Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2102.13452 · SciPost Physics Core

From integrability to chaos in quantum Liouvillians

Álvaro Rubio-García, Rafael A. Molina, J. Dukelsky

Published May 2, 2022• 28 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The dynamics of open quantum systems can be described by a Liouvillian, which in the Markovian approximation fulfills the Lindblad master equation. We present a family of integrable many-body Liouvillians based on Richardson-Gaudin models with a complex structure of the jump operators. Making use of this new region of integrability, we study the transition to chaos in terms of a two-parameter Liouvillian. The transition is characterized by the spectral statistics of the complex eigenvalues of the Liouvillian operators using the nearest neighbor spacing distribution and by the ratios between eigenvalue distances.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphyscore.5.2.026

Related papers

Dissipation and decoherence for generic open quantum systems

Lucas Sá

We study generic open quantum systems with Markovian dissipation, focusing on a class of stochastic Liouvillian operators of Lindblad form with independent random dissipation channels (jump operators) and a random Hamiltonian. We perform a thorough numerical study, focusing on global spectral features, the spectral gap, and the steady-state purity and statistics. We establish that all properties follow three different regimes as a function of the dissipation strength, whose boundaries depend on the particular observable. Within each regime, we determine the scaling exponents with the dissipation strength and system size. On the analytical side, we compute the average spectral gap at arbitrary dissipation and provide simple closed-form expressions for the asymptotic values at strong and weak dissipation strength. We also consider spectral correlations in generic complex spectra, such as that of the Liouvillian. We introduce and study, both analytically and numerically, the complex ratio of the nearest-neighbor spacing by next-to-nearest-neighbor spacing. Besides the usual level repulsion, we find that complex spacing ratios have a nontrivial angular dependence which offers a distinct signature of quantum chaos. It distinguishes integrable systems, which support the flat ratio distribution characteristic of Poisson statistics, and chaotic dissipative quantum systems, which conform to Random Matrix Theory statistics. We apply this new signature of quantum chaos to random Liouvillians and boundary-driven dissipative spin-chains. The results of this thesis can help understand the long-time dynamics, steady-state properties, and spectral correlations of generic dissipative systems.

arXiv:1911.02136•Nov 5, 2019•0 citations

Integrability versus chaos in the steady state of many-body open quantum systems

Josef Richter, Lucas Sá, Masudul Haque

The Lindblad description of an open quantum system gives rise to two types of integrability, since the nonequilibrium steady state can be integrable independently of the Liouvillian. Taking boundary-driven and dephasing spin chains as a representative example, we discriminate Liouvillian and steady-state chaos by combining level spacing statistics and an extension of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis to open quantum systems. Moreover, we analyze the structure of the steady states by expanding it in the basis of Pauli strings and comparing the weight of strings of different lengths. We show that the natural expectation that integrable steady states are "simple" (i.e., built from few-body local operators) does not hold: the steady states of both chaotic and integrable models have relevant contributions coming from Pauli strings of all possible lengths, including long-range and many-body interactions. Nevertheless, we show that one can effectively use the operator-size distribution to distinguish chaotic and integrable steady states.

arXiv:2412.16041•Physical review. E•Jun 2, 2025•5 citations

Dissipative dynamics in open XXZ Richardson-Gaudin models

Pieter W. Claeys, Austen Lamacraft

In specific open systems with collective dissipation the Liouvillian can be mapped to a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian. We here consider such a system where the Liouvillian is mapped to an XXZ Richardson-Gaudin integrable model and detail its exact Bethe ansatz solution. While no longer Hermitian, the Hamiltonian is $\text{pseudo-Hermitian}/\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}$ symmetric, and as the strength of the coupling to the environment is increased, the spectrum in a fixed symmetry sector changes from a broken pseudo-Hermitian phase with complex conjugate eigenvalues to a pseudo-Hermitian phase with real eigenvalues, passing through a series of exceptional points and associated dissipative quantum phase transitions. The homogeneous limit supports a nontrivial steady state, and away from this limit this state gives rise to a slow logarithmic growth of the decay rate (spectral gap) with system size. Using the exact solution, it is furthermore shown how at large coupling strengths the ratio of the imaginary to the real part of the eigenvalues becomes approximately quantized in the remaining symmetry sectors.

arXiv:2108.01677•Physical Review Research•Jan 14, 2022•13 citations

Lindbladian spectral statistics beyond no-jump Hamiltonians: roles of recycling and Liouville-space structure

