© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:2008.08408 · Nuclear Physics B

Identifying the Huse-Fisher universality class of the three-state chiral Potts model

Samuel Nyckees, Jeanne Colbois, Frédéric Mila

Published Mar 5, 2021• 9 citations

Abstract

Using the corner-transfer matrix renormalization group approach, we revisit the three-state chiral Potts model on the square lattice, a model proposed in the eighties to describe commensurate-incommensurate transitions at surfaces, and with direct relevance to recent experiments on chains of Rydberg atoms. This model was suggested by Huse and Fisher to have a chiral transition in the vicinity of the Potts point, a possibility that turned out to be very difficult to definitely establish or refute numerically. Our results confirm that the transition changes character at a Lifshitz point that separates a line of Pokrosky-Talapov transitions far enough from the Potts point from a line of direct continuous order-disorder transition close to it. Thanks to the accuracy of the numerical results, we have been able to base the analysis entirely on effective exponents to deal with the crossovers that have hampered previous numerical investigations. The emerging picture is that of a new universality class with exponents that do not change between the Potts point and the Lifshitz point, and that appear to be consistent with those of a self-dual version of the model, namely correlation lengths exponents νx=2/3 in the direction of the asymmetry and νy=1 perpendicular to it, an incommensurability exponent β¯=2/3, a specific heat exponent that keeps the value α=1/3 of the three-state Potts model, and a dynamical exponent z=3/2. These results are in excellent agreement with experimental results obtained on reconstructed surfaces in the nineties, and shed light on recent Kibble-Zurek experiments on the period-3 phase of chains of Rydberg atoms.

DOI: 10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2021.115365

Related papers

Commensurate-incommensurate transition in the chiral Ashkin-Teller model

Samuel Nyckees, Frédéric Mila

We investigate the classical chiral Ashkin-Teller model on a square lattice with the corner transfer matrix renormalization group algorithm. We show that the melting of the period-4 phase in the presence of a chiral perturbation takes different forms depending on the coefficient of the four-spin term in the Ashkin-Teller model. Close to the clock limit of two decoupled Ising models, the system undergoes a two-step commensurate-incommensurate transition as soon as the chirality is introduced, with an intermediate critical floating phase bounded by a Kosterlitz-Thouless transition at high temperature and a Pokrovsky-Talapov transition at low temperature. By contrast, close to the four-states Potts model, we argue for the existence of a unique commensurate-incommensurate transition that belongs to the chiral universality class, and for the presence of a Lifshitz point where the ordered, disordered, and floating phases meet. Finally, we map the whole phase diagram, which turns out to be in qualitative agreement with the 40-year-old prediction by Huse and Fisher.

arXiv:2109.01415•Physical Review Research•Feb 4, 2022•13 citations

Conformal and chiral phase transitions in Rydberg chains

Ivo A. Maceira, Natalia Chepiga, Frédéric Mila

Using density matrix renormalization group simulations on open chains, we map out the wave vector in the incommensurate disordered phase of a realistic model of Rydberg chains with $1/{r}^{6}$ interactions, and we locate and characterize the points along the commensurate lines where the transition out of the period 3 and 4 phases is conformal. We confirm that it is three-state Potts for the period-3 phase, and we show that it is Ashkin-Teller with $\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremath{\simeq}0.80$ for the period-4 phase. We further show that close to these points, the transition is still continuous, but with a completely different scaling of the wave vector, in agreement with a chiral transition. Finally, we propose to use the conformal points as benchmarks for Kibble-Zurek experiments, defining a roadmap towards a conclusive identification of the chiral universality class.

arXiv:2203.01163•Physical Review Research•Nov 14, 2022•29 citations

Tensor network investigation of the hard-square model

Samuel Nyckees, Frédéric Mila

Using the corner-transfer matrix renormalization group to contract the tensor network that describes its partition function, we investigate the nature of the phase transitions of the hard-square model, one of the exactly solved models of statistical physics for which Baxter has found an integrable manifold. The motivation is twofold: assess the power of tensor networks for such models, and probe the 2D classical analog of a 1D quantum model of hard-core bosons that has recently attracted significant attention in the context of experiments on chains of Rydberg atoms. Accordingly, we concentrate on two planes in the 3D parameter space spanned by the activity and the coupling constants in the two diagonal directions. We first investigate the only case studied so far with Monte Carlo simulations, the case of opposite coupling constants. We confirm that, away and not too far from the integrable 3-state Potts point, the transition out of the period-3 phase appears to be unique in the Huse-Fisher chiral universality class, albeit with significantly different exponents as compared to Monte Carlo. We also identify two additional phase transitions not reported so far for that model, a Lifshitz disorder line, and an Ising transition for large enough activity. To make contact with 1D quantum models of Rydberg atoms, we then turn to a plane where the ferromagnetic coupling is kept fixed, and we show that the resulting phase diagram is very similar, the only difference being that the Ising transition becomes first-order through a tricritical Ising point, in agreement with Baxter's prediction that this plane should contain a tricritical Ising point, and in remarkable, almost quantitative agreement with the phase diagram of the 1D quantum version of the model.

