Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2102.00739 · New Journal of Physics

Composable security for practical quantum key distribution with two way classical communication

Cong Jiang, Xiao-Long Hu, Zong‐Wen Yu, Xiang‐Bin Wang

Published May 18, 2021• 36 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract We present a theory for the composable security of sending-or-not-sending (SNS) protocol of twin field quantum key distribution (TF-QKD). We present methods to strictly calculate the finite-key effects in QKD with error rejection through two-way classical communication (TWCC) for SNS TF-QKD protocol. Unlike the normal QKD without TWCC, here the probability of tagging or untagging for each two-bit random group is not independent. We rigorously solve this problem by imagining a virtual set of bits where every bit is independent and identical. With explicit formulas, we show that simply applying Chernoff bound in the calculation gives correct key rate, but the failure probability changes a little bit. We calculate the key rate with strict bounds and security, and obtain key rates by far breaking the PLOB (Pirandola, Laurenza, Ottaviani, and Banchi) bound with composable security.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/ac0285

Related papers

Robust twin-field quantum key distribution through sending or not sending

Cong Jiang, Zong‐Wen Yu, Xiao-Long Hu +1 more

The sending-or-not-sending (SNS) protocol is one of the most major variants of the twin-field (TF) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol and has been realized in a 511-km field fiber, the farthest field experiment to date. In practice, however, all decoy-state methods have unavoidable source errors, and the source errors may be non-random, which compromises the security condition of the existing TF-QKD protocols. In this study, we present a general approach for efficiently calculating the SNS protocol's secure key rate with source errors, by establishing the equivalent protocols through virtual attenuation and the tagged model. This makes the first result for TF QKD in practice where source intensity cannot be controlled exactly. Our method can be combined with the two-way classical communication method such as active odd-parity pairing to further improve the key rate. The numerical results show that if the intensity error is within a few percent, the key rate and secure distance only decrease marginally. The key rate of the recent SNS experiment in the 511-km field fiber is still positive using our method presented here, even if there is a [Formula: see text] intensity fluctuation. This shows that the SNS protocol is robust against source errors.

arXiv:2112.13723•National Science Review•Sep 19, 2022•15 citations

Concise security bounds for sending-or-not-sending twin-field quantum key distribution with finite pulses

Tingting Song, Peiya Li, Jian Weng

Since its key rate can overcome the PLOB bound, sending-or-not-sending twin-field quantum key distribution (SNS-TF QKD) schemes attract more and more attention in the past three years. However, the inflection of statistical fluctuations on key rate was not considered quite comprehensively, which blocks the practical application of SNS-TF QKD. We take into account all the statistical fluctuations on probabilities, propose the finite-key analysis for SNS-TF QKD without any assumption on the type of attacks, and obtain the lower bound of key rates by applying an optimizing model. Then the finite-key rates are simulated under the reasonable values of some observed parameters, which shows that the key rates overcome the PLOB bound when the transmission distance is far from 350 km, if the number of pulses is fixed as $N={10}^{14}$. Compared with other SNS-TF QKD schemes, we provide concise and tight finite-key bounds since the statistical fluctuations of all parameters are considered against general attacks.

Physical Review A•Apr 7, 2021•4 citations

Sending-or-Not-Sending Twin-Field Quantum Key Distribution with a Passive Decoy-State Method

Ke Xue, Zhigang Shen, Shengmei Zhao +1 more

Twin-field quantum key distribution (TF-QKD) has attracted considerable attention because it can exceed the basic rate-distance limit without quantum repeaters. Its variant protocol, sending or not-sending quantum key distribution (SNS-QKD), not only fixes the security vulnerability of TF-QKD, but also can tolerate large misalignment errors. However, the current SNS-QKD protocol is based on the active decoy-state method, which may lead to side channel information leakage when multiple light intensities are modulated in practice. In this work, we propose a passive decoy-state SNS-QKD protocol to further enhance the security of SNS-QKD. Numerical simulation results show that the protocol not only improves the security in source, but also retains the advantages of tolerating large misalignment errors. Therefore, it may provide further guidance for the practical application of SNS-QKD.

