arXiv:2012.06159

Strange Metal Solution in the Diagrammatic Theory for the $2d$ Hubbard Model

Aaram J. Kim, Philipp Werner, Evgeny Kozik

Published Dec 11, 2020• 8 citations

Abstract

We show that the numerically exact bold-line diagrammatic theory for the $2d$ Hubbard model exhibits a non-Fermi-liquid (NFL) strange metal state, which is connected to the SYK NFL in the strong-interaction limit. The solution for the doped system features the expected phenomenology with the NFL near half-filling at strong couplings and in a wide temperature range enclosed by the atomic state at high temperatures and a Fermi liquid at low temperatures. We demonstrate, however, that this behavior in the weakly doped regime is due to the unphysical branch of the Luttinger-Ward functional. On the other hand, our analysis shows that the NFL physics is realized at larger doping.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.2012.06159

Related papers

Non-Fermi liquid of extended range at zero temperature without quantum criticality

Tae-Ho Park, Han-Yong Choi

Scientific ReportsApr 1, 20260 citations

Non-Fermi liquid over extended range at zero temperature without quantum criticality

Tae-Ho Park, Han-Yong Choi

arXiv:2408.14858Aug 27, 20240 citations

Strange metal to insulator transitions in the lowest Landau level

Ben Currie, Evgeny Kozik

arXiv:2310.20659Physical Review ResearchMay 24, 20241 citation

Entropy in the Non-Fermi-Liquid Regime of the Doped 2D Hubbard Model

Connor Lenihan, Aaram J. Kim, Fedor Šimkovic +1 more

arXiv:2001.09948Physical Review LettersMar 12, 202117 citations

Mott Transition and Strange Metal in Two Dimensions: A View from Cellular Dynamical Cluster Approximation

M. S. Laad, L. Craco

arXiv:cond-mat/0701585Jan 24, 20070 citations

Strange metal in the doped Hubbard model via percolation

Andrew A. Allocca

arXiv:2402.18626Physical review. B./Physical review. BOct 15, 20240 citations

arXiv:2012.06159

Strange Metal Solution in the Diagrammatic Theory for the $2d$ Hubbard ModelStrange Metal Solution in the Diagrammatic Theory for the $2d$ Hubbard Model

Aaram J. Kim, Philipp Werner, Evgeny Kozik

Published Dec 11, 2020• 8 citations

arXiv HTML PDF

Abstract

We show that the numerically exact bold-line diagrammatic theory for the

2d

Hubbard model exhibits a non-Fermi-liquid (NFL) strange metal state, which is connected to the SYK NFL in the strong-interaction limit. The solution for the doped system features the expected phenomenology with the NFL near half-filling at strong couplings and in a wide temperature range enclosed by the atomic state at high temperatures and a Fermi liquid at low temperatures. We demonstrate, however, that this behavior in the weakly doped regime is due to the unphysical branch of the Luttinger-Ward functional. On the other hand, our analysis shows that the NFL physics is realized at larger doping.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.2012.06159

Related papers

Non-Fermi liquid of extended range at zero temperature without quantum criticality

