Whether self-correcting quantum memories can exist at nonzero temperature in a physically reasonable setting remains a great open problem. It has recently been argued [S. Roberts and S. D. Bartlett, Phys. Rev. X 10, 031041 (2020)] that symmetry-protected topological (SPT) systems in three space dimensions subject to a strong constraint---that the quantum dynamics respect a 1-form symmetry---realize such a quantum memory. We illustrate how this works in Walker-Wang codes, which provide a specific realization of these desiderata. In this setting we show that it is sufficient for the 1-form symmetry to be enforced on a subvolume of the system. This strongly suggests that the SPT character of the state is not essential. We confirm this by constructing an explicit example with a trivial (paramagnetic) bulk that realizes a self-correcting quantum memory. We therefore show that the enforcement of a 1-form symmetry on a measure-zero subvolume of a three-dimensional system can be sufficient to stabilize a self-correcting quantum memory at nonzero temperature.
Whether self-correcting quantum memories can exist at nonzero temperature in a physically reasonable setting remains a great open problem. It has recently been argued [S. Roberts and S. D. Bartlett, Phys. Rev. X 10, 031041 (2020)] that symmetry-protected topological (SPT) systems in three space dimensions subject to a strong constraint---that the quantum dynamics respect a 1-form symmetry---realize such a quantum memory. We illustrate how this works in Walker-Wang codes, which provide a specific realization of these desiderata. In this setting we show that it is sufficient for the 1-form symmetry to be enforced on a subvolume of the system. This strongly suggests that the SPT character of the state is not essential. We confirm this by constructing an explicit example with a trivial (paramagnetic) bulk that realizes a self-correcting quantum memory. We therefore show that the enforcement of a 1-form symmetry on a measure-zero subvolume of a three-dimensional system can be sufficient to stabilize a self-correcting quantum memory at nonzero temperature.
Recent work has shown that a self-correcting quantum memory can exist in three spatial dimensions, provided that it is protected by a 1-form symmetry.Requiring that the dynamics of a system obey this type of symmetry is equivalent to enforcing a macroscopic number of symmetry terms throughout the bulk.In this paper, we show how to replace the explicit 1-form symmetry with an emergent 1-form symmetry in the bulk and an explicit 1-form symmetry on the boundary.To do so, we use the extended excitations of a three-dimensional (3D) toric code to confine anyons in a two-dimensional (2D) toric code on the boundary.The boundary anyons are bound to the bulk excitations by the explicit 1-form symmetry.Although the symmetry still has to be explicitly enforced on the boundary, this could conceivably be a more attainable constraint due to the accessibility of the boundary qubits.Furthermore, this only requires O(L 2 ) terms for a system of linear size L, instead of O(L 3 ) terms.
In recent years, topological phases of matter have presented exciting new avenues to achieve scalable quantum computation. In this thesis, we investigate a class of quantum many-body spin models known as symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases for use in quantum information processing and storage. We explore the fault-tolerant properties of SPT phases, and how they can be utilized in the design of a quantum computer. Of central importance in this thesis is the concept of quantum error-correction, which in addition to its importance in fault-tolerant quantum computation, is used to characterise the stability of topological phases at finite temperature. We begin with an introduction to quantum computation, quantum error correction, and topological phases of matter. We then focus on the fundamental question of whether symmetry-protected topological phases of matter can exist in thermal equilibrium; we prove that systems protected by global onsite symmetries cannot be ordered at nonzero temperature. Subsequently, we show that certain three-dimensional models with generalised higher-form symmetries can be thermally SPT ordered, and we relate this order to the ability to perform fault-tolerant measurement-based quantum computation. Following this, we assess feasibility of these phases as quantum memories, motivated by the fact that SPT phases in three dimensions can possess protected topological degrees of freedom on their boundary. We find that certain SPT ordered systems can be self-correcting, allowing quantum information to be stored for arbitrarily long times without requiring active error correction. Finally, we develop a framework to construct new schemes of fault-tolerant measurement-based quantum computation. As a notable example, we develop a cluster-state scheme that simulates the braiding and fusion of surface-code defects, offering novel alternative methods to achieve fault-tolerant universal quantum computation.
