Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2009.03249 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Unconventional U(1) to Zq crossover in quantum and classical q -state clock models

Pranay Patil, Hui Shao, Anders W. Sandvik

Published Feb 10, 2021• 26 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider two-dimensional $q$-state quantum clock models with quantum fluctuations connecting states with all-to-all clock transitions with different choices for the matrix elements. We study the quantum phase transitions in these models using quantum Monte Carlo simulations and finite-size scaling, with the aim of characterizing the crossover from emergent U(1) symmetry at the transition (for $q\ensuremath{\ge}4$) to ${Z}_{q}$ symmetry of the ordered state. We also study classical three-dimensional clock models with spatial anisotropy corresponding to the space-time anisotropy of the quantum systems. The U(1) to ${Z}_{q}$ symmetry crossover in all these systems is governed by a so-called dangerously irrelevant operator. We specifically study $q=5$ and $q=6$ models with different forms of the quantum fluctuations and different anisotropies in the classical models. In all cases, we find the expected classical XY critical exponents and scaling dimensions ${y}_{q}$ of the clock fields. However, the initial weak violation of the U(1) symmetry in the ordered phase, characterized by a ${Z}_{q}$ symmetric order parameter ${\ensuremath{\phi}}_{q}$, scales in an unexpected way. As a function of the system size (length) $L$, close to the critical temperature ${\ensuremath{\phi}}_{q}\ensuremath{\propto}{L}^{p}$, where the known value of the exponent is $p=2$ in the classical isotropic clock model. In contrast, for strongly anisotropic classical models and the quantum models, we find $p=3$. For weakly anisotropic classical models, we observe a crossover from $p=2$ to $p=3$ scaling. The exponent $p$ directly impacts the exponent ${\ensuremath{\nu}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ governing the divergence of the U(1) to ${Z}_{q}$ crossover length scale ${\ensuremath{\xi}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ in the thermodynamic limit, according to the relationship ${\ensuremath{\nu}}^{\ensuremath{'}}=\ensuremath{\nu}(1+|{y}_{q}|/p)$, where $\ensuremath{\nu}$ is the conventional correlation length exponent. We present a phenomenological argument for $p=3$ based on an anomalous renormalization of the clock field in the presence of anisotropy, possibly as a consequence of topological (vortex) line defects. Thus, our study points to an intriguing interplay between conventional and dangerously irrelevant perturbations, which may also affect other quantum systems with emergent symmetries.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.103.054418

Related papers

Monte Carlo Renormalization Flows in the Space of Relevant and Irrelevant Operators: Application to Three-Dimensional Clock Models

Hui Shao, Wenan Guo, Anders W. Sandvik

We study renormalization group flows in a space of observables computed by Monte Carlo simulations. As an example, we consider three-dimensional clock models, i.e., the XY spin model perturbed by a Z_{q} symmetric anisotropy field. For q=4, 5, 6, a scaling function with two relevant arguments describes all stages of the complex renormalization flow at the critical point and in the ordered phase, including the crossover from the U(1) Nambu-Goldstone fixed point to the ultimate Z_{q} symmetry-breaking fixed point. We expect our method to be useful in the context of quantum-critical points with inherent dangerously irrelevant operators that cannot be tuned away microscopically but whose renormalization flows can be analyzed as we do here for the clock models.

arXiv:1905.13640•Physical Review Letters•Feb 27, 2020•44 citations

Emergence of U(1) Symmetry in the 3D X Y Model with Z q Anisotropy

Jie Lou, Anders W. Sandvik, Leon Balents

We study the three-dimensional XY model with a Zq anisotropic term. At temperatures T<Tc this dangerously irrelevant perturbation is relevant only above a length scale Lambda, which diverges as a power of the correlation length, Lambda approximately xi aq. Below Lambda the order parameter is U(1) symmetric. We derive the full scaling function controlling the emergence of U(1) symmetry and use Monte Carlo results to extract the exponent aq for q=4,...,8. We find that aq approximately a4(q/4)2, with a4 only marginally larger than 1. We discuss these results in the context of U(1) symmetry at deconfined quantum-critical points separating antiferromagnetic and valence-bond-solid states in quantum spin systems.

