Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2102.03374 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Boundary time crystals in collective d -level systems

Luis Fernando dos Prazeres, Leonardo da Silva Souza, Fernando Iemini

Published May 20, 2021• 49 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Boundary time crystals (BTC's) are nonequilibrium phases of matter occurring in quantum systems in contact to an environment, for which a macroscopic fraction of the many-body system breaks time translation symmetry. We study BTC's in collective $d$-level systems, focusing on the cases with $d=2$, 3, and 4. We find that BTC's appear in different forms for the different cases. We first consider the model with collective $d=2$-level systems [Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 035301 (2018)], whose dynamics is described by a Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad master equation, and perform a throughout analysis of its phase diagram and Jacobian stability for different interacting terms in the coherent Hamiltonian. In particular, using perturbation theory for general (non-Hermitian) matrices, we obtain analytically how a specific ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ symmetry-breaking Hamiltonian term destroys the BTC phase in the model. Based on these results we define a $d=4$ model composed of a pair of collective two-level systems interacting with each other. We show that this model support richer dynamical phases, ranging from limit cycles, period-doubling bifurcations, and a route to chaotic dynamics. The BTC phase is more robust in this case, not annihilated by the former symmetry-breaking Hamiltonian terms. The model with collective $d=3$-level systems is defined similarly, as competing pairs of levels, but sharing a common collective level. The dynamics can deviate significantly from the previous cases, supporting phases with the coexistence of multiple limit cycles, closed orbits and a full degeneracy of zero Lyapunov exponents.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.103.184308

Related papers

Boundary Time Crystals Induced by Local Dissipation and Long-Range Interactions

Zhuqing Wang, Ruochen Gao, Xiaoling Wu +4 more

Driven-dissipative many-body systems support nontrivial quantum phases absent in equilibrium. As a prominent example, the interplay between coherent driving and collective dissipation can lead to a dynamical quantum phase that spontaneously breaks time-translation symmetry. This so-called boundary time crystal (BTC) is fragile in the presence of local dissipation, which can easily relax the system to a stationary state. In this Letter, we demonstrate a robust BTC that is intrinsically induced by local dissipation. We provide extensive numerical evidence to support the existence of the BTC and study its behaviors in different regimes. In particular, with decreasing interaction range, we identify a transition from mean-field limit cycles to correlated BTCs featuring sizable quantum correlations. Our studies significantly broaden the scope of nonequilibrium phases and shed new light on the experimental search for dynamical quantum matter.

arXiv:2503.20761•Physical Review Letters•Dec 1, 2025•11 citations

Genuine multipartite correlations in a boundary time crystal

Antônio C. Lourenço, Luis Fernando dos Prazeres, Thiago O. Maciel +2 more

In this paper we study genuine multipartite correlations (GMC's) in a boundary time crystal (BTC). Boundary time crystals are nonequilibrium quantum phases of matter in contact to an environment, for which a macroscopic fraction of the many-body system breaks the time translation symmetry. We analyze both (i) the structure (orders) of GMC's among the subsystems, as well as (ii) their build-up dynamics for an initially uncorrelated state. We find that, in the thermodynamic limit (and only in such a limit), multipartite correlations of all orders grow indefinitely in time in the BTC phase, further displaying a persistent oscillatory behavior around their mean growth. The orders of the correlations show a power-law decaying hierarchy among its $k$ partitions. Moreover, in the long-time limit the GMC's are shown extensive with the system size, contrasting to the subextensive scaling in the non time crystals (ferromagnetic) phase of the model. We also discuss the classical and quantum nature of these correlations with basis on multipartite entanglement witnesses, specifically, the analysis of the quantum Fisher information (QFI). Both GMC and QFI are able to capture and distinguish the different phases of the model. Our paper highlights the genuine many-body properties of these peculiar nonequilibrium phases of matter.

arXiv:2112.11510•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 20, 2022•23 citations

Exact solution of a boundary time-crystal phase transition: Time-translation symmetry breaking and non-Markovian dynamics of correlations