Tae-Ho Park, Han-Yong Choi

Non-Fermi liquid (NFL) behavior and strange metallicity, often marked by resistivity linear in temperature and the breakdown of Fermi liquid quasiparticles, are recurring themes in strongly correlated quantum materials, ranging from high-temperature cuprates to twisted van der Waals heterostructures. Enormous efforts are being made to uncover the origin of NFL underlying strange metallicity, yet progress remains slow. Here, we report appearance of an NFL phase in a discontinuous metal-NFL-insulator transition of the Holstein model away from half-filling. The NFL appears as a distinct ground state of finite regime in addition to the metal and insulator states in a phase diagram, not as a consequence of quantum criticality of a continuous transition. Also, the discontinuity of the metal-NFL transition produces a mixture between the two phases along the phase boundary to exhibit a two-fluid kind strange metallicity. The dynamical mean-field theory was employed with Wilson’s numerical renormalization group in infinite dimensions. We trace the NFL phase to a spin gap opening in the absence of a charge gap. This offers an intriguing route to understanding the NFL and intertwined superconductivity in correlated quantum materials.Non-Fermi liquid (NFL) behavior and strange metallicity, often marked by resistivity linear in temperature and the breakdown of Fermi liquid quasiparticles, are recurring themes in strongly correlated quantum materials, ranging from high-temperature cuprates to twisted van der Waals heterostructures. Enormous efforts are being made to uncover the origin of NFL underlying strange metallicity, yet progress remains slow. Here, we report appearance of an NFL phase in a discontinuous metal-NFL-insulator transition of the Holstein model away from half-filling. The NFL appears as a distinct ground state of finite regime in addition to the metal and insulator states in a phase diagram, not as a consequence of quantum criticality of a continuous transition. Also, the discontinuity of the metal-NFL transition produces a mixture between the two phases along the phase boundary to exhibit a two-fluid kind strange metallicity. The dynamical mean-field theory was employed with Wilson’s numerical renormalization group in infinite dimensions. We trace the NFL phase to a spin gap opening in the absence of a charge gap. This offers an intriguing route to understanding the NFL and intertwined superconductivity in correlated quantum materials.

Scientific ReportsApr 1, 20260 citations

Non-Fermi liquid over extended range at zero temperature without quantum criticality

Tae-Ho Park, Han-Yong Choi

A strange metal state appears in many strongly correlated materials from the cuprates, pnictides, and twisted bilayer graphenes to even bosonic systems. Enormous efforts are being made to unravel the nature of the non-Fermi liquid (NFL) which underlies the strange metallicity, yet progress is rather slow. Understanding the NFL behavior is crucial, in addition to its importance in replacing the Fermi liquid paradigm, in that NFL is the normal state from which new states of matter emerge like high temperature superconductivity. Here, we report the appearance of an NFL phase in a discontinuous metal-NFL-insulator transition in a ``non-engineered'' Hamiltonian of the Holstein model away from half-filling. The discontinuity of the phase transition between NFL and Fermi liquid metal renders the ground state at the phase boundary a mixture between them over an extended range like the extended criticality observed in cuprates and other quantum materials. The dynamical mean-field theory was employed in combination with Wilson's numerical renormalization group technique. We identify the origin of the NFL metal phase as the opening of a spin gap in the absence of a charge gap. Also, strong lattice fluctuations emerge at the boundary which should enhance superconductivity.A strange metal state appears in many strongly correlated materials from the cuprates, pnictides, and twisted bilayer graphenes to even bosonic systems. Enormous efforts are being made to unravel the nature of the non-Fermi liquid (NFL) which underlies the strange metallicity, yet progress is rather slow. Understanding the NFL behavior is crucial, in addition to its importance in replacing the Fermi liquid paradigm, in that NFL is the normal state from which new states of matter emerge like high temperature superconductivity. Here, we report the appearance of an NFL phase in a discontinuous metal-NFL-insulator transition in a ``non-engineered'' Hamiltonian of the Holstein model away from half-filling. The discontinuity of the phase transition between NFL and Fermi liquid metal renders the ground state at the phase boundary a mixture between them over an extended range like the extended criticality observed in cuprates and other quantum materials. The dynamical mean-field theory was employed in combination with Wilson's numerical renormalization group technique. We identify the origin of the NFL metal phase as the opening of a spin gap in the absence of a charge gap. Also, strong lattice fluctuations emerge at the boundary which should enhance superconductivity.

