In this study, we discuss a type of bulk-boundary correspondence, which holds for topological insulators and superconductors when the parity-time ( P T ) and/or parity-particle-hole ( P C ) symmetry are present. In these systems, even when the bulk topology is nontrivial, the edge spectrum is generally gapped, and thus the conventional bulk-boundary correspondence does not hold. We find that, instead of the edge spectrum, the single-particle entanglement spectrum becomes gapless when the bulk topology is nontrivial: i.e., the holds in P T - and/or P C -symmetric topological insulators and superconductors. After showing the correspondence using K -theoretic approach, we provide concrete models for each symmetry class up to three dimensions where nontrivial topology because of P T and/or P C is expected. An implication of our results is that, when the bulk topology under P T and/or P C symmetry is nontrivial, the noninteracting many-body entanglement spectrum is multiply degenerate in one dimension and is gapless in two or higher dimensions. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We have studied extensively the band-crossing patterns of the bulk entanglement spectrum (BES) for various lattice Chern insulators. We find that only partitions with dual symmetry can have either stable nodal lines or nodal points in the BES when the system is in the topological phase of a nonzero Chern number. By deforming the Hamiltonian to lift the accidental symmetry, one can see that only nodal points are robust. They thus should bear certain topological characteristics of the BES. By studying the band-crossing patterns in detail, we conclude that the topological characteristics of the BES are inherited from the topological order of the underlying Chern insulators, and the former can have more refined topological structures. We then conjecture that the sum of the vorticities in the BES in a properly chosen reduced Brillouin zone equals the Chern number of the underlying Chern insulator. This relation is beyond the usual classification scheme of topological insulators/superconductors.
We study the single-particle entanglement spectrum in 2D topological insulators which possess
n-fold rotation symmetry. By defining a series of special choices of subsystems on which the entanglement is calculated, or real space cuts, we find that the number of protected in-gap states for each type of these real space cuts is a quantum number indexing (if any) nontrivial topology in these insulators. We explicitly show that the number of protected in-gap states is determined by a
Zn index
(z1,...,zn), where
zm is the number of occupied states that transform according to
mth one-dimensional representation of the
Cn point group. We find that for a space cut separating
1/pth of the system, the entanglement spectrum contains in-gap states pinned in an interval of entanglement eigenvalues $[1/p,1\ensuremath{-}1/p]$. We determine the number of such in-gap states for an exhaustive variety of cuts, in terms of the
Zn index. Furthermore, we show that in a homogeneous system, the
Zn index can be determined through an evaluation of the eigenvalues of point-group symmetry operators at all high-symmetry points in the Brillouin zone. When disordered
n-fold rotationally symmetric systems are considered, we find that the number of protected in-gap states is identical to that in the clean limit as long as the disorder preserves the underlying point-group symmetry and does not close the bulk insulating gap.
What does it mean for a mixed-state topological phase to be chiral? Mathematically, chirality can be sharply characterized through the symmetry algebra of the mixed state. Physically, however, the question is far more subtle. In pure states, chirality in topological phase is tied to a web of familiar diagnostics, involving bulk-boundary correspondence, a gapless entanglement spectrum, a nontrivial modular commutator, and a quantized thermal Hall response. We show that none of these diagnostics remain reliable in mixed states. Instead, for decohered topological phases with a known error-free parent state, we propose two relative-entropy-based measures that can diagnose chirality, with one of them further extracting the chiral central charge. As a concrete example, we use these measures to analyze the
em2-decohered
Z3 toric code, identifying the chirality transition to be in the random-bond Potts class for the particle-hole symmetric channel, and the polarized random bond Potts class for asymmetric channels. Our results emphasize how mixed-state topology demands intrinsically new diagnostics beyond direct analogues of pure-state probes.
If an extensive partition in two dimensions yields a gapful entanglement spectrum of the reduced density matrix, the Berry curvature based on the corresponding entanglement eigenfunction defines the Chern number. We propose such an entanglement Chern number as a useful, natural, and calculable topological invariant, which is potentially relevant to various topological ground states. We show that it serves as an alternative topological invariant for time-reversal invariant systems and as a new topological invariant for a weak topological phase of a superlattice Wilson-Dirac model. In principle, the entanglement Chern number can also be effective for interacting systems such as topological insulators in contrast to
Z2 invariants.
Recently, it has been shown how topological phases of matter with crystalline symmetry and
U(1) charge conservation can be partially characterized by a set of many-body invariants, the discrete shift
So and electric polarization ${\stackrel{P\vec}{\mathcal{P}}}_{\mathrm{o}}$, where
o labels a high-symmetry point. Crucially, these can be defined even with nonzero Chern number and/or magnetic field. One manifestation of these invariants is through quantized fractional contributions to the charge in the vicinity of a lattice disclination or dislocation. In this paper, we show that these invariants can also be extracted from the length and corner dependence of the total charge (mod 1) on the boundary of the system. We provide a general formula in terms of
So and ${\stackrel{P\vec}{\mathcal{P}}}_{\mathrm{o}}$ for the total charge of any subregion of the system which can include full boundaries or bulk lattice defects, unifying boundary, corner, disclination, and dislocation charge responses into a single general theory. These results hold for Chern insulators, despite their gapless chiral edge modes, and for which an unambiguous definition of an intrinsically two-dimensional electric polarization has been unclear until recently. We also discuss how our theory can fully characterize the topological response of quadrupole insulators.