Federico Carollo, Igor Lesanovsky

The breaking of the continuous time-translation symmetry manifests, in Markovian open quantum systems, through the emergence of nonstationary dynamical phases. Systems that display nonequilibrium transitions into these phases are referred to as time crystals, and they can be realized, for example, in many-body systems governed by collective dissipation and long-ranged interactions. Here, we provide a complete analytical characterization of a boundary time-crystal phase transition. This involves exact expressions for the order parameter and for the dynamics of quantum fluctuations, which, in the time-crystalline phase, remains asymptotically non-Markovian as a consequence of the time-translation symmetry breaking. We demonstrate that boundary time crystals are intrinsically critical phases, where fluctuations exhibit a power-law divergence with time. Our results show that a dissipative time-crystal phase is far more than merely a classical nonlinear and nonstationary (limit cycle) dynamics of a macroscopic order parameter. It is rather a genuine many-body phase where the properties of correlations distinctly differ from those of stationary ones.

arXiv:2110.00030•Physical Review A•Apr 22, 2022•62 citations

Thermodynamics of coupled time crystals with an application to energy storage

Paulo J. Paulino, Albert Cabot, Gabriele De Chiara +3 more

Abstract Open many-body quantum systems can exhibit intriguing nonequilibrium phases of matter, such as time crystals. In these phases, the state of the system spontaneously breaks the time-translation symmetry of the dynamical generator, which typically manifests through persistent oscillations of an order parameter. A paradigmatic model displaying such a symmetry breaking is the boundary time crystal (BTC), which has been extensively analyzed experimentally and theoretically. Despite the broad interest in these nonequilibrium phases, their thermodynamics and their fluctuating behavior remain largely unexplored, in particular for the case of coupled time crystals. In this work, we consider two interacting BTCs and derive a consistent interpretation of their thermodynamic behavior. We fully characterize their average dynamics and the behavior of their quantum fluctuations, which allows us to demonstrate the presence of quantum and classical correlations in both the stationary and the time-crystal phases displayed by the system. We furthermore exploit our theoretical derivation to explore possible applications of time crystals as quantum batteries, demonstrating their ability to efficiently store energy.

arXiv:2411.04836•Quantum Science and Technology•Oct 28, 2025•5 citations

Symmetries and conserved quantities of boundary time crystals in generalized spin models

G. Piccitto, Matteo M. Wauters, Franco Nori +1 more

We investigate how symmetries and conserved quantities relate to the occurrence of the boundary time crystal (BTC) phase in a generalized spin model with Lindblad dissipation. BTCs are a nonequilibrium phase of matter in which the system, coupled to an external environment, breaks the continuous time translational invariance. We perform a detailed mean-field study aided by a finite-size analysis of the quantum model of a $p,q$-spin-interaction system, a generalized $p$-spin-interaction system, which can be implemented in fully connected spin-1/2 ensembles. We find the following conditions for the observation of the BTC phase. First, the BTC appears when the discrete symmetry held by the Hamiltonian, ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ in the considered models, is explicitly broken by the Lindblad jump operators. Second, the system must be coupled uniformly to the same bath in order to preserve the total angular momentum during the time evolution. If these conditions are not satisfied, any oscillatory behavior appears only as a transient in the dynamics and a time-independent stationary state is eventually reached. Our results suggest that these two elements may be general requirements for the observation of a stable BTC phase relating symmetries and conserved quantities in arbitrary spin models.

arXiv:2101.05710•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 19, 2021•58 citations

