Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2009.07853 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Experimental realization of classical Z2 spin liquids in a programmable quantum device

Shiyu Zhou, Dmitry Green, Edward D. Dahl, Claudio Chamon

Published Aug 13, 2021• 21 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We build and probe a ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ spin liquid in a programmable quantum device, the D-Wave DW-2000Q. Specifically, we observe the classical eight-vertex and six-vertex (spin ice) states and transitions between them. To realize this state of matter, we design a Hamiltonian with combinatorial gauge symmetry using only pairwise-qubit interactions and a transverse field, i.e., interactions which are accessible in this quantum device. The combinatorial gauge symmetry remains exact along the full quantum annealing path, landing the system onto the classical eight-vertex model at the endpoint of the path. The output configurations from the device allow us to directly observe the loop structure of the classical model. Moreover, we deform the Hamiltonian so as to vary the weights of the eight vertices and show that we can selectively attain the classical six-vertex (ice) model, or drive the system into a ferromagnetic state. We present studies of the classical phase diagram of the system as a function of the eight-vertex deformations and effective temperature, which we control by varying the relative strengths of the programmable couplings, and we show that the experimental results are consistent with theoretical analysis. Finally, we identify additional capabilities that, if added to these devices, would allow us to realize ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ quantum spin liquids on which to build topological qubits.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.104.l081107

Related papers

Experimental Realization of Spin Liquids in a Programmable Quantum Device

Shiyu Zhou, Dmitry Green, Edward D. Dahl +1 more

The advent of widely available computing power has spawned a whole research field that we now call computational physics. Today, we may be on the cusp of a similar paradigm shift as programmable qubit devices enable one to run experiments on a platform of actual physical quantum states. Here we use the commercially available D-Wave DW-2000Q device to build and probe a state of matter that has not been observed or fabricated before. The topological phase that we build has been widely sought for many years and is a candidate platform for quantum computation. While we cannot observe the full quantum regime due to the limitations of the current device, we do observe unmistakable signatures of the phase in its classical limit at the endpoint of the quantum annealing protocol. In the process of doing so, we identify additional features that a programmable device of this sort would need in order to implement fully functional topological qubits. It is a testament to technological progress that a handful of theorists can observe and experiment with new physics while being equipped only with remote access to a commercial device.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Sep 16, 2020•2 citations

Quantum-Coherent Regime of Programmable Dipolar Spin Ice

Krzysztof Giergiel, Piotr Surówka

Frustrated spin-ice systems support emergent gauge fields and fractionalized quasiparticles that act as magnetic monopoles. Although artificial platforms have enabled their direct visualization, access to their quantum-coherent dynamics has remained limited. Here we realize a programmable dipolar square spin-ice model using a superconducting-qubit quantum annealer, providing access to a previously unexplored quantum-coherent regime of artificial spin ice. By implementing a direct one-to-one mapping between lattice spins and physical qubits, together with engineered extended couplings, we realize effective dipolar interactions on frustrated lattices comprising more than 400 vertices. Tuning transverse-field fluctuations enables us to probe the real-time dynamics of Dirac-string defects and interacting monopole plasmas. We observe super-diffusive monopole transport, with scaling exponents intermediate between classical diffusion and ballistic motion, indicating dynamics beyond classical stochastic relaxation and consistent with coherent propagation within an emergent gauge manifold. These results establish programmable quantum spin ice as a scalable platform for investigating fractionalized excitations and emergent gauge dynamics in engineered quantum matter.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2603.28125•Mar 31, 2026•0 citations

Probing fractional statistics in quantum simulators of spin liquid Hamiltonians

Shiyu Zhou, Maria Zelenayova, Oliver Hart +2 more

Recent advances in programmable quantum devices brought to the fore the intriguing possibility of using them to realise and investigate topological quantum spin liquid phases. This new and exciting direction brings about important research questions on how to probe and determine the presence of such exotic, highly entangled phases in a noisy quantum environment. One of the most promising tools is investigating the behaviour of the topological excitations, and in particular their fractional statistics. In this work we put forward a generic route to achieve this, and we illustrate it in the specific case of \mathbb{Z}_2 ℤ 2 topological spin liquids implemented with the aid of combinatorial gauge symmetry. We design a convenient architecture to study signatures of fractional statistics via quasiparticle interferometry, and we assess its robustness to diagonal and off-diagonal disorder, as well as to dephasing - effects that are generally pervasive in current quantum programmable devices. Interestingly, when turned on its head, our scheme provides a remarkably clear test of the “quantumness” of these devices, with robust signatures that crucially hinge on quantum coherence and quantum interference effects, and cannot be mimicked by classical stochastic processes.