arXiv:0704.1472•Physical Review Letters•Nov 15, 2007•89 citations

Two-Dimensional J 1 − J 2 Clock Model: Enhanced Symmetries, Emergent Orders, and Landau-Incompatible Transitions

Pulloor Kuttanikkad Vishnu, Abhishodh Prakash, Rajesh Narayanan +1 more

We present a comprehensive study on the frustrated J_{1}-J_{2} classical q-state clock model with even q>4 on a two-dimensional square lattice, revealing a rich ensemble of phases driven by competing interactions. In the unfrustrated regime (J_{1}>2J_{2}), the model reproduces the standard clock model phenomenology: a low-temperature Z_{q}-broken ferromagnet, an intermediate XY-like critical quasi-long-range-ordered phase with emergent U(1) symmetry, and a high-temperature paramagnet. For J_{1}<2J_{2}, frustration stabilizes five distinct regimes: the disordered paramagnet, a stripe-ordered phase breaking Z_{q}×Z_{2} symmetry, two Z_{2}-broken nematic phases (one with and one without quasi-long-range order), and an exotic stripe phase with emergent discrete Z_{q} spin degrees of freedom prohibited in the microscopic Hamiltonian. Remarkably, this seemingly forbidden Z_{q} order emerges via a relevant operator in the infrared long-wavelength limit, rather than from an irrelevant perturbation, highlighting a nonstandard route to emergence. Using large-scale corner transfer matrix renormalization group calculations, complemented by classical Monte Carlo simulations, we map the complete phase diagram and identify Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless, Ising, first-order, and unconventional Landau-incompatible transitions between different phases. Finally, we propose an effective field-theoretic framework that encompasses these emergent orders and their interwoven transitions.

arXiv:2505.05194•Physical Review Letters•Nov 26, 2025•1 citation

Finite-time scaling with two characteristic time scales: Driven critical dynamics with emergent symmetry

Yu-Rong Shu, Liying Yang, Shuai Yin

Critical points with emergent symmetry exhibit intriguing scaling properties induced by two divergent length scales, attracting extensive investigations recently. We study the driven critical dynamics in a three-dimensional $q$-state clock model, in which the ordered phase breaks the $Z_q$ discrete symmetry, while an emergent $U(1)$ symmetry appears at the critical point. By increasing the temperature at a finite velocity $v$ to traverse the critical point from the ordered phase, we uncover rich dynamic scaling properties beyond the celebrated Kibble-Zurek mechanism. Our findings reveal the existence of two finite-time scaling (FTS) regions, characterized by two driving-induced time scales $ζ_d\propto v^{-z/r}$ and $ζ_d'\propto v^{-z/r'}$, respectively. Here $z$ is the dynamic exponent, $r$ is the usual critical exponent of $v$, and $r'$ represents an additional critical exponent of $v$ associated with the dangerously irrelevant scaling variable. While the square of the order parameter $M^2$ obeys the usual FTS form, the angular order parameter $ϕ_q$ shows remarkably distinct scaling behaviors controlled by both FTS regions. For small $v$, $ϕ_q$ is dominated by the time scale $ζ_d$, whereas for large $v$, $ϕ_q$ is governed by the second time scale $ζ_d'$. We verify the universality of these scaling properties in models with both isotropic and anisotropic couplings. Our theoretical insights provide a promising foundation for further experimental investigations in the hexagonal RMnO$_3$ (R=rare earth) materials.

arXiv:2503.16796•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 20, 2026•4 citations

