Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2012.15714 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Testing the Green's function coupled cluster singles and doubles impurity solver on real materials within the framework of self-energy embedding theory

Chia-Nan Yeh, Avijit Shee, Sergei Iskakov, Dominika Zgid

Published Apr 30, 2021• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We apply the Green's function coupled cluster singles and doubles (GFCCSD) impurity solver to realistic impurity problems arising for strongly correlated solids within the self-energy embedding theory (SEET) framework. We describe the details of our GFCC solver implementation, investigate its performance, and highlight potential advantages and problems on examples of impurities created during the self-consistent SEET for antiferromagnetic MnO and paramagnetic $\mathrm{Sr}\mathrm{Mn}{\mathrm{O}}_{3}$. GFCCSD provides satisfactory descriptions for weakly and moderately correlated impurities with sizes that are intractable by existing accurate impurity solvers such as exact diagonalization. However, our data also shows that when correlations become strong, the singles and doubles approximation used in GFCC could lead to instabilities in searching for the particle number present in impurity problems. These instabilities appear especially severe when the impurity size gets larger and multiple degenerate orbitals with strong correlations are present. We conclude that, to fully check the reliability of GFCCSD results and use them in fully ab initio calculations in the absence of experiments, a verification from a GFCC solver with higher order excitations is necessary.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.103.155158

Related papers

Triple Excitations in Green’s Function Coupled Cluster Solver for Studies of Strongly Correlated Systems in the Framework of Self-Energy Embedding Theory

Avijit Shee, Chia-Nan Yeh, Bo Peng +2 more

Embedding theories became important approaches used for accurate calculations of both molecules and solids. In these theories, a small chosen subset of orbitals is treated with an accurate method, called an impurity solver, capable of describing higher correlation effects. Ideally, such a chosen fragment should contain multiple orbitals responsible for the chemical and physical behavior of the compound. Handling a large number of chosen orbitals presents a very significant challenge for the current generation of solvers used in the physics and chemistry community. Here, we develop a Green’s function coupled cluster singles doubles and triples (GFCCSDT) solver that can be used for a quantitative description in both molecules and solids. This solver allows us to treat orbital spaces that are inaccessible to other accurate solvers. At the same time, GFCCSDT maintains high accuracy of the resulting self-energy. Moreover, in conjunction with the GFCCSD solver, it allows us to test the systematic convergence of computational studies. Developing the CC family of solvers paves the road to fully systematic Green’s function embedding calculations in solids. In this paper, we focus on the investigation of GFCCSDT self-energies for a strongly correlated problem of SrMnO 3 solid. Subsequently, we apply this solver to solid MnO showing that an approximate variant of GFCCSDT is capable of yielding a high accuracy orbital resolved spectral function.

arXiv:2211.12680•The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters•Mar 1, 2023•5 citations

Exploring Coupled Cluster Green’s Function as a Method for Treating System and Environment in Green’s Function Embedding Methods

Avijit Shee, Chia-Nan Yeh, Dominika Zgid

Within the self-energy embedding theory (SEET) framework, we study the coupled cluster Green's function (GFCC) method in two different contexts: as a method to treat either the system or the environment present in the embedding construction. Our study reveals that when GFCC is used to treat the environment we do not see improvement in total energies in comparison to the coupled cluster method itself. To rationalize this puzzling result, we analyze the performance of GFCC as an impurity solver with a series of transition metal oxides. These studies shed light on the strength and weaknesses of such a solver and demonstrate that such a solver gives very accurate results when the size of the impurity is small. We investigate if it is possible to achieve a systematic accuracy of the embedding solution when we increase the size of the impurity problem. We found that in such a case, the performance of the solver worsens, both in terms of finding the ground state solution of the impurity problem and the self-energies produced. We concluded that increasing the rank of GFCC solver is necessary to be able to enlarge impurity problems and achieve a reliable accuracy. We also have shown that natural orbitals from weakly correlated perturbative methods are better suited than symmetrized atomic orbitals (SAO) when the total energy of the system is the target quantity.

