Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2012.12274 · Physical review. E

Tensor network approach to thermalization in open quantum many-body systems

Hayate Nakano, Tatsuhiko Shirai, Takashi Mori

Published Apr 13, 2021• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the relaxation dynamics of open nonintegrable quantum many-body systems in the thermodynamic limit by using a tensor-network formalism. We simulate the Lindblad quantum master equation (LQME) of infinite systems by making use of the uniform matrix product operators (MPO) as the ansatz of their density matrices. Furthermore, we establish a method to measure the thermodynamic equivalence between two states described by the uniform MPOs. We numerically show that when an initial state of the LQME is a thermal Gibbs state, a time evolved state is always indistinguishable from a Gibbs state with a time-dependent effective temperature in the weak-dissipation and thermodynamic limit.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.103.l040102

Related papers

Tensor network simulations of open quantum systems

Dainius Kilda

The nonequilibrium effects of dissipation and drive play a key role in an immense variety of nanoscale and mesoscale quantum systems. To understand the behaviour of open quantum systems, we need accurate methods that capture the influence of the environment on the system, while managing the exponentially large Hilbert space required to describe the system. Tensor network algorithms offer an efficient way to approach this challenge. In this thesis, we develop and apply tensor network techniques to study the dynamics and steady states of various open quantum systems. The first part of the thesis focuses on the driven dissipative many body physics in coupled cavity arrays described by Born-Markov master equations. We extend transfer matrix product operator methods to Liouvillian dynamics, and utilize them to compute dynamical correlation functions and fluorescence spectrum of an infinite coupled cavity array in 1D. We also investigate thermalization, and observe the emergence of a quasi-thermal steady state with a negative effective temperature. In another study, we use infinite projected entangled pair state (iPEPS) methods to compute steady states of coupled cavity lattices in 2D. We find that a straightforward adaptation of iPEPS to Liouvillian dynamics is unstable, contradicting a recent publication in the field. The second part investigates more general systems involving strong couplings and structured environments that induce non-Markovian dynamics. We develop a powerful time-evolving matrix product operator (TEMPO) algorithm that builds on Feynman-Vernon influence functional formalism, and uses matrix product states (MPS) to represent the temporal non-Markovian correlations efficiently. We apply TEMPO to study the localization phase transition of the spin-boson model and the dynamics of two spatially separated two-level systems coupled to a common environment. Finally, we propose the Toblerone TEMPO algorithm, which extends TEMPO to many-body systems interacting with general bosonic environments.

•Mar 3, 2020•0 citations

One-dimensional many-body entangled open quantum systems with tensor network methods

Daniel Jaschke, Simone Montangero, Lincoln D. Carr

Abstract We present a collection of methods to simulate entangled dynamics of open quantum systems governed by the Lindblad master equation with tensor network methods. Tensor network methods using matrix product states (MPSs) have been proven very useful to simulate many-body quantum systems and have driven many innovations in research. Since the MPS design is tailored for closed one-dimensional systems governed by the Schrödinger equation, the next step for many-body quantum dynamics is the simulation of one-dimensional open quantum systems. We review the three dominant approaches to the simulation of open quantum systems via the Lindblad master equation: quantum trajectories, matrix product density operators (MPDOs), and locally purified tensor networks. Selected examples guide possible applications of the methods and serve moreover as a benchmark between the techniques. These examples include the finite temperature states of the transverse quantum Ising model, the dynamics of an exciton traveling under the influence of spontaneous emission and dephasing, and a double-well potential simulated with the Bose–Hubbard model including dephasing. We analyze which approach is favorable leading to the conclusion that a complete set of all three methods is most beneficial, pushing the limits of different scenarios. The convergence studies using analytical results for macroscopic variables and exact diagonalization methods as comparison, show, for example, that MPDOs are favorable for the exciton problem in our study. All three methods access the same library, i.e., the software package Open Source Matrix Product States , allowing us to have a meaningful comparison between the different approaches based on the selected examples. For example, tensor operations are accessed from the same subroutines and with the same optimization eliminating one possible bias in a comparison of such numerical methods.

arXiv:1804.09796•Quantum Science and Technology•Oct 10, 2018•79 citations

Low-temperature Gibbs states with tensor networks

Denise Cocchiarella, Mari Carmen Bañuls

We introduce a tensor network method for approximating thermal equilibrium states of quantum many-body systems at low temperatures. Whereas the usual approach starts from infinite temperature and evolves the state in imaginary time (toward lower temperature), our ansatz is constructed from the zero-temperature limit, the ground state, which can be found with a standard tensor network approach. Motivated by properties of the ground state for conformal field theories, our ansatz is especially well suited near criticality. Moreover, it allows an efficient computation of thermodynamic quantities and entanglement properties. We demonstrate the performance of our approach with a tree tensor network ansatz, although it can be extended to other tensor networks, and present results illustrating its effectiveness in capturing the finite-temperature properties in one- and two-dimensional scenarios. In particular, in the critical one-dimensional case we show how the ansatz reproduces the finite temperature scaling of entanglement in a conformal field theory.