Entropy•May 8, 2022•3 citations

Security Analysis of Sending or Not-Sending Twin-Field Quantum Key Distribution with Weak Randomness

Xiao-Lei Jiang, Yang Wang, Yifei Lu +3 more

Sending-or-not sending twin-field quantum key distribution (SNS TF-QKD) has the advantage of tolerating large amounts of misalignment errors, and its key rate can exceed the linear bound of repeaterless quantum key distribution. However, the weak randomness in a practical QKD system may lower the secret key rate and limit its achievable communication distance, thus compromising its performance. In this paper, we analyze the effects of the weak randomness on the SNS TF-QKD. The numerical simulation shows that SNS TF-QKD can still have an excellent performance under the weak random condition: the secret key rate can exceed the PLOB boundary and achieve long transmission distances. Furthermore, our simulation results also show that SNS TF-QKD is more robust to the weak randomness loopholes than the BB84 protocol and the measurement-device-independent QKD (MDI-QKD). Our results emphasize that keeping the randomness of the states is significant to the protection of state preparation devices.

Entropy•Sep 23, 2022•5 citations

Sending-or-not-sending twin-field quantum key distribution in practice

Zong‐Wen Yu, Xiao-Long Hu, Cong Jiang +2 more

Recently, the twin field quantum key distribution (TF-QKD) protocols have been investigated extensively. In particular, an efficient protocol for TF-QKD with sending or not sending the coherent state has been given in. Here in this paper, we present results of practical sending-or-not-sending (SNS) twin field quantum key distribution. In real-life implementations, we need consider the following three requirements, a few different intensities rather than infinite number of different intensities, a phase slice of appropriate size rather than infinitely small size and the statistical fluctuations. We first show the decoy-state method with only a few different intensities and a phase slice of appropriate size. We then give a statistical fluctuation analysis for the decoy-state method. Numerical simulation shows that, the performance of our method is comparable to the asymptotic case for which the key size is large enough. Our method can beat the PLOB bound on secret key capacity. Our results show that practical implementations of the SNS quantum key distribution can be both secure and efficient.

arXiv:1807.09891•Scientific Reports•Feb 28, 2019•89 citations

Secure Quantum Key Distribution over Long-Haul Optical Fibers Using Twin-Field QKD Protocol

Zebo Khudoyqulova, Khulkar Kasimova, Temur Eshchanov +3 more

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) offers information-theoretic security, making it a cornerstone of future cryptographic infrastructures in the era of quantum computing. However, long-distance deployment of conventional QKD protocols is limited by channel losses, detector noise, and the fundamental repeaterless Pirandola-Laurenza-Ottaviani-Banchi (PLOB) bound. To address these challenges, this paper investigates the Twin-Field QKD (TF-QKD) protocol, which enables secure key exchange over long-haul optical fibers by exploiting single-photon interference at an untrusted intermediate node. An elaborate system model is provided with optical channel impairments, imperfections of detector and phase stabilization conditions. Finite-key analysis, error correction as well as privacy amplification are placed and made together in order to increase robustness of protocol against practical attacks. The simulation data show that TFQKD can reach secure key rates of over 500 km and is out of reach of decoy-state QKD but nearly close to fundamental limits. These results demonstrate that TF-QKD has the potential to practicalize quantumsecure communication at large scale and in a costeffective way, which can constitute a sub-unit of the future quantum internet.

