A thermally isolated quantum system undergoes unitary evolution by interacting with an external work source. The two-point energy measurement (TPM) protocol defines the work exchanged between the system and the work source by performing ideal energy measurements on the system before and after the unitary evolution. However, the ideal energy measurements used in the TPM protocol ultimately result from a unitary coupling with a measurement apparatus, which requires an interaction with an external work source. For the TPM protocol to be self-consistent, we must be able to perform the TPM protocol on the compound of the system plus the apparatus, thus revealing the total work distribution, such that when ignoring the apparatus degrees of freedom, we recover the original TPM work distribution for the system of interest. In the present paper, we show that such self-consistency is satisfied as long as the apparatus is initially prepared in an energy eigenstate. Moreover, we demonstrate that if the apparatus Hamiltonian is equivalent to the ``pointer observable,'' then (i) the total work distribution will satisfy the ``unmeasured'' first law of thermodynamics for all system states and system-only unitary processes, and (ii) the total work distribution will be identical to the system-only work distribution for all system states and system-only unitary processes if and only if the unmeasured work due to the unitary coupling between the system and apparatus is zero for all system states.
A thermally isolated quantum system undergoes unitary evolution by interacting with an external work source. The two-point energy measurement (TPM) protocol defines the work exchanged between the system and the work source by performing ideal energy measurements on the system before and after the unitary evolution. However, the ideal energy measurements used in the TPM protocol ultimately result from a unitary coupling with a measurement apparatus, which requires an interaction with an external work source. For the TPM protocol to be self-consistent, we must be able to perform the TPM protocol on the compound of the system plus the apparatus, thus revealing the total work distribution, such that when ignoring the apparatus degrees of freedom, we recover the original TPM work distribution for the system of interest. In the present paper, we show that such self-consistency is satisfied as long as the apparatus is initially prepared in an energy eigenstate. Moreover, we demonstrate that if the apparatus Hamiltonian is equivalent to the pointer observable,'' then (i) the total work distribution will satisfy the unmeasured'' first law of thermodynamics for all system states and system-only unitary processes, and (ii) the total work distribution will be identical to the system-only work distribution for all system states and system-only unitary processes if and only if the unmeasured work due to the unitary coupling between the system and apparatus is zero for all system states.
In this Letter we investigate the concept of quantum work and its measurability from the viewpoint of quantum measurement theory. Very often, quantum work and fluctuation theorems are discussed in the framework of projective two-point measurement (TPM) schemes. According to a well-known no-go theorem, there is no work observable which satisfies both (i) an average work condition and (ii) the TPM statistics for diagonal input states. Such projective measurements represent a restrictive class among all possible measurements. It is desirable, both from a theoretical and experimental point of view, to extend the scheme to the general case including suitably designed unsharp measurements. This shifts the focus to the question of what information about work and its fluctuations one is able to extract from such generalized measurements. We show that the no-go theorem no longer holds if the observables in a TPM scheme are jointly measurable for any intermediate unitary evolution. We explicitly construct a model with unsharp energy measurements and derive bounds for the visibility that ensure joint measurability. In such an unsharp scenario a single work measurement apparatus can be constructed that allows us to determine the correct average work and to obtain free energy differences with the help of a Jarzynski equality.
Quantum measurement is ultimately a physical process, resulting from an interaction between the measured system and a measurement apparatus. Considering the physical process of measurement within a thermodynamic context naturally raises the following question: how can the work and heat resulting from the measurement process be interpreted? In the present manuscript, we model the measurement process for an arbitrary discrete observable as a measurement scheme. Here, the system to be measured is first unitarily coupled with a measurement apparatus, and subsequently the apparatus is measured by a pointer observable, thus producing a definite measurement outcome. The work can therefore be interpreted as the change in internal energy of the compound of system-plus-apparatus due to the unitary coupling. By the first law of thermodynamics, the heat is the subsequent change in internal energy of this compound due to the measurement of the pointer observable. However, in order for the apparatus to serve as a stable record for the measurement outcomes, the pointer observable must commute with the Hamiltonian, and its implementation must be repeatable. Given these minimal requirements, we show that the heat will necessarily be a classically fluctuating quantity.
For a quantum system undergoing a unitary, process work is commonly defined based on the two projective measurement protocols, which measures the energies of the system before and after the process. However, it is well known that projective measurements disregard quantum coherences of the system with respect to the energy basis, thus removing potential quantum signatures in the work distribution. Here we consider weak measurements of the system's energy difference and establish corrections to work averages arising from initial system coherences. We discuss two weak measurement protocols that couple the system to a detector, prepared and measured either in the momentum or the position eigenstates. Work averages are derived for when the system starts in the proper thermal state versus when the initial system state is a pure state with thermal diagonal elements and coherences characterized by a set of phases. We show that by controlling only the phase differences between the energy eigenstate contributions in the system's initial pure state, the average work done during the same unitary process can be controlled. By changing the phases alone, one can toggle from regimes where the system absorbs energy, i.e., a work cost, to the ones where it emits energy, i.e., work can be drawn. This suggests that the coherences are additional resources that can be used to manipulate or store energy in a quantum system.
