Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2102.02120

Error mitigation by training with fermionic linear optics

Ashley Montanaro, Stasja Stanisic

Published Feb 3, 2021• 49 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers could solve quantum-mechanical simulation problems that are beyond the capabilities of classical computers. However, NISQ devices experience significant errors which, if not corrected, can render physical quantities measured in these simulations inaccurate or meaningless. Here we describe a method of reducing these errors which is tailored to quantum algorithms for simulating fermionic systems. The method is based on executing quantum circuits in the model of fermionic linear optics, which are known to be efficiently simulable classically, to infer the relationship between exact and noisy measurement outcomes, and hence undo the effect of noise. We validated our method by applying it to the VQE algorithm for estimating ground state energies of instances of the Fermi-Hubbard model. In classical numerical simulations of 12-qubit examples with physically realistic levels of depolarising noise, errors were reduced by a factor of around 34 compared with the uncorrected case. Smaller experiments on quantum hardware demonstrate an average reduction in errors by a factor of 10 or more.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2102.02120

Related papers

Quantum Error Mitigation With Artificial Neural Network

Changjun Kim, Daniel K. Park, June‐Koo Kevin Rhee

A quantum error mitigation technique based on machine learning is proposed, which learns how to adjust the probabilities estimated by measurement in the computational basis. Neural networks in two different designs are trained with random quantum circuits consisting of a set of one- and two-qubit unitary gates whose measurement statistics in the ideal (noiseless) and real (noisy) cases are known. Once the neural networks are trained, they infer the amount of probability adjustment to be made on the measurement obtained from executing an unseen quantum circuit to reduce the error. The proposed schemes are tested with two-, three-, five-, and seven-qubit quantum circuits of depth up to 20 by computer simulations with realistic error models and experiments using the IBM quantum cloud platform. In all test cases, the proposed mitigation technique reduces the error effectively. Our method can be used to improve the accuracy of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) algorithms without relying on extensive error characterization or quantum error correction.

IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2020•81 citations

Error mitigation with Clifford quantum-circuit data

Piotr Czarnik, Andrew Arrasmith, Patrick J. Coles +1 more

Achieving near-term quantum advantage will require accurate estimation of quantum observables despite significant hardware noise. For this purpose, we propose a novel, scalable error-mitigation method that applies to gate-based quantum computers. The method generates training data { X i noisy , X i exact } via quantum circuits composed largely of Clifford gates, which can be efficiently simulated classically, where X i noisy and X i exact are noisy and noiseless observables respectively. Fitting a linear ansatz to this data then allows for the prediction of noise-free observables for arbitrary circuits. We analyze the performance of our method versus the number of qubits, circuit depth, and number of non-Clifford gates. We obtain an order-of-magnitude error reduction for a ground-state energy problem on 16 qubits in an IBMQ quantum computer and on a 64-qubit noisy simulator.

arXiv:2005.10189•Quantum•Nov 26, 2021•329 citations

Towards reliable quantum computation: mitigation and certification from NISQ to early fault-tolerance

James Alastair Casebourne Mills

The recent pace of experimental progress in quantum technologies suggests we may soon reach a time when quantum devices can be applied to solve problems of practical interest. Despite this, we are still far from being able to abstract away the effects of noise on quantum computation. The reliable execution of computations on current devices remains a significant challenge. This holds true both for computation with noisy physical qubits and for computation using the limited forms of error correction available on early fault-tolerant quantum devices. In this thesis, I propose methods for improving the reliability of quantum devices, as the field transitions from the regime of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices to that of early fault-tolerance. These span the topics of quantum error mitigation, quantum error correction and quantum certification. In the first instance, I propose methods for improving the performance of quantum devices affected by limited amounts of noise. Specifically, I present a method for mitigating the effects of time-dependent noise. This adapts a computational certification protocol called accreditation into a method for postselecting on weaker time-dependent noise behaviours. The method is analytically shown to lead to a provable reduction in errors for the case of depolarising noise, and demonstrated in experiments on superconducting hardware. I also present a method for mitigating the effects of photon loss in photonic quantum devices. Through a combination of analytical and numerical analysis, it is shown that there are wide regimes of photon loss for which this method outperforms postselection, the standard method of handling loss in photonic devices. Additionally, evidence is provided that the method enhances the performance of a quantum machine learning model known as a Quantum Circuit Born Machine in the presence of photon loss. Next, I introduce a framework for certifying the correctness of computations run on encoded logical qubits. This is sensitive to considerably more general forms of noise than is usually considered in quantum error correction. It can be applied to efficiently certify the correctness of quantum computations for large system sizes, beyond the capabilities of methods relying on classical simulation. In numerical experiments, the framework was applied to certify the accuracy of instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) circuit sampling and Trotterised Hamiltonian simulation. It can be used to efficiently assess whether quantum error mitigation may be usefully applied to a computation, to upper-bound the infidelity of the encoded logical state, and to extend the method of entropy density benchmarking to logical computation. The methods presented in this thesis contribute to the wider effort of building towards reliable quantum computation: both in the sense of reducing the effects of noise on computational output, and in the sense of certifying the correctness of computation beyond the capabilities of classical simulators. Only with reliable quantum computation can the full potential of this technology be realised.