arXiv:2107.07891•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Jan 6, 2022•10 citations

Coupled Cluster as an Impurity Solver for Green’s Function Embedding Methods

Avijit Shee, Dominika Zgid

We investigate the performance of Green's function coupled cluster singles and doubles (CCSD) method as a solver for Green's function embedding methods. To develop an efficient CC solver, we construct the one-particle Green's function from the coupled cluster (CC) wave function based on the non-Hermitian Lanczos algorithm. The major advantage of this method is that its scaling does not depend on the number of frequency points. We have tested the applicability of the CC Green's function solver in the weakly to strongly correlated regimes by employing it for a half-filled one-dimensional (1D) Hubbard model projected onto a single-site impurity problem and a half-filled two-dimensional (2D) Hubbard model projected onto a four-site impurity problem. For the 1D Hubbard model, for all interaction strengths, we observe an excellent agreement with the full configuration interaction (FCI) technique, both for the self-energy and spectral function. For the 2D Hubbard, we have employed an open-shell version of the current implementation and observed some discrepancies from FCI in the strongly correlated regime. Finally, on an example of a small ammonia cluster, we analyze the performance of Green's function CCSD solver within the Self-Energy Embedding Theory (SEET) with Hartree-Fock (HF) and Green's Function second order (GF2) for the treatment of the environment.

arXiv:1906.04079•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Sep 13, 2019•51 citations

Ab Initio Many-Body Theory for Solids Based on the Green's Function Formalism

Chia-Nan Yeh

Electronic structure of materials from first principles is essential for one-to-one comparisons between theories and experiments. However, the many-body effects resulting from electron correlation and their interplay with other degrees of freedom pose a great challenge to design an ab initio approximate method with good accuracy and efficiency at the same time. In this thesis, we present our recent developments of ab initio many-body theory for solids based on the finite-temperature Green’s function formalism. We begin by reviewing the basic concepts and definitions of realistic electronic Hamiltonians (Ch. 2) as well as Green’s functions at finite temperature (Ch. 3). Overviews of self-consistent many-body perturbation theories and quantum embedding theories are then presented in Chs. 4 and 5 as complementary materials for the following chapters. In Ch. 6, we present algorithms and implementation details for the finite-temperature self-consistent GW (scGW) method in Gaussian-type orbitals for solids. Our implementation is based on the finite-temperature Green’s function formalism in which all equations are solved on the imaginary axis, without resorting to analytical continuation during the self-consistency. No quasiparticle approximation is employed and all matrix elements of self-energies are explicitly evaluated. We show agreement with other, differently formulated finite-temperature scGW implementations. By migrating computationally intensive calculations to GPUs, we obtain scalable results on large supercomputers with nearly optimal performance. Inclusion of relativistic effects in scGW is discussed in Ch. 7. Our formulation of relativistic scGW is based on the exact two-component formalism with one-electron approximation (X2C1e) and non-relativistic Coulomb interactions. Our theory allows us to study scalar relativistic effects, spin-orbit coupling, and their interplay with electron correlation without adjustable parameters. We examine the effect of the X2C1e by comparison to the established four-component formalism and reach excellent agreement. The simplicity of X2C1e enables construction of higher order theories, such as embedding theories, on top of perturbative calculations. In Ch. 8, we use self-energy embedding theory (SEET) to study the spectra of the prototypical undistorted cubic perovskites SrVO3 and SrMnO3. In the strongly correlated metallic SrVO3, we find that the usual attribution of the satellite peaks at -1.8 eV to Hund or Hubbard physics in the t2g orbitals is inconsistent with our calculations. In the strongly correlated insulator SrMnO3 we recover insulating behavior due to a feedback effect between the strongly correlated orbitals and the weakly correlated environment. Our calculation shows a systematic convergence of spectral features as the space of strongly correlated orbitals is enlarged, paving the way to a systematic parameter-free study of correlated perovskites. Lastly, in Ch. 9, we apply the Green’s function coupled cluster singles and doubles (GFCCSD) impurity solver to realistic impurity problems in strongly correlated solids within the framework of SEET. We describe the implementation details of our Green’s function coupled cluster (GFCC) solver, investigate its performance, and highlight potential advantages and problems on examples of impurities created for antiferromagnetic MnO and paramagnetic SrMnO3. GFCCSD provides satisfactory descriptions for weakly and moderately correlated impurities with sizes that are intractable by existing accurate impurity solvers such as exact diagonalization. However, when correlations become strong, the singles and doubles approximation used in GFCC could lead to instabilities in searching for the particle number present in impurity problems.

