Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2012.04984 · IEEE Congress on Evolutionary Computation (CEC)

Hybrid Quantum Computing - Tabu Search Algorithm for Partitioning Problems: Preliminary Study on the Traveling Salesman Problem

Eneko Osaba, Esther Villar-Rodríguez, Izaskun Oregi, Aitor Moreno-Fernández-de-Leceta

Published Jun 28, 2021• 40 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum Computing is considered as the next frontier in computing, and it is attracting a lot of attention from the current scientific community. This kind of computation provides to researchers with a revolutionary paradigm for addressing complex optimization problems, offering a significant speed advantage and an efficient search ability. Anyway, Quantum Computing is still in an incipient stage of development. For this reason, present architectures show certain limitations, which have motivated the carrying out of this paper. In this paper, we introduce a novel solving scheme coined as hybrid Quantum Computing - Tabu Search Algorithm. Main pillars of operation of the proposed method are a greater control over the access to quantum resources, and a considerable reduction of non-profitable accesses. To assess the quality of our method, we have used 7 different Traveling Salesman Problem instances as benchmarking set. The obtained outcomes support the preliminary conclusion that our algorithm is an approach which offers promising results for solving partitioning problems while it drastically reduces the access to quantum computing resources. We also contribute to the field of Transfer Optimization by developing an evolutionary multiform multitasking algorithm as initialization method.

DOI
10.1109/cec45853.2021.9504923

Related papers

Focusing on the hybrid quantum computing - Tabu search algorithm

Eneko Osaba, Esther Villar-Rodríguez, Izaskun Oregi +1 more

Quantum Computing is an emerging paradigm which is gathering a lot of popularity in the current scientific and technological community. Widely conceived as the next frontier of computation, Quantum Computing is still at the dawn of its development. Thus, current solving systems suffer from significant limitations in terms of performance and capabilities. Some interesting approaches have been devised by researchers and practitioners in order to overcome these barriers, being quantum-classical hybrid algorithms one of the most often used solving schemes. The main goal of this paper is to extend the results and findings of the recently proposed hybrid Quantum Computing - Tabu Search Algorithm for partitioning problems. To do that, we focus our research on the adaptation of this method to the Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Problem. In overall, we have employed six well-known instances belonging to TSPLIB to assess the performance of Quantum Computing - Tabu Search Algorithm in comparison to QBSolv. Furthermore, as an additional contribution, this work also supposes the first solving of the Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Problem using a Quantum Computing based method. Aiming to boost whole community's research in QC, we have released the project's repository as open source code for further application and improvements.

arXiv:2102.05919•Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference Companion (GECCO Companion)•Jul 7, 2021•20 citations

An Advanced Hybrid Quantum Tabu Search Approach to Vehicle Routing Problems

James B. Holliday, Eneko Osaba, Khoa Luu

Quantum computing (QC) is expected to solve incredibly difficult problems, including finding optimal solutions to combinatorial optimization problems. However, to date, QC alone is still far to demonstrate this capability except on small-sized problems. Hybrid approaches where QC and classical computing work together have shown the most potential for solving real-world scale problems. This work aims to show that we can enhance a classical optimization algorithm with QC so that it can overcome this limitation. We present a new hybrid quantum-classical tabu search (HQTS) algorithm to solve the capacitated vehicle routing problem (CVRP). Based on our prior work, HQTS leverages QC for routing within a classical tabu search framework. The quantum component formulates the traveling salesman problem (TSP) for each route as a QUBO, solved using D-Wave's Advantage system. Experiments investigate the impact of quantum routing frequency and starting solution methods. While different starting solution methods, including quantum-based and classical heuristics methods, it shows minimal overall impact. HQTS achieved optimal or near-optimal solutions for several CVRP problems, outperforming other hybrid CVRP algorithms and significantly reducing the optimality gap compared to preliminary research. The experimental results demonstrate that more frequent quantum routing improves solution quality and runtime. The findings highlight the potential of integrating QC within meta-heuristic frameworks for complex optimization in vehicle routing problems.

arXiv:2501.12652•Jan 22, 2025•0 citations

Evolutionary Algorithm for the Traveling Salesman Problem With Innovative Encoding on Hybrid Quantum-Classical Machines

