Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2105.06394 · Physical Review A

Efficient nonlinear witnessing of non–absolutely separable states with lossy detectors

Ayan Patra, Shiladitya Mal, Aditi Sen De

Published Sep 29, 2021• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Entangled states are undoubtedly an integral part of various quantum information processing tasks. On the other hand, absolutely separable states which cannot be made entangled under any global unitary operations are useless from the resource theoretic perspective, and hence, identifying non--absolutely separable states can be an important issue for designing quantum technologies. Here we report that nonlinear witness operators provide significant improvements in detecting non--absolutely separable states over their linear analogs, by invoking examples of states in various dimensions. We also address the problem of closing the detection loophole and we find the critical efficiency of detectors above which no fake detection of non--absolutely separable (non--absolutely positive partial transposed) states is possible.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.104.032427

Related papers

Closing the detection loophole in nonlinear entanglement witnesses

Kornikar Sen, Sreetama Das, Ujjwal Sen

Detectors in the laboratory are often unlike their ideal theoretical cousins. They have nonideal efficiencies, which may then lead to nontrivial implications. We show how it is possible to predict correct answers about whether a shared quantum state is entangled in spite of finite detector efficiencies, when the tool for entanglement detection is a nonlinear entanglement witness. We first consider the detection loophole for shared quantum states with nonpositive partial transpose. We subsequently find nonlinear witness operators for bound entangled states with positive partial transpose, and show how the detection loophole can be closed also in such instances.

arXiv:1906.09046•Physical Review A•Dec 26, 2019•9 citations

Construction of a Non-Linear Entanglement Witness Operator in Arbitrary Dimension Using a Given Linear Witness Operator

Sonia, Satyabrata Adhikari

Entanglement detection is one of the important problems in quantum information theory. To deal with this problem, many entanglement detection criteria have been proposed. Among the proposed criteria, the detection of entanglement through witness operator (also known as linear entanglement witness (LEW) operator) may be considered as the most practical. Although the witness operator approach to detect entanglement is experimentally friendly, the construction of these operators is not a very simple task. Even if we are able to construct a LEW operator, our problem is not solved as it may either detect a few entangled states or not a single entangled state from a given family of entangled states. Thus, we need a constructive approach in order to tackle this type of problem. In this work, we provide a few constructions of the non-linear entanglement witnesses (NLEW) for $d_1\otimes d_2$ dimensional system from any linear entanglement witness (LEW) operator. The advantage of these constructions is that, if a LEW is unable to detect any particular entangled state described by the density operator $ρ^{ent}$ then our construction of NLEW may detect the same entangled state $ρ^{ent}$. Further, we have constructed NLEW operator that may detect not only a class of bipartite negative partial transpose entangled state (NPTES), but also positive partial transpose entangled state (PPTES). Moreover, we have shown that the constructed NLEW operators may be decomposed in terms of the tensor product of local observables and hence may be realizable in an experiment.

quant-pharXiv:2605.03605•May 6, 2026•0 citations

Detection of nonabsolute separability in quantum states and channels through moments

Bivas Mallick, Saheli Mukherjee, Nirman Ganguly +1 more

In quantum information and computation, the generation of entanglement through unitary gates remains a significant and active area of research. However, there are states termed as absolutely separable, from which entanglement cannot be created through any non-local unitary action. Thus, from a resource-theoretic perspective, non-absolutely separable states are useful as they can be turned into entangled states using some appropriate unitary gates. In this work, we propose an efficient method to detect non-absolutely separable states. Our approach relies on evaluating moments that can bypass the need for full state tomography, thereby enhancing its practical applicability. We then present several examples in support of our detection scheme. We also address a closely related problem concerning states whose partial transpose remains positive under any arbitrary non-local unitary action. Furthermore, we examine the effectiveness of our moment-based approach in the detection of quantum channels that are not absolutely separating, which entails the detection of resource preserving channels. Finally, we demonstrate the operational significance of non-absolutely separable states by proving that every such state can provide an advantage in a quantum-channel discrimination task.

arXiv:2508.15700•Physical Review A•Jan 9, 2026•1 citation

Witness expansion: A unified framework for analytical and measurable mixed-state resource detection