•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

Systematically improvable multiscale solver for correlated electron systems

Alexei A. Kananenka, Emanuel Gull, Dominika Zgid

The development of numerical methods capable of simulating realistic materials with strongly correlated electrons, with controllable errors, is a central challenge in quantum many-body physics. Here we describe a framework for a general multiscale method based on embedding a self-energy of a strongly correlated subsystem into a self-energy generated by a method able to treat large weakly correlated systems approximately. As an example, we present the embedding of an exact diagonalization self-energy into a self-energy generated from self-consistent second-order perturbation theory. Using a quantum impurity model, generated from a cluster dynamical mean field approximation to the two-dimensional Hubbard model, as a benchmark, we illustrate that our method allows us to obtain accurate results at a fraction of the cost of typical Monte Carlo calculations. We test the method in multiple regimes of interaction strengths and dopings of the model. The general embedding framework we present avoids difficulties such as double counting corrections, frequency-dependent interactions, or vertex functions. As it is solely formulated at the level of the single-particle Green's function, it provides a promising route for the simulation of realistic materials that are currently difficult to study with other methods.

arXiv:1410.5118•Physical Review B•Mar 23, 2015•91 citations

Coupled-cluster impurity solvers for dynamical mean-field theory

Tianyu Zhu, Carlos A. Jiménez-Hoyos, James D. McClain +2 more

We describe the use of coupled-cluster theory as an impurity solver in dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) and its cluster extensions. We present numerical results at the level of coupled-cluster theory with single and double excitations (CCSD) for the density of states and self-energies of cluster impurity problems in the one- and two-dimensional Hubbard models. Comparison to exact diagonalization shows that CCSD produces accurate density of states and self-energies at a variety of values of $U/t$ and filling fractions. However, the low cost allows for the use of many bath sites, which we define by a discretization of the hybridization directly on the real frequency axis. We observe convergence of dynamical quantities using approximately 30 bath sites per impurity site, with our largest 4-site cluster DMFT calculation using 120 bath sites. We suggest that coupled-cluster impurity solvers will be attractive in ab initio formulations of dynamical mean-field theory.