Dynamical Quantum Phase Transitions in Boundary Time Crystals

Sukrut Mondkar, Priya Ghosh, Ujjwal Sen

We demonstrate the existence of a dynamical quantum phase transition (DQPT) in a dissipative collective-spin model that exhibits the boundary time crystal (BTC) phase. We initialize the system in the ground state of the Hamiltonian in either the BTC or the non-BTC phase, and drive it across the BTC transition. The driving is done by an abrupt quench or by a finite-time linear ramp of a Hamiltonian control parameter under Markovian Lindblad dynamics. We diagnose DQPTs through zeros of the fidelity-based Loschmidt echo between the initial state and the evolving mixed state, which induce nonanalytic cusp-like features in the associated rate function. For quenches into the BTC phase, the Loschmidt echo exhibits repeated zeros due to the emergent time-periodic steady state, whereas for quenches into the non-BTC phase, the overlap vanishes and remains zero once the dynamics relaxes to a stationary state. We further show that the DQPT persists under the ramp protocol followed by unitary evolution with the final Hamiltonian. Finally, we analyze the finite-size scaling of the first critical time and find convergence to a constant in the thermodynamic limit, with distinct power-law approaches for the quench and the ramp protocols.

quant-pharXiv:2602.04792•Feb 5, 2026•0 citations
Boundary time crystals (BTC's) are nonequilibrium phases of matter occurring in quantum systems in contact to an environment, for which a macroscopic fraction of the many-body system breaks time translation symmetry. We study BTC's in collective ddd-level systems, focusing on the cases with d=2d=2d=2, 3, and 4. We find that BTC's appear in different forms for the different cases. We first consider the model with collective d=2d=2d=2-level systems [Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 035301 (2018)], whose dynamics is described by a Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad master equation, and perform a throughout analysis of its phase diagram and Jacobian stability for different interacting terms in the coherent Hamiltonian. In particular, using perturbation theory for general (non-Hermitian) matrices, we obtain analytically how a specific Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ symmetry-breaking Hamiltonian term destroys the BTC phase in the model. Based on these results we define a d=4d=4d=4 model composed of a pair of collective two-level systems interacting with each other. We show that this model support richer dynamical phases, ranging from limit cycles, period-doubling bifurcations, and a route to chaotic dynamics. The BTC phase is more robust in this case, not annihilated by the former symmetry-breaking Hamiltonian terms. The model with collective d=3d=3d=3-level systems is defined similarly, as competing pairs of levels, but sharing a common collective level. The dynamics can deviate significantly from the previous cases, supporting phases with the coexistence of multiple limit cycles, closed orbits and a full degeneracy of zero Lyapunov exponents.
Driven-dissipative many-body systems support nontrivial quantum phases absent in equilibrium. As a prominent example, the interplay between coherent driving and collective dissipation can lead to a dynamical quantum phase that spontaneously breaks time-translation symmetry. This so-called boundary time crystal (BTC) is fragile in the presence of local dissipation, which can easily relax the system to a stationary state. In this Letter, we demonstrate a robust BTC that is intrinsically induced by local dissipation. We provide extensive numerical evidence to support the existence of the BTC and study its behaviors in different regimes. In particular, with decreasing interaction range, we identify a transition from mean-field limit cycles to correlated BTCs featuring sizable quantum correlations. Our studies significantly broaden the scope of nonequilibrium phases and shed new light on the experimental search for dynamical quantum matter.
In this paper we study genuine multipartite correlations (GMC's) in a boundary time crystal (BTC). Boundary time crystals are nonequilibrium quantum phases of matter in contact to an environment, for which a macroscopic fraction of the many-body system breaks the time translation symmetry. We analyze both (i) the structure (orders) of GMC's among the subsystems, as well as (ii) their build-up dynamics for an initially uncorrelated state. We find that, in the thermodynamic limit (and only in such a limit), multipartite correlations of all orders grow indefinitely in time in the BTC phase, further displaying a persistent oscillatory behavior around their mean growth. The orders of the correlations show a power-law decaying hierarchy among its kkk partitions. Moreover, in the long-time limit the GMC's are shown extensive with the system size, contrasting to the subextensive scaling in the non time crystals (ferromagnetic) phase of the model. We also discuss the classical and quantum nature of these correlations with basis on multipartite entanglement witnesses, specifically, the analysis of the quantum Fisher information (QFI). Both GMC and QFI are able to capture and distinguish the different phases of the model. Our paper highlights the genuine many-body properties of these peculiar nonequilibrium phases of matter.