arXiv:2211.09784•SciPost Physics•Nov 14, 2023•5 citations

Constructing non-Abelian quantum spin liquids using combinatorial gauge symmetry

Dmitry Green, Claudio Chamon

We construct Hamiltonians with only 1- and 2-body interactions that exhibit an exact non-Abelian gauge symmetry (specifically, combinatiorial gauge symmetry). Our spin Hamiltonian realizes the quantum double associated to the group of quaternions. It contains only ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic ZZ Z Z interactions, plus longitudinal and transverse fields, and therefore is an explicit example of a spin Hamiltonian with no sign problem that realizes a non-Abelian topological phase. In addition to the spin model, we propose a superconducting quantum circuit version with the same symmetry.

arXiv:2209.14333•SciPost Physics•Aug 22, 2023•3 citations

How to emulate quantum spin liquids and build topological qubits with available quantum hardware

Claudio Chamon, Dmitry Green, Zhi-Cheng Yang

We introduce the notion of combinatorial gauge symmetry -- a local transformation that includes single spin rotations plus permutations of spins (or swaps of their quantum states) -- that preserve the commutation and anti-commutation relations among the spins. We show that Hamiltonians with simple two-body interactions contain this symmetry if the coupling matrix is a Hadamard matrix, with the combinatorial gauge symmetry being associated to the automorphism of these matrices with respect to monomial transformations. Armed with this symmetry, we address the physical problem of how to build quantum spin liquids with physically accessible interactions. In addition to its intrinsic physical significance, the problem is also tied to that of how to build topological qubits.

•Aug 13, 2019•0 citations

Superconducting Circuit Realization of Combinatorial Gauge Symmetry

Claudio Chamon, Dmitry Green, Andrew J. Kerman

We propose a superconducting quantum circuit based on a general symmetry principle-combinatorial gauge symmetry-designed to emulate topologically ordered quantum liquids and serve as a foundation for the construction of topological qubits.The proposed circuit exhibits rich features: in the classical limit of large capacitances its ground state consists of two superimposed loop structures; one is a crystal of small loops containing disordered U(1) degrees of freedom, and the other is a gas of loops of all sizes associated with Z 2 topological order.We show that these classical results carry over to the quantum case, where phase fluctuations arise from the presence of finite capacitances, yielding Z 2 quantum topological order.A key feature of the exact gauge symmetry is that amplitudes connecting different Z 2 loop states arise from paths having zero classical energy cost.As a result, these amplitudes are controlled by dimensional confinement rather than tunneling through energy barriers.We argue that this effect may lead to larger energy gaps than previous proposals that are limited by such barriers, potentially making it more likely for a topological phase to be experimentally observable.Finally, we discuss how our superconducting circuit realization of combinatorial gauge symmetry can be implemented in practice.