Yifan Tang, Chengkai Zhu, Yuzhen Zhang +6 more

Quantum information science aims to harness different kinds of quantum resources to accomplish specific information-processing tasks. These resources also play an increasingly important role in addressing fundamental questions concerning quantum phases and dynamics. Therefore, developing powerful and practical methods for identifying and detecting quantum resources is of great significance, with applications ranging from benchmarking quantum devices to understanding the fundamental structure of quantum theory. In this work, we propose witness expansion, a unified framework for constructing nonlinear criteria for detecting quantum resources that are associated with a well-defined group of free unitaries. These criteria apply to both pure and mixed quantum states and are based on polynomial functions of the target state, which can be estimated experimentally using multiple copies of the state and evaluated analytically in certain physical models. We show how several well-known resource-detection quantities naturally emerge from our framework, including the $l_2$ norm of coherence, partial-transpose moments for entanglement, stabilizer entropy for nonstabilizerness (quantum magic), and fermionic antiflatness for fermionic non-Gaussianity. Beyond recovering these existing structures, our framework also yields new criteria for detecting qubit and qudit magic states, substantially enhancing witness-based detection capabilities. In addition, it gives, to the best of our knowledge, the first analytical criterion for detecting mixed-state fermionic non-Gaussianity with respect to the convex hull of pure fermionic Gaussian states that remains nontrivial for arbitrary numbers of qubits, demonstrating the broad applicability and conceptual unifying power of the framework.

quant-pharXiv:2606.27105•Jun 26, 2026•0 citations

Witness of mixed separable states useful for entanglement creation

Nirman Ganguly, Jyotishman Chatterjee, A. S. Majumdar

Absolutely separable states form a special subset of the set of all separable states, as they remain separable under any global unitary transformation unlike other separable states. We consider the set of absolutely separable bipartite states and show that it is convex and compact in any arbitrary dimensional Hilbert space. Through a generic approach of construction of suitable Hermitian operators we prove the completeness of the separation axiom for identifying any separable state that is not absolutely separable. We demonstrate the action of such witness operators in different qudit systems. Examples of mixed separable systems are provided, pointing out the utility of the witness in entanglement creation using quantum gates. Decomposition of witnesses in terms of spin operators or photon polarizations facilitates their measurability for qubit states.

arXiv:1401.5324•Physical Review A•May 8, 2014•37 citations

Measurement-device-independent nonlinear entanglement witnesses

Kornikar Sen, Chirag Srivastava, Ujjwal Sen

Abstract Entanglement witnesses (EWs) are one of the most effective methods to detect entanglement. It is known that nonlinear EW provide better entanglement detection than their linear counterparts, in that the former detect a strictly larger subset of entangled states than the latter. Whether linear or nonlinear, the method is measurement-device dependent, so that imperfect measurements may cause false certification of entanglement in a shared state. Measurement-device-independent EW provide an escape from such measurement dependence of the entanglement detection for linear EW. Here we present measurement-device-independent nonlinear EW for non-positive partial transpose entangled states as well as for bound entangled states with positive partial transpose. Although the witness considered herein does not detect a larger set of entangled states than other nonlinear EW, it is more efficient in that it never leads to a false detection corresponding to wrong measurements. The constructed measurement-device-independent nonlinear EW certify the entanglement of the same sets of entangled states as their device-dependent parents do, and therefore are better than the linear EW, device-independent or otherwise.

