Simulating 2D Effects in Lattice Gauge Theories on a Quantum Computer
Danny Paulson, Luca Dellantonio, Jan F. Haase, Alessio Celi, Angus Kan, Andrew Jena, Christian Kokail, Rick van Bijnen, Karl Jansen, Peter Zoller, Christine A. Muschik
Quantum computing is in its greatest upswing, with so-called noisy-intermediate-scale-quantum devices heralding the computational power to be expected in the near future.While the field is progressing toward quantum advantage, quantum computers already have the potential to tackle classically intractable problems.Here, we consider gauge theories describing fundamental-particle interactions.On the way to their full-fledged quantum simulations, the challenge of limited resources on near-term quantum devices has to be overcome.We propose an experimental quantum simulation scheme to study ground-state properties in two-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (2D QED) using existing quantum technology.Our protocols can be adapted to larger lattices and offer the perspective to connect the lattice simulation to low-energy observable quantities, e.g., the hadron spectrum, in the continuum theory.By including both dynamical matter and a nonminimal gauge-field truncation, we provide the novel opportunity to observe 2D effects on present-day quantum hardware.More specifically, we present two variational-quantumeigensolver-(VQE) based protocols for the study of magnetic field effects and for taking an important first step toward computing the running coupling of QED.For both instances, we include variational quantum circuits for qubit-based hardware.We simulate the proposed VQE experiments classically to calculate the required measurement budget under realistic conditions.While this feasibility analysis is done for trapped ions, our approach can be directly adapted to other platforms.The techniques presented here, combined with advancements in quantum hardware, pave the way for reaching beyond the capabilities of classical simulations.
Quantum computing is in its greatest upswing, with so-called noisy-intermediate-scale-quantum devices heralding the computational power to be expected in the near future.While the field is progressing toward quantum advantage, quantum computers already have the potential to tackle classically intractable problems.Here, we consider gauge theories describing fundamental-particle interactions.On the way to their full-fledged quantum simulations, the challenge of limited resources on near-term quantum devices has to be overcome.We propose an experimental quantum simulation scheme to study ground-state properties in two-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (2D QED) using existing quantum technology.Our protocols can be adapted to larger lattices and offer the perspective to connect the lattice simulation to low-energy observable quantities, e.g., the hadron spectrum, in the continuum theory.By including both dynamical matter and a nonminimal gauge-field truncation, we provide the novel opportunity to observe 2D effects on present-day quantum hardware.More specifically, we present two variational-quantumeigensolver-(VQE) based protocols for the study of magnetic field effects and for taking an important first step toward computing the running coupling of QED.For both instances, we include variational quantum circuits for qubit-based hardware.We simulate the proposed VQE experiments classically to calculate the required measurement budget under realistic conditions.While this feasibility analysis is done for trapped ions, our approach can be directly adapted to other platforms.The techniques presented here, combined with advancements in quantum hardware, pave the way for reaching beyond the capabilities of classical simulations.
Particle physics describes the interplay of matter and forces through gauge theories. Yet, the intrinsic quantum nature of gauge theories makes important problems notoriously difficult for classical computational techniques. Quantum computers offer a promising way to overcome these roadblocks. We demonstrate two essential requirements on this path: first, we perform a quantum computation of the properties of the basic building block of two-dimensional lattice quantum electrodynamics, involving both gauge fields and matter. Second, we show how to refine the gauge-field discretization beyond its minimal representation, using a trapped-ion qudit quantum processor, where quantum information is encoded in several states per ion. Such qudits are ideally suited for describing gauge fields, which are naturally high dimensional, leading to reduced register size and circuit complexity. We prepare the ground state of the model using a variational quantum eigensolver and observe the effect of dynamical matter on quantized magnetic fields. By controlling the qudit dimension, we also show how to seamlessly observe the effect of different gauge-field truncations. Finally, we experimentally study the dynamics of pair creation and magnetic energy. Our results open the door for hardware-efficient quantum simulations of gauge theories with qudits in near-term quantum devices.
This thesis investigates advances in quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories, with a focus on (2+1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (QED), which shares important features with (3+1)-dimensional quantum chromodynamics (QCD), such as confinement and asymptotic freedom. Two main projects are developed. The first project investigates the ongoing coupling in a compact pure U(1) gauge theory using a step-scaling function approach. A quantum variational method allows calculations over a wide range of couplings. Plaquette expectation value results are compared with classical Monte Carlo simulations to obtain, in principle, the physical value of the lattice spacing. This method can potentially be extended to the study of QED, which also includes fermionic matter. The second project investigates the static potential between two charges, analyzing the Coulomb, confining, and string-breaking regimes. It involves the development of a tailored variational approach that incorporates system symmetries and mutual information to represent fermionic degrees of freedom. Results from a trapped-ion quantum device agree well with classical simulations, validating the method. Furthermore, this work evaluates superconducting quantum devices, noting issues with noise but also demonstrating improvements in hardware and potential through error limitation. Overall, this work underscores the feasibility of variational quantum algorithms for lattice gauge theory simulations and demonstrates their promise for advancing theoretical physics with quantum computers. This thesis explores advancements in quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories, focusing on (2+1)-dimensional Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), which shares key features with (3+1)-dimensional Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), such as confinement and asymptotic freedom. Two main projects are developed. The first investigates the running coupling in a compact U(1) pure gauge theory using a step scaling function approach. A quantum variational method enables computation across a wide range of couplings. The plaquette expectation value is matched with classical Monte Carlo simulations to obtain, in principle, the physical value of the lattice spacing. This method can be eventually extended to study QED, where fermionic matter is included. The second project examines the static potential between two charges, analyzing Coulomb, confining, and string-breaking regimes. It involves developing a custom variational Ansatz that incorporates system symmetries and mutual information to represent fermionic degrees of freedom. Results from a trapped-ion quantum device align well with exact classical simulations, validating the method. Additionally, the thesis evaluates superconducting devices, identifying noise challenges but noting improvements in hardware and the potential of error mitigation. Overall, this work highlights the viability of variational quantum algorithms for lattice gauge theory simulations and demonstrates their promise for advancing theoretical physics with quantum computing.
