From the perspective of many-body physics, the transmon qubit architectures currently developed for quantum computing are systems of coupled nonlinear quantum resonators. A certain amount of intentional frequency detuning ('disorder') is crucially required to protect individual qubit states against the destabilizing effects of nonlinear resonator coupling. Here we investigate the stability of this variant of a many-body localized phase for system parameters relevant to current quantum processors developed by the IBM, Delft, and Google consortia, considering the cases of natural or engineered disorder. Applying three independent diagnostics of localization theory - a Kullback-Leibler analysis of spectral statistics, statistics of many-body wave functions (inverse participation ratios), and a Walsh transform of the many-body spectrum - we find that some of these computing platforms are dangerously close to a phase of uncontrollable chaotic fluctuations.
From the perspective of many-body physics, the transmon qubit architectures currently developed for quantum computing are systems of coupled nonlinear quantum resonators. A certain amount of intentional frequency detuning ('disorder') is crucially required to protect individual qubit states against the destabilizing effects of nonlinear resonator coupling. Here we investigate the stability of this variant of a many-body localized phase for system parameters relevant to current quantum processors developed by the IBM, Delft, and Google consortia, considering the cases of natural or engineered disorder. Applying three independent diagnostics of localization theory - a Kullback-Leibler analysis of spectral statistics, statistics of many-body wave functions (inverse participation ratios), and a Walsh transform of the many-body spectrum - we find that some of these computing platforms are dangerously close to a phase of uncontrollable chaotic fluctuations.
The development of quantum computing hardware is facing the challenge that current-day quantum processors, comprising 50–100 qubits, already operate outside the range of quantum simulation on classical computers. In this paper we demonstrate that the simulation of limits can be a potent diagnostic tool for the resilience of quantum information hardware against chaotic instabilities potentially mitigating this problem. As a testbed for our approach we consider the transmon qubit processor, a computing platform in which the coupling of large numbers of nonlinear quantum oscillators may trigger destabilizing chaotic resonances. We find that classical and quantum simulations lead to similar stability metrics (classical Lyapunov exponents vs quantum wave function participation ratios) in systems with O ( 10 ) transmons. However, the big advantage of classical simulation is that it can be pushed to large systems comprising up to thousands of qubits. We exhibit the utility of this classical toolbox by simulating all current IBM transmon chips, including the 433-qubit processor of the Osprey generation, as well as devices with 1 121 qubits (Condor generation). For realistic system parameters, we find a systematic increase of Lyapunov exponents with system size, suggesting that larger layouts require added efforts in information protection. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
The failure of quantum thermalization due to Many-Body Localization (MBL) has evolved from a theoretical concept in spin chains to an experimental reality in synthetic quantum platforms, most notably superconducting circuits based on transmon qubits. Despite its significance, the MBL transition has been studied primarily under purely random disorder and local couplings, leaving more complex and realistic configurations largely unexplored. Here, we investigate the quantum dynamics of transmon networks subject to the unavoidable competing effects of correlated disorder and network-mediated non-local interactions. First, we show how to engineer the physical parameters of the quantum hardware to systematically control the correlated disorder patterns emerging in the system. Then, we demonstrate that the MBL phase transition is robust against such correlations, which is essential for tuning localization properties in realistic transmon devices. This robustness is established through the analysis of the block entanglement entropy variance across disorder realizations, which precisely locates the MBL critical point. Independently, we introduce a local memory parameter, whose dynamics at long evolution times reveals memory retention in the localized phase and yields a critical point consistent with the entropy analysis. These results provide a framework for understanding localization in complex quantum network topologies, with potential implications for multi-qubit processor design.
Transmon qubits arise from the quantization of nonlinear resonators, systems that are prone to the buildup of strong, possibly chaotic, fluctuations. Such instabilities will likely affect fast gate operations which involve the transient population of higher excited states outside the computational subspace. Here, we extend the statistical analysis from the spectrum of the generator to that of dynamics itself and show that the instantaneous eigenphases of the time evolution operator, in particular of their curvatures, allows for identifying the subspace most affected by instabilities. Our analysis shows that fast entangling gates, operating at speeds close to the so-called quantum speed limit, contain transient regimes where the dynamics indeed becomes partially chaotic for just two transmons. Surprisingly, this does not reflect in gate reliability, rather, slower operations lead to relatively enhanced errors.
Transmon qubits are ubiquitously used in superconducting quantum information processor architectures.Strong drives are required to realize fast, high-fidelity, gates and measurements, including parametrically activated processes.Here, we show that even off-resonant drives, in regimes routinely used in experiments, can cause strong modifications to the structure of the transmon spectrum rendering a large part of it chaotic.Accounting for the full nonlinear dynamics of the transmon in a Floquet-Markov formalism, we find that these chaotic states, often neglected through the hypothesis that the anharmonicity is weak, strongly impact the lifetime of the transmon's computational states.In particular, we observe that chaos-assisted quantum phase slips greatly enhance band dispersions.In the presence of a measurement resonator, we find that approaching chaotic behavior correlates with strong transmon-resonator hybridization, and an average resonator response centered on the bare resonator frequency.These results lead to a photon-number threshold characterizing the appearance of chaos-induced quantum demolition effects during strong-drive operations, such as dispersive qubit readout.The phenomena described here are expected to be present in all circuits based on low-impedance Josephson junctions.
Transmon arrays are one of the most promising platforms for quantum information science. Despite being often considered simply as qubits, transmons are inherently quantum mechanical multilevel systems. Being experimentally controllable with high fidelity, the higher excited states beyond the qubit subspace provide an important resource for hardware-efficient many-body quantum simulations, quantum error correction, and quantum information protocols. Alas, dissipation and dephasing phenomena generated by couplings to various uncontrollable environments yield a practical limiting factor to their utilization. To quantify this in detail, we present here the primary consequences of single-transmon dissipation and dephasing to the many-body dynamics of transmon arrays. We use analytical methods from perturbation theory and quantum trajectory approach together with numerical simulations, and deliberately consider the full Hilbert space, including the higher excited states. The three main nonunitary processes are many-body decoherence, many-body dissipation, and heating/cooling transitions between different anharmonicity manifolds. Of these, the many-body decoherence---being proportional to the squared distance between the many-body Fock states---gives the strictest limit for observing effective unitary dynamics. Considering experimentally relevant parameters, including also the inevitable site-to-site disorder, our results show that the state-of-the-art transmon arrays should be ready for the task of demonstrating coherent many-body dynamics using the higher excited states. However, the wider utilization of transmons for ternary-and-beyond quantum computing calls for improving their coherence properties.
In quantum information processing, a tension between two different tasks occurs: while qubits' states can be preserved by isolating them, quantum gates can be realized only through qubit-qubit interactions. In arrays of qubits, weak coupling leads to states being spatially localized and strong coupling to delocalized states. Here, we study the average energy level spacing and the relative entropy of the distribution of the level spacings (Kullback-Leibler divergence from Poisson and Gaussian Orthogonal Ensemble) to analyze the crossover between localized and delocalized (chaotic) regimes in linear arrays of superconducting qubits. We consider both transmons as well as capacitively shunted flux qubits, which enables us to tune the qubit anharmonicity. Arrays with uniform anharmonicity, comprising only transmons or flux qubits, display remarkably similar dependencies of level statistics on the coupling strength. In systems with alternating anharmonicity, for typical disorder in the qubit frequencies the localized regime is found to be more resilient to the increase in qubit-qubit coupling strength in comparison to arrays with a single qubit type. Our results, which we also confirm using generalized Bose-Hubbard models, support designing devices that incorporate different qubit types to achieve higher performances.