder we introduce. Our study thus reveals the fascinating interplay between disorder and quantum many-body scarring in a 2D system.
The success of statistical mechanics in describing complex quantum systems rests upon typicality properties such as ergodicity. Both integrable systems and the recently discovered many-body localisation show that these assumptions can be strongly violated in either finely tuned cases, or in the presence of quenched disorder. In this thesis, we uncover a qualitatively different form of ergodicity breaking, wherein a small number of atypical eigenstates are embedded throughout an otherwise thermalising spectrum. We call this a many-body quantum scar, in analogy to quantum scars in single-particle quantum chaos, where quantum scarred eigenfunctions concentrate around associated periodic classical trajectories. \nWe demonstrate that many-body quantum scars can be found in an unusual model recently realised in a 51 Rydberg atom quantum simulator. The observed coherent oscillations following in a certain quench experiment are a consequence of the quantum scar. At the same time, the level statistics rules out conventional explanations such as integrability and many-body localisation. We develop an approximate method to construct scarred eigenstates, in order to describe their structure and physical properties. Additionally, we find a local perturbation which makes these non-equilibrium properties much more pronounced, with near perfect quantum revivals. At the same time the other eigenstates remain thermal. Our results suggest that many-body quantum scars forms a new class of quantum dynamics with unusual properties, which are realisable in current experiments.
We analyze the Hilbert space connectivity of the LLL site PXP model by constructing the Hamiltonian matrices via a Gray code numbering of basis states. The matrices are all formed out of a single Hamiltonian-path backbone and entries on skew diagonals. Starting from this observation, we construct an ensemble of related Hamiltonians based on random graphs with tunable constraint degree and variable network topology. We study the entanglement structure of their energy eigenstates and find two classes of weakly entangled midspectrum states. The first class contains scars that are approximate products of eigenstates of the subsystems. Their origin can be traced to the near orthogonality of random vectors in high-dimensional spaces. The second class of scars has log2log2log2 entanglement entropy and is tied to the occurrence of special types of subgraphs. The latter states have some resemblance to the Lin-Motrunich 2\sqrt{2}2​ scars.
Recently a class of quantum systems exhibiting weak ergodicity breaking has attracted much attention. These systems feature a special band of eigenstates called quantum many-body scar states in the energy spectrum. In this work we study the fate of quantum many-body scar states in a two-dimensional lattice against random disorders. We show that in both the square lattice and the honeycomb lattice the scar states can persist up to a finite disorder strength, before eventually being killed by the disorder. We further study the localization properties of the system in the presence of even stronger disorders and show that whether a full localization transition occurs depends on the type of disorder we introduce. Our study thus reveals the fascinating interplay between disorder and quantum many-body scarring in a two-dimensional system.
Quantum many-body scars are atypical, highly nonthermal eigenstates embedded in a sea of thermal eigenstates that have been observed in, for example, kinetically constrained quantum many-body models. These special eigenstates are characterized by a bipartite entanglement entropy that scales as most logarithmically with the subsystem size. We use numerical optimization techniques to investigate if quantum many-body scars of the experimentally relevant PXP model can be well approximated by Gaussian states. Gaussian states are described by a number of parameters that scales quadratically with system size, thereby having a much lower complexity than generic quantum many-body states, for which this number scales exponentially. We find that while quantum many-body scars can typically be well approximated by (symmetrized) Gaussian states, this is not the case for ergodic (thermal) eigenstates. This observation suggests that the non-ergodic part of the PXP Hamiltonian is related to certain quadratic parent Hamiltonians, thereby hinting on the origin of the quantum many-body scars.
Quantum many-body scars (QMBS) are exceptional energy eigenstates of quantum many-body systems associated with violations of thermalization for special nonequilibrium initial states. Their various systematic constructions require fine-tuning of local Hamiltonian parameters. In this work, we demonstrate that long-range interacting quantum spin systems generically host robust QMBS. We analyze spectral properties upon raising the power-law decay exponent α of spin-spin interactions from the solvable permutationally symmetric limit α = 0 . First, we numerically establish that, despite the fact that spectral signatures of chaos appear for infinitesimal α , the towers of α = 0 energy eigenstates with large collective spin are smoothly deformed as α is increased and exhibit characteristic QMBS features. To elucidate the nature and fate of these states in larger systems, we introduce an analytical approach based on mapping the spin Hamiltonian onto a relativistic quantum rotor nonlinearly coupled to an extensive set of bosonic modes. We analytically solve for the eigenstates of this interacting impurity model by means of a novel polaron-type canonical transformation and show their self-consistent localization in large-spin sectors of the original Hamiltonian for 0 < α < d (with d = spatial dimension of the lattice ). Our theory unveils the stability mechanism of such QMBS for an arbitrary system size and predicts instances of its breakdown, e.g., near dynamical critical points or in the presence of semiclassical chaos, which we verify numerically in long-range quantum Ising chains. As a by-product, we find a predictive criterion for the presence or absence of heating under periodic driving for 0 < α < d , beyond existing Floquet-prethermalization theorems.