Crossover and Critical Behavior in the Layered XY Model

Roman Kracht, Andrea Trombettoni, Ilaria Maccari +1 more

Motivated by the interplay between 2D and 3D scaling signatures observed in unconventional layered superconductors, we present a systematic Monte Carlo study of the three-dimensional classical XY model with anisotropic in-plane $J_\parallel$ and inter-plane $J_\perp$ couplings. Our study includes very small values of the system anisotropy $Δ=J_\perp /J_\parallel$ not studied before, and focuses on characterizing the crossover from quasi-2D topological scaling to genuine 3D critical behavior. The numerical results for the critical temperature unambiguously reveal a logarithmic scaling with $Δ$, directly related to the topological scaling in the 2D limit. Despite the 3D nature of the layered XY criticality, topological scaling signatures survive up to system sizes comparable to the crossover length $\ell_J$, which diverges at small $Δ$ with a scaling behavior reminiscent of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transition. This shows that genuine 3D symmetry-breaking behavior emerges only at exceedingly large system sizes when the anisotropy is very strong. Our results indicate that new experimental evidence is required to clarify the extent to which the critical signatures observed in layered strongly correlated materials are shaped by their pronounced anisotropy.

arXiv:2603.19351•Mar 19, 2026•0 citations

Phases and phase transitions of the disordered quantum clock model

Pulloor Kuttanikkad Vishnu, Gaurav Khairnar, Rajesh Narayanan +1 more

We study the phases and phase transitions of a disordered one-dimensional quantum $q$-state clock Hamiltonian using large-scale Monte Carlo simulations. Making contact with earlier results, we confirm that the clean, translational invariant version of the model, for $q=6$, hosts an intermediate emergent quasi-long-range ordered (QLRO) phase between the symmetry-broken true long-range ordered (TLRO) phase and the disordered (paramagnetic) phase. With increasing disorder strength, the quasi-long-range ordered phase shrinks and finally vanishes at a multicritical point, beyond which there is a direct transition from the TLRO phase to the paramagnetic phase. After establishing the phase diagram, we characterize the critical behaviors of the various quantum phase transitions in the model. We find that weak disorder is an irrelevant perturbation of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions that separate the QLRO phase from the TLRO and paramagnetic phases. For stronger disorder, some of the critical exponents become disorder-dependent already before the system reaches the multicritical point. We also show that beyond the multicritical point, the direct transition from the TLRO phase to the paramagnetic phase is governed by an infinite-randomness critical point in line with strong-disorder renormalization group predictions. While our numerical results are for $q=6$, we expect the qualitative features of the behavior to hold for all $q>4$.