arXiv:2106.05796•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jul 5, 2023•1 citation
Entangled states are undoubtedly an integral part of various quantum information processing tasks. On the other hand, absolutely separable states which cannot be made entangled under any global unitary operations are useless from the resource theoretic perspective, and hence, identifying non--absolutely separable states can be an important issue for designing quantum technologies. Here we report that nonlinear witness operators provide significant improvements in detecting non--absolutely separable states over their linear analogs, by invoking examples of states in various dimensions. We also address the problem of closing the detection loophole and we find the critical efficiency of detectors above which no fake detection of non--absolutely separable (non--absolutely positive partial transposed) states is possible.
Detectors in the laboratory are often unlike their ideal theoretical cousins. They have nonideal efficiencies, which may then lead to nontrivial implications. We show how it is possible to predict correct answers about whether a shared quantum state is entangled in spite of finite detector efficiencies, when the tool for entanglement detection is a nonlinear entanglement witness. We first consider the detection loophole for shared quantum states with nonpositive partial transpose. We subsequently find nonlinear witness operators for bound entangled states with positive partial transpose, and show how the detection loophole can be closed also in such instances.
Entanglement detection is one of the important problems in quantum information theory. To deal with this problem, many entanglement detection criteria have been proposed. Among the proposed criteria, the detection of entanglement through witness operator (also known as linear entanglement witness (LEW) operator) may be considered as the most practical. Although the witness operator approach to detect entanglement is experimentally friendly, the construction of these operators is not a very simple task. Even if we are able to construct a LEW operator, our problem is not solved as it may either detect a few entangled states or not a single entangled state from a given family of entangled states. Thus, we need a constructive approach in order to tackle this type of problem. In this work, we provide a few constructions of the non-linear entanglement witnesses (NLEW) for d1⊗d2d_1\otimes d_2d1​⊗d2​ dimensional system from any linear entanglement witness (LEW) operator. The advantage of these constructions is that, if a LEW is unable to detect any particular entangled state described by the density operator ρentρ^{ent}ρent then our construction of NLEW may detect the same entangled state ρentρ^{ent}ρent. Further, we have constructed NLEW operator that may detect not only a class of bipartite negative partial transpose entangled state (NPTES), but also positive partial transpose entangled state (PPTES). Moreover, we have shown that the constructed NLEW operators may be decomposed in terms of the tensor product of local observables and hence may be realizable in an experiment.
In quantum information and computation, the generation of entanglement through unitary gates remains a significant and active area of research. However, there are states termed as absolutely separable, from which entanglement cannot be created through any non-local unitary action. Thus, from a resource-theoretic perspective, non-absolutely separable states are useful as they can be turned into entangled states using some appropriate unitary gates. In this work, we propose an efficient method to detect non-absolutely separable states. Our approach relies on evaluating moments that can bypass the need for full state tomography, thereby enhancing its practical applicability. We then present several examples in support of our detection scheme. We also address a closely related problem concerning states whose partial transpose remains positive under any arbitrary non-local unitary action. Furthermore, we examine the effectiveness of our moment-based approach in the detection of quantum channels that are not absolutely separating, which entails the detection of resource preserving channels. Finally, we demonstrate the operational significance of non-absolutely separable states by proving that every such state can provide an advantage in a quantum-channel discrimination task.
Quantum information science aims to harness different kinds of quantum resources to accomplish specific information-processing tasks. These resources also play an increasingly important role in addressing fundamental questions concerning quantum phases and dynamics. Therefore, developing powerful and practical methods for identifying and detecting quantum resources is of great significance, with applications ranging from benchmarking quantum devices to understanding the fundamental structure of quantum theory. In this work, we propose witness expansion, a unified framework for constructing nonlinear criteria for detecting quantum resources that are associated with a well-defined group of free unitaries. These criteria apply to both pure and mixed quantum states and are based on polynomial functions of the target state, which can be estimated experimentally using multiple copies of the state and evaluated analytically in certain physical models. We show how several well-known resource-detection quantities naturally emerge from our framework, including the l2l_2l2​ norm of coherence, partial-transpose moments for entanglement, stabilizer entropy for nonstabilizerness (quantum magic), and fermionic antiflatness for fermionic non-Gaussianity. Beyond recovering these existing structures, our framework also yields new criteria for detecting qubit and qudit magic states, substantially enhancing witness-based detection capabilities. In addition, it gives, to the best of our knowledge, the first analytical criterion for detecting mixed-state fermionic non-Gaussianity with respect to the convex hull of pure fermionic Gaussian states that remains nontrivial for arbitrary numbers of qubits, demonstrating the broad applicability and conceptual unifying power of the framework.
Absolutely separable states form a special subset of the set of all separable states, as they remain separable under any global unitary transformation unlike other separable states. We consider the set of absolutely separable bipartite states and show that it is convex and compact in any arbitrary dimensional Hilbert space. Through a generic approach of construction of suitable Hermitian operators we prove the completeness of the separation axiom for identifying any separable state that is not absolutely separable. We demonstrate the action of such witness operators in different qudit systems. Examples of mixed separable systems are provided, pointing out the utility of the witness in entanglement creation using quantum gates. Decomposition of witnesses in terms of spin operators or photon polarizations facilitates their measurability for qubit states.
Abstract Entanglement witnesses (EWs) are one of the most effective methods to detect entanglement. It is known that nonlinear EW provide better entanglement detection than their linear counterparts, in that the former detect a strictly larger subset of entangled states than the latter. Whether linear or nonlinear, the method is measurement-device dependent, so that imperfect measurements may cause false certification of entanglement in a shared state. Measurement-device-independent EW provide an escape from such measurement dependence of the entanglement detection for linear EW. Here we present measurement-device-independent nonlinear EW for non-positive partial transpose entangled states as well as for bound entangled states with positive partial transpose. Although the witness considered herein does not detect a larger set of entangled states than other nonlinear EW, it is more efficient in that it never leads to a false detection corresponding to wrong measurements. The constructed measurement-device-independent nonlinear EW certify the entanglement of the same sets of entangled states as their device-dependent parents do, and therefore are better than the linear EW, device-independent or otherwise.