Dingzu Wang, Hao Zhu, Guo-Feng Zhang +1 more

Spectral statistics probe integrability versus chaos and have recently been extended to Markovian open quantum systems described by Lindbladians, whose quantum-trajectory unraveling decomposes the evolution into no-jump dynamics generated by an effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonian and recycling jumps. In this work, we perform spectrum-statistics diagnostics for Lindbladians and their effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. We show that recycling processes, symmetry constraints, and the Liouville-space structure crucially shape the spectral correlations. In particular, we identify a family of spectrally separable Lindbladians whose spectra exhibit robust Poisson statistics, despite the effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonian varying from Poisson to strongly correlated complex-spectrum statistics. Our work establishes a unified spectral-statistics characterization for Lindbladians and their associated effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, deepening our understanding of spectral properties in open many-body systems.

quant-pharXiv:2603.18946•Physical review. E•Mar 20, 2026•0 citations

Dissipative quantum dynamics, phase transitions, and non-Hermitian random matrices

Mahaveer Prasad, Hari Kumar Yadalam, Camille Aron +1 more

We explore the connections between dissipative quantum phase transitions and non-Hermitian random matrix theory. For this, we work in the framework of the dissipative Dicke model which is archetypal of symmetry-breaking phase transitions in open quantum systems. We establish that the Liouvillian describing the quantum dynamics exhibits distinct spectral features of integrable and chaotic character on the two sides of the critical point. We follow the distribution of the spacings of the complex Liouvillian eigenvalues across the critical point. In the normal and superradiant phases, the distributions are two-dimensional Poisson and that of the Ginibre unitary random matrix ensemble, respectively. Our results are corroborated by computing a recently introduced complex-plane generalization of the consecutive level-spacing ratio distribution. Our approach can be readily adapted for classifying the nature of quantum dynamics across dissipative critical points in other open quantum systems.

arXiv:2112.05765•Physical Review A•May 11, 2022•35 citations

Symmetry of Open Quantum Systems: Classification of Dissipative Quantum Chaos

Kohei Kawabata, Anish Kulkarni, Jiachen Li +2 more

We develop a theory of symmetry in open quantum systems.Using the operator-state mapping, we characterize symmetry of Liouvillian superoperators for the open quantum dynamics by symmetry of operators in the double Hilbert space and apply the 38-fold internal-symmetry classification of non-Hermitian operators.We find rich symmetry classification due to the interplay between symmetry in the corresponding closed quantum systems and symmetry inherent in the construction of the Liouvillian superoperators.As an illustrative example of open quantum bosonic systems, we study symmetry classes of dissipative quantum spin models.For open quantum fermionic systems, we develop the Z 4 classification of fermion parity symmetry and antiunitary symmetry in the double Hilbert space, which contrasts with the Z 8 classification in closed quantum systems.We also develop the symmetry classification of open quantum fermionic many-body systems-a dissipative generalization of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model described by the Lindblad master equation.We establish the periodic tables of the SYK Lindbladians and elucidate the difference from the SYK Hamiltonians.Furthermore, from extensive numerical calculations, we study its complex-spectral statistics and demonstrate dissipative quantum chaos enriched by symmetry.