arXiv:2410.07640•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 28, 2025•5 citations
We consider two-dimensional qqq-state quantum clock models with quantum fluctuations connecting states with all-to-all clock transitions with different choices for the matrix elements. We study the quantum phase transitions in these models using quantum Monte Carlo simulations and finite-size scaling, with the aim of characterizing the crossover from emergent U(1) symmetry at the transition (for q\ensuremath≥4q\ensuremath{\ge}4q\ensuremath≥4) to Zq{Z}_{q}Zq​ symmetry of the ordered state. We also study classical three-dimensional clock models with spatial anisotropy corresponding to the space-time anisotropy of the quantum systems. The U(1) to Zq{Z}_{q}Zq​ symmetry crossover in all these systems is governed by a so-called dangerously irrelevant operator. We specifically study q=5q=5q=5 and q=6q=6q=6 models with different forms of the quantum fluctuations and different anisotropies in the classical models. In all cases, we find the expected classical XY critical exponents and scaling dimensions yq{y}_{q}yq​ of the clock fields. However, the initial weak violation of the U(1) symmetry in the ordered phase, characterized by a Zq{Z}_{q}Zq​ symmetric order parameter \ensuremathϕq{\ensuremath{\phi}}_{q}\ensuremathϕq​, scales in an unexpected way. As a function of the system size (length) LLL, close to the critical temperature \ensuremathϕq\ensuremath∝Lp{\ensuremath{\phi}}_{q}\ensuremath{\propto}{L}^{p}\ensuremathϕq​\ensuremath∝Lp, where the known value of the exponent is p=2p=2p=2 in the classical isotropic clock model. In contrast, for strongly anisotropic classical models and the quantum models, we find p=3p=3p=3. For weakly anisotropic classical models, we observe a crossover from p=2p=2p=2 to p=3p=3p=3 scaling. The exponent ppp directly impacts the exponent \ensuremathν\ensuremath′{\ensuremath{\nu}}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremathν\ensuremath′ governing the divergence of the U(1) to Zq{Z}_{q}Zq​ crossover length scale \ensuremathξ\ensuremath′{\ensuremath{\xi}}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremathξ\ensuremath′ in the thermodynamic limit, according to the relationship \ensuremathν\ensuremath′=\ensuremathν(1+∣yq∣/p){\ensuremath{\nu}}^{\ensuremath{'}}=\ensuremath{\nu}(1+|{y}_{q}|/p)\ensuremathν\ensuremath′=\ensuremathν(1+∣yq​∣/p), where \ensuremathν\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremathν is the conventional correlation length exponent. We present a phenomenological argument for p=3p=3p=3 based on an anomalous renormalization of the clock field in the presence of anisotropy, possibly as a consequence of topological (vortex) line defects. Thus, our study points to an intriguing interplay between conventional and dangerously irrelevant perturbations, which may also affect other quantum systems with emergent symmetries.
We study renormalization group flows in a space of observables computed by Monte Carlo simulations. As an example, we consider three-dimensional clock models, i.e., the XY spin model perturbed by a Z_{q} symmetric anisotropy field. For q=4, 5, 6, a scaling function with two relevant arguments describes all stages of the complex renormalization flow at the critical point and in the ordered phase, including the crossover from the U(1) Nambu-Goldstone fixed point to the ultimate Z_{q} symmetry-breaking fixed point. We expect our method to be useful in the context of quantum-critical points with inherent dangerously irrelevant operators that cannot be tuned away microscopically but whose renormalization flows can be analyzed as we do here for the clock models.
We study the three-dimensional XY model with a Zq anisotropic term. At temperatures T<Tc this dangerously irrelevant perturbation is relevant only above a length scale Lambda, which diverges as a power of the correlation length, Lambda approximately xi aq. Below Lambda the order parameter is U(1) symmetric. We derive the full scaling function controlling the emergence of U(1) symmetry and use Monte Carlo results to extract the exponent aq for q=4,...,8. We find that aq approximately a4(q/4)2, with a4 only marginally larger than 1. We discuss these results in the context of U(1) symmetry at deconfined quantum-critical points separating antiferromagnetic and valence-bond-solid states in quantum spin systems.