arXiv:2006.10060•PRX Quantum•Sep 8, 2021•13 citations
We build and probe a Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ spin liquid in a programmable quantum device, the D-Wave DW-2000Q. Specifically, we observe the classical eight-vertex and six-vertex (spin ice) states and transitions between them. To realize this state of matter, we design a Hamiltonian with combinatorial gauge symmetry using only pairwise-qubit interactions and a transverse field, i.e., interactions which are accessible in this quantum device. The combinatorial gauge symmetry remains exact along the full quantum annealing path, landing the system onto the classical eight-vertex model at the endpoint of the path. The output configurations from the device allow us to directly observe the loop structure of the classical model. Moreover, we deform the Hamiltonian so as to vary the weights of the eight vertices and show that we can selectively attain the classical six-vertex (ice) model, or drive the system into a ferromagnetic state. We present studies of the classical phase diagram of the system as a function of the eight-vertex deformations and effective temperature, which we control by varying the relative strengths of the programmable couplings, and we show that the experimental results are consistent with theoretical analysis. Finally, we identify additional capabilities that, if added to these devices, would allow us to realize Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ quantum spin liquids on which to build topological qubits.
The advent of widely available computing power has spawned a whole research field that we now call computational physics. Today, we may be on the cusp of a similar paradigm shift as programmable qubit devices enable one to run experiments on a platform of actual physical quantum states. Here we use the commercially available D-Wave DW-2000Q device to build and probe a state of matter that has not been observed or fabricated before. The topological phase that we build has been widely sought for many years and is a candidate platform for quantum computation. While we cannot observe the full quantum regime due to the limitations of the current device, we do observe unmistakable signatures of the phase in its classical limit at the endpoint of the quantum annealing protocol. In the process of doing so, we identify additional features that a programmable device of this sort would need in order to implement fully functional topological qubits. It is a testament to technological progress that a handful of theorists can observe and experiment with new physics while being equipped only with remote access to a commercial device.
Frustrated spin-ice systems support emergent gauge fields and fractionalized quasiparticles that act as magnetic monopoles. Although artificial platforms have enabled their direct visualization, access to their quantum-coherent dynamics has remained limited. Here we realize a programmable dipolar square spin-ice model using a superconducting-qubit quantum annealer, providing access to a previously unexplored quantum-coherent regime of artificial spin ice. By implementing a direct one-to-one mapping between lattice spins and physical qubits, together with engineered extended couplings, we realize effective dipolar interactions on frustrated lattices comprising more than 400 vertices. Tuning transverse-field fluctuations enables us to probe the real-time dynamics of Dirac-string defects and interacting monopole plasmas. We observe super-diffusive monopole transport, with scaling exponents intermediate between classical diffusion and ballistic motion, indicating dynamics beyond classical stochastic relaxation and consistent with coherent propagation within an emergent gauge manifold. These results establish programmable quantum spin ice as a scalable platform for investigating fractionalized excitations and emergent gauge dynamics in engineered quantum matter.
Recent advances in programmable quantum devices brought to the fore the intriguing possibility of using them to realise and investigate topological quantum spin liquid phases. This new and exciting direction brings about important research questions on how to probe and determine the presence of such exotic, highly entangled phases in a noisy quantum environment. One of the most promising tools is investigating the behaviour of the topological excitations, and in particular their fractional statistics. In this work we put forward a generic route to achieve this, and we illustrate it in the specific case of \mathbb{Z}_2 ℤ 2 topological spin liquids implemented with the aid of combinatorial gauge symmetry. We design a convenient architecture to study signatures of fractional statistics via quasiparticle interferometry, and we assess its robustness to diagonal and off-diagonal disorder, as well as to dephasing - effects that are generally pervasive in current quantum programmable devices. Interestingly, when turned on its head, our scheme provides a remarkably clear test of the “quantumness” of these devices, with robust signatures that crucially hinge on quantum coherence and quantum interference effects, and cannot be mimicked by classical stochastic processes.
We construct Hamiltonians with only 1- and 2-body interactions that exhibit an exact non-Abelian gauge symmetry (specifically, combinatiorial gauge symmetry). Our spin Hamiltonian realizes the quantum double associated to the group of quaternions. It contains only ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic ZZ Z Z interactions, plus longitudinal and transverse fields, and therefore is an explicit example of a spin Hamiltonian with no sign problem that realizes a non-Abelian topological phase. In addition to the spin model, we propose a superconducting quantum circuit version with the same symmetry.
We introduce the notion of combinatorial gauge symmetry -- a local transformation that includes single spin rotations plus permutations of spins (or swaps of their quantum states) -- that preserve the commutation and anti-commutation relations among the spins. We show that Hamiltonians with simple two-body interactions contain this symmetry if the coupling matrix is a Hadamard matrix, with the combinatorial gauge symmetry being associated to the automorphism of these matrices with respect to monomial transformations. Armed with this symmetry, we address the physical problem of how to build quantum spin liquids with physically accessible interactions. In addition to its intrinsic physical significance, the problem is also tied to that of how to build topological qubits.
We propose a superconducting quantum circuit based on a general symmetry principle-combinatorial gauge symmetry-designed to emulate topologically ordered quantum liquids and serve as a foundation for the construction of topological qubits.The proposed circuit exhibits rich features: in the classical limit of large capacitances its ground state consists of two superimposed loop structures; one is a crystal of small loops containing disordered U(1) degrees of freedom, and the other is a gas of loops of all sizes associated with Z 2 topological order.We show that these classical results carry over to the quantum case, where phase fluctuations arise from the presence of finite capacitances, yielding Z 2 quantum topological order.A key feature of the exact gauge symmetry is that amplitudes connecting different Z 2 loop states arise from paths having zero classical energy cost.As a result, these amplitudes are controlled by dimensional confinement rather than tunneling through energy barriers.We argue that this effect may lead to larger energy gaps than previous proposals that are limited by such barriers, potentially making it more likely for a topological phase to be experimentally observable.Finally, we discuss how our superconducting circuit realization of combinatorial gauge symmetry can be implemented in practice.