arXiv:1905.12050•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 26, 2019•57 citations
We apply the Green's function coupled cluster singles and doubles (GFCCSD) impurity solver to realistic impurity problems arising for strongly correlated solids within the self-energy embedding theory (SEET) framework. We describe the details of our GFCC solver implementation, investigate its performance, and highlight potential advantages and problems on examples of impurities created during the self-consistent SEET for antiferromagnetic MnO and paramagnetic SrMnO3\mathrm{Sr}\mathrm{Mn}{\mathrm{O}}_{3}SrMnO3​. GFCCSD provides satisfactory descriptions for weakly and moderately correlated impurities with sizes that are intractable by existing accurate impurity solvers such as exact diagonalization. However, our data also shows that when correlations become strong, the singles and doubles approximation used in GFCC could lead to instabilities in searching for the particle number present in impurity problems. These instabilities appear especially severe when the impurity size gets larger and multiple degenerate orbitals with strong correlations are present. We conclude that, to fully check the reliability of GFCCSD results and use them in fully ab initio calculations in the absence of experiments, a verification from a GFCC solver with higher order excitations is necessary.
Embedding theories became important approaches used for accurate calculations of both molecules and solids. In these theories, a small chosen subset of orbitals is treated with an accurate method, called an impurity solver, capable of describing higher correlation effects. Ideally, such a chosen fragment should contain multiple orbitals responsible for the chemical and physical behavior of the compound. Handling a large number of chosen orbitals presents a very significant challenge for the current generation of solvers used in the physics and chemistry community. Here, we develop a Green’s function coupled cluster singles doubles and triples (GFCCSDT) solver that can be used for a quantitative description in both molecules and solids. This solver allows us to treat orbital spaces that are inaccessible to other accurate solvers. At the same time, GFCCSDT maintains high accuracy of the resulting self-energy. Moreover, in conjunction with the GFCCSD solver, it allows us to test the systematic convergence of computational studies. Developing the CC family of solvers paves the road to fully systematic Green’s function embedding calculations in solids. In this paper, we focus on the investigation of GFCCSDT self-energies for a strongly correlated problem of SrMnO 3 solid. Subsequently, we apply this solver to solid MnO showing that an approximate variant of GFCCSDT is capable of yielding a high accuracy orbital resolved spectral function.
Within the self-energy embedding theory (SEET) framework, we study the coupled cluster Green's function (GFCC) method in two different contexts: as a method to treat either the system or the environment present in the embedding construction. Our study reveals that when GFCC is used to treat the environment we do not see improvement in total energies in comparison to the coupled cluster method itself. To rationalize this puzzling result, we analyze the performance of GFCC as an impurity solver with a series of transition metal oxides. These studies shed light on the strength and weaknesses of such a solver and demonstrate that such a solver gives very accurate results when the size of the impurity is small. We investigate if it is possible to achieve a systematic accuracy of the embedding solution when we increase the size of the impurity problem. We found that in such a case, the performance of the solver worsens, both in terms of finding the ground state solution of the impurity problem and the self-energies produced. We concluded that increasing the rank of GFCC solver is necessary to be able to enlarge impurity problems and achieve a reliable accuracy. We also have shown that natural orbitals from weakly correlated perturbative methods are better suited than symmetrized atomic orbitals (SAO) when the total energy of the system is the target quantity.
We investigate the performance of Green's function coupled cluster singles and doubles (CCSD) method as a solver for Green's function embedding methods. To develop an efficient CC solver, we construct the one-particle Green's function from the coupled cluster (CC) wave function based on the non-Hermitian Lanczos algorithm. The major advantage of this method is that its scaling does not depend on the number of frequency points. We have tested the applicability of the CC Green's function solver in the weakly to strongly correlated regimes by employing it for a half-filled one-dimensional (1D) Hubbard model projected onto a single-site impurity problem and a half-filled two-dimensional (2D) Hubbard model projected onto a four-site impurity problem. For the 1D Hubbard model, for all interaction strengths, we observe an excellent agreement with the full configuration interaction (FCI) technique, both for the self-energy and spectral function. For the 2D Hubbard, we have employed an open-shell version of the current implementation and observed some discrepancies from FCI in the strongly correlated regime. Finally, on an example of a small ammonia cluster, we analyze the performance of Green's function CCSD solver within the Self-Energy Embedding Theory (SEET) with Hartree-Fock (HF) and Green's Function second order (GF2) for the treatment of the environment.