arXiv:2501.08300•Physical Review Research•Jul 29, 2025•5 citations

Thermalization in open quantum systems

Israel Reichental, Anat Klempner, Yariv Kafri +1 more

We study thermalization in open quantum systems using the Lindblad formalism. A method that both thermalizes and couples to Lindblad operators only at edges of the system is introduced. Our method leads to a Gibbs state of the system, satisfies fluctuation-dissipation relations, and applies both to integrable and nonintegrable systems. Possible applications of the method include the study of systems coupled locally to multiple reservoirs. Our analysis highlights the limits of applicability of the Lindblad approach to study strongly driven systems.

arXiv:1711.02699•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 2, 2018•35 citations

Polynomial-time thermalization and Gibbs sampling from system-bath couplings

Samuel Slezak, Matteo Scandi, Álvaro M. Alhambra +2 more

Many physical phenomena, including thermalization in open quantum systems and quantum Gibbs sampling, are modeled by Lindbladians approximating a system weakly coupled to a bath. Understanding the convergence speed of these Lindbladians to their steady states is crucial for bounding algorithmic runtimes and thermalization timescales. We study two such families of processes: one characterizing a repeated-interaction Gibbs sampling algorithm, and another modeling open many-body quantum thermalization. We prove that both converge in polynomial time for several non-commuting systems, including high-temperature local lattices, weakly interacting fermions, and 1D spin chains. These results demonstrate that simple dissipative quantum algorithms can prepare complex Gibbs states and that Lindblad dynamics accurately capture thermal relaxation. Our proofs rely on a novel technical result that extrapolates spectral gap lower bounds from quasi-local Lindbladians to the non-local generators governing these dynamics.

quant-pharXiv:2601.16154•Jan 23, 2026•0 citations

OSMPS: Many-body entangled open quantum systems

Daniel Jaschke, Simone Montangero, Lincoln D. Carr

We present an open source code to simulate entangled dynamics of open quantum systems governed by the Lindblad master equation with tensor network methods. Tensor network methods using matrix product states have been proven very useful to simulate many-body quantum systems and have driven many innovations in research. Since the matrix product state design is tailored for closed one-dimensional systems governed by the Schr\odinger equation, the next step for many-body quantum dynamics is the simulation of one-dimensional open quantum systems. We review the three dominant approaches to the simulation of open quantum systems via the Lindblad master equation: quantum trajectories, matrix product density operators, and locally purified tensor networks. The package Open Source Matrix Product States combines these three major methods to simulate one-dimensional open quantum systems with the Lindblad master equation. We access the same underlying tensor network algorithms for all techniques, e.g., the tensor contractions optimized in the same way, allowing us to have a meaningful comparison between the different approaches based on selected examples. These examples include the finite temperature states of the transverse quantum Ising model, the dynamics of an exciton traveling under the influence of spontaneous emission and dephasing, and a double-well potential simulated with the Bose-Hubbard model including dephasing. We analyze which approach is favorable leading to the conclusion that a complete set of all three methods is most beneficial, pushing the limits of different scenarios. The convergence studies using analytical results for macroscopic variables and exact diagonalization methods as comparison, show, for example, that matrix product density operators are favorable for the exciton problem in our study.