Ravi Saini, Ashish Mani, Mani Shankar Prasad +2 more

The Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) is a widely studied NP-complete optimization challenge with significant theoretical and practical implications. This study proposes a hybrid quantum-classical framework using a Quantum-Inspired Evolutionary Algorithm (QEA) with Sort Gray Binary Encoding to solve the TSP. The proposed method guarantees the generation of valid TSP tours by eliminating invalid solutions. It employs quantum superposition with intrinsic randomness to enhance computational efficiency and scalability. The framework was implemented on cloud-based NISQ platforms, including IBM Quantum and AWS Braket, demonstrating its practicality and effectiveness. Experimental evaluations revealed that the proposed framework successfully solved TSP instances with up to 15 cities, achieving superior performance compared to classical methods and showcasing its ability to scale under NISQ constraints. The results also highlight the potential of hybrid quantum-classical approaches to overcome hardware limitations in current quantum systems. This study establishes a robust hybrid methodology for solving combinatorial optimization problems. It also sets a benchmark for leveraging the capabilities of NISQ-era quantum devices in real-world applications, thereby providing a foundation for future research in hybrid quantum-classical optimization techniques.

IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2025•4 citations

An advanced hybrid quantum tabu search approach to vehicle routing problems

James B. Holliday, Eneko Osaba, Khoa Luu

Quantum computing (QC) is expected to solve incredibly difficult problems, including finding optimal solutions to combinatorial optimization problems. However, to date, QC alone has still been unable to demonstrate this capability except for small-sized problems. Hybrid approaches, where QC and classical computing work together, have shown the most potential for solving real-world-scale problems. This work aims to show that we can enhance a classical optimization algorithm with QC so that it can overcome this limitation. We present a new Hybrid Quantum-classical Tabu Search (HQTS) algorithm to solve the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem (CVRP). Based on our prior work, HQTS leverages QC for routing within a classical tabu search framework. The quantum component formulates the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) for each route as a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) and solves it using D-Wave’s Advantage system. Experiments investigate the impact of quantum routing frequency and starting solution methods. Across different starting solution methods, including quantum-based and classical heuristics, it shows minimal overall impact. HQTS achieved optimal or near-optimal solutions for several CVRP problems, outperforming other hybrid CVRP algorithms and significantly reducing the optimality gap relative to preliminary research. The experimental results demonstrate that more frequent quantum routing improves solution quality and runtime. The findings highlight the potential of integrating QC within meta-heuristic frameworks for complex optimization in vehicle routing problems.

Quantum Machine Intelligence•Mar 23, 2026•1 citation

Quantum approaches to the traveling salesman problem: A critical review of formulations, complexity, and implementation limits

Florian Klug

The Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) serves as a standard benchmark for assessing potential quantum advantage in combinatorial optimization. This paper provides a critical comparative analysis of quantum annealing, gate-based approaches based on quantum phase estimation, and hybrid quantum–classical dynamic programming methods within a unified complexity and implementation framework. While theoretical results indicate reductions of the classical O ( 2 n ) scaling to approximately O ( 1.728 n ) for general instances and to O ( 1.110 n ) for structured cases, these improvements remain largely asymptotic. In practice, all current quantum approaches are strongly constrained by hardware limitations. Quantum annealing suffers from embedding overhead and noise, hybrid methods rely extensively on classical decomposition without guaranteed optimality, and gate-based implementations are limited by circuit depth and error accumulation. As a result, no clear quantum advantage over classical algorithms has been demonstrated at practically relevant problem scales. By systematically separating intrinsic algorithmic scaling from hardware-induced resource constraints, this work clarifies the origin of the gap between theoretical quantum speedups and experimental performance, providing a critical assessment of the current status and realistic prospects of quantum TSP methods.

Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications•May 12, 2026•1 citation

Two-Step Quantum Search Algorithm for Solving Traveling Salesman Problems

Rei Sato, Cui Gordon, Kazuhiro Saito +3 more

Quantum search algorithms, such as Grover's algorithm, are anticipated to efficiently solve constrained combinatorial optimization problems. However, applying these algorithms to the traveling salesman problem (TSP) on a quantum circuit presents a significant challenge. Existing quantum search algorithms for the TSP typically assume that an initial state—an equal superposition of all feasible solutions satisfying the problem's constraints—is pre-prepared. The query complexity of preparing this state using brute-force methods scales exponentially with the factorial growth of feasible solutions, creating a significant hurdle in designing quantum circuits for large-scale TSPs. To address this issue, we propose a two-step quantum search (TSQS) algorithm that employs two sets of operators. In the first step, all the feasible solutions are amplified into their equal superposition state. In the second step, the optimal solution state is amplified from this superposition state. The TSQS algorithm demonstrates greater efficiency compared to conventional search algorithms that employ a single oracle operator for finding a solution within the encoded space. Encoded in the higher order unconstrained binary optimization representation, our approach significantly reduces the qubit requirements. This enables efficient initial state preparation through a unified circuit design, offering a quadratic speedup in solving the TSP without prior knowledge of feasible solutions.