Gauge theories establish the standard model of particle physics, and lattice gauge theory (LGT) calculations employing Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods have been pivotal in our understanding of fundamental interactions. The present limitations of MCMC techniques may be overcome by Hamiltonian-based simulations on classical or quantum devices, which further provide the potential to address questions that lay beyond the capabilities of the current approaches. However, for continuous gauge groups, Hamiltonian-based formulations involve infinite-dimensional gauge degrees of freedom that can solely be handled by truncation. Current truncation schemes require dramatically increasing computational resources at small values of the bare couplings, where magnetic field effects become important. Such limitation precludes one from `taking the continuous limit' while working with finite resources. To overcome this limitation, we provide a resource-efficient protocol to simulate LGTs with continuous gauge groups in the Hamiltonian formulation. Our new method allows for calculations at arbitrary values of the bare coupling and lattice spacing. The approach consists of the combination of a Hilbert space truncation with a regularization of the gauge group, which permits an efficient description of the magnetically-dominated regime. We focus here on Abelian gauge theories and use 2 + 1 dimensional quantum electrodynamics as a benchmark example to demonstrate this efficient framework to achieve the continuum limit in LGTs. This possibility is a key requirement to make quantitative predictions at the field theory level and offers the long-term perspective to utilise quantum simulations to compute physically meaningful quantities in regimes that are precluded to quantum Monte Carlo.
This research paper provides a comprehensive review of quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories during the current era of noisy intermediate-scale quantum computing. It focuses on the fundamental framework used to understand strong interactions in high-energy physics and explores how quantum devices can overcome the limitations of traditional computational methods, such as the sign problem found in classical simulations. The manuscript is built around three primary pillars that are critical for near-term progress. The first pillar involves encoding strategies, describing the movement away from simple mapping techniques toward more advanced, compact methods that significantly decrease the number of required quantum bits by focusing only on physically relevant states and exploiting local gauge constraints. The second pillar analyzes specific variational quantum algorithms that use flexible circuit structures to find low-energy states, comparing different approaches based on their circuit depth and suitability for current hardware. The third pillar evaluates various error mitigation techniques used to extract accurate information from imperfect quantum hardware, such as methods that amplify and then remove noise or those that use physical symmetries to detect and discard errors. Additionally, the paper compares different hardware technologies—including those based on superconducting circuits, trapped atoms, and ions—to weigh their respective benefits, such as gate speed and connectivity, against their drawbacks. It also introduces emerging hybrid approaches that combine quantum circuits with artificial neural networks to improve simulation power and state representation. Ultimately, the review identifies pathways toward achieving practical advantages in the field and discusses the challenges that remain for scaling these systems to larger sizes.
Matter under extreme conditions behaves as a non-equilibrium, strongly-interacting quantum system. Such systems are in the non-perturbative regime of quantum chromodynamics (QCD), where their time evolution is classically intractable. Quantum computing offers a promising alternative, but present-day devices are limited in qubit count and circuit depth, so efficient formulations and algorithms are key to scaling toward experimentally relevant QCD simulations. A scalable framework is established for simulating energy loss and hadronization in 1+1-dimensional SU(2) lattice gauge theory, in which a heavy quark traverses a lattice of light quarks. Classical lattice QCD methods are translated into physics-informed circuits to prepare the interacting ground state. The evolution is run on IBM's quantum processor ibm_pittsburgh, where the charge distribution and energy loss are measured. A further study develops the quantum simulation of the fully gauge-fixed SU(2) Hamiltonian in a mixed basis, a formulation that is expected to remain efficient at all gauge couplings. Digitizing the continuous gauge fields with as few as three qubits per plaquette reproduces low-energy observables with 10−3 precision. Scaling to larger systems is limited by resource overhead, which motivates truncations that preserve the relevant observables. Sequency Hierarchy Truncation (SeqHT) exploits the hierarchy in basis-operator contributions. Demonstrated on the adiabatic preparation of the λφ4 ground state on ibm_sherbrooke, SeqHT reduces circuit depth by ~30%, suppressing hardware noise in the extracted observables. All simulations in this dissertation are validated on quantum hardware against classical benchmarks. These studies advance quantum simulations of real-time QCD dynamics.
Compact lattice Quantum Electrodynamics is a complex quantum field theory with dynamical gauge and matter fields and it has similarities with Quantum Chromodynamics, in particular asymptotic freedom and confinement. We consider a (2+1)-dimensional lattice discretization of Quantum Electrodynamics with the inclusion of dynamical fermionic matter. We define a suitable quantum algorithm to measure the static potential as a function of the distance between two charges on the lattice and we use a variational quantum calculation to explore the Coulomb, confinement and string breaking regimes. A symmetry-preserving and resource-efficient variational quantum circuit is employed to prepare the ground state of the theory at various values of the coupling constant, corresponding to different physical distances, allowing the accurate extraction of the static potential from a quantum computer. We demonstrate that results from quantum experiments on the Quantinuum H1-1 trapped-ion device and emulator, with full connectivity between qubits, agree with classical noiseless simulations using circuits with 10 and 24 qubits. Moreover, we visualize the electric field flux configurations that mostly contribute in the wave-function of the quantum ground state in the different regimes of the potential, thus giving insights into the mechanisms of confinement and string breaking. These results are a promising step forward in the grand challenge of solving higher dimensional lattice gauge theory problems with quantum computing algorithms.