arXiv:2212.00605•PRX Quantum•Aug 29, 2023•73 citations
The dynamics of open quantum systems can be described by a Liouvillian, which in the Markovian approximation fulfills the Lindblad master equation. We present a family of integrable many-body Liouvillians based on Richardson-Gaudin models with a complex structure of the jump operators. Making use of this new region of integrability, we study the transition to chaos in terms of a two-parameter Liouvillian. The transition is characterized by the spectral statistics of the complex eigenvalues of the Liouvillian operators using the nearest neighbor spacing distribution and by the ratios between eigenvalue distances.
We study generic open quantum systems with Markovian dissipation, focusing on a class of stochastic Liouvillian operators of Lindblad form with independent random dissipation channels (jump operators) and a random Hamiltonian. We perform a thorough numerical study, focusing on global spectral features, the spectral gap, and the steady-state purity and statistics. We establish that all properties follow three different regimes as a function of the dissipation strength, whose boundaries depend on the particular observable. Within each regime, we determine the scaling exponents with the dissipation strength and system size. On the analytical side, we compute the average spectral gap at arbitrary dissipation and provide simple closed-form expressions for the asymptotic values at strong and weak dissipation strength. We also consider spectral correlations in generic complex spectra, such as that of the Liouvillian. We introduce and study, both analytically and numerically, the complex ratio of the nearest-neighbor spacing by next-to-nearest-neighbor spacing. Besides the usual level repulsion, we find that complex spacing ratios have a nontrivial angular dependence which offers a distinct signature of quantum chaos. It distinguishes integrable systems, which support the flat ratio distribution characteristic of Poisson statistics, and chaotic dissipative quantum systems, which conform to Random Matrix Theory statistics. We apply this new signature of quantum chaos to random Liouvillians and boundary-driven dissipative spin-chains. The results of this thesis can help understand the long-time dynamics, steady-state properties, and spectral correlations of generic dissipative systems.
The Lindblad description of an open quantum system gives rise to two types of integrability, since the nonequilibrium steady state can be integrable independently of the Liouvillian. Taking boundary-driven and dephasing spin chains as a representative example, we discriminate Liouvillian and steady-state chaos by combining level spacing statistics and an extension of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis to open quantum systems. Moreover, we analyze the structure of the steady states by expanding it in the basis of Pauli strings and comparing the weight of strings of different lengths. We show that the natural expectation that integrable steady states are "simple" (i.e., built from few-body local operators) does not hold: the steady states of both chaotic and integrable models have relevant contributions coming from Pauli strings of all possible lengths, including long-range and many-body interactions. Nevertheless, we show that one can effectively use the operator-size distribution to distinguish chaotic and integrable steady states.
In specific open systems with collective dissipation the Liouvillian can be mapped to a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian. We here consider such a system where the Liouvillian is mapped to an XXZ Richardson-Gaudin integrable model and detail its exact Bethe ansatz solution. While no longer Hermitian, the Hamiltonian is pseudo-Hermitian/PT\text{pseudo-Hermitian}/\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}pseudo-Hermitian/PT symmetric, and as the strength of the coupling to the environment is increased, the spectrum in a fixed symmetry sector changes from a broken pseudo-Hermitian phase with complex conjugate eigenvalues to a pseudo-Hermitian phase with real eigenvalues, passing through a series of exceptional points and associated dissipative quantum phase transitions. The homogeneous limit supports a nontrivial steady state, and away from this limit this state gives rise to a slow logarithmic growth of the decay rate (spectral gap) with system size. Using the exact solution, it is furthermore shown how at large coupling strengths the ratio of the imaginary to the real part of the eigenvalues becomes approximately quantized in the remaining symmetry sectors.
Spectral statistics probe integrability versus chaos and have recently been extended to Markovian open quantum systems described by Lindbladians, whose quantum-trajectory unraveling decomposes the evolution into no-jump dynamics generated by an effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonian and recycling jumps. In this work, we perform spectrum-statistics diagnostics for Lindbladians and their effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. We show that recycling processes, symmetry constraints, and the Liouville-space structure crucially shape the spectral correlations. In particular, we identify a family of spectrally separable Lindbladians whose spectra exhibit robust Poisson statistics, despite the effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonian varying from Poisson to strongly correlated complex-spectrum statistics. Our work establishes a unified spectral-statistics characterization for Lindbladians and their associated effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, deepening our understanding of spectral properties in open many-body systems.
We explore the connections between dissipative quantum phase transitions and non-Hermitian random matrix theory. For this, we work in the framework of the dissipative Dicke model which is archetypal of symmetry-breaking phase transitions in open quantum systems. We establish that the Liouvillian describing the quantum dynamics exhibits distinct spectral features of integrable and chaotic character on the two sides of the critical point. We follow the distribution of the spacings of the complex Liouvillian eigenvalues across the critical point. In the normal and superradiant phases, the distributions are two-dimensional Poisson and that of the Ginibre unitary random matrix ensemble, respectively. Our results are corroborated by computing a recently introduced complex-plane generalization of the consecutive level-spacing ratio distribution. Our approach can be readily adapted for classifying the nature of quantum dynamics across dissipative critical points in other open quantum systems.
We develop a theory of symmetry in open quantum systems.Using the operator-state mapping, we characterize symmetry of Liouvillian superoperators for the open quantum dynamics by symmetry of operators in the double Hilbert space and apply the 38-fold internal-symmetry classification of non-Hermitian operators.We find rich symmetry classification due to the interplay between symmetry in the corresponding closed quantum systems and symmetry inherent in the construction of the Liouvillian superoperators.As an illustrative example of open quantum bosonic systems, we study symmetry classes of dissipative quantum spin models.For open quantum fermionic systems, we develop the Z 4 classification of fermion parity symmetry and antiunitary symmetry in the double Hilbert space, which contrasts with the Z 8 classification in closed quantum systems.We also develop the symmetry classification of open quantum fermionic many-body systems-a dissipative generalization of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model described by the Lindblad master equation.We establish the periodic tables of the SYK Lindbladians and elucidate the difference from the SYK Hamiltonians.Furthermore, from extensive numerical calculations, we study its complex-spectral statistics and demonstrate dissipative quantum chaos enriched by symmetry.