We address the question of whether symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order can persist at nonzero temperature, with a focus on understanding the thermal stability of several models studied in the theory of quantum computation. We present three results in this direction. First, we prove that nontrivial SPT order protected by a global onsite symmetry cannot persist at nonzero temperature, demonstrating that several quantum computational structures protected by such onsite symmetries are not thermally stable. Second, we prove that the three-dimensional (3D) cluster-state model used in the formulation of topological measurement-based quantum computation possesses a nontrivial SPT-ordered thermal phase when protected by a generalized (1-form) symmetry. The SPT order in this model is detected by long-range localizable entanglement in the thermal state, which compares with related results characterizing SPT order at zero temperature in spin chains using localizable entanglement as an order parameter. Our third result is to demonstrate that the high-error tolerance of this 3D cluster-state model for quantum computation, even without a protecting symmetry, can be understood as an application of quantum error correction to effectively enforce a 1-form symmetry.
Motivated by the growing interest in self-correcting quantum memories, we study the feasibility of self-correction in classical lattice systems composed of bounded degrees of freedom with local interactions. We argue that self-correction, including a requirement of stability against external perturbation, cannot be realized in system with broken global symmetries such as the two-dimensional Ising model, but that systems with local, i.e., gauge symmetries, have the required properties. Previous work identified a three-dimensional (3D) quantum system which realizes a self-correcting classical memory [E. Dennis et al., J. Math. Phys. 43, 4452 (2002)]. Here, we show that a purely classical 3D system, Wegner's Ising lattice gauge model [F. J. Wegner, J. Math. Phys. 12, 2259 (1971)], can also realize this self-correction despite having an extensive ground-state degeneracy. We give a detailed numerical study to support the existence of a self-correcting phase in this system, even when the gauge symmetry is explicitly broken. More generally, our results obtained by studying the memory lifetime of the system are in quantitative agreement with the phase diagram obtained from conventional analysis of the system's specific heat [I. S. Tupitsyn et al., Phys. Rev. B 82, 085114 (2010)], except that self-correction extends beyond the topological phase, past the lower critical temperature.
We discuss physical constructions and the boundary properties of various symmetry-protected topological phases that involve 1-form symmetries from one spatial dimension to four spatial dimensions (4d). For example, the prototype three-dimensional (3d) boundary state of 4d SPT states involving 1-form symmetries can be either a gapless photon phase (quantum electrodynamics) or gapped topological order enriched by 1-form symmetries; that is, the loop excitations of these topological orders carry nontrivial 1-form symmetry charges. This study also serves the purpose of diagnosing anomalies of 3d states of matter. Connection between SPT states with 1-form symmetries and condensed-matter systems such as quantum dimer models at one lower dimension will also be discussed. Whether a quantum dimer model can have a trivial gapped phase depends on the nature of its corresponding bulk state in one higher dimension.
The existence of self-correcting quantum memories in three dimensions is a long-standing open question at the interface between quantum computing and many-body physics. We take the perspective that large contributions to the entropy arising from fine-tuned spatial symmetries, including the assumption of an underlying regular lattice, are responsible for fundamental challenges to realizing self-correction. Accordingly, we introduce a class of disordered quantum codes, which we call "cored product codes". These codes are derived from classical factors via the hypergraph product but undergo a coring procedure which allows them to be embedded in a lower number of spatial dimensions while preserving code properties. As a specific example, we focus on a fractal code based on the aperiodic pinwheel tiling as the classical factor and perform finite temperature numerical simulations on the resulting three-dimensional quantum memory. We provide evidence that, below a critical temperature, the memory lifetime increases with system size for codes up to 60000 qubits.