•May 7, 2026•0 citations

Model-Independent Error Mitigation in Parametric Quantum Circuits and Depolarizing Projection of Quantum Noise

Xiaoyang Wang, Xu Feng, Lena Funcke +5 more

Finding ground states and low-lying excitations of a given Hamiltonian is one of the most important problems in many fields of physics. As a novel approach, quantum computing on Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices offers the prospect to efficiently perform such computations and may eventually outperform classical computers. However, current quantum devices still suffer from inherent quantum noise. In this work, we propose an error mitigation scheme suitable for parametric quantum circuits. This scheme is based on projecting a general quantum noise channel onto depolarization errors. Our method can efficiently reduce errors in quantum computations, which we demonstrate by carrying out simulations both on classical and IBM's quantum devices. In particular, we test the performance of the method by computing the mass gap of the transverse-field Ising model using the variational quantum eigensolver algorithm.

arXiv:2111.15522•International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory (LATTICE)•May 16, 2022•4 citations

Designing Machine Learning Error-Mitigation Protocols for High-Fidelity Digital Quantum Simulation

Albert Schmidt

The pursuit of high-fidelity digital quantum simulation is fundamentally constrained by the inevitable presence of noise in current and near-term quantum processors. While quantum error correction ultimately promises fault-tolerance, its substantial qubit overhead renders it impractical for the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era. This research addresses the critical gap between hardware imperfections and simulation accuracy by designing systematic, resource-efficient machine learning (ML) error-mitigation protocols tailored specifically for digital quantum simulation. Unlike generic error-suppression methods, our approach exploits the unique structural properties of simulated quantum dynamics—including time-translation invariance, locality of interactions, and conserved quantities—to inform the training of lightweight neural networks and Gaussian process regressors. We develop a hybrid framework that combines randomized compiling with data-driven noise-inversion models, enabling real-time estimation and subtraction of both coherent and incoherent errors without exponential sampling overhead. Through extensive numerical benchmarks on spin-chain and Fermi-Hubbard models, we demonstrate that our ML protocols achieve up to an order-of-magnitude reduction in infidelity compared to standard probabilistic error cancellation and zero-noise extrapolation, while requiring fewer calibration circuits. Furthermore, we introduce an adaptive online learning scheme that continuously refines the mitigation model during the simulation runtime, automatically adjusting to time-dependent drift in hardware noise. Our results establish a practical pathway toward scalable, high-accuracy quantum simulations on existing devices, with implications for condensed matter physics, quantum chemistry, and the development of quantum advantage benchmarks.

•Jul 14, 2026•0 citations

Quantum error mitigation via quantum-noise-effect circuit groups

Yusuke Hama, Hirofumi Nishi

Near-term quantum computers have been built as intermediate-scale quantum devices and are fragile against quantum noise effects, namely, NISQ devices. Traditional quantum-error-correcting codes are not implemented on such devices and to perform quantum computation in good accuracy with these machines we need to develop alternative approaches for mitigating quantum computational errors. In this work, we propose quantum error mitigation (QEM) scheme for quantum computational errors which occur due to couplings with environments during gate operations, i.e., decoherence. To establish our QEM scheme, first we estimate the quantum noise effects on single-qubit states and represent them as groups of quantum circuits, namely, quantum-noise-effect circuit groups. Then our QEM scheme is conducted by subtracting expectation values generated by the quantum-noise-effect circuit groups from those obtained by the quantum circuits for the quantum algorithms under consideration. As a result, the quantum noise effects are reduced, and we obtain approximately the ideal expectation values via the quantum-noise-effect circuit groups and the numbers of elementary quantum circuits composing them scale polynomial with respect to the products of the depths of quantum algorithms and the numbers of register bits. To numerically demonstrate the validity of our QEM scheme, we run noisy quantum simulations of qubits under amplitude damping effects for four types of quantum algorithms. Furthermore, we implement our QEM scheme on IBM Q Experience processors and examine its efficacy. Consequently, the validity of our scheme is verified via both the quantum simulations and the quantum computations on the real quantum devices. Our QEM scheme is solely composed of quantum-computational operations (quantum gates and measurements), and thus, it can be conducted by any type of quantum device. In addition, it can be applied to error mitigation for many other types of quantum noise effects as well as noisy quantum computing of long-depth quantum algorithms.