We present a comprehensive study on the frustrated J_{1}-J_{2} classical q-state clock model with even q>4 on a two-dimensional square lattice, revealing a rich ensemble of phases driven by competing interactions. In the unfrustrated regime (J_{1}>2J_{2}), the model reproduces the standard clock model phenomenology: a low-temperature Z_{q}-broken ferromagnet, an intermediate XY-like critical quasi-long-range-ordered phase with emergent U(1) symmetry, and a high-temperature paramagnet. For J_{1}<2J_{2}, frustration stabilizes five distinct regimes: the disordered paramagnet, a stripe-ordered phase breaking Z_{q}×Z_{2} symmetry, two Z_{2}-broken nematic phases (one with and one without quasi-long-range order), and an exotic stripe phase with emergent discrete Z_{q} spin degrees of freedom prohibited in the microscopic Hamiltonian. Remarkably, this seemingly forbidden Z_{q} order emerges via a relevant operator in the infrared long-wavelength limit, rather than from an irrelevant perturbation, highlighting a nonstandard route to emergence. Using large-scale corner transfer matrix renormalization group calculations, complemented by classical Monte Carlo simulations, we map the complete phase diagram and identify Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless, Ising, first-order, and unconventional Landau-incompatible transitions between different phases. Finally, we propose an effective field-theoretic framework that encompasses these emergent orders and their interwoven transitions.
Critical points with emergent symmetry exhibit intriguing scaling properties induced by two divergent length scales, attracting extensive investigations recently. We study the driven critical dynamics in a three-dimensional qqq-state clock model, in which the ordered phase breaks the ZqZ_qZq​ discrete symmetry, while an emergent U(1)U(1)U(1) symmetry appears at the critical point. By increasing the temperature at a finite velocity vvv to traverse the critical point from the ordered phase, we uncover rich dynamic scaling properties beyond the celebrated Kibble-Zurek mechanism. Our findings reveal the existence of two finite-time scaling (FTS) regions, characterized by two driving-induced time scales ζd∝v−z/rζ_d\propto v^{-z/r}ζd​∝v−z/r and ζd′∝v−z/r′ζ_d'\propto v^{-z/r'}ζd′​∝v−z/r′, respectively. Here zzz is the dynamic exponent, rrr is the usual critical exponent of vvv, and r′r'r′ represents an additional critical exponent of vvv associated with the dangerously irrelevant scaling variable. While the square of the order parameter M2M^2M2 obeys the usual FTS form, the angular order parameter ϕqϕ_qϕq​ shows remarkably distinct scaling behaviors controlled by both FTS regions. For small vvv, ϕqϕ_qϕq​ is dominated by the time scale ζdζ_dζd​, whereas for large vvv, ϕqϕ_qϕq​ is governed by the second time scale ζd′ζ_d'ζd′​. We verify the universality of these scaling properties in models with both isotropic and anisotropic couplings. Our theoretical insights provide a promising foundation for further experimental investigations in the hexagonal RMnO3_33​ (R=rare earth) materials.
Motivated by the interplay between 2D and 3D scaling signatures observed in unconventional layered superconductors, we present a systematic Monte Carlo study of the three-dimensional classical XY model with anisotropic in-plane J∥J_\parallelJ∥​ and inter-plane J⊥J_\perpJ⊥​ couplings. Our study includes very small values of the system anisotropy Δ=J⊥/J∥Δ=J_\perp /J_\parallelΔ=J⊥​/J∥​ not studied before, and focuses on characterizing the crossover from quasi-2D topological scaling to genuine 3D critical behavior. The numerical results for the critical temperature unambiguously reveal a logarithmic scaling with ΔΔΔ, directly related to the topological scaling in the 2D limit. Despite the 3D nature of the layered XY criticality, topological scaling signatures survive up to system sizes comparable to the crossover length ℓJ\ell_JℓJ​, which diverges at small ΔΔΔ with a scaling behavior reminiscent of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transition. This shows that genuine 3D symmetry-breaking behavior emerges only at exceedingly large system sizes when the anisotropy is very strong. Our results indicate that new experimental evidence is required to clarify the extent to which the critical signatures observed in layered strongly correlated materials are shaped by their pronounced anisotropy.
We study the phases and phase transitions of a disordered one-dimensional quantum qqq-state clock Hamiltonian using large-scale Monte Carlo simulations. Making contact with earlier results, we confirm that the clean, translational invariant version of the model, for q=6q=6q=6, hosts an intermediate emergent quasi-long-range ordered (QLRO) phase between the symmetry-broken true long-range ordered (TLRO) phase and the disordered (paramagnetic) phase. With increasing disorder strength, the quasi-long-range ordered phase shrinks and finally vanishes at a multicritical point, beyond which there is a direct transition from the TLRO phase to the paramagnetic phase. After establishing the phase diagram, we characterize the critical behaviors of the various quantum phase transitions in the model. We find that weak disorder is an irrelevant perturbation of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions that separate the QLRO phase from the TLRO and paramagnetic phases. For stronger disorder, some of the critical exponents become disorder-dependent already before the system reaches the multicritical point. We also show that beyond the multicritical point, the direct transition from the TLRO phase to the paramagnetic phase is governed by an infinite-randomness critical point in line with strong-disorder renormalization group predictions. While our numerical results are for q=6q=6q=6, we expect the qualitative features of the behavior to hold for all q>4q>4q>4.