Optical Communication, Photonics, Telecommunications, and Intelligent Machine Applications (OPTIMA)•Dec 4, 2025•0 citations
Abstract We present a theory for the composable security of sending-or-not-sending (SNS) protocol of twin field quantum key distribution (TF-QKD). We present methods to strictly calculate the finite-key effects in QKD with error rejection through two-way classical communication (TWCC) for SNS TF-QKD protocol. Unlike the normal QKD without TWCC, here the probability of tagging or untagging for each two-bit random group is not independent. We rigorously solve this problem by imagining a virtual set of bits where every bit is independent and identical. With explicit formulas, we show that simply applying Chernoff bound in the calculation gives correct key rate, but the failure probability changes a little bit. We calculate the key rate with strict bounds and security, and obtain key rates by far breaking the PLOB (Pirandola, Laurenza, Ottaviani, and Banchi) bound with composable security.
The sending-or-not-sending (SNS) protocol is one of the most major variants of the twin-field (TF) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol and has been realized in a 511-km field fiber, the farthest field experiment to date. In practice, however, all decoy-state methods have unavoidable source errors, and the source errors may be non-random, which compromises the security condition of the existing TF-QKD protocols. In this study, we present a general approach for efficiently calculating the SNS protocol's secure key rate with source errors, by establishing the equivalent protocols through virtual attenuation and the tagged model. This makes the first result for TF QKD in practice where source intensity cannot be controlled exactly. Our method can be combined with the two-way classical communication method such as active odd-parity pairing to further improve the key rate. The numerical results show that if the intensity error is within a few percent, the key rate and secure distance only decrease marginally. The key rate of the recent SNS experiment in the 511-km field fiber is still positive using our method presented here, even if there is a [Formula: see text] intensity fluctuation. This shows that the SNS protocol is robust against source errors.
Since its key rate can overcome the PLOB bound, sending-or-not-sending twin-field quantum key distribution (SNS-TF QKD) schemes attract more and more attention in the past three years. However, the inflection of statistical fluctuations on key rate was not considered quite comprehensively, which blocks the practical application of SNS-TF QKD. We take into account all the statistical fluctuations on probabilities, propose the finite-key analysis for SNS-TF QKD without any assumption on the type of attacks, and obtain the lower bound of key rates by applying an optimizing model. Then the finite-key rates are simulated under the reasonable values of some observed parameters, which shows that the key rates overcome the PLOB bound when the transmission distance is far from 350 km, if the number of pulses is fixed as N=1014N={10}^{14}N=1014. Compared with other SNS-TF QKD schemes, we provide concise and tight finite-key bounds since the statistical fluctuations of all parameters are considered against general attacks.
Twin-field quantum key distribution (TF-QKD) has attracted considerable attention because it can exceed the basic rate-distance limit without quantum repeaters. Its variant protocol, sending or not-sending quantum key distribution (SNS-QKD), not only fixes the security vulnerability of TF-QKD, but also can tolerate large misalignment errors. However, the current SNS-QKD protocol is based on the active decoy-state method, which may lead to side channel information leakage when multiple light intensities are modulated in practice. In this work, we propose a passive decoy-state SNS-QKD protocol to further enhance the security of SNS-QKD. Numerical simulation results show that the protocol not only improves the security in source, but also retains the advantages of tolerating large misalignment errors. Therefore, it may provide further guidance for the practical application of SNS-QKD.
Sending-or-not sending twin-field quantum key distribution (SNS TF-QKD) has the advantage of tolerating large amounts of misalignment errors, and its key rate can exceed the linear bound of repeaterless quantum key distribution. However, the weak randomness in a practical QKD system may lower the secret key rate and limit its achievable communication distance, thus compromising its performance. In this paper, we analyze the effects of the weak randomness on the SNS TF-QKD. The numerical simulation shows that SNS TF-QKD can still have an excellent performance under the weak random condition: the secret key rate can exceed the PLOB boundary and achieve long transmission distances. Furthermore, our simulation results also show that SNS TF-QKD is more robust to the weak randomness loopholes than the BB84 protocol and the measurement-device-independent QKD (MDI-QKD). Our results emphasize that keeping the randomness of the states is significant to the protection of state preparation devices.
Recently, the twin field quantum key distribution (TF-QKD) protocols have been investigated extensively. In particular, an efficient protocol for TF-QKD with sending or not sending the coherent state has been given in. Here in this paper, we present results of practical sending-or-not-sending (SNS) twin field quantum key distribution. In real-life implementations, we need consider the following three requirements, a few different intensities rather than infinite number of different intensities, a phase slice of appropriate size rather than infinitely small size and the statistical fluctuations. We first show the decoy-state method with only a few different intensities and a phase slice of appropriate size. We then give a statistical fluctuation analysis for the decoy-state method. Numerical simulation shows that, the performance of our method is comparable to the asymptotic case for which the key size is large enough. Our method can beat the PLOB bound on secret key capacity. Our results show that practical implementations of the SNS quantum key distribution can be both secure and efficient.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) offers information-theoretic security, making it a cornerstone of future cryptographic infrastructures in the era of quantum computing. However, long-distance deployment of conventional QKD protocols is limited by channel losses, detector noise, and the fundamental repeaterless Pirandola-Laurenza-Ottaviani-Banchi (PLOB) bound. To address these challenges, this paper investigates the Twin-Field QKD (TF-QKD) protocol, which enables secure key exchange over long-haul optical fibers by exploiting single-photon interference at an untrusted intermediate node. An elaborate system model is provided with optical channel impairments, imperfections of detector and phase stabilization conditions. Finite-key analysis, error correction as well as privacy amplification are placed and made together in order to increase robustness of protocol against practical attacks. The simulation data show that TFQKD can reach secure key rates of over 500 km and is out of reach of decoy-state QKD but nearly close to fundamental limits. These results demonstrate that TF-QKD has the potential to practicalize quantumsecure communication at large scale and in a costeffective way, which can constitute a sub-unit of the future quantum internet.