Quantum fluctuations are fundamental to quantum technologies, affecting quantum computing, sensing, cryptography, and thermodynamics. A paradigmatic example is quantum work, which, for a thermally isolated driven system, is identified with the variation of its energy. Although quantum mechanics provides precise rules for measuring energy and other observables at individual instants of time, it does not provide a standard framework for characterizing the statistics of their variations between two times. This ambiguity has led to competing protocols that can assign different work distributions--and, more generally, different fluctuation statistics--to the same physical process, with consequences for both foundational physics and quantum technologies. In this work, we propose four fundamental criteria that any consistent protocol for measuring energy variations must satisfy, grounded in conservation laws, state independence of the measurement apparatus, the no-signaling principle, and constraints on physical reality. We prove that these criteria uniquely select the two-time quantum observable protocol. We then show that this conclusion extends beyond work and energy to the variation of arbitrary physical observables, including charge, particle number, and momentum. This result has the potential to establish the foundations for measurements of quantum processes, possibly resolving ambiguities in quantum fluctuation measurements. Moreover, it enables the extension of quantum information concepts, such as entanglement and Bell's inequalities, to processes rather than instantaneous observables.
Considering a general microscopic model for a quantum measuring apparatus comprising a quantum probe coupled to a thermal bath, we analyze the energetic resources necessary for the realization of a quantum measurement, which includes the creation of system-apparatus correlations, the irreversible transition to a statistical mixture of definite outcomes, and the apparatus resetting. Crucially, we do not resort to another quantum measurement to capture the emergence of objective measurement results, but rather exploit the properties of the thermal bath which redundantly records the measurement result in its degrees of freedom, naturally implementing the paradigm of quantum Darwinism. In practice, this model allows us to perform a quantitative thermodynamic analysis of the measurement process. From the expression of the second law, we show how the minimal required work depends on the energy variation of the system being measured plus information-theoretic quantities characterizing the performance of the measurement – efficiency and completeness. Additionally, we show that it is possible to perform a thermodynamically reversible measurement, thus reaching the minimal work expenditure, and provide the corresponding protocol. Finally, for finite-time measurement protocols, we illustrate the increasing work cost induced by rising entropy production inherent in finite-time thermodynamic processes. This highlights an emerging trade-off between velocity of the measurement and work cost, on top of a trade-off between efficiency of the measurement and work cost. We apply those findings to bring new insights in the thermodynamic balance of the measurement-powered quantum engines.
Quantum measurements are known to affect the state of the measured system. Such a measurement backaction is due to the interaction of the quantum system with the measuring device. When the measured observable and the system's Hamiltonian do not commute, the backaction can lead to a mean energy change of the system. This energy change has been dubbed "quantum heat" and, in association with feedback processes and/or the interaction with thermal bath(s), proves to be a genuinely quantum resource to fuel new kinds quantum engines. We propose such a measurement powered engine exploiting the non-commutativity of local and non-local operations on a bipartite quantum system.We then investigate the origin of the quantum heat. Even if one cannot model the full dynamics of a measurement due to the collapse of the wavefunction, the energetic aspects can still be investigated by modeling the so-called pre-measurement. During this step, the system interacts and gets correlated with a quantum system which can be viewed as a small part of the measuring apparatus and called the quantum meter. Ideally, at the end of this process, the system's reduced state will be fully decohered in the measurement basis, thus corresponding to the averaged collapsed output states given by the measurement postulate. We find that the quantum heat received by the measured system corresponds to the energy necessary to turn off the coupling between the meter and the system. Using generalized definitions of heat and work, we moreover characterize the work and heat nature of these energy exchanges.Tracing the source of this energy one step further, we propose an autonomous description of a measurement. This is done by considering a flying qubit measured by the quantum field of the cavity it crosses. The interaction being position dependent, the kinetic degree of freedom is providing the required energy to switch on and off the interaction between the qubit and the meter field. A full quantum treatment allows us to evaluate the impact of the finite spatial and momentum extension of the qubit wavepacket. Since the kinetic degree of freedom can be affected by the interaction, it does not simply generate a time dependent Hamiltonian for the other degrees of freedom. We find the correction to this ideal dynamic and analyse its consequences on the nature of the energy fluxes. %spread/extension/broadnessTaking the opposite point of view, we compare the measurement cost of a qubit by a field propagating in a waveguide, depending on the initial state of the field. In the context of a circuit quantum electrodynamics setup, we find that thermal and coherent fields induce the same backaction on the qubit given the same energy constraints.The results presented and discussed in this thesis contribute to unravel the mysterious effects and mechanisms due to quantum measurements. Notably, they give an outlook to further analyse quantum measurement-based engines and to understand the energetic resource that measurements cost and constitute at the same time.