arXiv:2405.07129•IEEE Transactions on Quantum Engineering•Jan 1, 2025•6 citations
Quantum Computing is considered as the next frontier in computing, and it is attracting a lot of attention from the current scientific community. This kind of computation provides to researchers with a revolutionary paradigm for addressing complex optimization problems, offering a significant speed advantage and an efficient search ability. Anyway, Quantum Computing is still in an incipient stage of development. For this reason, present architectures show certain limitations, which have motivated the carrying out of this paper. In this paper, we introduce a novel solving scheme coined as hybrid Quantum Computing - Tabu Search Algorithm. Main pillars of operation of the proposed method are a greater control over the access to quantum resources, and a considerable reduction of non-profitable accesses. To assess the quality of our method, we have used 7 different Traveling Salesman Problem instances as benchmarking set. The obtained outcomes support the preliminary conclusion that our algorithm is an approach which offers promising results for solving partitioning problems while it drastically reduces the access to quantum computing resources. We also contribute to the field of Transfer Optimization by developing an evolutionary multiform multitasking algorithm as initialization method.
Quantum Computing is an emerging paradigm which is gathering a lot of popularity in the current scientific and technological community. Widely conceived as the next frontier of computation, Quantum Computing is still at the dawn of its development. Thus, current solving systems suffer from significant limitations in terms of performance and capabilities. Some interesting approaches have been devised by researchers and practitioners in order to overcome these barriers, being quantum-classical hybrid algorithms one of the most often used solving schemes. The main goal of this paper is to extend the results and findings of the recently proposed hybrid Quantum Computing - Tabu Search Algorithm for partitioning problems. To do that, we focus our research on the adaptation of this method to the Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Problem. In overall, we have employed six well-known instances belonging to TSPLIB to assess the performance of Quantum Computing - Tabu Search Algorithm in comparison to QBSolv. Furthermore, as an additional contribution, this work also supposes the first solving of the Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Problem using a Quantum Computing based method. Aiming to boost whole community's research in QC, we have released the project's repository as open source code for further application and improvements.
Quantum computing (QC) is expected to solve incredibly difficult problems, including finding optimal solutions to combinatorial optimization problems. However, to date, QC alone is still far to demonstrate this capability except on small-sized problems. Hybrid approaches where QC and classical computing work together have shown the most potential for solving real-world scale problems. This work aims to show that we can enhance a classical optimization algorithm with QC so that it can overcome this limitation. We present a new hybrid quantum-classical tabu search (HQTS) algorithm to solve the capacitated vehicle routing problem (CVRP). Based on our prior work, HQTS leverages QC for routing within a classical tabu search framework. The quantum component formulates the traveling salesman problem (TSP) for each route as a QUBO, solved using D-Wave's Advantage system. Experiments investigate the impact of quantum routing frequency and starting solution methods. While different starting solution methods, including quantum-based and classical heuristics methods, it shows minimal overall impact. HQTS achieved optimal or near-optimal solutions for several CVRP problems, outperforming other hybrid CVRP algorithms and significantly reducing the optimality gap compared to preliminary research. The experimental results demonstrate that more frequent quantum routing improves solution quality and runtime. The findings highlight the potential of integrating QC within meta-heuristic frameworks for complex optimization in vehicle routing problems.
The Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) is a widely studied NP-complete optimization challenge with significant theoretical and practical implications. This study proposes a hybrid quantum-classical framework using a Quantum-Inspired Evolutionary Algorithm (QEA) with Sort Gray Binary Encoding to solve the TSP. The proposed method guarantees the generation of valid TSP tours by eliminating invalid solutions. It employs quantum superposition with intrinsic randomness to enhance computational efficiency and scalability. The framework was implemented on cloud-based NISQ platforms, including IBM Quantum and AWS Braket, demonstrating its practicality and effectiveness. Experimental evaluations revealed that the proposed framework successfully solved TSP instances with up to 15 cities, achieving superior performance compared to classical methods and showcasing its ability to scale under NISQ constraints. The results also highlight the potential of hybrid quantum-classical approaches to overcome hardware limitations in current quantum systems. This study establishes a robust hybrid methodology for solving combinatorial optimization problems. It also sets a benchmark for leveraging the capabilities of NISQ-era quantum devices in real-world applications, thereby providing a foundation for future research in hybrid quantum-classical optimization techniques.
Quantum computing (QC) is expected to solve incredibly difficult problems, including finding optimal solutions to combinatorial optimization problems. However, to date, QC alone has still been unable to demonstrate this capability except for small-sized problems. Hybrid approaches, where QC and classical computing work together, have shown the most potential for solving real-world-scale problems. This work aims to show that we can enhance a classical optimization algorithm with QC so that it can overcome this limitation. We present a new Hybrid Quantum-classical Tabu Search (HQTS) algorithm to solve the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem (CVRP). Based on our prior work, HQTS leverages QC for routing within a classical tabu search framework. The quantum component formulates the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) for each route as a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) and solves it using D-Wave’s Advantage system. Experiments investigate the impact of quantum routing frequency and starting solution methods. Across different starting solution methods, including quantum-based and classical heuristics, it shows minimal overall impact. HQTS achieved optimal or near-optimal solutions for several CVRP problems, outperforming other hybrid CVRP algorithms and significantly reducing the optimality gap relative to preliminary research. The experimental results demonstrate that more frequent quantum routing improves solution quality and runtime. The findings highlight the potential of integrating QC within meta-heuristic frameworks for complex optimization in vehicle routing problems.
The Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) serves as a standard benchmark for assessing potential quantum advantage in combinatorial optimization. This paper provides a critical comparative analysis of quantum annealing, gate-based approaches based on quantum phase estimation, and hybrid quantum–classical dynamic programming methods within a unified complexity and implementation framework. While theoretical results indicate reductions of the classical O ( 2 n ) scaling to approximately O ( 1.728 n ) for general instances and to O ( 1.110 n ) for structured cases, these improvements remain largely asymptotic. In practice, all current quantum approaches are strongly constrained by hardware limitations. Quantum annealing suffers from embedding overhead and noise, hybrid methods rely extensively on classical decomposition without guaranteed optimality, and gate-based implementations are limited by circuit depth and error accumulation. As a result, no clear quantum advantage over classical algorithms has been demonstrated at practically relevant problem scales. By systematically separating intrinsic algorithmic scaling from hardware-induced resource constraints, this work clarifies the origin of the gap between theoretical quantum speedups and experimental performance, providing a critical assessment of the current status and realistic prospects of quantum TSP methods.
Quantum search algorithms, such as Grover's algorithm, are anticipated to efficiently solve constrained combinatorial optimization problems. However, applying these algorithms to the traveling salesman problem (TSP) on a quantum circuit presents a significant challenge. Existing quantum search algorithms for the TSP typically assume that an initial state—an equal superposition of all feasible solutions satisfying the problem's constraints—is pre-prepared. The query complexity of preparing this state using brute-force methods scales exponentially with the factorial growth of feasible solutions, creating a significant hurdle in designing quantum circuits for large-scale TSPs. To address this issue, we propose a two-step quantum search (TSQS) algorithm that employs two sets of operators. In the first step, all the feasible solutions are amplified into their equal superposition state. In the second step, the optimal solution state is amplified from this superposition state. The TSQS algorithm demonstrates greater efficiency compared to conventional search algorithms that employ a single oracle operator for finding a solution within the encoded space. Encoded in the higher order unconstrained binary optimization representation, our approach significantly reduces the qubit requirements. This enables efficient initial state preparation through a unified circuit design, offering a quadratic speedup in solving the TSP without prior knowledge of feasible solutions.