Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2101.10512 · Journal of Physics Conference Series

Does the Heisenberg uncertainty principle apply along the time dimension?

John Ashmead

Published Jul 1, 2021• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Does the Heisenberg uncertainty principle (HUP) apply along the time dimension in the same way it applies along the three space dimensions? Relativity says it should; current practice says no. With recent advances in measurement at the attosecond scale it is now possible to decide this question experimentally. The most direct test is to measure the time-of-arrival of a quantum particle: if the HUP applies in time, then the dispersion in the time-of-arrival will be measurably increased. We develop an appropriate metric of time-of-arrival in the standard case; extend this to include the case where there is uncertainty in time; then compare. There is – as expected – increased uncertainty in the time-of-arrival if the HUP applies along the time axis. The results are fully constrained by Lorentz covariance, therefore uniquely defined, therefore falsifiable. So we have an experimental question on our hands. Any definite resolution would have significant implications with respect to the role of time in quantum mechanics and relativity. A positive result would also have significant practical applications in the areas of quantum communication, attosecond physics (e.g. protein folding), and quantum computing.

DOI
10.1088/1742-6596/1956/1/012014

Related papers

Time dispersion in quantum electrodynamics

John Ashmead

Abstract If we use the path integral approach, we can write quantum electrodynamics (QED) in a way that is manifestly relativistic. However the path integrals are confined to paths that are on mass-shell. What happens if we extend QED by computing the path integrals over all paths in energy momentum space, not only those on mass-shell? We use the requirement of covariance to do this in an unambiguous way. This gives a QED where the time/energy components appear in a way that is manifestly parallel to the space/momentum components: we have dispersion in time, entanglement in time, full equivalence of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle (HUP) in time to the HUP in space, and so on. Entanglement in time has the welcome side effect of eliminating the ultraviolet divergences. We recover standard QED in the long time limit. We predict effects at scales of attoseconds. With recent developments in attosecond physics and in quantum computing, these effects should be detectable. Since the predictions are unambiguous and testable the approach is falsifiable. Falsification would sharpen our understanding of the role of time in QED. Confirmation would have significant implications for attosecond physics, quantum computing and communications, and quantum gravity.

arXiv:2211.00202•Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 1, 2023•3 citations

Recognition of the Physical Significance of Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle.

Hongbin Huang, Yihua Wang

Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle (HUP) is a central concept in quantum mechanics that reveals inherent limitations in the measurement of microscopic particles and profoundly affects the understanding of the physical world. This paper reviews the physical significance of HUP and its applications and research progress in modern physics. The complexity of measurements in quantum systems is revealed by deriving the uncertainty relation and analysing the wavefunction collapse and the classicalisation of quantum states. This paper summarises the current experimental verification of the principle of measurement uncertainty in different quantum systems and discusses the research progress in improving measurement accuracy through quantum entanglement. Recent studies have shown that controlling quantum entangled states can effectively reduce measurement disturbances and thus improve the measurement accuracy of quantum systems without violating the principle of mismeasurement. Despite the many advances made, there are still challenges to further improve the measurement accuracy in complex quantum systems. Future research will continue to explore the potential for applications in this area.

Science and Technology of Engineering Chemistry and Environmental Protection•Dec 25, 2024•0 citations

Recognition of the Physical Significance of Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle

Hongbin Huang, Yihua Wang

Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle (HUP) is a central concept in quantum mechanics that reveals inherent limitations in the measurement of microscopic particles and profoundly affects the understanding of the physical world. This paper reviews the physical significance of HUP and its applications and research progress in modern physics. The complexity of measurements in quantum systems is revealed by deriving the uncertainty relation and analysing the wavefunction collapse and the classicalisation of quantum states. This paper summarises the current experimental verification of the principle of measurement uncertainty in different quantum systems and discusses the research progress in improving measurement accuracy through quantum entanglement. Recent studies have shown that controlling quantum entangled states can effectively reduce measurement disturbances and thus improve the measurement accuracy of quantum systems without violating the principle of mismeasurement. Despite the many advances made, there are still challenges to further improve the measurement accuracy in complex quantum systems. Future research will continue to explore the potential for applications in this area.

Science and Technology of Engineering Chemistry and Environmental Protection•Jun 26, 2025•0 citations

Recognition of the Physical Significance of Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle

Hongbin Huang, Yihua Wang

Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle (HUP) is a central concept in quantum mechanics that reveals inherent limitations in the measurement of microscopic particles and profoundly affects the understanding of the physical world. This paper reviews the physical significance of HUP and its applications and research progress in modern physics. The complexity of measurements in quantum systems is revealed by deriving the uncertainty relation and analysing the wavefunction collapse and the classicalisation of quantum states. This paper summarises the current experimental verification of the principle of measurement uncertainty in different quantum systems and discusses the research progress in improving measurement accuracy through quantum entanglement. Recent studies have shown that controlling quantum entangled states can effectively reduce measurement disturbances and thus improve the measurement accuracy of quantum systems without violating the principle of mismeasurement. Despite the many advances made, there are still challenges to further improve the measurement accuracy in complex quantum systems. Future research will continue to explore the potential for applications in this area.