The breaking of the continuous time-translation symmetry manifests, in Markovian open quantum systems, through the emergence of nonstationary dynamical phases. Systems that display nonequilibrium transitions into these phases are referred to as time crystals, and they can be realized, for example, in many-body systems governed by collective dissipation and long-ranged interactions. Here, we provide a complete analytical characterization of a boundary time-crystal phase transition. This involves exact expressions for the order parameter and for the dynamics of quantum fluctuations, which, in the time-crystalline phase, remains asymptotically non-Markovian as a consequence of the time-translation symmetry breaking. We demonstrate that boundary time crystals are intrinsically critical phases, where fluctuations exhibit a power-law divergence with time. Our results show that a dissipative time-crystal phase is far more than merely a classical nonlinear and nonstationary (limit cycle) dynamics of a macroscopic order parameter. It is rather a genuine many-body phase where the properties of correlations distinctly differ from those of stationary ones.
Abstract Open many-body quantum systems can exhibit intriguing nonequilibrium phases of matter, such as time crystals. In these phases, the state of the system spontaneously breaks the time-translation symmetry of the dynamical generator, which typically manifests through persistent oscillations of an order parameter. A paradigmatic model displaying such a symmetry breaking is the boundary time crystal (BTC), which has been extensively analyzed experimentally and theoretically. Despite the broad interest in these nonequilibrium phases, their thermodynamics and their fluctuating behavior remain largely unexplored, in particular for the case of coupled time crystals. In this work, we consider two interacting BTCs and derive a consistent interpretation of their thermodynamic behavior. We fully characterize their average dynamics and the behavior of their quantum fluctuations, which allows us to demonstrate the presence of quantum and classical correlations in both the stationary and the time-crystal phases displayed by the system. We furthermore exploit our theoretical derivation to explore possible applications of time crystals as quantum batteries, demonstrating their ability to efficiently store energy.
We investigate how symmetries and conserved quantities relate to the occurrence of the boundary time crystal (BTC) phase in a generalized spin model with Lindblad dissipation. BTCs are a nonequilibrium phase of matter in which the system, coupled to an external environment, breaks the continuous time translational invariance. We perform a detailed mean-field study aided by a finite-size analysis of the quantum model of a p,qp,qp,q-spin-interaction system, a generalized ppp-spin-interaction system, which can be implemented in fully connected spin-1/2 ensembles. We find the following conditions for the observation of the BTC phase. First, the BTC appears when the discrete symmetry held by the Hamiltonian, Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ in the considered models, is explicitly broken by the Lindblad jump operators. Second, the system must be coupled uniformly to the same bath in order to preserve the total angular momentum during the time evolution. If these conditions are not satisfied, any oscillatory behavior appears only as a transient in the dynamics and a time-independent stationary state is eventually reached. Our results suggest that these two elements may be general requirements for the observation of a stable BTC phase relating symmetries and conserved quantities in arbitrary spin models.
We demonstrate the existence of a dynamical quantum phase transition (DQPT) in a dissipative collective-spin model that exhibits the boundary time crystal (BTC) phase. We initialize the system in the ground state of the Hamiltonian in either the BTC or the non-BTC phase, and drive it across the BTC transition. The driving is done by an abrupt quench or by a finite-time linear ramp of a Hamiltonian control parameter under Markovian Lindblad dynamics. We diagnose DQPTs through zeros of the fidelity-based Loschmidt echo between the initial state and the evolving mixed state, which induce nonanalytic cusp-like features in the associated rate function. For quenches into the BTC phase, the Loschmidt echo exhibits repeated zeros due to the emergent time-periodic steady state, whereas for quenches into the non-BTC phase, the overlap vanishes and remains zero once the dynamics relaxes to a stationary state. We further show that the DQPT persists under the ramp protocol followed by unitary evolution with the final Hamiltonian. Finally, we analyze the finite-size scaling of the first critical time and find convergence to a constant in the thermodynamic limit, with distinct power-law approaches for the quench and the ramp protocols.