arXiv:2408.14858Aug 27, 20240 citations

Strange metal to insulator transitions in the lowest Landau level

Ben Currie, Evgeny Kozik

We study the microscopic model of electrons in the partially-filled lowest Landau level interacting via the Coulomb potential by the diagrammatic theory within the GW approximation. In a wide range of filling fractions and temperatures, we find a homogeneous non-Fermi liquid (nFL) state similar to that found in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, with logarithmic corrections to the anomalous dimension. In addition, the phase diagram is qualitatively similar to that of SYK: a first-order transition terminating at a critical end-point separates the nFL phase from a band insulator that corresponds to the fully filled Landau level. This critical point, as well as that of the SYK model—whose critical exponents we determine more precisely—are shown to both belong to the Van der Waals universality class. The possibility of a charge density wave (CDW) instability is also investigated, and we find the homogeneous nFL state to extend down to the ground state for fillings 0.2≲ν≲0.8 , while a CDW appears outside this range of fillings at sufficiently low temperatures. Our results suggest that the SYK-like nFL state should be a generic feature of the partially filled lowest Landau level at intermediate temperatures. Published by the American Physical Society 2024We study the microscopic model of electrons in the partially-filled lowest Landau level interacting via the Coulomb potential by the diagrammatic theory within the GW approximation. In a wide range of filling fractions and temperatures, we find a homogeneous non-Fermi liquid (nFL) state similar to that found in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, with logarithmic corrections to the anomalous dimension. In addition, the phase diagram is qualitatively similar to that of SYK: a first-order transition terminating at a critical end-point separates the nFL phase from a band insulator that corresponds to the fully filled Landau level. This critical point, as well as that of the SYK model—whose critical exponents we determine more precisely—are shown to both belong to the Van der Waals universality class. The possibility of a charge density wave (CDW) instability is also investigated, and we find the homogeneous nFL state to extend down to the ground state for fillings 0.2≲ν≲0.8 , while a CDW appears outside this range of fillings at sufficiently low temperatures. Our results suggest that the SYK-like nFL state should be a generic feature of the partially filled lowest Landau level at intermediate temperatures. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2310.20659Physical Review ResearchMay 24, 20241 citation

Entropy in the Non-Fermi-Liquid Regime of the Doped 2D Hubbard Model

Connor Lenihan, Aaram J. Kim, Fedor Šimkovic +1 more

We study thermodynamic properties of the doped Hubbard model on the square lattice in the regime of strong charge and spin fluctuations at low temperatures near the metal-to-insulator crossover and obtain results with controlled accuracy using the diagrammatic Monte Carlo method directly in the thermodynamic limit. The behavior of the entropy reveals a non-Fermi-liquid state at sufficiently high interactions near half filling: A maximum in the entropy at nonzero doping develops as the coupling strength is increased, along with an inflection point, evidencing a metal to non-Fermi-liquid crossover. The specific heat exhibits additional distinctive features of a non-Fermi-liquid state. Measurements of the entropy can, therefore, be used as a probe of the state of the system in quantum simulation experiments with ultracold atoms in optical lattices.We study thermodynamic properties of the doped Hubbard model on the square lattice in the regime of strong charge and spin fluctuations at low temperatures near the metal-to-insulator crossover and obtain results with controlled accuracy using the diagrammatic Monte Carlo method directly in the thermodynamic limit. The behavior of the entropy reveals a non-Fermi-liquid state at sufficiently high interactions near half filling: A maximum in the entropy at nonzero doping develops as the coupling strength is increased, along with an inflection point, evidencing a metal to non-Fermi-liquid crossover. The specific heat exhibits additional distinctive features of a non-Fermi-liquid state. Measurements of the entropy can, therefore, be used as a probe of the state of the system in quantum simulation experiments with ultracold atoms in optical lattices.

arXiv:2001.09948Physical Review LettersMar 12, 202117 citations

Mott Transition and Strange Metal in Two Dimensions: A View from Cellular Dynamical Cluster Approximation

M. S. Laad, L. Craco

We introduce a Cellular Dynamical Cluster Approximation (CDCA) to study the nature of the Mott insulator-metal transition in the extended Hubbard model on a square lattice. At strong coupling, a d-wave Mott insulator is obtained. Hole doping drives a first order Mott transition to a non-Fermi (nFL) liquid metal. Remarkably, this nFL is caused by an Anderson orthogonality catastrophe at low energies due to the non-trivial competition between strong, non-local interactions and hopping. This constitutes the first explicit realisation of Anderson's Luttinger liquid idea in two dimensions. Many experimental responses in the ``strange metal'' phase found around optimal doping in cuprates are understood naturally within our approach.We introduce a Cellular Dynamical Cluster Approximation (CDCA) to study the nature of the Mott insulator-metal transition in the extended Hubbard model on a square lattice. At strong coupling, a d-wave Mott insulator is obtained. Hole doping drives a first order Mott transition to a non-Fermi (nFL) liquid metal. Remarkably, this nFL is caused by an Anderson orthogonality catastrophe at low energies due to the non-trivial competition between strong, non-local interactions and hopping. This constitutes the first explicit realisation of Anderson's Luttinger liquid idea in two dimensions. Many experimental responses in the ``strange metal'' phase found around optimal doping in cuprates are understood naturally within our approach.