Science and Technology of Engineering Chemistry and Environmental Protection•Dec 31, 2024•0 citations

Time dispersion in quantum mechanics

John Ashmead

In quantum mechanics the time dimension is treated as a parameter, while the three space dimensions are treated as observables. This assumption is both untested and inconsistent with relativity. From dimensional analysis, we expect quantum effects along the time axis to be of order an attosecond. Such effects are not ruled out by current experiments. But they are large enough to be detected with current technology, if sufficiently specific predictions can be made. To supply such we use path integrals. The only change required is to generalize the usual three dimensional paths to four. We predict a large variety of testable effects. The principal effects are additional dispersion in time and full equivalence of the time/energy uncertainty principle to the space/momentum one. Additional effects include interference, diffraction, and entanglement in time. The usual ultraviolet divergences do not appear: they are suppressed by a combination of dispersion in time and entanglement in time. The approach here has no free parameters; it is therefore falsifiable. As it treats time and space with complete symmetry and does not suffer from the ultraviolet divergences, it may provide a useful starting point for attacks on quantum gravity.

arXiv:1812.00935•Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 1, 2019•11 citations

Time dispersion in bound states

John Ashmead

Abstract In quantum mechanics time is generally treated as a parameter rather than an observable. For instance wave functions are treated as extending in space, but not in time. But from relativity we expect time and space should be treated on the same basis. What are the effects if time is an observable? Are these effects observable with current technology? In earlier work we showed we should see effects in various high energy scattering processes. We here extend that work to include bound states. The critical advantage of working with bound states is that the predictions are significantly more definite, taking the predictions from testable to falsifiable. We estimate the time dispersion for hydrogen as .177 attoseconds, possibly below the current threshold for detection. But the time dispersion should scale as the 3/2 power of the principle quantum number n. Rydberg atoms can have n of order 100, implying a boost by a factor of 1000. This takes the the time dispersion to 177 attoseconds, well within reach of current technology. There are a wide variety of experimental targets: any time-dependent processes should show effects. Falsification will be technically challenging (due to the short time scales) but immediate and unambiguous. Confirmation would have significant implications for attosecond physics, quantum computing and communications, quantum gravity, and the measurement problem. And would suggest practical uses in these areas as well as circuit design, high speed biochemistry, cryptography, fusion research, and any area involving change at attosecond time scales.