arXiv:2205.02508•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 28, 2022•2 citations

Kibble-Zurek exponent and chiral transition of the period-4 phase of Rydberg chains

Natalia Chepiga, Frédéric Mila

Chains of Rydberg atoms have emerged as an amazing playground to study quantum physics in 1D. Playing with inter-atomic distances and laser detuning, one can in particular explore the commensurate-incommensurate transition out of density waves through the Kibble-Zurek mechanism, and the possible presence of a chiral transition with dynamical exponent z > 1. Here, we address this problem theoretically with effective blockade models where the short-distance repulsions are replaced by a constraint of no double occupancy. For the period-4 phase, we show that there is an Ashkin-Teller transition point with exponent ν = 0.78 surrounded by a direct chiral transition with a dynamical exponent z = 1.11 and a Kibble-Zurek exponent μ = 0.41. For Rydberg atoms with a van der Waals potential, we suggest that the experimental value μ = 0.25 is due to a chiral transition with z ≃ 1.9 and ν ≃ 0.47 surrounding an Ashkin-Teller transition close to the 4-state Potts universality.

arXiv:2001.06698•Nature Communications•Jan 18, 2021•49 citations

Nearest-neighbor Ising model with a uniaxial incommensurate phase and a Lifshitz point

Eytan Domany, Bernd Schaub

The anisotropic triangular nearest-neighbor Ising model, with antiferromagnetic interactions, is studied. The phase diagram, as a function of temperature and field, has a complex structure. Two commensurate ordered phases are found. The transition to one is Ising-type. The second is reached from the disordered phase in one of two ways: either via an intermediate uniaxial incommensurate phase---which is reached at high temperatures by a Kosterlitz-Thouless transition and at low temperatures undergoes an incommensurate-commensurate transition---or by a single continuous transition. The latter transition is in the same universality class as the chiral three-state Potts model, with thermal exponent within 4% of that of the three-state Potts model. These two transition regimes are found to be separated by a Lifshitz point. The phase diagram and critical behavior were determined by analytical (symmetry analysis and free-fermion approximation) as well as numerical (phenomenological renormalization-group and Monte Carlo) methods.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 1, 1984•18 citations

Fidelity susceptibility as a diagnostic of the commensurate-incommensurate transition: A revisit of the programmable Rydberg chain

Xue-Jia Yu, Sheng Yang, Jing‐Bo Xu +1 more

In recent years, programmable Rydberg-atom arrays have been widely used to simulate new quantum phases and phase transitions, generating great interest among theorists and experimentalists. Based on the large-scale density matrix renormalization group method, the ground-state phase diagram of one-dimensional Rydberg chains is investigated with fidelity susceptibility as an efficient diagnostic method. We find that the competition between Rydberg blockade and external detuning produces unconventional phases and phase transitions. As the Rydberg blockade radius increases, the phase transition between disordered and density-wave ordered phases changes from the standard Potts universality class to an unconventional chiral one. As the radius increases further (above Potts point but still close to the tip of the lobe), a very narrow intermediate floating-phase region begins to appear. A concise physical picture is also provided to illustrate the numerical results. Compared with previous studies, this work brings more evidence for commensurate-incommensurate quantum phase transitions in programmable quantum simulators from the perspective of quantum information, showing that fidelity susceptibility can be used to study such phase transitions.

arXiv:2207.08337•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 24, 2022•26 citations

Using the corner-transfer matrix renormalization group approach, we revisit the three-state chiral Potts model on the square lattice, a model proposed in the eighties to describe commensurate-incommensurate transitions at surfaces, and with direct relevance to recent experiments on chains of Rydberg atoms. This model was suggested by Huse and Fisher to have a chiral transition in the vicinity of the Potts point, a possibility that turned out to be very difficult to definitely establish or refute numerically. Our results confirm that the transition changes character at a Lifshitz point that separates a line of Pokrosky-Talapov transitions far enough from the Potts point from a line of direct continuous order-disorder transition close to it. Thanks to the accuracy of the numerical results, we have been able to base the analysis entirely on effective exponents to deal with the crossovers that have hampered previous numerical investigations. The emerging picture is that of a new universality class with exponents that do not change between the Potts point and the Lifshitz point, and that appear to be consistent with those of a self-dual version of the model, namely correlation lengths exponents νx=2/3 in the direction of the asymmetry and νy=1 perpendicular to it, an incommensurability exponent β¯=2/3, a specific heat exponent that keeps the value α=1/3 of the three-state Potts model, and a dynamical exponent z=3/2. These results are in excellent agreement with experimental results obtained on reconstructed surfaces in the nineties, and shed light on recent Kibble-Zurek experiments on the period-3 phase of chains of Rydberg atoms.

We investigate the classical chiral Ashkin-Teller model on a square lattice with the corner transfer matrix renormalization group algorithm. We show that the melting of the period-4 phase in the presence of a chiral perturbation takes different forms depending on the coefficient of the four-spin term in the Ashkin-Teller model. Close to the clock limit of two decoupled Ising models, the system undergoes a two-step commensurate-incommensurate transition as soon as the chirality is introduced, with an intermediate critical floating phase bounded by a Kosterlitz-Thouless transition at high temperature and a Pokrovsky-Talapov transition at low temperature. By contrast, close to the four-states Potts model, we argue for the existence of a unique commensurate-incommensurate transition that belongs to the chiral universality class, and for the presence of a Lifshitz point where the ordered, disordered, and floating phases meet. Finally, we map the whole phase diagram, which turns out to be in qualitative agreement with the 40-year-old prediction by Huse and Fisher.

