Unitary operator discrimination is a fundamental problem in quantum information theory. The basic version of this problem can be described as follows: Given a black box implementing a unitary operator U∈S:={U1, U2} under some probability distribution over S, the goal is to decide whether U=U1 or U=U2. In this paper, we consider the query complexity of this problem. We show that there exists a quantum algorithm that solves this problem with bounded error probability using ⌈6θcover−1⌉ queries to the black box in the worst case, i.e., under any probability distribution over S, where the parameter θcover, which is determined by the eigenvalues of U1†U2, represents the “closeness” between U1 and U2. We also show that this upper bound is essentially tight: we prove that for every θcover > 0 there exist operators U1 and U2 such that any quantum algorithm solving this problem with bounded error probability requires at least ⌈3θcover2⌉ queries under uniform distribution over S.
We investigate the problem of finding the minimum number of queries needed to perfectly identify an unknown quantum gate within a finite set of alternatives, considering both deterministic strategies. For unambiguous gate discrimination, where errors are not tolerated but inconclusive outcomes are allowed, we prove that parallel strategies are sufficient to identify the unknown gate with minimum number of queries and we use this fact to provide upper and lower bounds on the query complexity. In addition, we introduce the notion of generalized t-designs, which includes unitary t-designs and group representations as special cases. For gates forming a generalized t-design we prove that there is no difference between perfect probabilistic and perfect deterministic gate discrimination. Hence, evaluating of the query complexity of perfect discrimination is reduced to the easier problem of evaluating the query complexity of unambiguous discrimination.