•Apr 25, 2018•0 citations
We investigate the relaxation dynamics of open nonintegrable quantum many-body systems in the thermodynamic limit by using a tensor-network formalism. We simulate the Lindblad quantum master equation (LQME) of infinite systems by making use of the uniform matrix product operators (MPO) as the ansatz of their density matrices. Furthermore, we establish a method to measure the thermodynamic equivalence between two states described by the uniform MPOs. We numerically show that when an initial state of the LQME is a thermal Gibbs state, a time evolved state is always indistinguishable from a Gibbs state with a time-dependent effective temperature in the weak-dissipation and thermodynamic limit.
The nonequilibrium effects of dissipation and drive play a key role in an immense variety of nanoscale and mesoscale quantum systems. To understand the behaviour of open quantum systems, we need accurate methods that capture the influence of the environment on the system, while managing the exponentially large Hilbert space required to describe the system. Tensor network algorithms offer an efficient way to approach this challenge. In this thesis, we develop and apply tensor network techniques to study the dynamics and steady states of various open quantum systems. The first part of the thesis focuses on the driven dissipative many body physics in coupled cavity arrays described by Born-Markov master equations. We extend transfer matrix product operator methods to Liouvillian dynamics, and utilize them to compute dynamical correlation functions and fluorescence spectrum of an infinite coupled cavity array in 1D. We also investigate thermalization, and observe the emergence of a quasi-thermal steady state with a negative effective temperature. In another study, we use infinite projected entangled pair state (iPEPS) methods to compute steady states of coupled cavity lattices in 2D. We find that a straightforward adaptation of iPEPS to Liouvillian dynamics is unstable, contradicting a recent publication in the field. The second part investigates more general systems involving strong couplings and structured environments that induce non-Markovian dynamics. We develop a powerful time-evolving matrix product operator (TEMPO) algorithm that builds on Feynman-Vernon influence functional formalism, and uses matrix product states (MPS) to represent the temporal non-Markovian correlations efficiently. We apply TEMPO to study the localization phase transition of the spin-boson model and the dynamics of two spatially separated two-level systems coupled to a common environment. Finally, we propose the Toblerone TEMPO algorithm, which extends TEMPO to many-body systems interacting with general bosonic environments.
Abstract We present a collection of methods to simulate entangled dynamics of open quantum systems governed by the Lindblad master equation with tensor network methods. Tensor network methods using matrix product states (MPSs) have been proven very useful to simulate many-body quantum systems and have driven many innovations in research. Since the MPS design is tailored for closed one-dimensional systems governed by the Schrödinger equation, the next step for many-body quantum dynamics is the simulation of one-dimensional open quantum systems. We review the three dominant approaches to the simulation of open quantum systems via the Lindblad master equation: quantum trajectories, matrix product density operators (MPDOs), and locally purified tensor networks. Selected examples guide possible applications of the methods and serve moreover as a benchmark between the techniques. These examples include the finite temperature states of the transverse quantum Ising model, the dynamics of an exciton traveling under the influence of spontaneous emission and dephasing, and a double-well potential simulated with the Bose–Hubbard model including dephasing. We analyze which approach is favorable leading to the conclusion that a complete set of all three methods is most beneficial, pushing the limits of different scenarios. The convergence studies using analytical results for macroscopic variables and exact diagonalization methods as comparison, show, for example, that MPDOs are favorable for the exciton problem in our study. All three methods access the same library, i.e., the software package Open Source Matrix Product States , allowing us to have a meaningful comparison between the different approaches based on the selected examples. For example, tensor operations are accessed from the same subroutines and with the same optimization eliminating one possible bias in a comparison of such numerical methods.
We introduce a tensor network method for approximating thermal equilibrium states of quantum many-body systems at low temperatures. Whereas the usual approach starts from infinite temperature and evolves the state in imaginary time (toward lower temperature), our ansatz is constructed from the zero-temperature limit, the ground state, which can be found with a standard tensor network approach. Motivated by properties of the ground state for conformal field theories, our ansatz is especially well suited near criticality. Moreover, it allows an efficient computation of thermodynamic quantities and entanglement properties. We demonstrate the performance of our approach with a tree tensor network ansatz, although it can be extended to other tensor networks, and present results illustrating its effectiveness in capturing the finite-temperature properties in one- and two-dimensional scenarios. In particular, in the critical one-dimensional case we show how the ansatz reproduces the finite temperature scaling of entanglement in a conformal field theory.
We study thermalization in open quantum systems using the Lindblad formalism. A method that both thermalizes and couples to Lindblad operators only at edges of the system is introduced. Our method leads to a Gibbs state of the system, satisfies fluctuation-dissipation relations, and applies both to integrable and nonintegrable systems. Possible applications of the method include the study of systems coupled locally to multiple reservoirs. Our analysis highlights the limits of applicability of the Lindblad approach to study strongly driven systems.
Many physical phenomena, including thermalization in open quantum systems and quantum Gibbs sampling, are modeled by Lindbladians approximating a system weakly coupled to a bath. Understanding the convergence speed of these Lindbladians to their steady states is crucial for bounding algorithmic runtimes and thermalization timescales. We study two such families of processes: one characterizing a repeated-interaction Gibbs sampling algorithm, and another modeling open many-body quantum thermalization. We prove that both converge in polynomial time for several non-commuting systems, including high-temperature local lattices, weakly interacting fermions, and 1D spin chains. These results demonstrate that simple dissipative quantum algorithms can prepare complex Gibbs states and that Lindblad dynamics accurately capture thermal relaxation. Our proofs rely on a novel technical result that extrapolates spectral gap lower bounds from quasi-local Lindbladians to the non-local generators governing these dynamics.
We present an open source code to simulate entangled dynamics of open quantum systems governed by the Lindblad master equation with tensor network methods. Tensor network methods using matrix product states have been proven very useful to simulate many-body quantum systems and have driven many innovations in research. Since the matrix product state design is tailored for closed one-dimensional systems governed by the Schr\odinger equation, the next step for many-body quantum dynamics is the simulation of one-dimensional open quantum systems. We review the three dominant approaches to the simulation of open quantum systems via the Lindblad master equation: quantum trajectories, matrix product density operators, and locally purified tensor networks. The package Open Source Matrix Product States combines these three major methods to simulate one-dimensional open quantum systems with the Lindblad master equation. We access the same underlying tensor network algorithms for all techniques, e.g., the tensor contractions optimized in the same way, allowing us to have a meaningful comparison between the different approaches based on selected examples. These examples include the finite temperature states of the transverse quantum Ising model, the dynamics of an exciton traveling under the influence of spontaneous emission and dephasing, and a double-well potential simulated with the Bose-Hubbard model including dephasing. We analyze which approach is favorable leading to the conclusion that a complete set of all three methods is most beneficial, pushing the limits of different scenarios. The convergence studies using analytical results for macroscopic variables and exact diagonalization methods as comparison, show, for example, that matrix product density operators are favorable for the exciton problem in our study.