arXiv:cond-mat/0701585Jan 24, 20070 citations

Strange metal in the doped Hubbard model via percolation

Andrew A. Allocca

Many strongly correlated systems exhibit strange metallic behavior in certain parameter regimes characterized by anomalous transport properties that are irreconcilable with a Fermi-liquid-like description in terms of quasiparticles. The Hubbard model is a standard theoretical starting point to examine the properties of such systems and also exhibits non-Fermi-liquid behavior in simulations. Here we analytically study the two-dimensional hole-doped Hubbard model in the large $U$ limit, first identifying a doping-induced percolation transition in the low-energy sector occurring at a definite critical doping ${p}_{c}$ depending on lattice structure. Using the critical properties near this transition we rewrite the Hubbard Hamiltonian and motivate a low-energy lattice-independent large- $N$ model with distinct non-Fermi-liquid properties. We show that this model has linear-in- $T$ resistivity with doping-dependent slope maximized at $p={p}_{c}$ and power-law optical conductivity ${\ensuremath{\sim}|\ensuremath{\omega}|}^{\ensuremath{-}2/3}$. Though the parameters used in developing this theory mean it cannot be directly applied to the cuprate superconductors, we nevertheless reproduce several important phenomena observed in their strange metal phase and also predict these same qualitative behaviors to manifest in other lattices near concrete hole dopings.Many strongly correlated systems exhibit strange metallic behavior in certain parameter regimes characterized by anomalous transport properties that are irreconcilable with a Fermi-liquid-like description in terms of quasiparticles. The Hubbard model is a standard theoretical starting point to examine the properties of such systems and also exhibits non-Fermi-liquid behavior in simulations. Here we analytically study the two-dimensional hole-doped Hubbard model in the large $U$ limit, first identifying a doping-induced percolation transition in the low-energy sector occurring at a definite critical doping ${p}_{c}$ depending on lattice structure. Using the critical properties near this transition we rewrite the Hubbard Hamiltonian and motivate a low-energy lattice-independent large-$N$ model with distinct non-Fermi-liquid properties. We show that this model has linear-in-$T$ resistivity with doping-dependent slope maximized at $p={p}_{c}$ and power-law optical conductivity ${\ensuremath{\sim}|\ensuremath{\omega}|}^{\ensuremath{-}2/3}$. Though the parameters used in developing this theory mean it cannot be directly applied to the cuprate superconductors, we nevertheless reproduce several important phenomena observed in their strange metal phase and also predict these same qualitative behaviors to manifest in other lattices near concrete hole dopings.

arXiv:2402.18626Physical review. B./Physical review. BOct 15, 20240 citations

Strange Metal Solution in the Diagrammatic Theory for the

2d

Hubbard Model

We show that the numerically exact bold-line diagrammatic theory for the

2d

U

limit, first identifying a doping-induced percolation transition in the low-energy sector occurring at a definite critical doping

{p}_{c}

depending on lattice structure. Using the critical properties near this transition we rewrite the Hubbard Hamiltonian and motivate a low-energy lattice-independent large-

N

model with distinct non-Fermi-liquid properties. We show that this model has linear-in-

T

resistivity with doping-dependent slope maximized at

p={p}_{c}

and power-law optical conductivity ${\ensuremath{\sim}|\ensuremath{\omega}|}^{\ensuremath{-}2/3}$. Though the parameters used in developing this theory mean it cannot be directly applied to the cuprate superconductors, we nevertheless reproduce several important phenomena observed in their strange metal phase and also predict these same qualitative behaviors to manifest in other lattices near concrete hole dopings.