Using density matrix renormalization group simulations on open chains, we map out the wave vector in the incommensurate disordered phase of a realistic model of Rydberg chains with

1/{r}^{6}

interactions, and we locate and characterize the points along the commensurate lines where the transition out of the period 3 and 4 phases is conformal. We confirm that it is three-state Potts for the period-3 phase, and we show that it is Ashkin-Teller with $\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremath{\simeq}0.80$ for the period-4 phase. We further show that close to these points, the transition is still continuous, but with a completely different scaling of the wave vector, in agreement with a chiral transition. Finally, we propose to use the conformal points as benchmarks for Kibble-Zurek experiments, defining a roadmap towards a conclusive identification of the chiral universality class.

Using the corner-transfer matrix renormalization group to contract the tensor network that describes its partition function, we investigate the nature of the phase transitions of the hard-square model, one of the exactly solved models of statistical physics for which Baxter has found an integrable manifold. The motivation is twofold: assess the power of tensor networks for such models, and probe the 2D classical analog of a 1D quantum model of hard-core bosons that has recently attracted significant attention in the context of experiments on chains of Rydberg atoms. Accordingly, we concentrate on two planes in the 3D parameter space spanned by the activity and the coupling constants in the two diagonal directions. We first investigate the only case studied so far with Monte Carlo simulations, the case of opposite coupling constants. We confirm that, away and not too far from the integrable 3-state Potts point, the transition out of the period-3 phase appears to be unique in the Huse-Fisher chiral universality class, albeit with significantly different exponents as compared to Monte Carlo. We also identify two additional phase transitions not reported so far for that model, a Lifshitz disorder line, and an Ising transition for large enough activity. To make contact with 1D quantum models of Rydberg atoms, we then turn to a plane where the ferromagnetic coupling is kept fixed, and we show that the resulting phase diagram is very similar, the only difference being that the Ising transition becomes first-order through a tricritical Ising point, in agreement with Baxter's prediction that this plane should contain a tricritical Ising point, and in remarkable, almost quantitative agreement with the phase diagram of the 1D quantum version of the model.

Chains of Rydberg atoms have emerged as an amazing playground to study quantum physics in 1D. Playing with inter-atomic distances and laser detuning, one can in particular explore the commensurate-incommensurate transition out of density waves through the Kibble-Zurek mechanism, and the possible presence of a chiral transition with dynamical exponent z > 1. Here, we address this problem theoretically with effective blockade models where the short-distance repulsions are replaced by a constraint of no double occupancy. For the period-4 phase, we show that there is an Ashkin-Teller transition point with exponent ν = 0.78 surrounded by a direct chiral transition with a dynamical exponent z = 1.11 and a Kibble-Zurek exponent μ = 0.41. For Rydberg atoms with a van der Waals potential, we suggest that the experimental value μ = 0.25 is due to a chiral transition with z ≃ 1.9 and ν ≃ 0.47 surrounding an Ashkin-Teller transition close to the 4-state Potts universality.

The anisotropic triangular nearest-neighbor Ising model, with antiferromagnetic interactions, is studied. The phase diagram, as a function of temperature and field, has a complex structure. Two commensurate ordered phases are found. The transition to one is Ising-type. The second is reached from the disordered phase in one of two ways: either via an intermediate uniaxial incommensurate phase---which is reached at high temperatures by a Kosterlitz-Thouless transition and at low temperatures undergoes an incommensurate-commensurate transition---or by a single continuous transition. The latter transition is in the same universality class as the chiral three-state Potts model, with thermal exponent within 4% of that of the three-state Potts model. These two transition regimes are found to be separated by a Lifshitz point. The phase diagram and critical behavior were determined by analytical (symmetry analysis and free-fermion approximation) as well as numerical (phenomenological renormalization-group and Monte Carlo) methods.

In recent years, programmable Rydberg-atom arrays have been widely used to simulate new quantum phases and phase transitions, generating great interest among theorists and experimentalists. Based on the large-scale density matrix renormalization group method, the ground-state phase diagram of one-dimensional Rydberg chains is investigated with fidelity susceptibility as an efficient diagnostic method. We find that the competition between Rydberg blockade and external detuning produces unconventional phases and phase transitions. As the Rydberg blockade radius increases, the phase transition between disordered and density-wave ordered phases changes from the standard Potts universality class to an unconventional chiral one. As the radius increases further (above Potts point but still close to the tip of the lobe), a very narrow intermediate floating-phase region begins to appear. A concise physical picture is also provided to illustrate the numerical results. Compared with previous studies, this work brings more evidence for commensurate-incommensurate quantum phase transitions in programmable quantum simulators from the perspective of quantum information, showing that fidelity susceptibility can be used to study such phase transitions.