arXiv:2205.13907•Scientific Reports•Mar 13, 2024•12 citations
Noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers could solve quantum-mechanical simulation problems that are beyond the capabilities of classical computers. However, NISQ devices experience significant errors which, if not corrected, can render physical quantities measured in these simulations inaccurate or meaningless. Here we describe a method of reducing these errors which is tailored to quantum algorithms for simulating fermionic systems. The method is based on executing quantum circuits in the model of fermionic linear optics, which are known to be efficiently simulable classically, to infer the relationship between exact and noisy measurement outcomes, and hence undo the effect of noise. We validated our method by applying it to the VQE algorithm for estimating ground state energies of instances of the Fermi-Hubbard model. In classical numerical simulations of 12-qubit examples with physically realistic levels of depolarising noise, errors were reduced by a factor of around 34 compared with the uncorrected case. Smaller experiments on quantum hardware demonstrate an average reduction in errors by a factor of 10 or more.
A quantum error mitigation technique based on machine learning is proposed, which learns how to adjust the probabilities estimated by measurement in the computational basis. Neural networks in two different designs are trained with random quantum circuits consisting of a set of one- and two-qubit unitary gates whose measurement statistics in the ideal (noiseless) and real (noisy) cases are known. Once the neural networks are trained, they infer the amount of probability adjustment to be made on the measurement obtained from executing an unseen quantum circuit to reduce the error. The proposed schemes are tested with two-, three-, five-, and seven-qubit quantum circuits of depth up to 20 by computer simulations with realistic error models and experiments using the IBM quantum cloud platform. In all test cases, the proposed mitigation technique reduces the error effectively. Our method can be used to improve the accuracy of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) algorithms without relying on extensive error characterization or quantum error correction.
Achieving near-term quantum advantage will require accurate estimation of quantum observables despite significant hardware noise. For this purpose, we propose a novel, scalable error-mitigation method that applies to gate-based quantum computers. The method generates training data { X i noisy , X i exact } via quantum circuits composed largely of Clifford gates, which can be efficiently simulated classically, where X i noisy and X i exact are noisy and noiseless observables respectively. Fitting a linear ansatz to this data then allows for the prediction of noise-free observables for arbitrary circuits. We analyze the performance of our method versus the number of qubits, circuit depth, and number of non-Clifford gates. We obtain an order-of-magnitude error reduction for a ground-state energy problem on 16 qubits in an IBMQ quantum computer and on a 64-qubit noisy simulator.
The recent pace of experimental progress in quantum technologies suggests we may soon reach a time when quantum devices can be applied to solve problems of practical interest. Despite this, we are still far from being able to abstract away the effects of noise on quantum computation. The reliable execution of computations on current devices remains a significant challenge. This holds true both for computation with noisy physical qubits and for computation using the limited forms of error correction available on early fault-tolerant quantum devices. In this thesis, I propose methods for improving the reliability of quantum devices, as the field transitions from the regime of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices to that of early fault-tolerance. These span the topics of quantum error mitigation, quantum error correction and quantum certification. In the first instance, I propose methods for improving the performance of quantum devices affected by limited amounts of noise. Specifically, I present a method for mitigating the effects of time-dependent noise. This adapts a computational certification protocol called accreditation into a method for postselecting on weaker time-dependent noise behaviours. The method is analytically shown to lead to a provable reduction in errors for the case of depolarising noise, and demonstrated in experiments on superconducting hardware. I also present a method for mitigating the effects of photon loss in photonic quantum devices. Through a combination of analytical and numerical analysis, it is shown that there are wide regimes of photon loss for which this method outperforms postselection, the standard method of handling loss in photonic devices. Additionally, evidence is provided that the method enhances the performance of a quantum machine learning model known as a Quantum Circuit Born Machine in the presence of photon loss. Next, I introduce a framework for certifying the correctness of computations run on encoded logical qubits. This is sensitive to considerably more general forms of noise than is usually considered in quantum error correction. It can be applied to efficiently certify the correctness of quantum computations for large system sizes, beyond the capabilities of methods relying on classical simulation. In numerical experiments, the framework was applied to certify the accuracy of instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) circuit sampling and Trotterised Hamiltonian simulation. It can be used to efficiently assess whether quantum error mitigation may be usefully applied to a computation, to upper-bound the infidelity of the encoded logical state, and to extend the method of entropy density benchmarking to logical computation. The methods presented in this thesis contribute to the wider effort of building towards reliable quantum computation: both in the sense of reducing the effects of noise on computational output, and in the sense of certifying the correctness of computation beyond the capabilities of classical simulators. Only with reliable quantum computation can the full potential of this technology be realised.