arXiv:2501.17407•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Apr 1, 2025•0 citations
Abstract Does the Heisenberg uncertainty principle (HUP) apply along the time dimension in the same way it applies along the three space dimensions? Relativity says it should; current practice says no. With recent advances in measurement at the attosecond scale it is now possible to decide this question experimentally. The most direct test is to measure the time-of-arrival of a quantum particle: if the HUP applies in time, then the dispersion in the time-of-arrival will be measurably increased. We develop an appropriate metric of time-of-arrival in the standard case; extend this to include the case where there is uncertainty in time; then compare. There is – as expected – increased uncertainty in the time-of-arrival if the HUP applies along the time axis. The results are fully constrained by Lorentz covariance, therefore uniquely defined, therefore falsifiable. So we have an experimental question on our hands. Any definite resolution would have significant implications with respect to the role of time in quantum mechanics and relativity. A positive result would also have significant practical applications in the areas of quantum communication, attosecond physics (e.g. protein folding), and quantum computing.
Abstract If we use the path integral approach, we can write quantum electrodynamics (QED) in a way that is manifestly relativistic. However the path integrals are confined to paths that are on mass-shell. What happens if we extend QED by computing the path integrals over all paths in energy momentum space, not only those on mass-shell? We use the requirement of covariance to do this in an unambiguous way. This gives a QED where the time/energy components appear in a way that is manifestly parallel to the space/momentum components: we have dispersion in time, entanglement in time, full equivalence of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle (HUP) in time to the HUP in space, and so on. Entanglement in time has the welcome side effect of eliminating the ultraviolet divergences. We recover standard QED in the long time limit. We predict effects at scales of attoseconds. With recent developments in attosecond physics and in quantum computing, these effects should be detectable. Since the predictions are unambiguous and testable the approach is falsifiable. Falsification would sharpen our understanding of the role of time in QED. Confirmation would have significant implications for attosecond physics, quantum computing and communications, and quantum gravity.
Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle (HUP) is a central concept in quantum mechanics that reveals inherent limitations in the measurement of microscopic particles and profoundly affects the understanding of the physical world. This paper reviews the physical significance of HUP and its applications and research progress in modern physics. The complexity of measurements in quantum systems is revealed by deriving the uncertainty relation and analysing the wavefunction collapse and the classicalisation of quantum states. This paper summarises the current experimental verification of the principle of measurement uncertainty in different quantum systems and discusses the research progress in improving measurement accuracy through quantum entanglement. Recent studies have shown that controlling quantum entangled states can effectively reduce measurement disturbances and thus improve the measurement accuracy of quantum systems without violating the principle of mismeasurement. Despite the many advances made, there are still challenges to further improve the measurement accuracy in complex quantum systems. Future research will continue to explore the potential for applications in this area.
Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle (HUP) is a central concept in quantum mechanics that reveals inherent limitations in the measurement of microscopic particles and profoundly affects the understanding of the physical world. This paper reviews the physical significance of HUP and its applications and research progress in modern physics. The complexity of measurements in quantum systems is revealed by deriving the uncertainty relation and analysing the wavefunction collapse and the classicalisation of quantum states. This paper summarises the current experimental verification of the principle of measurement uncertainty in different quantum systems and discusses the research progress in improving measurement accuracy through quantum entanglement. Recent studies have shown that controlling quantum entangled states can effectively reduce measurement disturbances and thus improve the measurement accuracy of quantum systems without violating the principle of mismeasurement. Despite the many advances made, there are still challenges to further improve the measurement accuracy in complex quantum systems. Future research will continue to explore the potential for applications in this area.
Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle (HUP) is a central concept in quantum mechanics that reveals inherent limitations in the measurement of microscopic particles and profoundly affects the understanding of the physical world. This paper reviews the physical significance of HUP and its applications and research progress in modern physics. The complexity of measurements in quantum systems is revealed by deriving the uncertainty relation and analysing the wavefunction collapse and the classicalisation of quantum states. This paper summarises the current experimental verification of the principle of measurement uncertainty in different quantum systems and discusses the research progress in improving measurement accuracy through quantum entanglement. Recent studies have shown that controlling quantum entangled states can effectively reduce measurement disturbances and thus improve the measurement accuracy of quantum systems without violating the principle of mismeasurement. Despite the many advances made, there are still challenges to further improve the measurement accuracy in complex quantum systems. Future research will continue to explore the potential for applications in this area.
In quantum mechanics the time dimension is treated as a parameter, while the three space dimensions are treated as observables. This assumption is both untested and inconsistent with relativity. From dimensional analysis, we expect quantum effects along the time axis to be of order an attosecond. Such effects are not ruled out by current experiments. But they are large enough to be detected with current technology, if sufficiently specific predictions can be made. To supply such we use path integrals. The only change required is to generalize the usual three dimensional paths to four. We predict a large variety of testable effects. The principal effects are additional dispersion in time and full equivalence of the time/energy uncertainty principle to the space/momentum one. Additional effects include interference, diffraction, and entanglement in time. The usual ultraviolet divergences do not appear: they are suppressed by a combination of dispersion in time and entanglement in time. The approach here has no free parameters; it is therefore falsifiable. As it treats time and space with complete symmetry and does not suffer from the ultraviolet divergences, it may provide a useful starting point for attacks on quantum gravity.
Abstract In quantum mechanics time is generally treated as a parameter rather than an observable. For instance wave functions are treated as extending in space, but not in time. But from relativity we expect time and space should be treated on the same basis. What are the effects if time is an observable? Are these effects observable with current technology? In earlier work we showed we should see effects in various high energy scattering processes. We here extend that work to include bound states. The critical advantage of working with bound states is that the predictions are significantly more definite, taking the predictions from testable to falsifiable. We estimate the time dispersion for hydrogen as .177 attoseconds, possibly below the current threshold for detection. But the time dispersion should scale as the 3/2 power of the principle quantum number n. Rydberg atoms can have n of order 100, implying a boost by a factor of 1000. This takes the the time dispersion to 177 attoseconds, well within reach of current technology. There are a wide variety of experimental targets: any time-dependent processes should show effects. Falsification will be technically challenging (due to the short time scales) but immediate and unambiguous. Confirmation would have significant implications for attosecond physics, quantum computing and communications, quantum gravity, and the measurement problem. And would suggest practical uses in these areas as well as circuit design, high speed biochemistry, cryptography, fusion research, and any area involving change at attosecond time scales.