Electronic structure of materials from first principles is essential for one-to-one comparisons between theories and experiments. However, the many-body effects resulting from electron correlation and their interplay with other degrees of freedom pose a great challenge to design an ab initio approximate method with good accuracy and efficiency at the same time. In this thesis, we present our recent developments of ab initio many-body theory for solids based on the finite-temperature Green’s function formalism. We begin by reviewing the basic concepts and definitions of realistic electronic Hamiltonians (Ch. 2) as well as Green’s functions at finite temperature (Ch. 3). Overviews of self-consistent many-body perturbation theories and quantum embedding theories are then presented in Chs. 4 and 5 as complementary materials for the following chapters. In Ch. 6, we present algorithms and implementation details for the finite-temperature self-consistent GW (scGW) method in Gaussian-type orbitals for solids. Our implementation is based on the finite-temperature Green’s function formalism in which all equations are solved on the imaginary axis, without resorting to analytical continuation during the self-consistency. No quasiparticle approximation is employed and all matrix elements of self-energies are explicitly evaluated. We show agreement with other, differently formulated finite-temperature scGW implementations. By migrating computationally intensive calculations to GPUs, we obtain scalable results on large supercomputers with nearly optimal performance. Inclusion of relativistic effects in scGW is discussed in Ch. 7. Our formulation of relativistic scGW is based on the exact two-component formalism with one-electron approximation (X2C1e) and non-relativistic Coulomb interactions. Our theory allows us to study scalar relativistic effects, spin-orbit coupling, and their interplay with electron correlation without adjustable parameters. We examine the effect of the X2C1e by comparison to the established four-component formalism and reach excellent agreement. The simplicity of X2C1e enables construction of higher order theories, such as embedding theories, on top of perturbative calculations. In Ch. 8, we use self-energy embedding theory (SEET) to study the spectra of the prototypical undistorted cubic perovskites SrVO3 and SrMnO3. In the strongly correlated metallic SrVO3, we find that the usual attribution of the satellite peaks at -1.8 eV to Hund or Hubbard physics in the t2g orbitals is inconsistent with our calculations. In the strongly correlated insulator SrMnO3 we recover insulating behavior due to a feedback effect between the strongly correlated orbitals and the weakly correlated environment. Our calculation shows a systematic convergence of spectral features as the space of strongly correlated orbitals is enlarged, paving the way to a systematic parameter-free study of correlated perovskites. Lastly, in Ch. 9, we apply the Green’s function coupled cluster singles and doubles (GFCCSD) impurity solver to realistic impurity problems in strongly correlated solids within the framework of SEET. We describe the implementation details of our Green’s function coupled cluster (GFCC) solver, investigate its performance, and highlight potential advantages and problems on examples of impurities created for antiferromagnetic MnO and paramagnetic SrMnO3. GFCCSD provides satisfactory descriptions for weakly and moderately correlated impurities with sizes that are intractable by existing accurate impurity solvers such as exact diagonalization. However, when correlations become strong, the singles and doubles approximation used in GFCC could lead to instabilities in searching for the particle number present in impurity problems.
The development of numerical methods capable of simulating realistic materials with strongly correlated electrons, with controllable errors, is a central challenge in quantum many-body physics. Here we describe a framework for a general multiscale method based on embedding a self-energy of a strongly correlated subsystem into a self-energy generated by a method able to treat large weakly correlated systems approximately. As an example, we present the embedding of an exact diagonalization self-energy into a self-energy generated from self-consistent second-order perturbation theory. Using a quantum impurity model, generated from a cluster dynamical mean field approximation to the two-dimensional Hubbard model, as a benchmark, we illustrate that our method allows us to obtain accurate results at a fraction of the cost of typical Monte Carlo calculations. We test the method in multiple regimes of interaction strengths and dopings of the model. The general embedding framework we present avoids difficulties such as double counting corrections, frequency-dependent interactions, or vertex functions. As it is solely formulated at the level of the single-particle Green's function, it provides a promising route for the simulation of realistic materials that are currently difficult to study with other methods.
We describe the use of coupled-cluster theory as an impurity solver in dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) and its cluster extensions. We present numerical results at the level of coupled-cluster theory with single and double excitations (CCSD) for the density of states and self-energies of cluster impurity problems in the one- and two-dimensional Hubbard models. Comparison to exact diagonalization shows that CCSD produces accurate density of states and self-energies at a variety of values of U/tU/tU/t and filling fractions. However, the low cost allows for the use of many bath sites, which we define by a discretization of the hybridization directly on the real frequency axis. We observe convergence of dynamical quantities using approximately 30 bath sites per impurity site, with our largest 4-site cluster DMFT calculation using 120 bath sites. We suggest that coupled-cluster impurity solvers will be attractive in ab initio formulations of dynamical mean-field theory.