Finding ground states and low-lying excitations of a given Hamiltonian is one of the most important problems in many fields of physics. As a novel approach, quantum computing on Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices offers the prospect to efficiently perform such computations and may eventually outperform classical computers. However, current quantum devices still suffer from inherent quantum noise. In this work, we propose an error mitigation scheme suitable for parametric quantum circuits. This scheme is based on projecting a general quantum noise channel onto depolarization errors. Our method can efficiently reduce errors in quantum computations, which we demonstrate by carrying out simulations both on classical and IBM's quantum devices. In particular, we test the performance of the method by computing the mass gap of the transverse-field Ising model using the variational quantum eigensolver algorithm.
The pursuit of high-fidelity digital quantum simulation is fundamentally constrained by the inevitable presence of noise in current and near-term quantum processors. While quantum error correction ultimately promises fault-tolerance, its substantial qubit overhead renders it impractical for the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era. This research addresses the critical gap between hardware imperfections and simulation accuracy by designing systematic, resource-efficient machine learning (ML) error-mitigation protocols tailored specifically for digital quantum simulation. Unlike generic error-suppression methods, our approach exploits the unique structural properties of simulated quantum dynamics—including time-translation invariance, locality of interactions, and conserved quantities—to inform the training of lightweight neural networks and Gaussian process regressors. We develop a hybrid framework that combines randomized compiling with data-driven noise-inversion models, enabling real-time estimation and subtraction of both coherent and incoherent errors without exponential sampling overhead. Through extensive numerical benchmarks on spin-chain and Fermi-Hubbard models, we demonstrate that our ML protocols achieve up to an order-of-magnitude reduction in infidelity compared to standard probabilistic error cancellation and zero-noise extrapolation, while requiring fewer calibration circuits. Furthermore, we introduce an adaptive online learning scheme that continuously refines the mitigation model during the simulation runtime, automatically adjusting to time-dependent drift in hardware noise. Our results establish a practical pathway toward scalable, high-accuracy quantum simulations on existing devices, with implications for condensed matter physics, quantum chemistry, and the development of quantum advantage benchmarks.
Near-term quantum computers have been built as intermediate-scale quantum devices and are fragile against quantum noise effects, namely, NISQ devices. Traditional quantum-error-correcting codes are not implemented on such devices and to perform quantum computation in good accuracy with these machines we need to develop alternative approaches for mitigating quantum computational errors. In this work, we propose quantum error mitigation (QEM) scheme for quantum computational errors which occur due to couplings with environments during gate operations, i.e., decoherence. To establish our QEM scheme, first we estimate the quantum noise effects on single-qubit states and represent them as groups of quantum circuits, namely, quantum-noise-effect circuit groups. Then our QEM scheme is conducted by subtracting expectation values generated by the quantum-noise-effect circuit groups from those obtained by the quantum circuits for the quantum algorithms under consideration. As a result, the quantum noise effects are reduced, and we obtain approximately the ideal expectation values via the quantum-noise-effect circuit groups and the numbers of elementary quantum circuits composing them scale polynomial with respect to the products of the depths of quantum algorithms and the numbers of register bits. To numerically demonstrate the validity of our QEM scheme, we run noisy quantum simulations of qubits under amplitude damping effects for four types of quantum algorithms. Furthermore, we implement our QEM scheme on IBM Q Experience processors and examine its efficacy. Consequently, the validity of our scheme is verified via both the quantum simulations and the quantum computations on the real quantum devices. Our QEM scheme is solely composed of quantum-computational operations (quantum gates and measurements), and thus, it can be conducted by any type of quantum device. In addition, it can be applied to error mitigation for many other types of quantum noise effects as well as noisy quantum computing of long-depth quantum algorithms.